High Court Karnataka High Court

M/S Rajarajeshwari Earth Movers vs M/S Mysore Minerals Limited on 11 November, 2010

Karnataka High Court
M/S Rajarajeshwari Earth Movers vs M/S Mysore Minerals Limited on 11 November, 2010
Author: Ajit J B.V.Nagarathna
 

 

E15???  '?§ 3, ii 
}g€§'£%i""'§~?? :' 1753} $3

32; 33% E~§£3>}£ %$§Z'%i§§'"':i' 23%' §§;&?;E%g%":"}%§{;% $5? §.£&g§§§'}§fi:i4{}:«R%£K:':"   "

§§;:'§'E£§ 2*§§$  2  my G? §%§:§}7%'E4}.'*<*€E}§.1'3g§        

FEE $§i»%'§'?;

'§'§$ E§§§%7'BLE   :§:::%§séa  



Em. §§:::§€§:.;§; E§m,;*::3%':**;:,f;'E.§§'é§;

 %§g;%,§e;?5é;;  L  I'

55

   %

in §g,§f.:é,,3?%».;.., ??£§';?';'?&$iE?%:"': %
§m'w§E=:§;"§§¢§&£::§§%i§§;§,fi§"3_"§§i§§3§E%§'é

 *1_§B§*'* 3&3: Iéag; fiém fa?
" ~ §gZ;%__s';%€§§§& £315: E§@§$§;

 Ei%;'  _ jégfira §§i:"2$E"%§§ Lémétssééfi

  ' --  ififimmg at 3%?
L' ' .. 'V L 'w ;'{:§,§9&§§ :  12:.

 -~ 3&3 E1;

 

 

E5: g%§§$E}Z&_:2f£

 



  

 

E ffi¥§; §+fi";<"fi§;?§ES 5%

%a:§:'3"E%'§="%%'?"'?';" iééifi §

   

12%' ggaaamag fiiéfg 23:23:: W gmssmfig '§1éiig§,,.Bfa§%'%}%i':*a;j
ciiszxzfwgizm E333 gfitiiiaiz ffiaé.  Sfiéifiiiifi  fif
fi:'?&im*a%3%}§3. ma fiafiafiiafiem $33. gig:   :13? "RE,

6» mmmm nu

 

§E"1WE§¥;'r._     

3fiE§E%§£Efl§E& ~ 
83$ fiamggiéagézg '    
figgagl &"§@rf;«*;;;%;.  j?;'z:%fi§'§I' _
:r?:%%:;; ;.:si§§g_%g<'%:   
B'é;3.:«_2**z'%§:;:":'.'-éétxuwii €,'3[:'§:a§?as«§
"§%%i3¥3§i§fi?*§:

 .2gi:-%z=r:;s;« W '$ai"§:éi1%._{3,~,";E;*E§; . E S §;§:}a§%z'2:

   

 {fag Sz'§$%%:§§§;:5;$§:§.;fi$gi§ fifivag gm
~ .. f  ':3;,2§~§$§Ea;§2;j':f%.:,§' Eigfigfi

'       .

 

* firaié Lfgxiétadg

  '  3. gm: ggm at 3%,

  

. fimfig fifimgaéayfi -~ 3% iififié,

  

    _  
    j
'213.{:.2:3:{.:% gassaa 33:: fi5A,§§€;,§5{E§§f§§%1:£Z§V_§:: :1fj:$ §;i§~   

 



' V V ' ' . 'V  m    :

4:  x $33.'.

 

3 2&5 
§§?&§é'??§§.:2:3

E=3f7§f§%fi§"E'E23e:§, $3; Em
 5  §§2"m%:3§*.
($['i.A.K ,Va$a!}th, AC.'-Vo 1:)

 

3%; fififiifiami mag; $32911}; 3&5: Sfifififiifigig, §§a§g:a:; ggaggggagég

 222$ gmfiiifizi ,.§"2_E$& VAV%§:3.f€:§§:r"'$§::'é;*;%$t§:1._.  sf

 

firiziiraiésaiz magi Qfifiéfiiafiefi'-:%l;:':A§;%§  §:~:;;gg;:;:' '1';

fizfifi $,§::s%::;%_  fa?' eéiéifiaiééijfigg 23% éayg
zigfffg  gé'; fa§€é%%*£ng:w
 {g§§§§§§§?

