'I
EN 'r_:~;33 Hliifzi caum' 0:3 KA§k:IxEA'}$A}{A AT *:a;xr«z'<;%s,m:z%»:a
DATED THIS THE 25'?" DAY 02: gum' ] _
BEi1'€)R1%L:
H{)N'BLE MR. ;z;s'r;c;:~: mzxgg; '3Y}a;;afl%:a;::;=1)%'§?%L' i .
2~v1:sc3::L;,;¢\:;::1;s FERST N0. .344§'€§}': :>;}::;¢}6 (Mm k
B}£i'I'W}élEN :
Sri. C. V<:n_iCh§n:1appaRed;i}-',__ " . -
Resiéeni L)T{'?v§ui§§ai3:§:':§[imv
'Jifiage, A;:e};;s,E"T'"z:,§_z:{§;V-if-_ "
Eangaiezre §)i:~:V£;*je.:E:__ ' ¢_ V AP?'fi?l.,ANT
(By s1mi. K. '1'. Gk;;:»;;¢:;m Agfwcaie}
ANDi
1.
2»A;s.L;I3i;;F:ad in£§’iz-,:.._
‘ Inszlfargsta Gzgmpazzy” “””
. S£… Pairicks .{3i*;;:r::h
._ £&%;i§£ifi31 :g;..’A§ S’ VF3§:u::.z’
1’vI§’:~’.€um’ Fi}-aiiTI= V
Bangalgre-.360 025
Rcprus;enk:d by iis
” ” * –. V’ D31 %sis£m2~:£1 Manager
_’ R. Arun Kumar
Eifa Ramamurthy
‘i\xIa§£.:r, N0. 1 178
4&2 Cross, 14*’ Main
IN)
Prakashnagar
Bagzgaisre RESPONB¥_._N’JC’S_’V:-~–., -1- V
{Sh:.’i. F. B. Raju 5:31′ R.aE~;;:3(>rzdani N0. )§ ,j’V’3t}i.}:L:{;:«iéliR;d§$p1iiif}C’:1i« .2
dispegsed)
This Mi:;ueiianfi_;;cai is V§”i1;€t{iVv§,iI”1iif’}i””§$1tf§€.:ii.£.)I’i”
1′?3{ 1) 0f the Meter ‘!ehic}es A~;:’ii<._againsfiéze" jzédgément and
awani daimi 22.(}3m2{}G5 ;s::a2:s:~;ed_§r;% 3'vi.V':':__ Ne.:. "5i~U2.a'}€34 on 'aha:
file of the Vii Ac%::!i€is:}:,E"'~..Iu.=:1;ge,:_I$;?§.a.§':2.I,}er, bfietcr .z'§¢CCi.€§€I1'£.':1
Ciaims Tribunal – 3, Crsuzfdf '§'"§t'!'f'I€'_11'V§" :€;§a1_1's;ve.'$,, Metra;'zn¥itan Area,
BaItg:«;1i:3rs (ECCH-3),.p&¥{§.}4, _a§(.1Wi;1g fiT!v2? "~.£3}:i3t¥'t pciiiiml Fm"
C{}E1'}}3€1'}Sii'£§'{T}l1&E}€..i€3£§.'*-. V' ' '
T§1i:s Agfipcfi.c$é;.§fi1.iz"gg"«.é;;§:,fi£:aIing this day? Ehc C-uuri
delivered the f::s'11{§v_I§':';g:~ = M
[5 t2%:§;§ M-'E N '1'
Hcarzi £33; {:'e3uVii;:;:.'l'V fqz' zippmiiarri and the rezspurzdeni.
Tabs zipptzifarxi'"1c1ag§___{nv;~:l wiih a muicr auc.-itisnt inwivirxg Eire
7§gc§1.i£:i::vin–s';imd~fi§ the firsai !"£3Sp(.}§'3d€§I1i.. As a msuii ufiiu: 3.i.:c§£.§£::n£,
ha }md"'sui'I}::r£:ii'j_gficvuus irzjufiess am} was h0:spiia.i.i:~«:¢sd. Even aficr
V-hjcaimerzé, fig': was iimnd wiiia a psnnantmi diszcibifiiy mi' 13.5% in
bud}; ami on ihai basis had Laid a ciaixn {Ear
"-.Vumrripcnsaii<.1n ':3cii:srt: ihsi: Tv'Ez.3ir Acuizisszuir-3 Ciairns Tribunai
” < .§.3.§3fGi'£'£a{if.¢E' rci,E:r:rcd is as 'ih_e Tribunal' 11:22? brtzviiy) T115 Tzibunai
