IN THE HEGH c<:3:3a"§' 9? KARNATAKA
szacuw asmwt AT DHARWAD
EJATED "rs-us THE W BAY *m7# '3'1}*'~§E-,;
BEFQRE A ‘ ‘% %
TE-$5 HONELE MR. 3SSTE¢E”~aé$~HOK¥B;. .%.4!§;!’§fi_§-%uI«’i?}:4E’§P;I
xwsm pyrmcssx:.%§sc>.26§;’é3;:ét;::§{:s;¥;iEm%V:
BETWEE¥\§: ‘V «
Ni3’é€A§*PA
AGE: 39 veaasf O.€.C:'”F.!.:i_,,’–,j;–.._ ~ %
R/G mam am, ‘¥’§§i%.;¥S’£A§3i”§t&\VE’, a «
QHARWAD. ”” % :PET1′!’§C?NER
(BY SRI 348, $89,335::’§%{3;~,[§:§§;%v;:%: V
AND:
. ‘rHAE%”:%A%i§4Ai”AKA :§r§é:€2§Rsi*w,
aavars .r§a.:s’;sx:~;s=;<, AVEHARWAE 52' yrs
aE%G;$mA?.;'*v«.A%_
V 2, Bfi;S;¢aP?§%'3i'§fi1f5x€.§.v5s??'A HA§$X§'fi;Qg
_ ?¥?g§z3¢3R, GCC: DREXIER,
" " £{§'4iFi.§3§.TAK;%'e' U¥\EI'iz'§RS!TY,
_?*;5;VATE–..jE§AGAR; DHARWAQ. :?,E§PQ?§SEf*é"?5
'%{~3v';3§:% »4A:.Lz;<AR3:;£s: s. HZREMATH at
…-Si-'~iI cw. EHAT, A§'s.iS.§ ma R1;
R2 18 S§RVE§ AME E..§¥’slREP’RESE§’K§TED}
‘ms PETETION IS FILED Linnea ARTICLES 22s”;2ii§z§:5″k227
9? THE cs:~:s’:”1″sm1mz or INDIA FRAYING TO 3jE€:i;AR._”EV5TE~§.E
A?FGI¥~£”¥”‘MEN”¥” oz: RESPQWENT No.2 TO THE POST C3F ‘EL*’FiI\i(“ER”:
AS NULL AND vars Area zssae A WRIT QF MArémjMU’s:7.Q “(H5
FIRST Rasmmem T0 AWGINT THE:-‘E’rm§j0¢;e§2. T€}._TE&fE.’PG;ST j
OF DRIVER.
“ms PETITIGN comma 32%; ma f~;i’T£:”;§.VR§E\iG’~’f?;FE;£f;§./_Vjf3HA_§t’, m»
COURT MADE THE FOLLOWING:
respanden,§’§§§_2″§Q, thégriver in the serviceg of the
:’esp0:3€$er’:t ‘§\£;Vc:a;’3%Va£”:e;§ “f§r. a–~.§£>’n§equent§ai writ cf mandamus in
the respgr»._r”:Vde:’1t””i’%§<:<_:.§1":;<*h.i* a:;5'p<§«§"é§t the petitioner ta the said pest.
ffhé'A..§r¥af §éééts of the case are that the first
re5s%p§n;é§ntff%:2;s%;:':*;%grsis~:y fsgueé tfie Eistéfigatétm éated 24.94.§2
' '{fisf'E!"'§é}€;*§,.€__£'€-{£33 §%'a§vE{§ng the agpiécations from quaéifieé carséédates
"' -Tiyj'AfQ%'*»axp§5i:itvr;§«ér:t to the post as? driver. "rim petitianar beienga to
V' 'ftaéfkwa-ffifi ciags (categcryuz). Oat 9?' the 8 posts, one post was
fer <:ai'.egery~1.' The petitianer appeared for the
t"'-ééitervéew an 1412.32. The petitioner was the emy efigébie
$3M.
3
candidate in ::ategary~1 for the past in cgueggtion. Hewevef’, ta his
éésmay, the respeszdent §\£0.2 who dces not evén be§_e:2:gf-«4.£:«w._the
aategaryd, has been sen-:-cted to the post
petitiener saibmétted represesztatiaas .;:I.ata d
and 16.§4.03 (Armexurewfi, B1 3: Bi»,re:;_;1ve§ti§*e_§;%}g” $,’f’§’:5?”1″«’&;i*1.§é;§s
representaticns déé not iead E1£rriTV_a’::_y*snJhés<e.{; hat :;%§és.i._c4e.::stfa§ne:£L'
to 'me this writ petitien.