   3.3% agar: £2? mgetézer €32'

 £2Z§;n§§§$§f; __;  «V

A Lk Efi  f&;% $;$' Ee§g% géwggggafi  is saga fafarfiméé

fitasttzifi Egiafaaezz $35

 

"5"..m%:,é§~*§§;--f:@é*§ aggsgyaiiazzi fig wag $3 {ha rmmrzaiggzéz. with

 

   ' 

 jg fiiaaf u;':£$§*_,  
5..f'§§ifi'$;.?3:{}fi am: ijéfiifiéiiaiiéfi 533%; agaégggz :é;%:§:7 mic:  
22,E§;§€3§€:% gagzéaii 31:: fi,§g%§§52§{.%*E: §;"2%?'-}._{§"-$2}. 232$ %§:g% $2'; %

 



 

4 MFA 9475,/2010 3
MF"A947?,'201 0 _ 

2. The petitioner in arbitration _.  "     

No.25=O50/2010 is before this Coury   

order passed by the learned tr1a1' Judge  

the request under Section 

Conciliation Act, 1995 (for gfshort,   %%

3. The matter   

rm  is%'i:f%&kj¢I1*;éééd in an
processing of  The Central
  '  and Forests
IMOEF, for  undezr Section 2
of the Foj:-mt  1980 in favour of the
   """  temporary 

p-em' 113*    of Six montlna from 05.10.2000 in

 fav-éur.  had called for bids for"

 :the ore and Rchaitanya Kumar is the

 bidder. On the recommendaticn of

  Kumar, the respondent had accepted the

as the processing agent for Byndoor Bauxite

flz

E §v’.T§§.§3: %§’Z’§,fi.,’»’I§ ii?
?»’E§”§z%~’%=?°”?f’:¥§ 31 13

hiirgg fig az’: agzwmgfiz Ema bmrg fimtgzwfi £3223 _.__ A’

aha psiiéiméfir arm; €335 :*%p:.:::’:fia§:€; an ‘-é§z:=r

pmcmaizgg fif fiazzxiwf Lafirifzg

Eazzxiifi $, fi§;a?a.§$§ – 3 :3? ‘€§E$»%§$fi§§$$fi§

fim aasrm fif aw a a2.2£mma§;;:a§ }};:u $§§§1′:7§§f:{:@ ;mz§

{:§5:ra%£:.a {£2 ms §§?§€§§3.. ;f?’f_ %§%§§E§::Z:§g–.._§§.$%:%3§§$i$§3 frrxzzz
f*s§C§§? $233 §a*m1..:§’ fiéf %:”%’;.,§ ?§;$ E§§i’§fifiE gm

vgeriaizg gfirmigségfizfi réfégwfié fiéém _§a§§§}E;I’%’Cu§:fia§ Em Efitifif

gym %;.§.{:s:.,:2_§5§3%,% 5:’ ix

aka gym a§”‘fé:$”§§;%:§ 233%.: paiéfianar
mfi r%§§5:;3;a§.§e:7:a’£ $9323 §;:*:–._§§:l:*%% $533′ a mfimé af 5 ymm
wiih §ih”%§’§$f’ §x*§é§:;’;§§§§§::. 9%? $3′; izzmiaéaé Eifgifiiiéiiifififi
§§ V igaae fiffi %i$f”.!§@i’§ $§ Eaaaa

ié§.’%:%22.a*::’:::}’:2f§v rmgg fiéfifii ‘kg’ E%§§E§,

$9; saga fimfia 313;: E25; {E23 §>%iit:5m:3¢:*§

~~ ?§’E§§£ iéw rmpfixiéganz Ezaaé gm: sfiaémé

,: ‘i;&a;§¢;’ ‘§%2¢ gaiti fawguésafii $5 {$13 mfiggkiiéafifi ég atéii

fim

Q5 33%.

5 §a¢€?~’:% §$€:»’?§;*”C£*;§ES 3%
%.£E”5’x§i%’??f 3332 ET?