8
3 V
having awariiczzd :;1 11.3131 sum mi’ Rs.1,T7,50{‘.i’- wiih in£t.3?£:;$t_,_ {he
app:-diam is btziiarrz this smart, seeking cnh;i1§ct:nié:::?{£ hf: *
cuzI1pen:=$ativn. –
3. Ii is puiniad nut ihai; the a.ppc§:¥:t:3i7 §viiva:.: iai .’
pennancni disabiiiiy would cer£::;i1}viL3Q”*~§}t: £it:V.§)§’i_\ii*.:i.§ {.5.§_:’ a’1:;£:’i1’i’E:¢s in V
Iifs. Thc Ttibunai has :”g;fani.e;1″”a §§al’ifj
&_ M iii’ 1 ,z:;:_3:–
iowmds 1033 up Jumcniiiaki $6 in a ‘:a.1’g,t:r
sum. The ha; 3: Jiu fiat: cxitmi 0?
R:;.49,00{};’« are ctsiwcrricd. The:
Tribunal. g}$;fifie& Uniy Rs.3(},{}{)Q;_ whiie
depriving E;§::;: imV:iua§._rtr£d§ca%..__t%:>qic11ses ihai wart: incurzftzzi, That
appt:¥iafa’i’v hm} in-.ui1’déIfg:§ irésaimcmi iizr 3 mr:siL§c:z”ab§c:; petting}
.ViI1:i:u:1:1″€n;z§ fI1§sa5e:¥.ia::m1z1s expandiiare whigzh has noi, been
:.:{$;r_a§£:_§;sa’i:::§’_~;;;ic:s§;uéiEe§y. The Tribunal has granicé c:en¥y 3. sum «inf
requirczs in be c:nh.2m.uc:s;.§. The: apptsifani hazi
:p»{“£:-Utitifiiii Iim£t:z1″aI in t:>;iab§i..*s¥: {he in.::(.m1e {had he was ezanting ai
The T:fibu;1a§ hexwcvtir has: negated iht: gauze and has
8
ti , -.
ads;3p’:t:d R3_i25G.?« for {he pxzrpcxses 4.31′ m:7§pu_§vi11g.._’Viiw
mmpcnsaiiun. That accidcmi. was mi’ E336 ycztar ESG3 __:;:£:.¢i :;i’:§:;fii1aifigg_ ~
ihai 816 appeiiani had no: progimzamd adttqmxis t:*«:i<ier:1£:':: ;i»z; VSli}'i.)§f){}¥".iV VV
uiwhis imzome, the Tribunai has aii.rib;1ibd :a;i:';".r_1fi.;*s i1ci'fi:g,'.iii'e,
nuiiunai imrurmz of' 'Link: apptzihini'-i;i."*~pr(.3cc%:¢§i.ng-lei;ci.:~;jri}E§£:ie {he V'
ccm1p<:31saE,%<m. This: has mgiuiiczzi i¢:s'7i%}'t:{Tri.E§zs;3a§ gr3fiiir::"g meagre:
anmuriis iuwarais §t;.*¢:»,a of im.:mn.::~ €vi%:1V1?%ng_.–.i:fieA_'.'§:er_§.m;i of Ercaignczzi
whiic {he perimi '§:={§¢i, ihtaugh he %:a&
ufiderguiltz §¥t22:;i_IT1€:’§¥”3’i,~fi)I”VE2 ~§i41’r’igf:iin¢;._. r
i:z$;§iE5r_ €56″:a_Vm:1j¢;i’-.§7§§w;:;1″zE:~; aiissabiiiiy its (:(}I’££.1&:1″I1t:(§, am
accuuni of fizz; “mV.;ii.{s:1_a’i;imfignc being Eaktii} on iht: fezwssr side
..V.again..n9;cag”m a,m(m:fi_i5 giranicd as mn1pc:1saE§n, 0:} acazuunt of
‘.§}iS%;”§’i§i§2…v’v'{§.”§.$’ ‘£:)1} ihtssrs grzmndes Ehai the :<ip}'Jt:13flI1i is sucking
anh'anC&mefii 531' Cikmptsn sa.ii(:::":.
“{‘h.<:'Cz.;un:sc§ E231" fin: rc:;;3c.mLia:ni can {hat zzfmrsr hazad, vmuhi
'Céti*';3§.}s¥§:'~«z:I2y su:.:§1 i;:¥z§m.m.;cmeni. The C{)lIfiE;t:§ wuuid xuihnrii. iitai
{§}.E$ ;i;1w:::I"d ¢3i,'t.;nmptmsa£im3 unéicr {E223 imad ru.m«-pcctmiary dmmigfis
3
6 .
unicss ihttre is aciuai §u:s:.~; :3? earning, ear 3, (§§m’i::uii:3n g:.EfViTt:;f;z3a}’:.$fi_
Vim ::zpp¢:;?E:.mi is rim; tzniiiiad in any msmpcnsaiémn_=i%;_;wéi’ri;i.§§”fitéggh’ »
disabiiiiy. The mmptzmgaiizzn umiczri ..€.E1;::’ stzyieraiv'”e£}::sSé::3§Li.g;n*:~;} V
hcadss wayuid atieqtaaicziy address i§’m”‘ e;;i:;2§-_3*n’ flit”.;;’om;3§:nv:;§;ii.i;§i2…
Thcrcibre, {ha qucsiism <3? eni1an;;'i3:i<m:11i {cxxararxis "zii:§3'§'§§"§ii}g'V Licms "
Ht): aritazc.
