‘3
E
IN ‘E’§iE E3631 CGURT 3? KAR1’€A’1’fi..KA AT BA.NG;fl»g’5( fi@
msrga THIS -mm am may 3? FEBRIEAREE, u
?RESEZ1’*~ET
Ti-IE I-i0I~:=+gLE 2m.JE35T3{{:EiLf:a;1§, m*§j1L% _
s§_?§{i} ” L % ” * ”
krz-:3 E£$§’BLE mgmswxtfi”a.sR3m:\;g;s§3.§:3¥1′.aA ” T’
‘:Xf§.F.A.1\?;:;:.. %k52%gg;%£V::m”ee €’:x;:iJ’2 %
§E’i’%E-E:
M2&3};:::*:;§;’i§%”;’;;. _ ‘
S153, {:_’;.A iii’;;_»E§g:3’a§=’z;::;:a:3w31z3.§’,
a3;:«;f-iii’ 5’7′ §”{~%a;:*3,””‘ _ H
ia;§:::;;i” S§e:”:=.._§; ‘-Zifi. Eivfgizasifi
<LEj§":i{:i_§’;<;:§E23;{1'i:.
‘A E3’u3::’1§aj%; §¥§1′”§sE7:§1a3, $513.}
V . ‘L EZ§§§§é,Sii;,
S [ ca; Man} 2.3113353,
n Agéé about 32%} }f€a}”S;
r _ ‘ifiaeiha Ezzgizzzzer ‘iA?<};'}<:s-i
' "E{a31<::§"1ugara $'{'l'€fi'iZ,
Tixisia Exiszasiezz, {§E'zi::£§z:'::-ggaizazg
{§?;i::ié%1' 2:55' the: Exziami" {::jy"{'ii*f3}
3 C, (7%, §3?§8;€§'1i§i.1fi'§E3:',
S j :2. {,}z:2vi1':z§:a3 ?v'Ea§2:}:",
3%' féi £L'ia:"f:.2§:'éi EEK Efiaéaci,
if
I
5,.
C’)
iéiaickmagaizir,
{E..{L’:. €_7W;’1:::1′ cf £1115: Metal’ (:;y;”:1i’:)
{§~;, T. 8’£3*€t:t}_, iihickinagalzii’,
€,§’:1i’i:.€ci India insL1ra11C:t:”: C341,
Thogariharzkai Buii:;1i11g, ‘ ‘
K, M, Rflad,
Ci}1:1:::k:11aga3m’.
{Tfi}: Sri, M, “U, §3€1iZ3I18.C§’ia, fgai’ ”
R1 35 R. 2 -~ zmtigrt.g1i$pt;z3,’:§:;:fi wit31,3:,’ 0. e:{.ai::=:d-‘;2Q~ 18-69)
Thgis. .:;:v;m; fi1%:::d éffijs. :%2–3{;;) ‘:36’ M? Act agagmsa: the
ifus}:g11:.e;:3i;.,a1ie:§_”aké;-i@’§:l –.z_i::a_£z3e:i }5}.~2!I3€3*E: ;.:sas:’~3:c:{i in MVC
Na 1-2:1; :z£:i::;::;: ~ 23;; tfias: fi’i€!”.’¢}f the A-cm, f}i$f?:”i::tt., Jusige and
?x;’i¢:f:.”3.”i3$i?~, }§z%.C”Fg “{;Zffii§.n:{ag:aELu~; pariifs aiiawing the Claim
§j2e’é:i’é:.&:33:1 :”‘r}r” <:¢31*;:.p€::?;1'::af.i:}1i'«. zisiid sraekirsg €.:1ha.:r1<:E:m€::n: 9?
I_f:€}i11E~3§i1'§f:Z~:é:'P.§§£3_'}.";'iQ,. ' ' " "
~'5i§'§1§S. a§;:;:sé,:,aj ______<j:;::smi;:1g {:11 ff)!' H€ia?_"'§}3§, "§Ti:§_s {'§§~3.f~;}
?&'§E§1 §;32 c'2t_iii.vert:d iihz: i"%;}§1:’:§é v is a €:;ia§ma11¥;”s a.;::pr:af: {ii3*<:':;{::.&c:i agairmt fizééz
4' . fi:i"§;Z§3?:._f§.$"§€%"i'§_.. j::{:§g::e'::z'€ 3136:? aaafarri €i8.'¥f.fTi{§. 3€,3«~E1=2€3€}:1E pagsfié
31$ ?;.'2:'_'¥f 2{'iE€j3ij: an T336: 53$: zizf {ha giviidfi, S§I}f§s;'i.r.iC3E,,
" 'éff%:é<*i§.g€% 333$ §%*E€:r:%:«::«:r %'2;§.A€_":"§', s: §f5§°€’iE’§?§”.}£},
fl
.,_, ._Rr:%3}:a:?>:3r:§t::1’£s v . L’
3″}€§1iI3€i, {>11 a:::a_c{, a.;::peii:331″§. fail down
anqi s:_:$i.a_§§1<::::§ §nju:*i€:$ – fracturfi: af mack {sf feE:m1""g:ij 3.116:
f;"ac1:ure {if Efifi wr'i5%:= Thfi £:t<:}:" has op§1"1::<:_%_ éfihfr.
