C S Goudar S/O Sadashiv Goudar vs State Of Karnataka Rep By Its Secy on 7 August, 2009

 s-> .

m '1'i~§E HIGH Comm' 0? KARNATAKA 5 T 'L
cgacurr BENCH AT DHARWAD;   if'.  J" Q
DATED THIS THE 7TH DAY; ..A;Ic:fii$'r' :é«'f;;:§ §'   
PRESE§T«:m':A--V,x : 
THE HON'BLE MR..ms*r1c:é:  2s,z.g:1~1A'NV- §H.aN*;"*;§r.:igc:-£;.:3%§§AR  "
THE HOINVBLE z§::'1éE=;. MGARATHNA
WRIT wP'13?TIT:IGE'E   (:3-KAT)

mwmmy     

1. (3 S c;~(:m)A1=:: 'sic smgsnlv GGUDAR

z">_»,GE:'5:>. YEj'ARs..   '

SECRETARY"  "  

GRAMA E;=g:*ecI~iA¥_  BIDRAKAN

V . siangmaa TALUK,
,,  uTrARA':<.ArJNAr:A flISI'RIC"i'

PAޣ%MESWAR L HEGBE
 _ Sm ¥;&.X§fiNARAYAN HEGBE
 ._ . AGE.:,_ES8_"E'EARS
' SEE;?R}T'ARY, GRAMA ?ANi3H&YA'F
 R_]{}~.I?i0-ENALLI, SIRS! TALLIK
,.U'i'fI'ARA KA-RNADA nzsrascr

 V.  QAWA T DEVALAMAKKIKAR

 S] G TARA T EEVALAMAKKIKAR
AGE: 51 YEARS
SECRETARY, GRAMA PANCHAYAT
JANMANE SIRSI TALUK
UTTARA KANNADA I3iS'Ti'RICi'

 



4. M I SHEIK
S/O ISAK SHEIK
AGE: 52 YEARS
SECRETARY, GRAMA PANCHAYAT
KAVACHUR, SIIDDAPUR TALUK

UTTARA KANNADA D1sTRrc:f-E" . A 

5. LAXMAN M GAONKAR: 
S/O MAHALAGE GOAN'KAR_
AGE: 54 YEARS  " _
SECRETARY, GRAMA PANCHAYAT
KOLSIRSI, SIDDAPUR '.-f"AL13K.,_ , 

UTTARA KANNADA"DIS?_1_2E;(:T   .. 

5. cHAN::)RA;:x§NTr1"s";~:.é;;Ie:"  ''

8/0 sA9A.smVA~.%NAIi-;_  ~

AGE: 51 YEARS" 
SECRETARY . ' T  
GRAMA PANCHAYAT, *K.jAN(3»Q'13«. 
sIRs1TALUI<"=.__ " ,  4 " 
UTTARA .I{ANNAi".I}A m3rRv1c'I"'

JA$ivI0£§'«i»1 4C~D2UvA   %%%%% 14 .
»s/ ,0' MAI£AhIALA'GURUVA

AGE: 55 YEARs'%'  " J
sEc_Rfi:irAR¥"«..,,_ 
GRAMA' PAN::i§;§';'AT, SA'ii¥NAKO§'PA

  $IDAPUR  .
  U"Iu"I'ARA mrgriana IZ}§8'I'1"~ZIC'I'

 4 Ram-i1M}<:I;iA1\I A BHAGEWASI

"S/0 AHMEDKHAN BHAGEWADI
'- _ 'A233; 53 YEARS

"SEQRETARY

 "~<:;RAM PANCHAYASI', HEGGARANE
* --.S5{DDAP£IR

U'I'TARA KANNAQA II)ISTR'I(3'I'



A 5.; M    Q

HARISCHANDRA R THIMMAPUR
S/O RAMA 'THIMMAPUR
AGE: 51 YEARS
SECRETARY
GRAN! PANCHAYAT
EDALLI, SIRS: TALUK
UTTARA KANNADA DISFRICT
GANAPATHI K NAIK 
S/O KERIYA NAEK
AGE: 55 YEARS
SECRETARY , .
GRAMA PANCHAYAT  _
SIDDAPURA  "
UTTARA KANNADA D!ST§3iC'i'.   

V _      PETITIGNERS

(BY SR1 DAYANANVp.'sA,_P.iTi§}V, Aiitzi-;)_~: 

STATE 01?. 1<;aR1'=§A1*AKA

f uR$PRESF;I*ITED BY ITS SECRETARY

"  RURAL DEVE-LGPMENT AND PANCHAYAT RAJ

IEEPARTMENT, MULTISTORIES BUILDENG

"  _ }3AI~ECx'AL£)RE-S60 om

"  T:-§1»=iT§V§§r§U'rY SECRE'1'ARY(lZ)EVELOPMEN'I')

ZILLAFPANCHAYAT

" ,.U'§.'.'I'ARA KANNADA SISTRICT

f~i!%§F2WAR

 'THE I_i}§RE(,'f1"OR ( PAf'JC}{AYAT RAJ}

65 EEK-OFFICEO DY. SECRETARY

T9 GOVERNMENT RURAL DEVELOPMENT
ANS PANCHAYAT RAJ DEPARTMENT
MULTISFORIEE BUILDENG
BANGALORE--56{} 001



11.

