Karnataka High Court
Sri Basavaraj Murthy vs K R Manjunath on 8 July, 2009
in: THE HEGH <::0::m*- or-' KARNATAKA AT _gg;fq<3Ai;:3éE T'
DATED THIS THE 38% Dz§;fQ1«* shim
BEFORE
THE; HOWBLE MR. N.VAF_\:IAfE.f,)AV.'1»;' H
M.F:A.1\iC}L;MO4~4mQ§Q§G.7{MV} A
BETWEEN:
1. SR: BAsAvA§2A;«z,_V;x§UR'1§%Hafi
SIG LATE sU§APP;a' . '
AGREE ABGLYE'
RfAT.GRAMA--§3E3f§:T1:iA znasesa; ..
mm :xIA.;:;:;--;%r;_ mgr": 5:, ..
EviAi4%V?2LLI-- '1f'Ai,L3V};<.;'j' -» . " --
M2%NE)Y§x'?}EST'RI€f-'If, ' APPE§_,LAE~I'1"'
{B}: 8:33. S ii:-R:€s}:,g:;:2i;<:3C;2=;9rE§
-VmfiNQ%;L.m %» .
' ::.. :=: £5 I'»--iA'§~£.=§LYI§é'?a?H
L-..s,r::,: i.gP«.TE;'«.§{."E?.;?:}3¥€C3ASEfu'P;E\1§Y,
2\a§7AJ€:Ii1?,
we 120,, E*R3'xf.f'H{a MA
?OOE?.Néi--PEz3:JN?; 1.m*C:z;*:',
, ._UTTfisi%;%v§~}P.mL1,i,
:3pg~;_GAL©RE-5 :.
' _ A' :2; NATIQEW, ENS{}E%A§'sf€3§:1 :39 ::m
* R73;?,:G§0NéL omcg :-:<;.;-;£2.3.ii)'? PAE§SEjj_Ei -1-.14 M'«;2'~::":1x:r::.*--«
2479/{>6 ON THE FILE --Z? c::;:-rs.%z.I:>v;3:~1sh:;.z:g-".f%1_<f;::;::J_A
AND SEEKING ENHANCEMENT' #3?' C€}h*I_§'E;--2§FSA'E'IOffJ,. " . 2
'This appt=:ai, Coming z':r";--.L.:I."5é'";»V3."» h:~*;::IT'ing5...t.F;is§{"%1§§f, {he
f3c;urt, dc":1iVert=:d the following: " ..
',*rw§:;_:.3c%m:Nr« « .
This is aV_c1aimanf'e§.Va;§p{=j:a1""'f(3¥"5i?:n?I:anc62ment of
campensaf.it}f§.
2. "!_'1"_16:A'7f§31gii'z1gs;._ £:f__ Tribilnai on the issuers of
negIige:r1€;€: and !iaf':i 1'i*.:};'"ii1s:11rar:::e company have not
'E'§(':£":"£"g {"t.'3,.E1€?("1 i"I3f7(5V qizéésttion either by the iT"iSIi¥'€",I' as?
i1'1.s;;'1*r~r=:d'.f"i'hé:refm*€:, they need not be reconsidered.
medical evidence, Claimant had
3! 1f"f2°:z'<°:e'iA T}"'"z'{'ii fnlinwizig in}; 11*ies:
F'fécf.1Irfi of both the harms; of right ieg at Eewar
3 iigrcl
VA 2 Abrasinn ever f'ig?1f,WI'§§§¥i
iii) Right Ulnar S§1yi<'z1"d process fractzzre.
'f\uqgg'\,-\,5m,.V.{£LA '
4. The claimant was treated in KS
Bangalore. He was an inpatient from
1 '3 .3.'2C*O6. The fracttlras were ..redI.'if§§§{j'' ': '
r<=:dnct"im1 and inrerrsal fixaticm.