§%%§fi&r3:: Ema égafieé a éatafi

§i§§{E$,;?§ ii} éfifne

?:§:’::& §E*$’£§;E33L$:;a&3.” €:%’:s;%:: ma

mmt éamé & S Qflfififi $5 $33

§§.,§§g§i3E%.7§g “§{‘§’m gfiéjiiimzarf apgz. :m:z_§a§”‘v:§a’-§;::%§,;’§;%:%;fi.AV ”

fiat the fflpmifiami can-.”§m% ;:*£:§1§é:
u§1:;@::e:m}§ 3% aggfimeargi is s:i§§,.’é:;4.__ff@§’i€fi$%§:§a%g,§€:4;%&§:$g §:§§:%<%$nmi1:gg_ ii fig 131% Ex Ekffififififi

ma '«3;§:§;§§§ $3: $;§§§3§§&3:.i:3z:§ :m%g;,2 was fiéafi

" 3%?

1 & 2 Q? Eha Caéa af ififrvfi

” gfméé wit}? fimiéms % £3?’ €223 fiziri far %:$m§.>§:’a,fi§

3% ffifiafii iézfi ywfiflfigrzi and 33% fifiégfim §u

“”‘ii:a*.sm§3§¥;:s;:33_i agfsgé rmmnéefii E2233

§§”§E?fi.. §¥§?§,=-“‘§§E,$ 3%

%:E§’S’§«€» T??_;’?ZEE §

%m§§:i:§ flag ‘fififififi r&s§&’i: af ‘§:’1;fi

ifiifififi asféfiaz” wag mt gafitfi azz §5g%,§%§§s. _..7§f%i%;§:§:’:§,”–.:§’2$

gmfi a§§§%£a§:.£.,§:’: %&,::am::;§ ‘- :m1:a$,:=__ it ?T
Gfiiiimaéfiéfififiéii hag imam §.$§°§£.%*;§ €E’:§_’,é”-&$;::1:*:«i§..;§2′?::>_VV::2::f§;
§éx{%§Ki?;;§§;§ r:@*:.z.%ti:§ 2&3 in

gufiwgéii 1&3: @523; _

2%’ $&;%é;’«§§7.z*§3§§s§:£i%:% é:2§%£3;§ zhzfim
$3 an fiw3%% fifgg giiiiflmfirg

a§}§$?,;.};$;:: gfaé M%;§?$§.?;?V7:§$ _:}¥$$§f;:$$§2$:é:1i¥;i fax’ 3, gifififfisfi €35 §

graaxfi fifiz %.2*t£’–‘:a2~ yaam $32 mzziziai
2*:%$::*a::’:$:’3%fi fiéfiraiiégg €51: Eiw §’&%e§K73:’§§%3:’§.’i; {ha iémg és

Q? Eieiiar {sf

fig €315 gm fig £35 –

§:”z?2;é:*:’£” 332:3 …é;£:::é;f§§§§%g§}g $293 Ema fiiégfiaziaiaé: 323$ Ewan

the gamma :3

if: gm ii:%::€=:§ flaw; 2§x:.:§2s:’::;@, ‘§’h§
Efifi msgrzéfi ‘ES %5i:2-:2″ fiatfi
miizi mqazagiwé 231$ raggmrzaazzi. Egg {Egg iattar

§;4¥§§-.2E:§§;% §:§ §1§§§ gmazaai Em” fianhfmzimg

/X.

3 ;%§F1i%. §%%?§;’:E§’3E§ &
§».e§?§z%=%?’°?’£’ §

‘aééi Q. firfi émiséaaziz is mézazxs

réfimgéazz”: fir: ma ifiiifiéf zfiaissfi §§,%%:§{.T%E€Z? éyazézpmgfzééé. ‘ A

pfifizfimg témi i:%:..a ‘- Erma ‘r5

dssaéséma hag m Tm mézgzfz in fim Eéa§§”§§ §él&1i§€:s;?”3;§.@fi§”.

fismgazzjg mg the mmériier “§m*9
ménirg ea iififiifiififi, ‘E”‘;:’:fi aazm gfié ga:§;s§:£_;a:i¢3 is t§:a§;§ yégisfi
Emving itmm eiagsfi; {Em gééf

maasizrs %3..:3:§§r’ :§ :31? %f::r;_:§?a$%;4V%€;§’§§f2§VV,§ie9′: égriaa.