3. Sr: G.K. I-£ireVg?::«s.V§%?c$ar;._t:;1ea £’e%:’:r:;§ed_ counsei for the
petiticner’ “–§e{itifi’;~:–a§* pessesses vafid drivérgg
iicencef r1r§”«.aet$_ crétefia mt out $25 the
aévert%sameaf:}–.._VAA – V ‘
_§~§Ere§’fiat.h,…§ne ieamefi c6ur2seE fer the respcrsdent
553,1,:.éub;%;vE.:$’%t§:%%f éhe Beard 9:’ Appeintment (far shart, Bfifix}
:7″,__ §er1siiti:’f:éé seem: 52(2) of ma Kamataka gtaze
‘._,__iJ:”:§_x:ers§§sesV'”‘g®’§, $88, has famsarded the Eist gf $e¥acted*
V¢a$..fi§iEdéies 3:¥”i£’§ tfie same is apfimvafi $3; tfie L%§’*:§ver$§i:’y Synfiicate
*~.,_§%: ‘ fie farther sasbméts tizat the s&£ect§er; has men
ifiaéé by ‘Sim 8033; cm téze basis :3?” the quaiifécatioyz, experience
araé perfennance cf the candidates én the érztérview, we sufirsséts
4
ifiat {fie {easement 559.2, a candiéate beéengérzg fie ger:er§’E”‘»:7″2er§t
categery, was seiected by the BSA agairsst the vaca::~;1s’§§%?e:»§
fer categsry-1. Ascardirsg ta him, if a s:£éEab%e_,c_a:i1’€§.i:d’e:Aift;& Er? “a’s:T3§
catagciry Es mt avaééabie, it is span to i;.:£1f:i3,:ésjs%’t*;.z*§§”ap,fié’E§j;_t :;a
candidate beionging to gaaerai. mer§§’–.Aé’ategar§f,”.A.és”pe’§ ‘:%§§~»
Gcvemmerst ilérfier dated 2§.0$.i§V§}.$:’;’%» He s;’§i.:.1:3V_r:r’1ir§t:-:4; éhare is’
m Eiiegafity in the ap§e§:.*.-§r’fignt_<'§ § 'fti¥i§ :éf&s&:pond'é§it' v?%3o.2 as a
éfiven
safveé, baa he i':a s"Llrejrrfgéir2e:¥_ s;3:*f:__§'e§r'asenied.
5, Yhé'—.§Vd*¢er€%$ém"en%' isguafi at Annexure-A aarmafka
mag; §9;s€;:§e.gf_:'a§Efi::e%"'§er…_.a«carzdiéate hewngérég 'ifi cate§or'y-:L
'§'€%3Ae£:3:. anTA~e§§'§§§:v%.é"cagzfiiéate b$§€#§"§§§3"Eg is ifiat categsry is
:' <.___gszaélafaée;'t§:é:'é'Lj§ié%§£§Eé res: fiave been iagy aaaagisn far the figs?
'».__:fa:<s;;§anéé'r'ej:§ ":.§:%;%§¥érs§iy is tfigew wen Em gas: is the garseraé
"ffie statement 3? abjectisns fifiefi as Eaehaif am? im
U–:é.'§vé*;駧§? argiy g%ve$ €59 gmcedure for makéng tha agpeiniment
§~{;§"§§ E$ séierst an whether as? am: am; cai1d%c:¥ate bekzngirig ta
z: é§.teger§e'~i was ava§§a§§a. Tha aetitécnar ciaims that he is the
335%
iene eeradieate frem cetegeryfi. This essertiee E43'~._:§1«4e%'£§}er
eeefirmee E20? denéee by the first responders': §ie.§e:ere§'i'~7g.'ej'*-5%:Téte-.»
eeunter.
