High Court Karnataka High Court

United India Insurance Company … vs Sri Palani on 18 August, 2011

Karnataka High Court
United India Insurance Company … vs Sri Palani on 18 August, 2011
Author: A.N.Venugopala Gowda


gm 7% E€§G§~% cam? 0? £~<ZAR§a:?ATAKéia A? 8;%?'~éG&é_i"}?'iE
mmm @3413 ms 18"' am' if}? msugfi,

EEFQRE

"mg §~i€}§\§"8é.E:' MR, JLESTECE saw; VENUGG_?*~£aL§:£§'2%E®,§ _ '~

MESCELLANOUS FER$"§" AP@m.L1.§a§Q,-:?fi.;:3é;<3{339-{é;a;*i:;__

BE'"WxiEE§'s3:

N am:

firarsch Qfféce : Ch§CkB§”§E–§Q”3EU;T . __ _
Ragyesented by its Dév§§£5oé’3a§ Csfféteé
Bfifioad, Shimaga ‘–

Repregented byiécgs fiéviggiG£’§a§:’V.?~’Ea.§fé3ga?_§f ‘

Uzéétéd Inééa Insuranca €jiQmpa.:*:’§; L.’§_%”s°:§:’%:’:Lr_§.

._ _ _ « .V ,’,APPELLfié§\§”E'”

($3; Sri ;53s,§”‘]’§?xf§6:?3_:’é§B i’E?:’3’_Ef}, 23%-:2_7j–i–\{_. ‘ _

fi¥”x§D”

2* Srwaéamé — _ 4′

gm T”‘E*;.E_r1a§;pa .

_;f%,!@wSh§i;a;’ £’»”:a:’Ti<e%:"-Rciad
.. «.§C§"2é{:£<a:§2ag"2::–§%.;;j ____ H ,

_V %'a§:<§g'»e;':;a'::_v'=1,$s:5;vii_;?*'%a Samgcéga Egtata
'§v'§aj:":?:5:fi' Cffiasfgza

— .”«.§'”§E:%?V’§’§;,?§V§’$’-§’§!f::3V§§§ 5393?
A {f%éE::§<a %§i:.:fa§a§a:;'
" ' HRE§?G§'mEra§T§

aéégmgshwar 3 Sfiagm & 'xférzafi ammaf zamsx my 9::
T 'm:§.§.?~; ;;§fane:;;m:;a:a,:v2.@, 523»: 'Ear $2}

Tézég Eviwa £9 flied under S€€§é{}€"§ Bfiii} 3% E;':f,C,fia€i

fiTa7g§5:ng: aha mar éaiefl if',:3,E3.2G€}8 yams $5: 2fi¢£;'a; ::

'..,,.~Q2

wéiizén 33 Gaga frag: we 531:3 {if €)€'§€!'" am in cage sf

defa::§tr Ea pay interest ai: 12% far the de%a=g*e:j"'«{§}fer§'i::::§,

This aggeaé by the mgurance mmgany is 3ga%{{::t V§E:"{fev:.?:'z§'r:§?é';<A "

to degegét wmgensatéorg er? R.S1$4g!.:.§é;:V§1'/!.":4:l

,2. Sré A.£\/§.\.r'er':§<ate:~:h_f E@a:*';":.ie{2"– z:QsL;.ej2§7?:A§.Vé§pé§§s*i:*;+;; 'g

for the aggxeiiant, csntezéfied ' E§?:: a t; _theV"§;V§'C'V':ha'§:§ eweé fir:

haéflérég that the i3€":§OS§i Ehé
gomgensatéors of submitted
that the $055' been arréveé at
33%, the: 'waz;Ed wark wt to
Rs»Z9,S';S§/"';A»..:gV;jVdi?§VVé;§y§éA.;_ mm_o'§§§E't'atEon 9? the émpzggnefi

{}E'fi@§'&

3v,"'LTeam.é'<i–Vggggfisei appearing far ihe 2"" £'€E~}§Z}€}§E§t':L"T3'3Z

»$§;§bmé$::e§M :.?'; 3f:,__ rm interfeierzca wéih the émpugned erder és

" (;aV§ 3% –. V V 3

Exfésl E5 the éasazaasse miéay, "fie am;*::§§ye:"

