Karnataka High Court
Hanumagowda S/O Bharamappa Patel vs The Deputy Commissioner … on 2 February, 2009
n~ .w~~~- ~ . « ,.~ t -*1". "u ~ 71; .1. 41*-:' '*
75231; filial}; 5- 'BR? 037 }5u'%R}s..%§$;§x.4-E AT '.;f£}s2'a}£%L{}E{i 'as-y .?_}.L-; :v3j,;§__+3§§«
3
3%: 'ms H591-é seam': cg §<fi:R%éA"£'fi§
fiéfrfifi Ti-{ES THE 239 9a? 4312* §r'§ER;§Li's.RY 3€.%§£:E;s§ ;'__'__L- "
BEFGQE
":32 ;-;ea:*a:..af asa. ;szss?sc?::}%§sas:.9%»ag::z.%;< i n
é%§a?éL}fsg%£%':37{;'*'£'¥*€}fia
EEO §%%A§i§«.?a2§;'-§P?A P "'§'§i".
:2»: ¥5.;.'-e.% " «.
am s--:.a~.;sAsAGm??A %a:LL;;;sg::;t '
:~:ga;;2:;~e;===,z:~.= "§"AL%.,Ei»<; -- V .
agwazgegge azgraesr
'V " -;,--;5PE?;T:Q:--s£R
{By .: $4. 3 35%; ? ;e;.*rsc$::§%:E. -- ,' V'
2; Tg:_--~':é;.*".*:%'.~.1.f:=*.1_..2':'"~; §*::§a:§-e:,2é3:.»;
W, .
V " _ é:'_f€}é}E'§'{.%f ;<.;a§é;§m':::;§a;;a 1»-2:5 §A?»5éj.:i§pi}§{§:; aasfZi?_}§7{;:2::aa3 my
TEE E13533 {TG§_§}3':1" €337' §<I.'_.%_'E{E'é' 'T!a}"{A A? E 1*'-E€"3;'§L<}I{£ §?€.P.}§<;.12?§3i}'§7 2G€§€3
5&3} ?«£§h{3RA$£ 3%} BA8A'sé'AN@{§i.§DA
58 '(EARS
REG E*%A§\S§% THAVARE;
HARSHAR ?A%..iJz§€
SA§'fia%€GERT£ €}$$'§"§Z%CT
«%${'C.Z} %<AP'€"§%~§A§%AJA 83% 8.5a8§:'Jfi%f~éGQé..!SA .
35- '{EA.R:'7:3 1
RES £'«1A?€DE T'r£A'JAF?_E?
2-~iAR§§:'fisR TALUK
Bfi3s'§NGERE SQSTRECT
si{§L*} 8ASAVAL%¥'£GAP?$¥. E-IJQ 3AS§a*e'.-'5 ?£{3sI§3U{}.¥i
3 YEARS - _
R25} %'»§A?~iS% T§'"§A"v',;'5:RE3
§%!%§{%£-§A§{ TALLEK '
$§§'v'.5;£'é'GERE Q§8T§{§%'TT
:3; am .,5zSH.3'»% :24 ;<1;32aés';'e%,?{;<.;m2?a:s§::"=:;»+';'é%C«:;5{';*='é§a a=_%,.3:3 3;
sag, §2 9;; gzsgpge :2};
":':~»;:s.;- yam: ::2€?=;?'%,':':r.';:---é :::~;~: Ezaafi grgzzga A§:"s':c:.gs. 2:25 A243 227 3;:
mg C€}%~é"?-';7§'é'§'i§_"§§g'Zi%g{ _' :':=:mA._ T*,=%;"2"_,.a;*-ms "E9 QSAEH THE eaaraa
aT,24'¢<2"ws%'r+1a<_~;3£$ $245. 91,. fi;::.:,,PfgR mail'-$E, gags are 32222.": ma R1
T-Q as '$3 mo: f:z~+z::=,% $$?:1%_PA;$S%Q§é=3%TE 'AL2_GwA:a22£ Ts; mg PET$3'§Q£*~éER
9:' mg %*aA':'E <:;=4__§:::3,*;{3s._m A::{=::;::L,.« ;a§::<3;xs. zasg 21:} :aa.5m Area AT mg
gays 2? .R$.m;;wp:a 532;,-'::¥a wzzrg-: 1% guamga $aa;';c'n2:~e: re
CQ§\%T%i%éU§,E 'za:::. PA'? 335;;-: £Q.P%§PASS3Q%-éA'E'E €a_LL€,Z9J*J;%?~££E £5? "gag am";
:12? R$'$42;'fi;?»§-,P_§é. * . ..... ..
