IN THE HIGH comer or KARNATAKA.
DATED THIS THE 12th DAY.oF1oc'§f6i3EiT,_ 20:39
BEFORET ' 'T
THE HON'BLE MR.JUsT1¢E%
WRIT PETITION No¢...142_47-.iiT;42'e2 on' 2eos{(s-RES)
C/W W.P. 14471 --._72.o1?_20a9 (S-RES)
W.P. 14247-262/09%,- T
1 VEVIRN. "
/QE.LA"I'f:2 NIANDEESWARAIAH
Age 59'year.S«.. T. "
R/A'I'.# 1 1 ;.1.*-*1/LAT;-1RUsHREE"
I"C"MAlN SI-EIVANAGAR
' 'VRAJAJINAGAR BANGALORE
. V' iu2£R.GA;.«NAGE:"é{jwDA
._ /0' NARASIMHEGOWDA
" assrears
' R'/A':j# 154, 3RD MAIN,
6TH CROSS
. C PET
' BANGALORE
V. MR.H.G. LINGANNA S/O.SRI GANGAPPA
AGE 59 YEARS
R/A'E'.#46.A, 7TH CROSS,
UAS LAYOUT, SANJAJ NAGAR.
BANGALORE 5.
V. '_ .BA_NGA;'oRE
4 MR.v. MUNIVENKATAPPA
S /GLATE VENKATESHAPPA
AGE 59 YEARS _
R/AT.# 13- 16 TEACHERS HOSTEL :
UAS ,GKVK, BANGALORE ' ' «-- "
5 MR.B.N.RAMA RAJU _
S/GLATE V.S.NARASIAIIM_ '1: ._
R/A'I'.# 37/2{OLD NO V;'51 " ~ .
PIPE L1NE, BEHIND DHATTATPAYA TEMPLE?
MALLESHWARA3/i;..BANGALORES'-._A " "
6 MRM.SIVA REDDY S/0%;-LA<rE1..MAL1,AREEDY
AGE 59 YEARS -_
R/AT.#_ .59, 2ND ;MA1Nfi.R0GA'D.j 'V "
GKV NAGAR,_A:.,LALASSA:\r1;)RA,""""
POS'I'; 'BANGAl}O.R.*$ A
MR.B.KEE\riPAi:ING!1I;:%H'fO BORAJAH
AGE . _'
R/AT.#"'84", 4MALLIGE} RATE,
2ND 9
\r11)YARANYA;vAGA_R,'A.§ '
MAGADIRAOI). "" '-
2 »M'R.SRIN'NSA"-MURTHY S/O.LATE NAGALPPA
<...AG_E 593-'.E1%_RS.
R/AT'.# '19.,'/f2.3:RE MAIN RAOD,
PALACEV-GU'1-TAHALLI
-V BANGALQRE3
w/o:_MR. D. DEVAPRABHAKAR
: AG'E'*59 YEARS
Ri/AT.# 1/ 1 1ST FLOOR, 16TH CROSS.
1' "LAKKASANDRA BANGALORE
MRBHADREGOWDA S / OERAGOVVDA
AGE 59 YEARS A 3
E AK
11
12
13
R/AT.# D--31
UAS QUATRES ,1-IEBBAL
BANGALORE
MR. B.N.NAGESH '
_S/O.LATE DR. c.R.NARAYAN,RA__O~ '
AGE 59 YEARS _
R/AT.-# 1079, A BLOCK
8TH CROSS SAHAKARANAGAR
BANGALORE .,
MR. T SJAGABISH' S/O I;ATE"T"SID.DAPPA
AGE BQYEARS
R/AT.#92'1,2ND"1X'CROSS'." _ A .
3RD MA.BJ..1VHOSAI<EREHALL:.j_'~.AV
BSK I_I11,STA'G.E .. A
BANGALOR'E'?.._ A
ZVZS/O..LAT'E: O HANNAV_EERA1AH
V?
R/'A.#105;v._1ST-MA"-IN" '
C SECTOR :\_MRUTHANAGAR
;' SAI-IAKARANAGVAR POST
BANGALORE SSSSS
MRSIRC. VISHALAKSHI
* v§i~,!'O.1::V_..i..SA'1*I~1YANARAYANA
' AGE*59;=YEARS
R;A."4s:=..-:82 IOTH B MAIN
IST BLOCK, JAYANAGAR
" BANGALORE
MR. G. MUNIRAJ
S/OLATE G.GANGADH.ARAPPA
AGE 59 YEARS
R/A.# 13/2 MARIYAMMA TEMPLE STREET.
D.K.LANE.CI-IIKKPET CROSS.
BANGALORE 5. 5
av' '
16
MRC. GOPAL REDDY.
S/OLATE CHANARYA REDDY
AGE 59 YEARS
R/ATALLALASANDRA GRAMA
YELHANKA HOBLI
BANGALORE
(By Sri:E\/IANMOHANPN, ADV A
W.P. 34471972/09
BETWEEN :
1
AH RAYUDU _
S/O. LATE PAJJAPPA, '
AGE 59 1f'Em2s _ -
NO.9{1i4], :a;AN1fI~%:o.<:i1~1 "
1sA1<£AI<ARA,NAG;xR~~P_0ST
:3Ar«IQAL_0;2'E.;~~ " "
V 1§iA(:§AvRAV'P.PA._ "
* 'vs/0. IATEVENKATARAMANAPPA
AGE 59 YEARS.
NO. 2643 CROSS, 287" MAIN
-GKVK POST, JUDICIAL LAYOUT
V .3A.NQ.A-:._QRE ~ 65.
GOVERNMENT OF' KARNATAKA
S" DEPT OF AGRICULTURE,
' MS -BUILDING
DR. AMBEDKAR VEEDI-II
BANGALORE
RERBY ETS SECRETARY
ORDER
Common questions of fact and that so
decision making, hence with
counsei for the partiesfthe pet-i..ti’0ns
together, finaily heard by this
common order.
2. ‘§’he__ petitioners have served the
respondent–3.iJn:ive_rsity differe’nt””p’0siti0ns and have
attaiiviedttvtheivfageniiiotf except for Sri.Gopa1
Ready} Eetitionerf W.P.14247–262/2009. The
common of the petitioners is that the age of
.sfiperai1nnati0n the respondent~UniVersity though
gtiixed filed a representation to increase the
age to years, which when not considered have
.._nresen-ted these petitions for a writ of mandamus.
3. The petitioners in the circumstances cannot
claim as a matter of right for increase in the age of
ii
c of
*~;;\
superannuation since it is for the State
prescribe the said age. In that jqiew 0f’tE1’e:twné1tterV,
petitioners have not made outta legal’ righ’t. er ‘a :”c-Qfitlfa
obligation on the part of *r;h’e.__Stat’e. Vas”,:t’eX¥invQk3e
extraordinary writ jj_.1risdicV1_;t_t:(if1f.:__1’¢:a; issu\ writ of
mandamus. It is that a writ of
mandamus is ‘;1o_t a be issued for
the mere
are seveordingly rejected.
3%
Sd/~
JUDGE