E3. The ifribzmal has' a_ii*'a_rded" .¢amp*w¥.;*1I:¥"1_g fi'3§3dS2 '
F Pain and agony 'M " -. : 'Rs..f'>{'J,("10{}
W Medina! exp«5n'ses,"' :Rs.Q'.2,£"){3(".t
HI" CQnvej,z. é§:r3:fé.'E§é;:.;?301'--2.fj's?2f£1E'n§-- : F€s.5,€)(30
TV Lc$;:~j.s c-Ts?'ir}{1é*:';'::-t§<€1i*rii1f§g;--._t7r€::étm.€=:nf. : FZs~;.1'2,f}{)()
V Losséé :f}f" a1né:1ii:i§:s : 3-?.=;.i2_f)1{}{){"}
%,_-'mr,é3'~.M MMMMM F€s.1,('19,{"}€)(§
V * 'he:ar*d Sri.{'}irisI'3, learned cnzznseti far
ciaitfiantj:ir*§§§7:Srimkfiamggariappa, iearneci cennsei far
Vfiihff inmimnce company and E have been fakazi fhrnzzgh
"'-§:=:T2ri;{i:4i'm7€: and the impisgned award.
?. {En rec:nns%(§é:r:az§i<m :1? the earidexxcvsg E am 0? {ha
V' apinian, trih:maE Shmfid have awa"1*dc==:rl ffflififlfiflfiafiflfi
'5'-\a"~,.' ,
zmder 'thc=: hezad "fiitlirét less 0? earnings" and also
towards "ftimre meriiitai expenses".
8. PWQ' --- T}i'.V§n0(i Kiimazi, has _.,a'$:s§é::ised'«V
pemzsnent physica} disabiifiy 03'" the: right i('3'*;3'&'§:i¥"1.fi'§'£"3:vh 13}S ':
35% to 87%, 5% of fbe right t:vf§fié»i*'%?ni'h b'--1_§1?ki; pf
whole 'n0:1E: to
assess permanvsarzt p§1;:£f§ifCQ§_ {"1§_S§.'§}7s§}§f§~--.Vifi~é§-V58 Eoss of
t=:aI*nir;g {:ap.9§(;%.§}'..;_'-i€:.M}f}'?{3;.___'f'h6: Claimant W35; aged abrqmt
33: §'f:8T$§v.§3f,fi1(':'=.fif"i'iA€': _€§f..§i::§:ident¢ He was 3 coolicz by
<1c€:t;ps3.?.i('zn; f:?1efi%f0rE:, his irz<'::'amt=_: is §3SSE'.SSfid at
98? tfivdfifih. Therefore, Ciaimant Wimid bfi
'c2r1ifi§};'axémm of §s.,5'?56€3I'i (I€'s.3,.6{){"§ X' 36} under?
*£i¥*3j€3f:"?7i€::;a:§"§ -'*'39SAé§V0f f:1f.1n*e earnings", The «r:¥aima¥1'( xxrifi
ha??? rd i':-:':'€ie1'g0 one more Qperatézm far remavm sf
~-iznpiafzts} "§'h<=,ref0:'6:, Campansatian sf ¥'~'€$,'£{§}{"}f}i},:'- EYE
". ?3§$,?'$«}'f'{§ft€§ mntier the head "flrfurft mfidécai fiX}§f"":TE{§§UI}'"fi"'
' H9'. ¥"£"i E5116 "!"€':E%1i§?, E p9:%°.:=; Ehe fcaffiawingi
ORDER
‘THE: appeal is accepted inj§’§’9’1t_:. ”
award is nzodiiied, {:mn1pensat’§'{:;”: ‘–_§§f ;*().C3«,{)”t”?_1:'{“}~,/jié”.
awardefi by fim ‘£iI’ih1ma§ is €z1:?1anCe”<i'–th /–
with kltfrrtst at 50/9 pr-,i"~.annzwiffi the tlafi"-*:":'ii"" vpetifimt
iii?! the date": 0f rF:aIisaf.i01% §:?§3I:;?;ifiS;~.._.§'i'§f§:'~fi€'_{T€fCt€'d to bear
thftii' casts.
sax…
M Judge