High Court Karnataka High Court

Alla Baksh Modin Shah Kathib vs State Of Karnataka on 16 July, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Alla Baksh Modin Shah Kathib vs State Of Karnataka on 16 July, 2009
Author: Manjula Chellur B.V.Nagarathna


E&E¥&?$g%w
cmctmt Efififflfi arr firmwgg .

myma $313 mm :3?” DAY 93* J::f§..*2′,; Q

PRESE{i§¥T::”‘ 3 .;< %
irrm :+m1~mLE Isms. &1Is TI¢E._'§r1ABiJ?;f–3;,§:;:'§fiE£}3§i;Li3;3
A

ii'I~2'E germas ssiafi aizs;*r:m §;'§?.1§.:%GA&T§§HA

W.wa.gs;;2m7%;

3ET’WEE§g ~

,%:,L;§ .8§m<:$':;; M :i'i}£§E§\Zi $§»a:aH §{A'E'fH'EE
gm @«z<;§%:§}:}:N%%$'E§A%§ai ms
ACE-E3 $4 $

1%,: Q ~.§{AN{§f%,E§;' .'E';;%E;:%:} R;
DfiA§wA§ ."*

2. W&§§§:_;m:a;’:*

L;s:%?: .:?§%;;2;i:§;:{A§%é:, ;’%;¥3’\§.§

5 %$?;§?§ £2? §<Ama?Amm

. §Y"£'E"S S;§:QRE'E3¢;RY

L Yéagvgsgzzg §§:m§m§§%§%?

‘ éimaam SQUEE-Efi
§fi;;’*~EGAL@§E W 5% gm

pd

Siii}

ix}

TEE SECRETARE,
LAND ‘FREBUNAL
EEIQNGAL ‘I’fi;}.;UE{,
‘$§S’FRZCT: D§~iARWg%§

ANNAPPA Timppamwsa PA.§?;%.E€E£A§Lv?$fi;’;.;§~’;»%%
smca mm 8%’ LBS _,?«%”A§’:<'_§;?~EA A?§I§é'_;§,.E?§3}§

g-J .

MRMANA M mppa %;:>:é;:2%a;<:»:;am'm§%'%j

Sm Lfi'?E AE'éNA__P*P!4'a '§§£iE'vE'{%§?§§\Efia. "
MAJQR,
maaxmmvgg; '=9;;€;.;*x;:.a:ae@é;T:J;:%V€;§:§: §§'\EE
Eeigmaag Ef£§VE§§.., ~.

AWN §§?+;:xz;;;:m2 ,a:L$;w@?,% j}3AE§%’§{KA?%A’*£.AR
Es!EAJC~’R

SfQ__§_.§§~’fIfE: ;%;§§§{%_§*F }§ ‘Ti§:{_§?E3i§; N.E\EA
9gxm§T¥.;4’aé:A’£A§’g..:§+2;as MEGALAGEEE am
§¥%$5::;E’€€f:AL,”E=%?;%’aT€”‘fi?_E€§__””–. % %

3{iii}§”;’§’f§?§;§§,_§§’§m§:5’§.§i§a§.’§§?*é}§;??z% ?ARs%§{§<;é%?%;éfv"A,§©{

. ?:§AJ@§%».. = *

"«::§;".,%:§ §,g%'F5E".§%E*{.E%§;i§P;% ?§i'EPP&N?§%.
@;;§&a%§{T§§wANgvgE§ figs ME:fi?s.L&§-ER; ms:
% . % ~V.§ivA;*§{}g§;§..HA¥'E§£

k'A%§{§<'::%3~;é;§ P @3131;

§zi;é£@’R

LATE §.?*«E§€fi.P?fi; ‘§’E§.’§?§§3,%§*€?’~é5£%

* *=.._?§§RA%{E{J%f€1%¥;%§§ gm E§:¥;§Qw’%Lg%GER§ 32%:

– , &%.;§a§s§J%; §§§§:f’EEE

$E%’£’§’ .E3;%E%Ev’;%Ti~§E ? “E’G§fiS;%§
§§»’E&4§Q3’§
Sffl LATE z§§?E;’£fi.§3*’?’ig% ‘?P§§P??;E'<$'§'é5.A

* $3.3.