5. On ihczié e.;§e;’fé-:§*a’§. {Si7.;§i’3;a?3§3.ii§?’émii ii xzmuiei inirfimév ihai. ‘at:
wuuid szzifizr i%un1–c§€pé’§~’g2t£%:.;éi’».:;i.7 arneniiias wéticzh 3:6 wmuid havcs
uE.ht::rw§:+.x:.; crsjnéf-‘;’::§;’i, »’i7.”hc”Tr§§m:aa3 has gralxiad enziiy Rs;,i{},{}(3G§»
Euwaiveisi Eé.-353 {VV’;’§..”Eii°f}t3IIii§.{§S whisk rczquirezg in be enhancad. En. my
(}}’.)§VI’}3i_i-.’-11,1£.~1i§”‘:;;£ii.§§E’E!v1fi£:i§ Six??? of Rs.}{},{}{){).:’« tmiitsr Ehis head wuuiai
be in’-«:,3rc5¢?i’,’ .
Infizyiéir as {he mcdiuai €’5Xp€:3’l’ita’8§-E am Uiififififiltiti, i’zu>i;gh {he
app;~.=.§;a;;: has 1;:s+mduc:t:d %::ii§.~s in {he exécni :3? Rx.4’i(}O{}I’»; iht:
‘”‘-.T1fi?5t:nai has gmniezsd irniv RS.:”¥{},GG{}f:-, T}u:rc: are no rvaxons
,r
“a$$§gr:;::d n<;gaiing iéitz biiis and iiw d0€…3I11.IIt:¥1i:~; grtrtiucfiti in
5
*7
1′
respect oi’ the adciiiiunai E}Xp€f3II1§i:’»S which. are wiih ?1¥:i(i’.”~._ H.j§f§E§:E;
ihc appciiarri it; tmiiiitsai in asmfn az’m>unL~s t:>:;pe:mic::i:. ié2 a Ai«{‘}’E;sli§’–s§i’§::; ~
of Rs.2€3;GOQ.?- luwarsis mcdicai fixpfifififii-;,.4 in’ acigiiiifl-“r xie«:__f_ Sis;
amuuni gmiaicd by $31: Tribuzxai
Sin1i.la:*Ey, iuwarzis; 111i:;g:c:E§.anc{.i’;s.:; cxperidfizzrez §mi_\;;f«’ .21 s.~;um mi’
R:;_5{}(}{‘.f- has Eager}. Eirsczn ir’t~:ait;:;§ £22?
2.: c:1si<ir:ra':.§§é»V in award a i.}_:ri3m~.:r :.~;m'n us!' V
“i’hé–.é%Ic{.)§ne E._§;:é:-~V.:&:’§::i;?’.¥fi;:§i2i§1§. ?3.3.:–; ‘amen izziian <.:m§jg ai.
Rs.i,2§{}f– w§14:;:rt;:2:s-h'c 'Wm; eaming, zzmm ihan R3-:ué%{}!€§{3x'- as
E:m£t.ié::cie;i–.'E;y 133:: d<2c£§:fié:3.i:s '§¥I"é?{ilE£§€§i. "fhuugh the TréEm'n::i 1:23.};
mzi -E1.*;:'«&.%:;:-..4i'f}:-:;t:*:§3::fa.z%1a;.}§i},2 ceanvimzaizsj'; in :s'i,£}°3}7l}I"i. wi' £215 nzaicriai
t'\
}2"f.§z3a;armc aiicasi R.;~;.?~._G1 8.:’- an rm 3.: Exam: ‘mtcn
_ . _ E
‘«;£§Eu’g;§§,(;:Li 33 the inL«:>z2’1£: :2? ‘she appcéizmip K’ {Ems is iaksza énicx
.j;:;.§n_siéiémiitytg Liza: 21I’I]i}i.1I°!i mi’ §npt:I::sai§:m ie>wa,3″s_:.~; mi’
“-. §.’r’i’s.f§1.}mt: wuuiai ham: in %:»<.-;: g,r;»2§:§.:.:<§ in 22:': aciaiiiésmai rsum :.:.si'
8
8
R.:a;,§1_,f§(}€”¥- aiE:::a:4i for 3: ;:et:z’§:3(.i :1}? xix mc.mEi3.~.;, ia z;<i;3.i__ii<3:§"£.:f3: {Erg-
azzmuigé aiwady gm.:"§i<;:d.