KUNDARAGI, YELLAPUR TALUK
UTTARA KANNADA DIS'I"RIC'1"'
ASHOK N. BI-IANDARI

AGEQ ABOUT 47 YEARS   -T
GRAMA PANCHAYAT SECRETARE
NEGGU, SIRS! TALUK   V '
UTTARA KANNADA Drsrggxcrr

MANJUNATH V. fiEGDE""' -  '

AGED ABOUT 5e_Yi=;ARrs  "   
S/O VENKATARAMAN.A§jE-G}DE' ;   _
GRAMA PANCHAYAT--sE;<:fR£:TA.RY '  ._ 
DEVAGIRI,.'KUMFA"TA.EgUK ;  A
UTTARA..1mNrrAaA rmrazcr  V. 

ANANTH  ,HAvaG0i:;%1 '  

AGED 'AB'G{:ET 5e_Y5:AIes«  .
3/'G'T'GA1$:-EsaégHAAVAGQLI _ 
GRAMA PANCHAYATSECRETARY
NA}3U_ M,2,s1<Ei~2I;'i~:U:s.4fI::x TALUK
UTTARA. KANNAIEA DISTRICI'

; UMAPATH1 G 'HE('E}DE
 4-*.,A<3_1:«;Du Aaofimas YEARS
 é  sir; GANAPATH1 HEGEDE
" ~ _ VQRAMA. PANCHAYAT' SECRETARY

B£§LB.A,," KEEMTA TALUK

 --.VU'£'TA'?fA'AF{fi.NNABA DISTRICT

 cH;i§N':ji§AHAs V HEGDE

3m':.vENKAPPA HEGDE

- AGE): MAJOR

V  *ۤ--RAMA PANCHAYAT SECRETARY

'  ALAKODU, KUMTA ';mLm<

UTTARA KANNADA DISTRICT
 RESPONQENTS

VV (BY SRIYUTHS K.VI[)YAVA'T'I, HCGP FOR R1~R3,

ASHOK N. NAYAK FOR R2,



HEGDE NEERALAGI an PATIL FOR R4, R6-R11 AN13v.;§1.4~~..
AND  4,   
K. PRAKASH HEGDE FOR E44213,

MRAYAN V. YAJI FOR R14, A9vs.,)

THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILES UNDERA' '{ fI( iLES.V2'.?V6" " V

8:. 227 OF CONS'i'I'i'U'I'iON OF  inpm "«_TP;§A3f1Hje;,V_" _'m
QUASH THE ORDER m'. I1.'?u20?€}3'~i'N Awzfu. N0';1-2:929

TO 1939/2900 FASSED 13Y__THE* AH0N'B1.££--%A K.AF£NAfI'Ai{ " _
ADMINISTRATIVE TR1BuNAL--,,.__BANGALQREVA vn:§E' ";am~1Ex.A' V

AND 1:«rrc., 
THIS WRIT PE'ifmoN  Q{)Iv$1re§§~--.oN FéR  01235393,

THIS DAY MO!-IAN'  MADE THE
FOLLOWING:- V '3 . '  

 the  E31" the writ mtition, the direcfion

is's§{1édL.by thé  Administrative Tribunai, Bangalere

'V 'A  Nos.1929 ts) 1939/ 2000 was considercci by the

A  . E:"§.i:_.;-ztiz  After consideratrioa, the respondent No.2

»-~”-r_1_:he Government has concludcé. that the scrvictc

AA 1;’je:1:r5t:i…r:’:;-.”.€,««fi by responritmi: News! 4 to 7,5 in the post ef Bil}

“Cfiiaiiectorj ciztrk cannot be taken into acceum: hr the purpose

” for seniority, in View of the cenccmed Rules. ‘Thus, the order

of the Karnataka Administrative Tribunal is aimady

implemented. if that rvizspczmdent Nos. 4 to 15 are aggieved

¥'”””>

_ 3&9′

by the order 0f the State Govcrnm€:3;1t dt. 18.5.2(3{?”F._, it is

open for them to pxncced in accoréance with 1a§;§f”¥V§:§:fc-u{fi::.V’tI:1e

apisropxéate femm. In View cf the State

cit. 18.5.1206′? nothing s;111*sriv».:f-s””i11«« this V’

Accmfiixlgiy, the writ petition :33 ”

became itnfinctuous. The _of f;1f1c*.__ bé

coxlsidered in accordance gffiiisposal of
Writ Petitiou, Misc. jsdvszjcg and Misc. w.

No.6 1590/ O9 _$is.::-_r3.ot tV'<§£¢§:()z'1$id:j.i&§.€:4aii{)n.