\’\.\f».§§

Pamxmwavggfi R/:1′; §v§EGé:L&C%ERE @:%:T%%j% jT%
Hfiéififih, ‘E~1A\f’ERE

S§¥£§T SH.»%NT;%VE-3% E7′ E’§RE%’v§éE\§E

I\1£AJQR %% ~
we §._,A’E’E ANNAPPA T}§I}’?A’I§§§Pg

S{22′:i}

PARAKKANAVAR, R18 MEGg*§L?;GE_:R§

§~iAI’€Gi§L–, H?s..’v’ER§

aim; SM’? GEETHA M .E’vEGU§;§’
gvggggg
3/Q warm z%EVE?€A1?PA–‘_T’E§!?*§?i%%§”3″3%§z§
E’1’ARAKKA§*~ZA’$?’AR, :§a;:3k;:»z:§c3£fia;:;;¢;<; BEE am
HANGAL,.HA,VEE?.§._jf~ _

4. Nz%EASEZ§$§AA§%§:}i’A§¥é- §E~£.’§?;?Eé’§ (iVZ{;%EYA KfiLLA?§’.§R

S1.NC£Z_VQ.;_”§A5D m/%j:J:*qg

4%.; $51? %2§;5;:fik:W;£B%;%§AL’i%
MAEQR W1£”}..’E¥IA’i%fr’5=;’3′;{E~g’E;%C%–&%RY;?a §{&LLPUE
§f&’1’«..:§§;%§§€}?;L, ggéagwag

L§,f%§¢&}§fiE’§:EEgTH.&
% M;2;<i3&%$;® LA'§'E 3 KALLfi:,'i??¥JR

– % k %2@;sA;3 %E.f§§¥;’f%’Gfi.L, méggwag

4{¢;%% ksg%: %g;,§xANAmA
Mama gm VETTAL Mugmy
r<,:m* I~§&NGAL, mgmrm

%%&2r;@; -A*%53:x,/:':* VEJAEA §{%.;EEe'E&EE

31'/Zfixdififi EVXQ E,.»%§§~§fiVE?%QRA
RZAT it-*§fi£§SP;L; §E~§?:RWfi§

éée} 22mm 3 E{,:%,L.E.,APL%R
§%!iAJQR we Rgazgavfimmm
R/AT HA§\3'GAL, Emawga

E§:$mNmN*r$ 4%} E0 4i¢i~A;?E %
REP§<m:2NTg§:2 BY mm: *

am HQLDER :R%§sPemE§?{'N§.£;ga.;%;

'.,;._ R1';:¥S§%<i¥:;€§§7'§;}E§'§E'I'S k %

gm' 3a;;§¢m*
gmgwzax %:’*sa:§§%:z:A%;’m mm : ;:2aa*:,

%,%L;%:’;+s£%:g ,.-.5;E~’4″TP._:_E}’i%,§.; §:£;L;x«:::§~s::§ aw mg f?RELE.%’a§§’§’€RR’f

%%’ %:§§’;i:a§::;§:;;%%A5§;g%:%§ %%%% fém’, §’a:’§A?«ki§”i.l¥§,-fix €;:§%E;.w’§ A;

%%§§§%:;::%$;i§%g:;fisfaa §’GE.L£¥W§NG:

e}U§§ME2iI?

Eiiéiazé; the igaimefi Sazzngei far the agyeiéamt,

(J1

2,’ We have gene Eihraugh the esr&é2r3′.;of§. fi*?§;a

Eearned Simgie Szsdge as xx-‘e}} as QI’€3i€f’S 9j_f– .

Tribunai, which came ta be a§1a.§§_e::g e.é§§’ b§:,%’§’a§*é:. t’:1e_ ‘

Eearned Single J11 ége.

3′ The afimiifted “é;pv§§;fig’s”:é?e 3:16
§\»*§r.S§;e& Hussain 53%.’? fa?

gfaflt sf ragpeet $§
fR,SLN§.6′}” gunéag siiuatéé
at §”L::f*%.§2g the
fpe¥:§§a%f§,{:_§~% ‘*i:fiif:;.éA:.L:V’A;«’§;»1::~3fi§’?s:1§_;_:’:L”§”:*£3€ee&iz”i’:g$, S}-*@i% fimafiaizz

Ssh f§f’&S€1′:§. agpeééamt samfi ma mead

c’§:.gj’9£ez§§’:§.A§::g’i:}:at Em is the ffifiififi’ 33:: af’ fizé §@fi€a§iéft behéné E3}: gjgefi fiussaén S333

;a3§sé;. ‘E33 fig afiiétiaé E5 gei amzspassicy régéfis £33 313%

fggatmazg’.

