‘.3
SENTENCING AF?EE.LAfiT,!’ACCUSED i’VE(3.1 TO UNDERGO R.’2;’–.»FGR
1′ YEARS, APPELL}?.fi3TjA{.’IC.’USED §-18.2 TO UNDERGG SJ, [FOR A
PERICEEB (SF 5 Y§AR’$ FGR THE OFFENCE ?UP€I$HA8i…E U}’$:’.’30’?
R/W, 34 19:; AND Fi.iRTfiER SENTENCIM5 APPELLAf23T1″A*CjC3EJS:?£)”‘ _
l\iO.1 TO umnenso R1. FOR 6 M{3=’.NTHS_ fiu’!_D* ‘ _
APF’ELLANT,’AC<3USED Iva: T0 UNDERGG $.}..F!ii%R"6; %§é3rx:":':-is' . "
FOR At»? QFFERCE PUNESHAELE airs. SECT"E{}?~é '3¢?j.0T*'..
IPC. 3cm; THE smrgmcss SHALL Rm: CQNt3UR_REN'fl__Y.-, f
This agpeai caming oi': fGf'heaf§'n§'this é .¥a5§r,'..ihé
delivered the fwlawifig:
Cenvicted accugég./.A_ ‘§%i’i.._:§;;:;ea¥ éa$ ivi”:$t the
jzzdgement pasgeé by §.’;$i.2rt, Beigaum
in sessiens cg*se”«A1.r¢%~;,5ié.x2a=:Eo’ ér”G?;J;_1T§D2 Cafzvigtinfi tha
appeiiarztg ,f figfiishabie under Seczticn
307 9!’ t}§’é “iPC:.§4a?;aé::§§i£§’§ ::?é::fEia;)’r{3¥’i}fléf the 19:;
“E-4’ie5arz’:i : ceunsei, Sri,K,P, Shiva
Prasaéfior {ma ‘a;:g&iia*:§t:~~~’:nd sri, Ramesh Kumar, iearneé
” ~r.§0vé.f:§:r:?;s{ntV..?£e2aA$érv;**fn 36? read with Secticn 34 G?’ ti’_1..&__ ;e”§:§ia_i§°:”st*«'[
the said judgement, the accused: ars;-J éppgiaé; ”
6. Learned agvipeiiantsf geunseiv’C*:>:1tet:fié1t§3ét tfére
is absaiutaiy no materiai evieiei9i’i;Ve:’%’i:€:_Vbrii1§.’Aiétafiusigbetween
the acts cf the a<:c:u's§; ;i . argd efV'Airfi§.;ries by
fiacesaheb or MaA::§s§1a.'_…._§-i eV Manisha, the
ccmpiainarzt vébgariy aémitted she
reached assauiteé airzé
Vtai-can as an eye-witnéss
a:::mnt, ~ $§'miiari:;;%AAI%j§;é:_'¢:§§fi}:;'::cis that eviéerzce of PW-4 I
daes ,::@t_ inffiséh tévhfifiefiée as he aim reached the snot
' "'i'at ei*'; 5»*i??.'§tfi*;.."_:=eegaAi= éWit} nature bf ihjurlm mffered by
ccmtenticn that the injiiries ware found to
be A$–§.lfVr°}[:)i_E *§l:'§ fE'?:3:'1£UfE! and therefzzre, charge of effence under'
T """–. Ee;::tia2'{ SS7 of the IPC was impreper 3:13 the iearnefi Trial
A j;§udgé.~'has aisa seriousty erred in ignering materiai evidence
,;::_:f15 retard which disrneis aii aiiegatierss abaut intentirm in the
' mind nf the accused to km the '\.iiCZi¥'¥'1$. He wasufd corztené
aw
V' "c.r'dit:a'%yi»–.ct:u'rsAe at héiiite to cause death.
V –Vthat1'én..féf:e'ténce from Primary Health Centre, he admitted
K vtiaosaheb and feund fcsiiowtne injuries and he was
on admissier: ts the hc:-s;ftai:-
F \
K51}
examinefi a5 ?W–: and Dr. Deegieak: Madhukar Katttbie
examineé as PW-3′ 59th at thesa cmctérs have
and treated the victim pw-3, E
12, As per evidence at PW-1 — D2′,
when _PW–3 was groduced before
6,03 p.,m., he found the fc:¥i0va;.§’ng. i!’1j4i=i&’§’i;t2{}’S§-‘–:- ‘ t. V t. ‘V
” (3) Cat iacerated vv:3untiVt’t§}etr_theV’it-.. Qcéigttai
ternbcrai reéiera méa_$urind”s’*.Z’§; 1″: V
(b) Cut iacerateé°’w_<mm§vVé§aQ:t».€);S ';=:.Q.5 cm
ever the iefi:»5§d& G:.f'*t*§2€2:':h&$t»,'_" I
HeAdgscribed"t.hsé&..jh§u'ries 33 simpie in nature and
aczimits i.nLc:r«§fs'::{1exafnitiat¥6%: that they were not sufficient in
, %'"3,3; "'V".'T;'hé.:='é§}idence cf Dr. Beépak Madhukar a<amt:;e ;s
at
and his famiiy members. The Parties were agitating the
matter in cm: court is aise not my admitteet…ey.4'_:'the
accused but the accused want the Cetirt te
statement. In fact, the accused heiée
copy cf the document reiating pA'f'eeeed,ih'§e';~~;VVIt tsjaisc '' V
hot in dispute that e evhehnei theivheeiee ef A1
and Raeeahet: and hit feihtiiy usirsg the said
ehermei fer wete-;rfQttv_ irriéetiefittieit«.i'f€%.htt; accused were
unhappy cf; 'Vettfi Vtiterefere, they after:
preventeei**P\tif .ce«$i.eeti:igi wetert
'PW~3 was eeiiec;-tine water
the is1eiee:;§i§«i.tg%g§;:Veecutrieeitit'Free': this, it is deer that the
._va:h¥itfit§'~sity:'tzetweehthewaccused and the vietim is a geeesie
Vigfetit't'epné2afie:§i'v.Aij'u.errei between them and the incident in
rji.i'eetier:. ".3;}{it.7'vi1.8.99, the accused having feend PW-3
fleeiieetihétztiaiter appears te have attacked him. The pertior:
it "v~Itet:t'he..Abetjy chosen fer the attack is head and ieit parties: cf
ehest. The ebject usefi in the aseauit is axe.