Simiizzzriy, iht: umnpen:~;a.i§;..”m “:m§;ar;is_ e’ié’;~s3f}iEiEAj; ‘<._\~*§{').12~§_§i z«.!§T:s£j
I S E I "Y"
nave in as czzstancca. ;
m:~.;pz.m.deni. Em’: fin: appefiatwi any :§m’.;¥3
ficad oi” £}{3I”i’3.pt.’£H§§1::?.E.§()¥’i_5 :3;:§*«.§:fc::: dim%m.:Ei_:m U1.’
immmc GI’ £53′ £Z»E1¥Tf32″§§’§g_ am wiih {he
vary as:c:vi:L1i’§é§z’2 * A’:*é+»v5’*v”}_v§€.> §”:’i::§:’:Vif’;Vi’t’.« «:t1’g’$iugEc§’V in ‘r:::1z’ae gr fem; {xix
t:a4rr:ii;g–::.apac%i§.: ..s.:0s’u§d be;-n§:E:2si’i%14c L::ms;§£ierai.ia:n Em” ihc grant oi’
£:{;3I11″§’anszi”E”ii.ar1R’Sxizgwariix disabi.§i.£§; Thirg by -éE,:s&ii'” is awi fiat: mic
t;L’r%.ir;t;fi_:i :::.:s:fiIrV1V¢: {§§.i:s::iE3iEi£}! a.i’fm:i:«; ihes agpgciiané. in more ways i?Ia3.*:
_ {me n’£;-me%.__g}’,’ $3552: ££>:;:s us? tsaméng c:.af;a;.z:i§§; ix reiiucsd which may
230% §:;::._:_ iII’ii’rx:c3′.ia{c: or uapabic mi’ hazing @:;i.a%>§i.~4he:d 23.1 Ehc iriai. E:
z”%::3Eiij§ Eiuzi Ezmamz Eargtz ami éuurihzzr 81¢ dis~;a.’£:»§E§i§g 2%.:-:–;u§i:~; in
“adep1’§m’:§:;I3 ¢_>i”:,:ET:z::r .§.’ur.’u:iie.m:~; bsing ;.’:er§E>n’:m:LE is; eapaciiy wi’§§e.;§1
may mat rc:~;z2;iiT in t~:ar::i:3g:; 3:422″ 2;m1¥:;i ht: »;.;:§”32:.ra;:§c’rés:ed as :s1mmz%Eéc:~;.
E’>
I .. .;4;,.”i’; ‘r'{ ‘§E “fi_~~’:’;’a 1. f L?’ 2.’.
:26 £.»€}fi:i..,3§ mi} .3 ms i–,,(};J.tyi:§ :3, at,
9 .
Htsmzc, ihcrzs is juési§§E.a.:a£.ia.3:3 in gmtzi €31′ c::n1;}e:1;.:ea:£écm~i§§wa;f:is
disahiiiiy mriwiéhrsianciiilg, ihaé i§¥€$!’E:’> sxzas no pr(}<;i'_.('£§'déA1fi*%=§§';z£i{m
:24' i3'§i;:0i'3"1i~3. H::z1¢.::«:, {he £i§"ff.'%f:3i}2i¥iZ is; c:r2€;i»iie:<:§ mi <ii:s;i§:;:£1Ei%y"m1_zj_ 1§"i':i:
very basis mi' wh§u§'1 figs T:*'ihur:a.§ E';23..~; 'g3"e$t:e:£:e§::L§Ea;.:;:::'fi.p1'3ié§'._i.§it:._
im:wm.:~; sh.a§l ha F.a.§<..::n ai Rs.3§3Ci{};5~».§i§*:sieac§.31.35: 'Q/héu§; 'V
uvana Eézcz appefiani is en§;iE;E;:d £63"éfi}"5é§fL1'2i1£§:"£§t2§"§§ i”i:e_3a*f2}*>c:::;rg::,i.imrr
L:mi§r ihis head ‘:.3j«g Rs.52,?6§}»}«~;.’ ‘V ‘L
(*3. Ae;e.:L:r4ii:r::,’»_zf1.§y, “cI$p’C.§:’l§_ ‘;.’:?’.s£}’:,3e»’f.”‘,'{§.VV The appeEE.a11.§ is
ttrziiiizsd E,e:__;.¢;_ iiiigsfi” é£1:..:ig_iiVViig>.1_£2;E._Vi;:§:;2g3@:::;.:é.£§¢2;1 mi’ R.~;.’:}§,26{}.:’~ wiih
inieresi {.h_._t:rt:e;)t1 ai V699?)-zi€:?}A£1’1n £’I.”0m Ehc: dale oi.’ {he award.
Judge