4%, Thé §:%.’:§r{3 mgganésné: herein £3

Qiaémarat sagkimg §sCr:,2panc:; régiats in z”e3;j;_§%_;és *:’ .

¥e”z*§: same iarifi agairmi: tha…f:;’:;r::}:Wfé;é:§;:»r:’%::i4§.::t=<_V

Eazzdiard' Tha maéariai 'nm%._1ghi?:«Qz*:'*_

mmarié sf 'Eha maiteer 3*a:"§j:v:e;,:ecc:%§é3″;é:§} réghis
ravaaieci Mzifiyad _.§§;v%;$$§}:vv’.Qzzitivatéiag 31$
iané an by faurth
reapanéef°§.:€f§a:§{€g%§;s:§’:§.’ gas exchange sf
:*2as’§i<:e;:;;Q S339 and the faafth
regpefiéézffifiig 3.9%? fat ravaaatian :35

te2"2a_:%f;'¢_§;*.a3*:&nizzégfiifigv apes": téwe éenant '£52 Su§*:*a:':§a§*

?,ha=Eea2_sa,

}%aaa»§*c§1?1*3g is éihe agpeiéagrzt, 332$ giapg we-re

"by {sari}: respanfifimimiazzdéaré ta éake "éézé

"'~– _;*e%mca%§@z':: sf the iarzanajgz :3 $313 iagicai ezzfi,

V' Th3E"€§Q§"'€, Syeé E£us§a3§:': S8}: presumed Ea: Cfiiiiifiué

" '~ ea3£{{"'é"<

'\¢"'§

as terzaiif: cf the said iafld. €§:}fQz't1.;:1ate§j.;',_..__f€§1;Z$

wntentiarz of the appeflam cammt he
based 5:: the facing} aituatign as up '£5
thé name 0f 2&1: Syed Htgssaiifi ..:%s' a3-I'a-f§*:e:§§ §*r"§7

{ha $u§:§3%s'atQ§*'s cshgmm a.r:,€i_4$1,:EQ.;'=~:'a§':;?ez:tTV€:=i:.

e3"E'§if°§$S are made in {he _3*;és%fg3mdeni,
Therefore, as an "'a;§2 :'~:xfe}§ "iA;h e name
disciosed in gu1€iv"ai;e:}'ff§ fiza name of
the thiré viii'z£$%I§%;"'éi3c303es ngifizer
the :::é,;::§ Safe E25?" iha §:"e$en'i
a~pspe§'E3_;'$:Q–.._V'}'?f1%§*'%'2 maifiréaé {:9 Shaw E313?

.__m%ié§':z3va—««éapafiméni §@E'{}3._1"§{§%§ flag iazxi

regpzézzgiasezzi a_:';& 33% E333 paéé taxas

&3":1.::§_ §?£..§":,s;*:,=~t::_"". "§§i?':£§2s {yam §§§'?' QE'i?i?'8_E"&S.

am

::§= §§§'3,€§'.'§ fine gimaiimé was as gtaéefi abmge,

'%*?k%:3»$§%'j::~2Q,2@2;195$ aagmg m m fified Gr: iéza fiéa (:2?

_E%:'§ufi3§.ff at §§8.§="&fE'§ Tb}? Mr. Sjggeé Hzzgsain S333? aazhiafirs

323.1733 is be m.:1'L2r:":§3&:"e<§ as {}E3».'§\§@x'%/E.§'§5i3._ ';::f'§..&:'

cammgfmement 0? Saar?' at fimiga}
Sjieé Hzzggaifi. S293 aaughi "far afi$€3ai*a%:£§M:f1 "&§ii7§E3é:s3'?i:3. "

aZt$r::: §38I"Ef¥§.3I1$I}'{ £:":ju:1ci§cazi:,'; '§*}i'Qi§?9':i?£:'§f£§ V

%m':e:'§Qcu§ar§; appiicatigrz

temparary énjunctian aga€»:1.%;j£ 'ihéA:§Qur'{?:;»:*é§3;::Qr1d_§?3r:f:~-

Eandiord and otfiers c§aimii:g 'und§r" 31%;: . £:8:.f:;'i€W€Q "bé
éigmissecgi, Spam $15431 éigmi3séE._9f E:§%v,-§.. 3%?' 83.3%}.