'V V tthdeubtediy, when a person causes injury er: a vitai pert ef
the heady with a weapon iike axe, certainly, has to be
53%
;…$
J;.~.
is hit PW-3 and her overt act is oniy causing isjury to PW-2,
Tbs issrrzed Trisi Judge found her siss guiiiy sf4…§ffsrzs:e
uncier Sectisirz 30? of the IPC because she is _
suppiisd are is A1 regarding
svidsase is cc:z1vin«:ing=
v
20: Heme, it w::i:s.§.d bss”§’mstssis{_ is ‘fés’s’*nsr using
iémvisisn under Sestish far sttemst
an the fife sf fin the basis
of this .’;’;§;n%zi:;::sn sf A2 far sffencs
under $sCtiss.:’:ssfiiifi-§Vs«f impmper and needs
inierfsrsf.-..:ég.’_ his acquitted cf the sffense
unset sS’sst§s’:*:.V3&?VV:sf EEFQC,
‘{hs””‘s.;:Vs_s;tEvsn is what sffsracs she has
‘.__ssV%%ti:’:3§t*n:–ss;» j駣:a:.s:r*dir:§ is the prssssutisn and victim, she
ss’:.;ss<;i asses sisns an the "wrist sf PW-2 and dsctsrs
'have sssfirnéed it, She wiii therefsrs be iissie fer csmiictién
"'..fg2fiAVd'e::;Ss?stisn 323 sf the IPC and rust Ssctisrs 33?. is far as
ssncsrnsd, on ths basis of what is discussed shave, I
sis: sstisfisd that his sssvictisn under Section 30? cf the I?C
3:1,
;_.1
L2'?
is wsii bsisnssd, susssrtss by rsssssinss sf the is_s__mss
Trisi Judge ass E thsrsfsrs, ssnfirrn the same,
22, New ssmisg to the susstisr: sf ssiif’1%:s:f;r:s.},f’s-“‘i7: :..i’:§_:
seen that A: has been ssntsm:sd'”‘i:–::y If1rssfsVlj:iss–sssVs..A
imprisonment ans A2 hss seen se:r:fsVnsssi”fs if5*1gfs~s.rs. si:-.§fi;::vi’sV._
imsrisonmsnt, As discussed –ssj£res.rs t}”:s__ c;§r:srris–:Vshcés in ”
wfiish the sffsnss has bssfi .cis:¥éfi:T§iit–ssE”‘s~1i3;:ishe manner sf
csmmissisr: 0%’ dffsrrts} “‘sf:é”1V”‘rvsisvsst factors far
::sns§s’srstisi”:_V ssj,-.’;s ‘i2§s%1e{‘t%iisf;’t§1s ‘;».j2s7’rissi sf imprisonment
impssscivsssfi ss%jVV3%2″§s’_juss ssiici prspsr, an ssrssisszrins
sit facts ‘s:3s’– s¥rcgfr’;stVss’s.ss»,«.Vi fiimj the ssntsnss is fssrsh,
Hence, it nss§:isV_}f*sr:3Li’ctisn=锑3&.s rsvgsrds A; is csrassrined, sinss
” V’ i:s’§~r.é,§:’sss¥ssi..Adswri”ifisv charge frsm sffsnss snssr Sestisr:
“3__z’::’?_.tus–~sf._3g3 IPC and as sins is s wsrnsn, she is
sssissssci. s fins sf R.s,5,au’3Qi~ sis: sf which Rs,5U0/«-
‘~-«.__ s.i2sii ss” payable is stats and Rs,4,.5Q0,f- shsii bs said ‘is
yisiém Ls, Evisnishs -~ ?’v’v’-2. As far ss A1 is ccmsemssf,
have ssnfirmss the finding sf the Trisi Csurt thst hs is
u:.”ssiEt<y of the sfismts unssr Ssstisn 3:37' of the IPC, he is
ssrstsrzcsd ts 2 years rigsrsus isssprissnrssswi with 3 fine sf
as