Z?’ ‘A fssuzgéi thaé; {Em

geagazaamygagypagéians ; .’ 23:1: 3 §f§m& fagéfi
mm a-:’*::i_ .:3z1$§,”$”‘:i:a:V_” E33′? af wzfiflrzimcég Eiagzmg

mmimi

;gg:;%$$ggLagm §?i§§§- 3
fa: agwiffimi =g%E3£mm”§§_i}* $°:.3f§m§m with

flaw -~ .3 ea? Ehé agfwgmfimi {hat fizg

agwiiant wag ffgfifi 2% mm’ amt

fay a wzfilmé sf Em mgirzétéfi mag azzmmafigzraiiygi

[

g §a€;2′<:& a:s«é?§g;.%§:§ &,
"?'?'§ $332}; $3

m:*afi?m:.;m fifié §§m*a;%:%& d 233.3 §zer*:i§§ 9? ..

gwrmésaiazz Ema: §€§@E~F§ Eisrg fazrféwg" $13;§3E'§3;i"€§§ iiégfikv '%

Eaaw grifié Q? S yegm iéffilfifi szgmmzéfia §:?5:gz;":%*;£e'

a:*:$::.?:c:..%.'i:'§.:§§; 53%' fits $213233 §%&s%§ _§§}':i{%i?: Ea g*:§;§§_I1; i%g.::::ii£:z*1–4 '

ggmzaégas Eififiifflé, Em auknim agifif gééfisgé %
ggafarg is 33:2: zyami Ea "§%.2§€§§§;<:7:*._ §a3.'%;i;":;i%§; kiééié § sf

fifim fiat 334% ax: izzmrim :*:':&a$::}:fe_ ifigmrjg is Em

samgafi 31$ E-'Ea réféfgészai is: cgfiam

mfimgnfiawfifi §;%3€:%a;§*a$3"g T'§{'§:aé;:_ mid 'EEE-2

r@§§w:*,§.§$:§:;.,."m.::*;%; *—g:'§:::é;az::i 3%' aiéafiq is that,

Efiflfifi §ima :_s$': fi1§'§"."%§.§"§§y 3% wauié aéaa

§f§.?E?¥§%'354%Ef»» 4§:.f:;§:§' :E9§:&i:~ .'§{§%3§.§$*é:§%;f.iz;::§:* Eggs a§;§'€&§i:§ ffimi a

é;;;;:2*§;:$é:1§3§2.2% mi' an m*§2:%::=§f%:23z§ mafia

V&!:,.-i:§§:§2 E3 ::;a?:;'%§§;g:%

K 3% u Ezma 93$':-"saw irks: §&§}§f§3 g%§§a:*$:::§:;'§

–“‘i1T%f§f€;%w fig: £3 £33 335% $1? ihfi :z::2″°” aé méégf air; as mum};

T mag: Emffiira §:*

35:9 £2: &§’§}’ afiar

233%: az*?§i’:3=aE figs

mt: §;§*%é’@§§. ( ‘mfara E33: $3

./.”

 2    'gm 
1::  '

c =~TA%z9:2:.’_§2′.;2.i§;::”.£%73:.::*.,::f.::. am ?:E_

33 zaggm ;;%é»E”§§$§.’:Efi &
%:§?:%,%&;??; 231%

€§’E§§LS in gmazfiazm grit}: ?E?fi€£iaé:’: 3% fif 231$

ta iéha Swat’: $23? Sififiéfifig m.$&&2:;2*%§ *§3::§i:,1f§’v~a;,:’%:izf:

fim namm sf irszerim §2fi, .A

{;*»§;%”£3″&1:*:E§:$£.E’.%{;*-=%, figa ma @:::§;:*;z*::e¥a:i__ *§§é;%.’::.V_ §§s:~’:::r:i::’.::’: ‘f’:1%f§§{a:;§_i§
whisk is $2″: rmmat sf gram $5 iéétgféxgz §;*z§’§;;:é{:*§{im1. gmfi

