High Court Karnataka High Court

R Raja Rao vs M/S Samrat Ashok Exports Ltd on 23 June, 2008

Karnataka High Court
R Raja Rao vs M/S Samrat Ashok Exports Ltd on 23 June, 2008
Author: Jawad Rahim


$51.”:'”‘E§ Tiafifi THE 233% 3%? G? 3€J§’*éE
gamaa
:5»: z;’:s§=?r”>:f:.:§a,

§§;§S?i3?~§E3E?~é”§”S

H17} SE”? i%$§§E ?§°§E

; 3%” €:*?%§.§§§..T ?’:§§%§*i

3?’? ,£f”§,:’§4§2§§*’3 =-

f§E§*é’§”,,f;i3s€:fILi $83.2 FQR ?’H;E
‘ SEQ: .E?3~§ Q?” “§’§*%’§ 3,? §?§£”§”_,

$3???

_ T “is, :E»f?’${i§ a:&.§,::. as’ “mg
fi£§’s,.§i35;”§f?E E391 TPEE §’sP;§ELi_..5a§=§”§” ?§.fi.’¥’E?§G “§’§–%§RT Tififi
§’L€.’}§E_,
$5

;

£%~if,:& 35;’ ‘ . ._ i
“:3-+::¢ aim ;*”3ZL§E}
C2,’?

::’_:§aaE§<: i'3"§i 5&:2,2$:§2
_.$'§£s";:E%E{.i§§v'sE§ ::';%s~'?§§a;a:§§;
s&1€Q&i§T??,.,?é€3 3'?-é;.¥.. RT.~Z$?€;3»
:§§:

“£2; %;} ff§-gestj ” ;i=:e;;:;;§?e:e:é 3?:

1 7 a’.’..–»

gas? fif §”%3.é:,€’§,a’3§§:-, _§.T~».z:-:;;2″§;’_»’§ §§*r§’:;:-é::%j:é€;..§;::%: sniagasi fléiiié

a§§§%”:§’s:%é::{é =f::;s:*:4::%er=;”%;;i3§t’:: ::;§§:;%2

iféfiiéiifiiz ,;S:3£s§:’._gg 3.23;} Eéiiéfiififi?

Q5 §*”§§%?%3′”§’¥’§§” ifzg ;¥”&S§§i§'”:§€E’?€ W Eéfiiifiéé faiiaé ii}

– 5

___§TaT¥ €323 e:;§:7=:§«§:.§::*%é:2§; fag §’i&§if¥’§§?£1§§ ‘gag’ ‘ifia fiafiartfzfigséi

32$ géaa fair iF’fei’§’¥§S§§§¥”§ es’ 2′ a§§§%%:” ihar” ii: $3″? $23 33%?

fsgm me %”ttS;°:§?’:{§&§’2;i – a;;:z.§.-::,e”‘ as ié wéseifzar ifieg egwagé”
§;§§*:*2:;3;::s::§f fiza isffasééé “”7f::§ gag; :§::”;§$?:.:f”:’::%E:”:§ fee as ésiwif’
féaa arwaé 3§i§$%”E as. zarsifimaéaieéfi

2? £3 iiéaéa $433 :23 §§§::§?.»A:;v§?¢? zfigzsnfia b’2€b.?Va..¥T%::V’V’§§§1.’:’

E

a

§&§§§r::{:*&::’:i was §rfi%__i%§§%%ri2;飔§_<" ais ;:;:§;:":;a'%A:§a% afiérzaéf 3::

§§§%3i;;!;'?§$§'§f ?s§=3,2, '@532? E3 §v'§-§V:':a:L}§E%s§ £Z%«§f5e:::_::{'_'.=sséa§ E'$§?€§ 2;": $3

we gzi-:'é*£-253:2. 1§§3';*:f:$%: "'–'%;7.é":–=z§::*:=:""'v§::?i%@?:'2 Er: fififfiéfififfi was

;°".§§.?: ;"§§?f'éS£é'§§*§E§§*¥;§ §§;r'}:a: %a,:é:i3§:s*:§e':*:i, {§a%;'2<y'§§':"% the ::§"'§§'F§IE,

fifi 22"§§::§§::&r2:s, €31 ééhaéf Q?' iééa §&§§i§"§"'§%2&%'éi§ SQ

i ,.