"..%:":~§:;';A;a;*§f%a":':':;<o,2-4 cazggszassg 3:4. FCR ¥2:%,;., HE2'¥':R3%'»§G, ms
§";mi~":';-;§§':;%':s:;:a'%:..:;§::;,'3£-- ésuewzgasa:
GRJEER
AA _?§§%%:%.€2:fie§* in iéfig gzzetéiéar: hag saught §fi§' qiiashérzg
fcrééf dated 2%?' fixprii 23% pa$sed by first responciarari
1:-'A§;gg[Véfifi@xu§¢ E. F€.§f'""§}8§ €¥'E§fi¥':éf' hag aim gcszjghi far 3
/
ax: 3:: 3:: 3 :.:_%:~§ a_.':'_:;,:s«':',z% 5);» ma :{s:a=z',a;=;A ;:a=.::'E:a:¥s;2a La2:s~:~;"%;%§T3j'§%é;,§i": $3 ::§~7E€ié§é
E3" EERZEEE {jQU.I%§§' Q37 §€,,é'a§i}%E%.TA,§iA 2'-'eff 1?:-g~'%'~Ei'}:.L';1*E7'2.§E '--£%-'.§'3'5e,12'?§3
5%
$312 firs? resperséeirzt ans} wrégéquefitéy, ihe fifst
§e$§anéent was ééresieé is Cfififiidéf $76 remrt fihat {my
be gufimfiteé fig me ihiré respfirséent and mm 9:"§f'fe'z"§j--§:':"':'
aacaarfiance wiiirz 23%;, in the iigfit of the H
aércaiarsiscvernmefit aréers, if 333%; %"$$23_e'~::% §§3¥'fi" »€_i;'*:"f:§«§2'§
ééme regaréérsg iha E¥"':fi'E§§$E*?"f'1é§"'§':'£"._6f_ co¥:§:;:_s'fs;@.i:3s:f:*s«fs~'§:§. "
a%£aw3n:;as by $373 parsarza éesifefé-I
during the rafevarrf Eary in
éampiéanse w§€§j:he ééresffin Canrt, fire
'finird VV:'m';af1azar an 27%"
5&:;er:*:t:$;'__VvE2€3§§§ :".;_§f;;é af the fegéster
maifitairigd fiw,-e7 '}'a%*:s%%dsr, wherein ihe
flame af ?§1é*§ef%§:§§7i:;ef%*V.'. geéevagfi yea? ':96?-=63 has
~.§::&@:f;»»'§:%§9;;$;%<Vv$%f"é2*:§___i;§f:Af.& name :3? 'me §§il!"§"'§ resspandenfi
nh'3E2-« t*«%!§€f? §i}'§3§¥§'?U?€é, has same in fihe cerzcéusian ihai,
i'a&}'i'i';i:"1"'V'r»¢.=.*s.*.§:g::'fl é1if:_«rV§T:'eVz1't was appainfed as fiaiei on 2'?%'*
'fibepiembgfifi Q56 and the reg%s*i:e:' €§r the yes? '£962-53
T"%é$3_'_fa$;er wréfien. 'Fhefe3'%% :1 ?%'se firs? resgaenfirsmi has
2%.; 'i'%§i:' §-:§<;;2»§ é.,f<;:.;;<'s"{}§4 §<;;22.:<:~:4fi;:'m§'aL 334;' .§§5a§*xé§;;*§:§,{3E€£ as ..§'}.:"-zgifi, 3; 2:5-':s3 :;;2:~' 2%;
El"? "SHE Efiififii {'i3E§§3f.'§" Q?' §~ifiR}$;%T2%.K:E 51.? Eg¥£'£i3.%Li3§iiI f1}=£.F.';'«3:':=.'i "I2".-':3?= GE" ;?€=§.?éé
5
faker: up fhe mafia: for cansicieraticn an 2&3" zfipréi 2666
am :°e}ac§e§ the gage 9% fiéiifififiéf' fa? gmfif ef
C;{T3§'?"¥§QSS§§?'¥33.'e aiiowamaé an the grsund ihsi, :3ai§§;:'3§_"€e.sf
was not wcsrkmg as fiatei as am 15% §*.ab{ua?y 7-:
£9 thgt fiate, cap'? of vxfiésfi is $3. "E59
ihe writ peiiiésfi, wé%ha;2%..§:enéjuc;§§;rj:gf 'elgxgqmgiy and
vgéiézsut §&C§§§f%g the ma§%é% reéeazzné
mateféfi 3v2§§3ifrv§e' %:gf:~ {.;'_"j!:_';£.?fi':f;'.'a§§a¥"£<3€ 31' ihe
d§i"E=€':i§C3fi beéfig éggriexsas?