%2′:§»;:2:’; §{a§ :3?’ £23′: 32.23% am

m§§m%2::§gr::, Erzéméfiéxz’ m 7%

mgsgigma % ; $5
‘§§?§§£¥iT’;§1 wauéfi
E53331 $.33 _ I whéséz aamai ‘ix
§:2§.%=E%§ gm am 3%’ fig
Efifiéi? t.?i£a?§.”<_§%§§§§$}£zi§£:' 32% 32:21; fi§§§}§$&E}§§ in as
$5 3%" & afimitramr £33 {Ex

£5 "§'T§§§_€§§.Efi€§iafifi§< Emgiwég fiféfii" 332%? Eufim 1

ii? the gwfi an %3afi§
223% gafit af

§m3§§ iha §T§f§fi$i§

Em % m';::£$§§&?;a& 'aafgre &@*

R : arfigz £5 grfizéifi $3 agaam," gt aha rmgzégiemfia

u-

./4′

3; Es-€§?5é *§%?§;”2fi3′.$ 3*;

§’2§§’?i§%??§§2%:éE§

Ek mew fi§ gram; 3%’ miarim imémnfifiafl §’a;.§E.._”§:;;? ”

§:3z*§i§$§*a’;i:§§f: %:~$f§3*<§ ma §@'§..§§§ éf Egxrfis ii': :E;;;&; v_':::::i«;.§::'.§.A_T.§§7<

fimfifitfifi {:33 5'? 2." 2:11;"

raw

gage wag 37:’:%:&:*§:*&’:a& in ‘aim §%§E§*§§i:z§g”~:::§m:2:3£§:”– ‘ ”

*3§:*z’z§’sa fafig mmgfifigjg? §’&;’:&§;aj{‘&’§;:%§;.:’§a&Ts,r:a ‘gm
ga $§’é3..§§%% ::§fim§F*£§__ fin:-gag –$!eg:v;§§%e_ $12; wag
§ fifimi $33 §L<%:;§§:$'f2§Ef::'§ z»s,,..%._" 37$ ;a2s.;;§.§g.#.¥:¢:.a§;vv~C§wgm am
aazviéar §§a:a£:agg-4'§:}..'§\§§– 3; sfiatafiaai
a§§i*§:'§::'-its 5éai§;:.:=ejz:7f§5:%'%§§mas:z§? ha

gig-,:%$;§:

_ “E aixaesé ééstfiiééafi 52:: mg Exam:
finéfié; gapfir £2-iéflfiliféifiiiiééi {sf
fiiifififfifiéé fig it ifi $33
§fi tha rééwfiiéi $2 sfzf ii;-*é&1§:&,

” . héfnéa éfigfiaaéa is gisxfia gfizsgigsai azzizzraa-3
€§§,*a3i;§.P§3%:§%i::§f’V’m§’§ 333:?’ fiem a haméygiymw fii’

AA gi:§’:?es’.;2:;E.:§:%§;$ %s..,1%. §i§i§$ fiam 5 £r§§;§E§mm7 3?
‘ _ V §g§;::’$§§:;§§.s§ 33:2 ‘2.:§,3’:§ Efi gas? 3%? sf iaatiziag

bE%£%_ ifi ‘me gag; 2%: E £5 gag m:3.§£§;%:°

gzafnm §°§,&§£ fififiéi fig? ifififimazzi 31$

Samgm’ «$341»

? $1 $3 “:§’;?§{:§ figmzamkg. fafmiéf ‘.