fraazémm 2:31' n€:(:k «risf fmzur is €;1::vi0uSi§J m<3ré;'._5€:x§t:ré fiisgaig V'
izhtit f1'a<:*s:.urr3 Qf wrist Ha has assaésseti z:"iiSab:iii–fj£ »:3§' .?{"":'?'x£3 in
'i§§:r:§::, Agapeiianf :,::1ci<:":mW:::2§ ?::"ea:'i,ra€:11£ asj§:pa%:ie:=1t"'vf<té1v.L
111011': iih.:»3.:'1 1? da}='$§ :21 s3:1rge:7¢""aa:}éf:3 pezrfisxfiiiczi-I 3131131311?
wag §i"ESfZ'i'ft'x;'3.. Cir: aci;:§:i {if t_.1i;:::.§:1_§é_1ri&:s smsf;ained in 3
raaéi i’r9:§*’§”:’c: .;:,§é:i:i€ié%§:.$:~;. 1?.E1z:’a§3i§:+r*i§’i::§*” —- {.?§.E?:_i_Y}1q’Ei£1’§I= {$3661 a Ciaim
‘;3€i’.i%:.ie”:.2′:”;:”‘A_€*:E§«:§::i’i;f:g~TV%.::§:”:.:,g352>:%é:?;V%é€.a;1′.%:>i”: cfizf .i;f),Qi’.},iT:i}€f3/ -« f:'<?:1::":
i:§.:€: z':<:ssp:*:z':rfz:';2*..:":E's:,
, '$3.16: ::af§Ci"'i:'fi§§:3:2 gt:€:t:%1:§::::i": ifiaiti éitizmsa 2.11:; befara mi':
1435, The, '§':'ibi_2:"1ai, afiier Ezaarémg the
§%::a:ii__?:é::s:fi :?zi3£3"::,3é§ :21": $3013": Si{§€:$ magi afifi-1' cfirzsiciermg tiara
3:31 2:_i:3<:1.1;13e:":t&s:"jas fivééfiiscfi 83Jfiii83§§¥E': an gsecarajl, hag
fhfi étéssiitzfz f:«¢:§?§ti«:2:2 in gtxarii and 8;'é5é'2«iiI'{iié":(§
VA 2 _::€_j:*§:".:§:§ef*;:?:§*sa7s.ér§tm mi' RE, E,3E%fi{}é[.'%,!» §'v"'i§§3 i:';':&r€;s€_" at éf:% pg:
/2
V' frag}: 3:h:%_=; »:§.a:I€.<:: {:65 §Z%€:§i§'f§{3§?i;"3:§:i§ {ha éiata :13?' pa§;:13;&nfq
1
£
EL §3ei_i1g agg*ifitv<:°:t'i 333; the 1Z11':;3t.igr1::td .j1T:dgé:"x:€::1%.
and awarcé, 431%: agapeiiaizt has p3:e$erm:s:i tfriis ;§;3§;::gg,~s§1',17 ;_:§z=':
gie g1'<:3's.m.eii that the: co§:'.:p<5::1$ati0n
'?i"i%3i_1I1a_i isa inad<:::':;_2,1at.6: and fl
:1T:cs€i3if§_:i:1g thtiiz _§uc§,g:_n€::1f a::€i.»z§a&_{.§3*ri&€::§ .
