Karnataka High Court
The Commissioner Of Income Tax vs M/S Karnataka State Construction … on 8 December, 2009
IN '1';----£1-:2 1--411011 C()LER'l' 019 K/\RNA'I'AK/\ M 13/\:\1<m1,<3R1~:
I")/\'I'I13I) T1118 TI-----11$ OE-ST" 1'»-xv OF m«':<:1:sM1.31«':R, 2(;'t'§é3'»
PR£CSE:3I\E'I'
TE Hi I--iON'{'3I.1C MRJ USTICIS KL.M1\N;JL£}NATi I'~
AND
*1';---11:: 1T10N'1-am: MR.JUS'I'ICE AI'{1xVlNI) V "
rm N(;.3é£.$j;;OO4 ' H
Bi£'I'W'}.€[£N: V -
1 . The C()1'11111issi()1"=e17 l1';(rI;V'_1::%*wi"a,$<V.A _
C.R.E31.1ilding. Qz:e(2n..-j§P§0~e1d' x AA
I-f3a1r1gaz1o1"L:,_ _
2. The i)€f3§L1[.§:fC(}:'I}t'$1iSaC5§i6I":C3§'V 01' I'1'1E:?'(:'1':iC--1.e1x
Assn? 5'-.43': fi&?.I1f';~ =Speci2j;-1 __ 1%}. 1j1g;§E?45'
C .R.I1311E.E;f_i_iV1;1_',<,__{. ROé.L'd V
App(=Eia11I.s
{By S1':iy1.11.l'1s§MVX/' S511;-:(rt':~:;1I2;z _&~K.V.A1'\:'i1"1(:1. :'\d\»*<.)ca1.cs;)
AND: M ; m
_K211'11a-1E'.zJi<:1 813116 'C<i)1"1si 1'uc.'i1'c')n
C0:'1:;{<.)1*a.{.i<')11 Lit}.
'V * _ 'N iv.r*_1_i'i~:1:g..j V1-3i2.;wa1'1'. V R2-:.jz1_j Vi :1ag'211'
§3;111g:«"1l<):fC. _ I{c:spo1'1c%c111'
' (By S1_"1"S,P;-11'*1h21sa1'21t.i1i. Ad\»'orc2'.z 1:?)
'l"l1iss'{1:1;_)g)i3z-1] is l'il(-'(:1 uxldea" S(:'.(.'1'i()El 260A of tn('r0rm=. 'l'e2.x Am.
§E3€§-.3__ a.;_'vi'ss'i:'1;-jg' 0111. of 0rd(*:' (I1£1l(-.'(l I.31-- i2~2()(}3 p21:~s:~s€-'.s£.a:':U'21i q1i('S1i()IlE5 01" iuw s31';1L:.=(l ii1£'~.r(>&1:. 2-IHUW
l.N(~':'2.1'].)j)('.'V&'Ef and SN zlsirio the o1'(i(?1's"e 1.')a1saSt*(§ by the l'I'z'\'I". i.32'1:'1g21l<:)1'c.=
in §'l'$X_« N().S}§I'3/B2i11'1§_.§/ 1998 ('iélififl 3 i ~ E2'--2()(}I3 <'<')11l'"iI'2':'2iz'1,<_§ 1'i'1(-= m'("1c:"
'of t'i'r (3011'1:I1i:s++ic)11t=:" and (%o1:fi1'1'1: U1:-* ():'(lm' ;.)2-1ss.1)n1_v (_3c>1'1111:is-.;s'siI:(=r of lI'!("('JI]]€' '§'a1x. .r\s-s+soss:':1Ilc.)wiI1_;;':
The (.'0m'1m'cr:'1I 1'ir1ding of the 01'c.'1(.*§'H
Comn'1issi(:»1'1c:' of Inc(_>mc T21): {1":.v'1J)»1A5>v<:»2-'1'l'.-"s},_V
f111'1l1er <rnI'i:':11cd by the Inp.on10 'TIBLEX.V_;'§1)}){§IVi_';'%1fr'v
I~3;mgz.il('>:'(r. in 1'1'/\ No.9I3/VI3':fi5}1V/E38 i:=,
('.'€l."{'.'C1 in question in sifxis z1&;.>i'.j'é-:21?"!.o"";-111swc:9"'i'h(" follm-wing
J{_s'I')GMI§N'i'
s31.1bsi.a111i2'1I- questions ()f'.I2iWi» '
I .
W'heE.1'1g::{:' 1hC 2-1';')1.3z;:iI.g1£'ef-,_z.u.iII"':m'iE.ics; \.v<.':*c
c?()1f;fé§%t §*°i1_i1 . '}«"1<.)'1ri_i11g. -- 11,1131.' We':
RS; '3:g85.30'3;' 3 '"199/c;_ V1'V1v121a'g";;nmoney earned by
'"i'hz:_AQj;$sc's'§:;C(% 'chjri1'1g;§ 1.Ii(*"m::"1"e1'1I. £1.95-§L'."-'-'»."s'!I'1t"i'1E.
y-3:11'.Cérxifiioi M .E.;)(.'.*r_t 1"(----:T11 :;'tl :15; an i1'1('0n'1c* 0!' the
'£1_S$(f"SS€C'. a--1"5: 'i1b_ '.l"1«:;1d Vnm. av("1"uc(i. clc:~.sp:'1(~ the
2.ts:'§§es$c:c'.VH:-112'1'1ntaiming 3']ICI'L'.J.i11..iIf';' ssys1.c11'1 of
V A'a,1<'<.:0L1:'1fi'ng___;3;'1vd Imving (ie(.'1z:-wed in Form 3CD
A .I{»:%1)1';a_f%. that it had :~.1<i%('r1'u ed'?
.'--.V'2."\'J_12--ci1ié1' rm». appellate aL1E.l'1c)1*iE.icrs xvere
-(":'(,'13'i':C'.(?'E. in
" __AR$.6.L"34.f:379/--
l'1oldi1'1_;__§ Ll'1z41t 21
cm pl eye con:1'ib1.1i'.inn
1.
w21:’cis PF 8: ISM’ paid bot;-1t.c(‘{Iy c.r2nmn1. be
{£isa.IIm\rcd L1!’1d(:*!’ sm’t:’e.:r1 ~/~’IL3B <)I'1..hc :'+.Lt1'.?"
W .
t.hi_s’ day’.
sum 0!’
.<sun1 oi'