%%:$§§:l§§*::.~3:§’i
/

32 ‘;%’§?”:”% ;’Z3%?”fi,?§£§§€§ 5%
§z€f%%§%??§:E§3é$

kfiszfi, whiéa mmifififigzg 232$ acxgge ff f.é§z}::§$ 3

gage in ?a.%% émgzémii $5 fi?.Z§.?3’@i8-a :3? :§é§_a:*&;fi§§r’:3>aé’§ igfzguw-;£?é1*.. f

gm: iiiigaarégm eréfif $23 gszighz ‘Z{§:;.*’§3§§ £3
fim Saar: mam: m §a%§”i% ‘%:Z_E*’;;a gm:
‘*é%’§&§’.;-‘§%}’£§§5 iii aiimf _ 231:2 Vééifiaus
q1;%’§Zs§:gtg&a2z*ée£,_ V b h » ‘

3%. “§”§m §2i..f§…§:*’§£_,,.’f°’;§aé:;;’u “§5:fifiWafi ‘w§£t.”2

z*£§a:’§;+::$§ %;!$é’;”‘T’é;%*%:§i:}§§%?§V fig iafmsaé as

it is $31.33
s:::%.t%§§*m:i Vf§;%:a%:, iii? §£”:}:§.§,,§’E£A’«”§i:_i$§:.i”f§. $§3$i2%§ %& afifiwfifi wizaaré
?:§::**m@§A fig ‘£23 afisfiéiafig ratfiaéga §

gaafiagfii; E35; am

§£§;?§;i§§§;VV”‘%f§€§§39:§};?5€;§f;$%§a% 5:33;’

:2, .E::”:%:a;’: aw: $32 iimg aami agaég ii ifi

fl mmkammfi fifiigafimz gbfigzaifi 33$? Ea

.-

%; 3% an ggfier Q? ir:’3?3.:.:§§::*m:L Enfisaaéfi the

3% §s§’§?..§i §’==€>”?§:$.5’3§ ES %
?=a§§§%i3é~%’??; 2:} E §

pmfiw aw m

“gay tfém ififizsgaa ~«« 3 sf E323 A’

kéégafig %§é'”§”:§fi mzzgififififi fie: gwgg sf §m%.%.ma§'”$§::t.f.§;¢:”_::;’:§;.s=$AiT.::’i:2.i 1

9:3 ‘3:

$5 aaxaraifia Q? §:a:§$r’~.=::’£i§31;gr§y.$’f;%;¥$5:g:* ‘-gag: f

&§}§E3iG&°’2i£:§% 533 smzgéai;

safigfizefi Ttftmt. ?;;§”;g flgim is :29′: ¥@i§§i§%;.§§ $.35″; ?£;»r’*i:,%f:é% wégrfisg
{Ema fiism ég Sfzfifillfi §°:2§$§imif€{$

El “§’§;¢ $§,,i{§.._V ‘j::i::aaE§§@:z fi;2:”1i3′:vi;.§¢§: V’ §j§%§:”‘*x;«& wit}:

refamzas:-a €33 *§§’§’w{.é’i§°2g:-*§:4 ‘ ‘A V ‘§% tayfié as
aéfiuaifi _ mg 32% fzzfgésfir
$§fi zéégt 33¢ fismziié fig aligwasafi; whfiré

ii Afxamifiis-¢f a;¥,::- afififiam ffiifififigfg Efifiéaaég téimt

@$.n§:§é&§§:ai$ fa? :-=1: ‘gig %;;§:m ‘

Amgfi mi’: fig wg am gi’ ‘$23 viw fiat

” §”§.§§f1®§§ §§’¥;?.fiE.E$.f7§;’%, ‘:3 $3 thwa

€:;€z)£:<n: §s*':a:§fi:'2, Emfifig, %:§2z,=';

VT W 3 3f fim .

aw mimreé kg:

mm}? Ezzéiwfi WE Ezagifizz is afié

49%

gfi. §§€Z§*?.§’%. ;$é?§,:’§§fiE§ 3%
E§¥”§a§4%?’?’;’3:?i;’§

rim: Wfi are {Em z;:$:;*3E*§% $5 iézfi :::assa;–4.A’§3§§V’:.

am zmifgz fixazmixaizg “f;E§’3;§ Sfiflififiiifiéiifi wig: r&f@zf’€?.%”:%_:Tf;».T.%:’;%”;¢:

grargt sf i:1_§2;1§3;::E:§m;: &i% am é22ze&rEm m$_f§§u;mA ‘§};iI:§.;’3f_iaE1.”:*_”§f.’Ei.@I;’.;:”§;.Zi’.i”;¥.;1 f