fr}, W6 image hrjgrci
fr}? €.h:i:i a§:«§:=e':§_a:3.§" azmtiv '4 agjpetaring for
fhfi: r<%:s~:33a:":.ZT:% :4′ c’.n$i<i<3:z'a's¥.€
'ieitizgth {if i.i::–"§'l .*v
2?… 33gf?€.::* €,}f§3_3"f;?.f"iV'§Vi':§3EZ'E.'1S8§ of %:.i%:a_e _§:;n::'%_gm€::"1%_ anii
'-a.a¥a7£:.;{*E' 33*-35% e:t°:f§_t§.ca§f €%'.va;%é.1:3.t=;i<3:': :3? éhfi I:{:ai.e:éai an :€:c:;o:"c:i, it
aggfgeiéazgt 313$ $2_.:s%:9i§:®:"i gr§€'uS
éI1j¥;:3f?§<%3:2?;,.%,§}:i:fi:{:3§"g:s:":f: €:*€a'::1"}::fi1'1£" §'<i;r §;"1z:*::*:=.; Shag: E'? vriayg ii";
"3;r3£:2..s::;:r§i1T_a'i _e5::"":<i :i:;:r:'§&:'g~s;::s'i€: s:_u"gc:*jg anti ixzzpiagiat hag Efsaain
VA 24%: might Eaazre szfiffirafi 33337:": arid agazzy e*:§:_:§§::g
.. _?E"f;'fi{fiE€i'§{ "§'"E":::t fiéééttair 213$ a§5$f_§$$€:€§ f1,i:1{:*s§§na§
€:_'%§.$a§":f:fi?.j; 9%' "§'€T}'%'..»€; E1; rfispécf {sf §'"2_gE:'?{. §,€':"é3f:'t1' Eémh; "$336
p:?':§'::*g":a;.9;:":<':"-::".T:'E {§§saE.3é.l'fi7»;' if. Whaifi §.'i{'§f§j§ :::"*::11:?.3 Hf: =2<%9zi£:s: 'flair:
OW
'I":'i,bu::a} is moi: jt:;st.£fiur~::<t7$ 1:1 3wa§d:1':g cG§::p€:1_1s;§_ai§0m
§ET'I'W8.}Z'C3S C{Ti1T1Vfi'fsf§i.1"i(.?€3, i".'1{3i.'s1f'iShii"1g anci :é;aV_'{}1':?fif;{§'i;;"{1t\
ciiaxges. if is {.1152 zxasrsr of i:.hi1:;iéi3 §’5.u
neat. _§E.1Siifi.fE{i in awarding t.mw’afiiS §:§>$s— .c3i’VV.i:_;3_C{:5ii:1ei§W<:i1.:3:E:1gV
Eaizti L1}: p(i3'i€}{1 2111:? i:.<§§~'g;r(i:3"'i'¥:$:3;:3; ;::fLzaiizfsrfiiiésg" ciisabiiéty
and €:iis{::}:11§£a:'t. aria u:1_%:a};}'§i::'jé%:S§5i iaiéjng i:i'.1<i:s€.
:*eieva:f:_%f "f:§%;CiTe:;f's r:{§::§¢a.i{ic:r;_:%§.*t'.§£i;:1 aizii ifgavégzg r<:ga:'d m
éhrs-, 1"Ti:f–Tfi§i_'i.Z'€ 4-azzci _é§:_§rai:.iq:€§' trea.tr:1<~::nt.§ paisz anzf: :a.g<::I";§;
$1fsff%::j£;<:% h3: V .a§§T3péEiéi*§'€ €i.sr::*"':§?sg §'1'€é:%'t{:2£::*:{ §32i.=:1'i<:":<:§ anii
'g't.=e1'{i:ve'v:2a"7;€5.:«ZT~i%g-§¢:: éiéf <'§i$a?f£ §i%y* agaeaaéiéi b}: 39:12:: fiaefm' as 3't:if€i3":'€:€i
{E1 is ::':':':{§€?§€:r'::3 '€336 {é€3¥r:p1._:§’i3§’:i:1g fiéixii
3:325: a.{i:e;:’:{ia:1t. §:§’1a3:ge$ Es; E,f:3,{}fi0 f’ –
:7} LG$s ref iflifififllfi e:i:_1:’i_:1g
§LF€.’5:§}}1{i1E{ psztfiad . R3. E8,C>i’3f3;’–
:3} LGSS <3? si%;ii}.%":f1fii§'2S; disabiiity,
:%is{:::m1f::::'€: and ;::'1£::ag};3i:T:<:$s. §$,5}€j3§i3{Z¥{};'~«
/é..»~»-
‘§”i*zf: ‘_i’§’ib2_1§1z3§i iiasz rig§”§?:.ij»~’ aWa:”dz?:Ci _§::T’s.5i.’.j 311$
:’wa3*€i$ msciécai at
§~%?s’2’f%,3}é§_/~ am. §’1_1,i’.1:r€:*: §T:1r:”:di::ai axgaeiiififis’.at. _A4R$.’$A.gE”§;{§i’_:f.§J;V’
The saggy: iii: 119$. itaii £92′ ixaifitrferciigafi, « 1 ”
‘r€giI’;g. :fr:as0′:”2js, ..ti’i16:t a;:§.;;sé»aE ” fii£:%::.1[‘~¥:1§£”~ *’
ihii: <:iai:3;1a;m;— ::-mpeiialii i::=; a§V§{;'«§§::d ifi~._ ";')a:*¥: g.'<iE{i izhfi:
ji_':(§g;'i1"i€"7:3'1'{ and. awarri:€i~:3_i:ed:'AV. }§.@_§{2'f-).%}5 gfiéséci in MWQ':
Na, :2:3;J2:: an fight: §i§§:V_éf_Vti§§_3iV :%,as::1,%%’ ._;uc:ge, mg
‘?=gE::3′::he}:f’ is 1§”i€’;i’€§}jif maciitéifitfi. “f”hr3:
ié2″€:a}i1.é§3 §’_?.~3ei,;i;”:.1£A’i:€*:)’:”*:’.:V ‘ H .