Eéugsain Sah amenfieéi' hig tha main suit

seakézég t3":§&~§"Q3§*'}§:r:§i$$e3*a;3£:;=z: as W933. M_@a:':=a;h§..3.&, wi'{.}:

$23 §_';fiE"'i'}:fi'3§E':{3€3T'iT:7'§:8AIT?_f Kamaiaka 231:6: Refemns

"'~..V_§;1f;;:::é:*:”i§§;é:-.. Lané ‘?r:3bu:::a_1 as Mr, gyezi Eéusgaigz

!§a§g’vwaB3 _’:;:ji9;i.m§fig :3 E3 {ha $3333.32: E,§3’%.é&i” faurih

” ‘–__ “Zff€$§}{§}I”§!:;:éi’}’€ »– Eanéééré much §:’i{>:* SQ E956 @r:ifi;a?§$fi

Q2″: §1.:a§’£_§a:i1§:’:g ihga E$a’§:’}:”;a3:Vf}f %Z§’i£”-3″é(33§,{E?”ffiS”‘§~’§£*:’§i;”;:T§g’4

gaamg is ?:a:rE: 3:5? aside aslkpeiif”g::?é:?,:’;%$_éii}éi;§–..’fig?i

é”.

znemafiééag iihe ma%:is:*
figjpeéiaééé Trfiunai i!3…;can:2:V§’§§¥:€éj’:%}5;:*-3.§g$é3§e’–af.v§,e::ancy
§3€Ei’iFif€&1″§ “$33 §m3;rt}”: }~§1;sgai.:3
33$?’ it is Ci?;:n§&:§§~é§§?r:«%;;:::”LV’%§§’». Sapyaééaéat. Etfira
Ejiéfifif §§*a¢e@é§_’§:gs $3;-efi

Eiugsésigg “§:§;1a amzifitzztéan “iiizai ‘ihe

§3E’€;€;§fiE :$§”»3E;§V}vf4″;:;’i?»2;*E}§é3:;”:*2i2§:a§ “::~a:§_.%:§%,_§9;:é Ea r;:c:;z1%::7.m:e hég Eataazacjg

z°§g_§_;§’i.s, Eixég séaém as fggitar 3:33.”: izaazzmi.

:::::”:$é’e;§}sré:§_ &$ 3 §@s”£€2§° mi: fisag fiat gei iagai

is §z€%f;x:~é:z**§t the régézig §§ Eség §§:$’£:$*; faéiiézéz Eékfi am

aé§§3%;§;_£§ Eaihar. “§”‘.’:’::@r&f$:*a;%§ {E28 fiihéi” €§2″.’i’i8’£’§.§§8?:1 af
” -.,’:E”:.e_ .;L§;3§aE:§ha§:%; t.}?.m_€: aégzag wéi’§§ $}.:«*&£i Eéuggaéa $333» $39;

” = giésié :;:’L2E%.§’i;a§:?:”:§ 22% Egsafi zsziwéa Qsséjfiisié 3:33

cmxsééeraiia fig 333$ §”2%;§ aéaim 3.3 §§:~e§’2af§£é.a§§=-7 i§§’§€§§’t§’

i;~.._ ihé _ *

53% gaiiegezé i%’T:§§ S336: is’: haigg %éa3″: ejéeszziisfi

%%*:_§$$aér::. 33%; i?’E%::::”::$z%:é§};; E? §}«'”&éi E%%’:.2.gga.:?:;”_;_

fig $§E§C&&€§ ‘:.%’zs1-23’: aémiag flaés 3§3§eE§a:*:ih;§::f;.V ‘

‘:3; ragga’: at? ‘i”}”i& aiifigafi W13}. .{“;”i;-iégraxifégajfiaigf E2213″.

egEa”‘§_§:7$E: Eaifi ?ig7:§%:’é. §?E”§§”€§%3iEf5:@Z§§’Z§j;;*:”?¢;g’*?€’V 3.’V”%f,f€E’f§’7¥.f$;§.”?,€{,VV

2a>§§:§”:z Sjgaé §~§::;333..§:z $2333. V§§j;°s:’:f:*£m*”=%§£>s :a;;3§;rasE:f§£&E:@ ‘?t’;<'::l=g *