§ :32? 23325: @132. E3: ihfi $3; fiériaizg m::»a;ggm§;.e:zg

‘m’E:wa&&:: fim 1% £3 ymmérfi ‘§’Em
figs: $5 flag 1’ fmxfi. H the
fifimmfif a§:;paE§§::%_i$ ;'”:§;3§,§$§E§§§,
Wiih ffiffigfiréfifi ii: fig a faafi:

than: fix far a mazearaé $1′
at: __ – 3 Efizimig §$’f:.:&§* filatafi;
§;4~,§%;2§};§ “§”%§k’§;!§§.§§fiE’§.”§ by ‘$26
ggfiéegfigzfifg’ gggfifiéii fiégg ggaié $33 2:33. gamg aflmi,
ufiifiga iwfi Eagmmg a mmmmfimfism fig;

ifiguécé $2′: Efixi:”@?E§};€3 slzzaigéfiafixg fimt

53:3 §sa§§£§§&z”:*£§: :13 vwzsmfi’ fig azzfimzzé mxiiiizg

._:s:é§:*éV.g;”:rra,e €:.%:i2s§4_§a$;§€§% Ema Qxirsma Efi 52:: fiilii East. izmgfimri What is

_Va:7§g§i2i”§é:;az§: fig 5% mmmmnimgéfizm égaam 3&3: 2&3

‘V ‘ résafipéfififizgz Egg §§*2§§§ magzgei Sim? ‘i:%zs.~3 mafia:

*8 § Eiilgfi §«’3éL?§,§5.2%E$ &

$

Ea%§’é».=?<~??'?; a

iikaiy im 3% yiamafi. %§§:'& thfi §$§&"§ ifi? éégiauggimfi

§€£i3§2§=§§§1 23:1 i'%E.i%=£ $3' tha §§fi'£:'i*5€L§if3i'3;fi§f"$. 5 ;. é

G-amm3;§.z®§.'%;§.§m fifamé §.§§§§R2§3i§ %'%1§:S§§.. b

afiflifif 'i§§%.3§fi aim izzéiiaaia fig: :2:::;"€§§_g ;3;5.,g:.asr:;..§fé<§i§<;:" §;a¥"*t$9.§§é§ez§ ;, A'

mam aim agmg aim

$g{fi:?i_'j'&§:32;§z;_¥_ E?

Eifzévmfig ‘§«?¥€i’ sfiffi ef tééé fiw {Erma Ihfifiii :19:
§.3″?$$3€§ ‘§$’I§’§.”§.’%; mfemnm ifi if ;&– arzé. :3:

bag ‘aawza

};:§2″ – . féfiasg ‘E’;§°:€:

azzfirimgmzzfiaimg 2..§£ f€§i::~§§ ‘kiwi {Em
f&%§§§”§€§§2’1’§§’§ __€–§1€: &§;t’tEfifi’Ei§i’fi;; in ma

-z

fiat flag mafia” ia
fig; _§T:’:% — .?§::>$Vf$§:’§: %%§§: Eéfifiis fifiafiigsg Ea: gag

fizfaig fig?-%; :§”§§r§_f%%..i§%§;:§;’i’§;€§€§§’%E&§; $§i§::§z§:’: Q2′? maria Sf ‘£332

$%§’a:*.::?2-32:”; i§Z”:§:;5%’_*a,;*:%§:~T;;¥?’3 2%? Eéfi gégmemfiizi £3″: £3 zmzgh sag it

gs Em: ga in§z:gy§rs:a§ E? aim £:*’§’3é”;ra§§:* ?%§§§% wézfim

iiégfiiy is aygwgfg £3 £3 magi”; asa flag

$§§eE§@:1″i: §f E% m fiflffiffifi fix firm fif fix

‘ay way gf 3 sgméfia wfiggmzw, it £5 aka ;

/

3% §<'é'§"§_f';?§3§
2%? f:?*§??§§%:3ii3

gr .

gyms; fir fig pe’a’§fim:£2:*§ agfiééamé; ‘m 5333: mzgh g

bfiffiffi firm §:§”?::%§f€§”§;§,§§’ ii? $:”mi§$§?§§§ Ziiéiififi’ :;9:;{;:::”%§;§ % 1 ‘

fiéifi’