‘J’. The very fact the: the eet%%:’§’_ee’er’Te’wee:”eeiieeffer
interview is indicative ef eés meei?fi.§~..the e%~f§,§i:ii3t’32’.,§r:«é§e–zfie..5 If he’
were em: eiigéeée, he weeidfiet hee.eV:i:eee._vce¥E.ee« ifesf éeterview ea
e5§. Nowhere in the etetem’e2€3.:.e%1.ei§§ecE’§’e§;e:’it., is statee that the
eetitieeer wee ?euee_”eeseite’e’§e–.if’: V . ‘ V J
eeceee ree.;3eeeeeV:’s:v’fp.effe%’e§eece”may have eeee feeee te ee
better ehee the, the eeeiéeeey. See that :e ee
__=;_%,reeee..«:§fe%’ e’:ier:§r%%’sgw._,V}tvV§2e eeeeéeimeet fie tee eetitéeeesz The
Aeeeéefig,_ ieVA;:eeA’;’:*;%:eeei fie tee eetiiéeeer weeie eeve eeee
eee§er’e’éeee3e§§’e_e%:’駒:e ereeeee ef Ea) eée ee’: being eiieéeie gs;
Ewes ee§””‘ee§e§;.eeéieeie eee {e} eée net eeieeeéee te eetegergt-e. E»:
.:”:”.’§§ee.ee§e_g1§seVV’eefeeee ef the fire’: reeeeeeeet éieesereéeg ehei tee
–§jet§”%.:–%Ve’ee’r eefferee fsem are! e:’ fieese ieéege. E? e eeeeéeeée
T *”..eeE’eegin§ te geeereé merit eetegery eerferme better ee eceree
eéeeer eeeri-ze thee the eeeeieete eeieeeéee ie a reeeevee
333;
§
catagsry, the aame aafmat be 3 greasné 1%? éenyiag the p53′: is
the réserzseé caiiegory taadiéaiai Secéaé 3?a§$t§ce er:§hr§necE___§:2 time
Canstéiutésa af Enééa, fies ta be securad.
§. Fer at: the aferegaéd reagafis,
agpsinimant of the regpevrréagzt §%$,_?»~~a_$ i§i1锑V’fd*%§§za:%’; _’ ThVé
%:’:’ega:§ar%%:’;r £3 cammétieé by the first r£2spé_’£§::~’g%2n€=£.3_%:§§#’$féé§$;*~;Eééi
what car: mt be East géght sf is ‘:I.*:1;_3’E….evefé”-véhea §:§f§’;é;’«:_§f”E£;3C”I§”t§a?’%%t§w
M2 is wrorzgfuify aggoénteé, he E”:a.?§VVE§:’ae:%.._ser§§’¥fig.igs fisiériaxar fgr
the fag: six;–~,raaAéfS;, .§-§éI:;;may . %:3%;%”be:::;§me evaragefi ta get we
§r§xzer”s1ja§’-.§E§ ‘thew sf:é2’§E~c:é§. Cilcvammant arid ef the §%.,§§§§£
sects? :.::2§er:éé’k4%_::i§§b Vi .;t§és3._r?e%§.§*e dean’? éé: prayer m resaraze téze
aéiéfrty fEr5:£””m=,j5_§_;¢érs§e:3$ £3n§a:a:”$§ty ta rehabéiétaéa ééie
E”é$E3p3§f%Vi;*»€”:’gif1’£..§f*§i§.,;’;.,_§’;€_£?’é§t§E”§§ 3 sagarfiwzerary gas: gr 33* making
any a’EtAé§:%iai§%3gé”.’;2..:*z”aégem-as: En aaccsrfiange wété: Eavv,
H iéxé E’E$fi$?E§&§’E§ §i§$,2 has fiéssééargeé fiég wark a$ a
–..’vV’2*é’§;~e?’,’T?e§f§e %%:”$: respafiéenéz. ififiéverséiy sééagii as: raswer €i?§§
gaf§I.§%%g~§§§ § :9 him far the as: aix yaarss S§m%§a:’§§;,, the geiiiimar
§§::r:§i’Te-niétéaé is any saiary fa? ihe iast géx years; aa he 3:35
aflazaiégz rm? wfifkea, aémaagfi 312$: a sitaéaiéfifi §$ fifééiéfi by %%2&
193%
‘?
first respenéerzt Universéty anéy. Hewever, other than the
payment sf backwages, the peiitéeraer is erztitieezi §s:z;VV_T»a:§T~.,_i:%’:e
genéfits iike seniarity, gromctéon and =.::ent§§2a§t_§£_ .’6fVV’_’;:~é.:§*v-§§é%_V
smtianaiiy treating tégat the petitéorsm” erafigrad t§_”:é:*”saéjr*;,s§::.*:é§$ sf *:_E9§e’=
first respwdent Efiniversiiy an the day ,:%>A§: 1v§?k2E;<£h..' V?-%ié" sLg::'a3:§;e5
mspméefit jsined its services.
1}” Accorééngi? thés;–~Qgtitigrfl’:fé _fii§§£3’3Sefi ef’.’*-A ¥’%é”r:$ orfier a5
to costs.
$%¢*