§a3';i.&:éE'£3z:; $5 fifaa zazpgzgiéaifi: 2i:%§$:f%_::;%235.%;.eE§(? :':5%:E:§.§3g G?
533% '§"9'%z'&§"}EZ8 E'®C€%Z'ée.;'~*é '"E'f@§'3?%§6 _'::§;~e:};::vL"3:2§;* gitéay a? 'iha

pariéaa Emééaaie 3:: 27:9 éfthég 3:g:rg:2&E§_a2:%,

was £123': §a;§f:::s5%:~e;V;€;:s;:§.V{*::*;:".': -.§§._f£E':_s' E3526; '£3': qézesiéfifi as a
¢a2§f§:%_*;,-«'a§:;,:§:" Eéaggaézq $333 E*§gE'*:'5z {mm
39%? 33$:-2§3;"&§, ._ §%;._%_7«;as,~;%i3; fiw 'fizérfi 2*&$f;3s"s*:£§e§::*%: 2?':'";::,"s

*§5;a§:.§.r%:"1 §~1"%§S$éS';i:iiG§.'"§ :::;af ihe 23333? £::§:i::i%2"a"{§:"zg {ha gama,

V V?§$'3:'é'§ Siatgiifi £3 :9 gig afféség firzai mask

'§§_"%?}'vE4Af:'$—3%$.91??? in ':§*:& jgaai" §§§2 éisaéf, "éha

?::*2:é'a%:":ajf;' §%;..§éa:%@:§§' if §j;@:§ }§23§$9,§§§ 322%; 'wag 2*a"%;s3%«;:&§§

'b'§»=' "'E3"§2':::.L' firm éigéfz $5 '5Z}"§%§8 cazfiazziézzazzs :3'? §%2»;"2»

3,.

“§:}2′;E””{§é:§V__f:&:’}§ 37:13:; $3.9 &§$SH$§ $5 331}? G’§§'”E<8E" ;a"§2a%ez°§a§ Ea

BE

$E%:{::W fi';a'*i Sjgeé §"'§i§;£~§$3§?;"§ Sab £Q:'::'€;%:';::,:@& K; 3

4

iezzaigé 3:3 {ha apwpesizzéaé £23.}; ridafi SL V

‘2

. m

ap§3a’§§a;’1’:. saigzmi $%§{3C8€§ fa £2?

Sf;-feé ?€§é,:$;a§_é:2 533$ §:?:j.: ‘2?*£:’*i__%,m3;,__4C2€”_”.

Eéméiagiy, in ifhe ahaezizcs :32″ gaff; :”z*:T:%:5::e§**.i;;’:2fl§’~.:i}:f§

E 2??

:9 $§:m:§;=’ éhaé ‘fézés agpafiéafii a$– Q’:=: $§_%§L?i§A;
imizzazfiéaiaéffi pféa? is that :i’;.;a5f;,r-ifwas £3″: ‘;3:§$sé.$$%$?: Q1?
iéfzfi Eanfi as a ‘5@r”:a::%”§’;%_Qn: 51$” §<;§';:Vi*E?; ragpééfiant, Em

aamzai Szmcéeé fir: %*:*;fL;@:*s§”:”*: :=%:§'”:a

j:%.:;3s”-§*§*;”‘:a5<£é;E.%;';'s_i é}§E.fz§€§'¥§€"_iQ?{'§ 3'? $33 33.326 ag gm? :*@a%'$:a:,:%

' '<2?

ré{;s”,;ré$.;2»fia£.§g ‘mafia a ‘i:§ ‘tiza gkreiiazfiééfigg in $23

“‘§f§§:3g§§ fiaiifi.

”&? aiagéiazn, we 338* {$333 $23

.V _.§_f_§§.2i:£:5:*: éfhaji ‘iiza éegxzzad fiéizgéa £:;s§g& $33.3 jmgiéfzéai

%;

ii-5′ :%:gE:’;-S’ é’:f’£* ”

$<3:':'§'ErzE':§::g '%:':<2@ g3*a3§*;" <§a::$}=? :’igE’;».§§T._V

§2’é:<;&:::" Q? %"}2%2n:§, 2'"@g§:ra:":fi§§iz_% agaé.r:3'§i .

iiézég agggzgiiazai.

E5}. .§%c§9:”&§.s*3g§§:’, :}:e_a;3§§€:–»3E§”‘%.$:
A.

JUDGE