AA§'¥é–{}5f.'%Z'2§Z}§a%E"'s€§§ :':zgs;:'am:<3 gaéiay' £Q\:'%?§§§§ {me ask 5}? ES

__$%%""s"1$§8'e,f§§S 'gy shaarasmg tizaér wages 3': R$_i,%S,fi{}G,f-7 gw

1

3:2

J fix”

..a «a ,

— £3:-“::fi¥L€g:na§ zgréar %$ afiasdéfésgik 3

‘J1

the risk 9? 2% emgzimyeas ghzxwing ma isiaé z»~zages_..;;§f ES

€:z”:;:»§@yee§ at R§¢§.,€_”}Q,.€}G8/~ 9.5, Thus, par ‘x:’\.1€I?F’E<%}§';?t'%:%f.§",'<.vf£.'E"?§
wageg w0:'$ :1Et:§é ‘4″%é,é%.:«;é%: . :«nt:’eV 2

c@:’1sE§er&téor: and we reievan: facéaz 3 fiQ£§e€,i:”%:{§” g::ér;@’r:j§;’:a_§é:._

sf éésabéiéiy am the E053 0 s” _ (:a*.«.3..:j§2é:§§” :’:§3;33V:tf§€:vy”‘:%§la’s’~i§ be” V

determined’ Thug, {fie :::}.;,xéi:i’saE’3<3L'n §§'y';2.bEe/§b3~' the

apgeféani ta the 1'; iVé':,"S"§"Z3,{';,i§'"§.(;:'£f';'v§f§§;'5I :v¥"«;§§:§:Z§V: be Q$¢29,%'7.18

(Rs:499,sex:97,:@r5_x3Qg"is'a2:§;

7. %2;z§€§:3;5.grTr:e?’r§:.V’§;:Eaétenéng the iiabiiity on
‘aha agggévééa:;»£i%»V%oyé§.%k’ affij a_b@§}é Rs.29,54?/~. The 2″
:”eSpond e;~=rj1t;’-e%rv:1§;;§.§’g.r§%§VrV.»E€’a~x§%*;’g’*”r2£>t Quegtéaneé the OE”d€f'” afid

awargi.,a:iei:é’锑:’:”:_§V;’:é’;:.§ t’§’*>e 2t0ta% com§ensa%:£em gayabie at

Ea véeeagg the iimraes sngumce wéééch it ma

aggeifaat, the ‘bafancg amazmt §:a$ is he

@Ee:;»:3::s§€§:3*~:b§;%’..–:A§:§e 2″ reggmdentzemgiayer,

” *–._E:2 t§2e yesuéi”, E213 agpeaé is &E§€}’v’xf€:é Er: gar: am 328

,/fig, . {b»§§(a ‘§§%\

{E

“ma CiI}f§’E;38′?ESaEEéC}F% gmsuret gag/abie by téée a§_§::}§§§$n%
giandg fiaécarméréeé at R§’2§,§é?/~ 2/\fi€?’§ Efl§*1′?€§§ 3§”.”:}:’;:):.{:J;”!\T= .’§’;3′.,z”fi

fmm Q:-1K12.28O8 t§EE the @3119 :2? éegesii.

Sut Q? the ammmt 5:”: depc§it,>_i§jg, é€x§1:’§’e§’:§aE:v%.§%é ;a$’

abcwe be paid is the i’*§,Vr,e4s~,:9@§9:’é5e :’:~t a:”s§%~ l%;hié &’ba’5F;a.r’*:’:::~:=::”~%’

amosmt reieasad én favwr cf ‘ifsza”a;:~pe§§a€2-f:. ” *

Neeéfesg is Qbésszrve %mk:V§ resganfiemt £3

entétéeé to reaiége vjRs,?5f’;87€5;’;{{- {?i§s;;,$-6;:<iVf;"2 – £329,547/~)

aiorag with __.%;*:%:'1e2:=;fei5=.i: .§ro?'er;: ?j_%ie.._2"*? §<_:snd€nt"

Efa rtéeé' ~':!:§V_beaf";*: 2t§:§:€E'2=V..:fes_§e-ciéve mgztg,

Bfaw 'meé EE§e@f…}jVa.wa 2