High Court Karnataka High Court

C M Puttaswamy vs S G Hegde on 7 August, 2009

Karnataka High Court
C M Puttaswamy vs S G Hegde on 7 August, 2009
Author: V.G.Sabhahit & Nagaraj
 M 5; _ * 5%"?-r§§~*ia'3E'$g;+§'-.

'9».
2
2

(B3,? Sfé iv': 3 83*-ifiaGfi\'w?v'AT St E 1: 3fi\GI"'35.'§§ESi-i, fixi}'v'$.} ._  9T

:--'ii\£fi :

3. s G HEGDE, E.A.S.,   
mg nzagcma «::>s= mg umzvsagm & 
aauc..aT;a;*«s mafia PALACE as;-maj 2 
a;~.:+3ALaaE 1 2 

m '-¢E3A':'AB*r§A5$E§>'i'.C:? Em;<:mo:a;:   k     L
?az%«zAR:a mes sscaraas:-w' fgafrr 'a'i:f5:"TE'<*3'F~§
5': * ?s..<'."'.-iffiaz;~fi!%s.3i5z§,+%:;i'a%%k   
3fi?éGr'%L€-RE5';ji__--_V_   = 

3 :esaus%;fia;=L2A  %

  M
AQED £~£:l€;i~?;.Ef'-ST.  M
Ga: ?EiESESE3'§T    ' 
§§~§?1?§?x"§'§~iE'ié'E{.'}"i'%'% 3:33;-%€'i:";?~'§'?r§§

$fis:"*~iEV.é'3sVRAE';;'3;i'%E:"i"':3é~§ 
J ..;f${§?ifis*éAR1?ET'?ALi§K
 }{i'§'i"§Fx§3§.? 313? ~~~~~ 

  %$;'cs.'%$Va*§%§,§*i;xs
_ ;&.r;§::' away 59 ms
 235$ i'.E?JTU&ER 1%; §m;..is"
 :3 :.:'::ai.:..Es:aE 3;: siEV"RASANTHE
~  S<3'Wé'¢AR?ET
"~%:§§Aa:.; :'"3i$T
'  AQCUSED

   {£332 Sri saaaaaaa ir'%I$;E€¥iA"§'%-*§, gm ?€§§'<: R3 3; £2;
 "sag 282.9: 3599?, Amen ma R3;

5&1' 5 v§$?éV€ES'v'iAR.&3fiaH, $3631', Ffifi R-ii}



Afi§:'éfiié':3='2":"§ssaéé gr; §'v'.?,258i%€}fG4 iiaté

ii»

2?.?.2i§{3§ sfiews freat théré ifi afi arrive: (2% $iay: 'ii';

*s:'=»:".?'.1188?/68 anti iiéi the ififéfiifi scsrfier is %.i'aat§:";.*_¥$;i;§, __'_:;§%:§

Siéfifi caésuifi fig:-*2 taker": as fiéi' ifié fiiféitiéfi éf tfi_is_§é.f;s~--:§§t;.A.T.:'~  % T

3. Tfiéféféfé, Eiavirag régafé ta 'ii*"§'r,3 E§§iE'3$é §£2§a" fact; 

are saiififiefi that there £5 sir:;" a{;'i*E§;2i ...':?ié
ércier éf this ezéurt aim? jn ;'¢°a::iA,_...L:§V7é;é:%:iex_;:sjf é:$:i'r2Té;e§  the
fififfzfiiéifiafii 'nirrsseif Sufifftigs.iifiiffi§:.é"5é:g'éf:ié:;f: Esguaé by
thifi muff has fieézgé'::¢.fm§§ié:i'».usiLi::%é_"a.fg;'i_ .§§é»;*'9:{¢iaEr;afit has";
been grcmetga 0fv   and the 4%'

reswcziifiérzi %_%f:_as~ .%'§és:'~.-1éVfia:; :fii;'e::t'@.:é" *:6 iii?' aver fihéféé.

4. "§'%1é .45"4.resp;§$fl%i;;gr§t;..V§;§ie§i.g with 3"; respcnéentg fiiafi

1:9

w,?.z59§;'a3 %@;mSe§ ma 28.:iCi.IE;EE§6 an

1222..

fiézame firzai. 3:5'; ihe Cififimfiififiiéfi,

'   Eea{f§:=§"%c¢t;_r§s:el'§.V_f§r the $3 respondent submits that he WEE

_;_:};<§':%:3§§ie§ ~~=;%§§E.f*a We éffiéf'.

é;+'"%. "'fi?£€s*:€3¥'§%fifii*:, WE izaéissé that fiavésm ffifiéffi is we

–«’.4fa”%.2:::’:?a $ai§ fifiaifig, if is smi Eiéééfiflai’? ifs frame €§'”E&§’§€: afié

\J>

an

ixécérfiifiaéy, ma: éfiiiiéfiiffii i3&’fiEiV§<f§i"{._V§Si