.f;é:°;e, .’>tf§3s §é;’1éfi?g?%e §C::§§7E§%F’;’§ §T§’%!E;’%?;§T& 23:23

?ze§§$; s:§.?;%é*avia:*:.%;%§’::i’:*’.§f~_§:~§”:aiax:a§*:i ‘§J3E’$”£’iS§%’£”sS 5:? Seaiim

“V.._A:s”a2’§§f;=’§”;:s:’:§;?;.:e;Tr;’:%_ s;;;a%§§Z?”.”‘——–§*%’s;3%é*3!$’§?é%”§ §’E§§¥’§§i¥’§€; §:§¥”z§$§”é:ffi2§’§i ii} iééfi

_ §<'§%§}§:::2T.:::':::§§;%£ 2;?:::»éis 2&3: S";2%3$&§é.sE§;*""§i

Vvmh Q'. I

123%? i?:"':&:'f;?'j:§:'é'§*§'2:':§*&'s':% 3; Qififiiefé ma: he éééfi igaéé €533 32'ra§<ué;r's?.

9, £1.41

:3w&:s§§'«;.s:§2;;::s;-:cs:é 3;? :§&::a%-ta: iééai wag sgfiéééani aria?

;a:;;:[:%g~:§e§ wasra mi: Eésiséé ta 3% f;sfi:§2ar' mgzégéxeé.

1:, éfigifiifiaiéafii 3233 gfiiaééfié ifréé 33:3? §§'$$E" QE3 tag

(%i*

i§_

ffleaiéérg 3':%'§~E 1% iia fig: wafi 32$' mix; éfiiafiiéfiiiéfi i§: :;%"*i.§2§;*a
"gag {Ea Efiifiléijié zfaisea' by iiha r'2s§§r2§&i:3i$, §-%§ :%s;%;~2=~§;é::s'_;"~T.:*:':a

i8"*"€i"

ififfirsaa gm: ?€3T§””%’%f§?f'{§ $1;

the a’§r:§:;:s*§i as ;=”§§§?€€é§ ié 3:’: gages; $:;7i§:§ é§§.;f:;s;%:§3::s§ “§;§%;%’§”?a=§

agiisn $3 i§T?”si&E”E”1§§§§é§,

:’»a§:e afzaigé :2 griliféilé iégg Qfffifiifl E2 éééffifié is fiava
V A§T:%E§{‘% “s:;e:’:”:2’%r:§i%&§f. if éfféééié is ismmiiiaé :,:2’§:”T;”:;’é::a%

§$Z§fTL3§&%’::E eésafignig ::;§:é?sa:§:::&<r:i fiiéiiifiiifn :2: ii; féééws,

1:3 §°'§f}%i'*§§¥§f"", Eiéiéffité "E": fig: E2 § $§&€;§E§ giaiaia

?§-E:

5%?

3″‘: 3?%wfia;

ml

:m$§§::§§ 3? §;r’:;*=;§§%§;~”:$ Q?’ ifififiii

$2″

fig!
w
m.

K””\l”

1:53″

fig.

W

fig fagcciggeé wag ::§*’:’aé;«.__§?’:a?s.»%§Tzrizf§f’ ”

.. ‘I

§§ifE§ :2é;r:§§:r Ea

geggfiz is’: 3:: 3 gigs

‘;;””:?§”¥’%§§§%”:§ :3?

ifigéiaéfz ”

K

” &t:*;;Te:;.a_§’:§[:”‘:¥s;; 32.,z::§r’: iaaésa fig éififiéfifié with i;Fé§§§§§?§§’§§%E?§E,

§§:;&:’2:;sa 9:: gasgégzg aha fiéfzfiaiéi éegxet-i§’:;:§ .3: $€=.aa:;.r’%fg:’e;:._i-:;:’z’

ézzégé §’~.§§§§§i§’T£3;§;;§ ?%;§:s:;’ir;i% _3és§=a::§:’=’%<: 2;'i::::S§:i§ ?i'€:§§'§"{§%?';§;?

W

may faéwéy ?¢§§'2z§$§§%';s {E

-E:

ifsé §u;%E$§?§:”:a::i,

‘rum

” 32%;; am 525$ Eggs; %§ra.§§:§§.’.£;fi:$rasi i%’:ee~’- is

accggéé after’ éggizzayzge sf’

§?f;éi.”‘%’2§ %:’_§aa¥~:;”%’iz”r’s;ae::z§:’;e§ $2′: this cagé ¥a??%%Er”&?33y’ iffié ‘E?§§§ ifiiéfi

E k

” ‘%:;;:;a:p*:E’%§§ éfia $’s;§§§::;’:£§ Q? fiarvaéésga ffifiaffigfifi i§F%§f§’§i§fE”i§§7fi