§y iéée by the '§:%;:&2"V';2;é:*§§.Eeégrfied Cfi3;}?'¥S$§ smearing fa? fassesfiéefitg
. earafw pe§"u£.a§ af the §rd&f imgugrzefi
'§§f&%'$e*é,Ab§*V"f§r$€ résmnéesi , it is mafiifasf 0?': '?§"?€* face 5%
__ %«%:é '~§::»%§§r fifififiéfi figs $35 saéd aafihariiy Sinai, thé aatheréfy
'V V u ?'e§€fié£3i€€§ firm Siam 9% $528 respeaféase ffiéffiéfi srsd
gé %§_7{}?.5§~5'__'i" UP E<L§§§{§'-éfi;.'i;§a§;i3. fa, E' %i;¢J2'*:%;,§fizE,%i}§€;;F:§ W _§"_?z-':3. E 2?.'§3 {W
P:-E EEZ 3135.211 {TCZ2}._;R.T C2? ;£é2}23§£?'_%.':<;% AT }.§..3£$fQJaLQR§3 'EH-',1's§C», 13375213 2§,?{.i6
fiffifiééfifid %fa.:r?%":er and carésiufiefi the praceefiings. §F'i _¥_"§'?'y'
véew: suaiz pmmeééngs ecfrzafijéed withmfi $9":/*:":pE%2%%:ft;e5_'fa§"*.%_
iha déregtiargg ésaueé hy this Smart fiéfififii be ::a;':%gf3%;*::;==f3'L-§t "
my stretgh 0% %f"f'?i3§§f"t$§§fi§'!. §~%e§2cee:,' %3*;i '§$«E§éb§$;4t§"§'}E:vsét
335339 at the threéhaié an this g.r_aus*°:§'3A§é2§e, %s:§€§%:_0§:€ ''
érfia fufihaf merits grad éen3er%%$'§§.:Vf§§f;§$_¢asV&a..V.
5. §§"i the %§g%:t of t%§:;s:{"'j§3;ct.§%%%¥€'§v':$§§E;%f§issf:*;s'£2'r;§§f.;a$ 3? the
case, 32% writ peiééisegx fiigfi. of as
faééaws: % « Q 2 % K
.. pefififiner is
afifiexefi :3 ' ~ ' " '
:;g:«;; g§g;:-ea: mfiafiaf by ,4;-;e
245' Aprfi 2flfl5 fiaaring
V ?--£§_:5,f'23§3-Q4 véde fismesurzsre E is
" aside;
" 155;? Matty S?8I'§dS remiéféaf 53854 fg 9gj'fo'J/2
(1--*
" :§;;§$pa§m§e:?£ is refiafiséder we mafia: afreséé
arm' £6 fake 8,figfif"S;§?'§8f8 dacissarg 53::
?;%E7 riéiifé ms %;g*a§s:%;§§%Qs';2 gs' §%:§.?2':_mT::?§3 222%
, ' 7' ' .
33% 37? ii HEGEE G3' E{:*a§§"?£:"s"§L%i-.m" 'i. A"? §T§:'§?~EéIL="%EJf}§i}f '-§'w.53€'Tl"€:::=.};';'3':31" 53%? 2993
a?§rec%;'9:'3 a;s.{s;;;> 3:' ffie safd mgm ggggge
the gamer arffser u Se-..é$§;»;éa$§§V
agagzarfésnéfy 5:' heagaag %
res§a;m¥e:'?f3. 5% (§}-- :3?
»f%:sr§g;g§;_. _«:;f;~:§f§$fe§_V a;3a:'ij; .éis§a5{se éf fim
3393529, «§;3W_;t'§'arss:'§§§, 3? gay
rafié, sa:§$§?i:§';§:§:--§¥e:%§§-.:;f"':'3f' ihree mcrrifis fram
fhe a'a3§fé_Vé§.ré#::s§;:~fV isf..\é'} segy at?' ffiés Gffiér.
.....
Iudqe
9
“SEE grésiésé aiazssa 1;?’ §<=..s%§~i?*s:%'§';%%s;s% A'? §:.a.;as;.3.;§:':3;::;«; 2:a;§T:*:?,s§§'a:§3§iéi§:r;