V, mg}: “R52, ::i<"§;<f:if§if§;'-
A E35». ;.2<%3{,:.% E4 ,1»
cja Viffsifgvfifi-ééiiieizfiz:§3;_2:'§,:%§3:;12g f{'§{}{i
a;"::.r;i" Efliazzaiazai siaargfitg Rs" §.5},é'j}{}C% /' «-
{ti} .;%§$$ :3? §.§i;<ét:::f:1fi civfiiag
%::'5ai:1'1';$;:i: gmzéad Rs' i8,€}€}i'}/' ~
" éé} L085 0%' fi_:i::_:m afiiflifiifififi
<;§§sab'§;1i.%:jg 3:11} z.iiS::a::;11§"g31'?; R35 5051366 f ~»=
£3 §9%_4?.§'.'i';§'€f: ::*:€{§:7_s::s:~':.§ €';XpfiE"':SEfi~T'= §$¢ '2;"'f:,é3£3if};' »~
C20
"§"h<:: appeitijant. is r:r:t.§t1€,.::i tr); 3 iota}; ri:0111p{::1$a:i<3f;:*.g)§
Rs,1,???3i<%/nfi as against §–2s=}.,3£%,€)if3{1f« awartifiti"big—–:i§§3%?é_:_
'if;*i§":;*s;::1a§, 'The enhanced :::{3n1;3§;:1$a%?i01:;"' = = _tT-r:'e
.'{€is,¢%=4,3'fi€~'if~ Wat}: i11f£m$2f 21%;. 6°25; ';;s,a;_"'f1"§3§:ia.t.i1é" €i§:2.*§i:.?i_ iii?'
p:i~:ii.%_*iie::'1 {iii thf: (Ears: af 2"ea1i5ai:§'r§:;:,._V
Tha third §'£'3S§}G11{i€:i"}3f. — Eflfiiiyfifififi {fies} ~ i_$_cii:'§§tc1:.e.d to
cifipasiif $3.2: $1:.i1a:"1c<.=:{§. _::<i:_:::;;::e:ié;§,fi;ii§éf;–,, a1:fn<3u:1'€:T 0:"
§u;s*
wa$:I§<s:_. "fi'€fi"i}, 1".i'iri"zT%'ai*:: ééf {71'f(?iT3§T3f€ cs? %".§"1£%j1.1(ig";3§::"1t.
"¥"'§7s<~% é_%;%,§':§::;£:%:€i_ V{Ef.};i1'":v{'L§&'i§§..".i'tf?é.i'.'fi{3I1 wfith '%.m:€::'€~:$i: $113.1} 33$
:"€%_€aS<%*xfE' "$1 .§':s:v:3é;::'9' féfga:-E agégjxfiéiaizég im'§31&:€§_a'f.€§§; am
;_{:§i%:33€:f$?§L'i fzf' "fS&Z3E€f 3.3}-' 3121?: Efhirci :'s:=:S;3{:§;1(Er::i;1%f –~ §3T:$3E§§'a81"?;i'_'_ff';
ijfifiicsi §f§i:'fi$2t<::{i '£6 zkav.-T i:}::r;': £.-:Wa3':%, at':-L':z3:'£§i':1gl:s;,
M
Eéfifi.
3%
Eéi
Eafifig