High Court Karnataka High Court

Chandraiah S/O Late Basappa vs The National Insurance Co Ltd on 11 November, 2010

Karnataka High Court
Chandraiah S/O Late Basappa vs The National Insurance Co Ltd on 11 November, 2010
Author: N.K.Patil And H.S.Kempanna


RE TEE mesa cwm E2)? KAERNATAKA. AT BANGALORE
m’z*E.z:3 Tms Tim 1 W my 01? HGVENmER,_.f%§1.€t§~-..v

WE SEE”?

Tim HGRELE rum. Jusfricg ” R

*z*m:: I-{€.}Z’I’BLE 2»m4:::mcEk*H.s-KEz¢mg:ma %

M.F.A.NO.T71L%j;;?§)05 am.

BMW EH:

am
AGED,4syrz*_.&A.”ze:?;-«V.__”‘. . .
12/M-JQnmALLE:ta¢m;Lx,,
c35mca1<:.a.Ys=s1{A2e*A}§ALI;1. TAI..'IJK,
TE3Bߣi}RD1'.STRIC"3;'-

_ .4 % …APPELLAR"i'

V m; Nnaégsxmxan, Amt)

1} E 533;" . "

2; -.’.;fHE.z~:§'”1}3:cxAL mzsummcg co. LTI}.
mzfammz emcm,
sugfimm semmx,

V x BANGALGRE-569 G01.

‘ nix 3 srmm am rmxsmm mnnrms,

PR£3FgM..CEAH§RA$KEEAR RAG,
330.4?-52-?, 8 RAM,
VEHAKAPATHEE, AI’.

3. sm.maam
wm arm:-mmraa
A333 46 mm

2.; G A ERRAPPA cnmmuxn
mm sumnme, KUMARA 3-mam,
€ifi}5I£§FA.TKI NAGAR, am cams,
LAG-GERE, BAEQALQW.

(BY SR1 Eaaassaxamnm, ADv.g1’R¢12§1, ~. 1 ” L
33:. F.SHIVAKEI1i§AR,AI}V.-,.__B'{>R 123; ‘
R2 KQTIGE nrspsasmn Vm §’1*;1..1f.%_._9.2o my

TI-I13 mm m mmn UI{fif£R__&E§STI{f)r%_v1_73( i} or av
am’ Ammsr THE ‘ 14..V,:a;V:iq’n::a% Awézén ngrmn
ae.4.2ou5 Passw m lav»-2: AHf> ;4972.{_;££§§54’_<2H THE mg Ev*;L;V«.%€;%:;:§;19r:;:as,A?1o2¢ Am sssmza

E1§”fiAHCuEM_V.*E1e’rV(3F ‘s:::v<m §»E2e's..°s.*i*:c:1sa'.
' " mtg cmmm cm mg gamma mas mm

kw – r§;%2<§;1Bém"L«q,, fisfimma THE FoLmwm3:–

apmz by 'aha shaman: is éizfecfiad against me

A ' comma judgt and awarfi datw;

.f§3.’§.%G5 paasad Nt.’3.4’§?’2;’ {)4 0:1 tlm fflc 6f the:

K {WW/WM

« A_

3
IV Addimnai Judge & Member, MACT; figabre

(SCCH 30.5) {for afwrt Tribunal}. Thfi ‘FI’ibux1ai its

impumieé cammnn _}’udi1t and award awazwcl-5:1′

9:’ %’ 2,21,&m;- with intermt at 6% pa. fra1’fi:”t2:ie;T

pemsn 6:1 payment as X

slag t ft): ? é,00,0%[ – an

by firm quantum of by ttw
‘I1*ibLx.Im1, the cla12na’ :31.’ VA present thia

appwfi ” » flwmpensatiesn awardad
¥3Iwarda V’ ami ether caxxvantiarxal

hmgis, eff tija’ am mfimnmmmt.

A brieffiacm afthae caseara:

3.115. the 3″ responderfi ane the

decmsw Shiva’ kumr. It ‘as: cizntcnded

k V » amseé was a bachebr, agea abuut 25 yeam,

__ a pmviafian stare car-ning ? 1€3,0fi0f- hum. He:
W¥z9’aa hak and filtluzy prim” m fine éata af aczcidm. Tim!

an 3.é.§€304 at about 11 p.:r1., éua ts; rash arm ngligsnt

%

vi

drivirzg by the drivm sf the asfiendirg

aemsea S win: was gem an me

suatained and suxzcumwd in the

spat, On amount of

the parfi’ lives, have

ma apwllant was mmua?r’w§”ta V’

Lnzflw 8-acttfian 166
agairzat that resupandenjfi’ aama up
for iim the Tribunal,

in am dacummtazy
‘:1 the claim’ wtitiun in part

awarding Lfié: Eaf A§EsV.”2,21,&O@f«~ uncler difiwmt heads

;mt%s»%*p.&, mag aissamfiaa Wiizh the

appellant has prwxmtad this appeal

.j3;a:_ We have mm firfi caaunaal fir flsm

L A _ mm mums: fur the aw mpenamt and
mag anurme1far§ trmpoadent–inau.t-at-,

XWMWMWM

3

4. Afim’ mrdxfl evahmnian of the

award arm éthasr relevam matesriai availablge 6;}

emrges is that the a afthe

swath 0f the dacwsefi am mt

wag agfi abeut 25 33% 3.

‘§?txe1’nmm¢ cftkze dacmaaaaggessgd *f;-mug: is kk

an the lower side’ cihcupafinn
arm the fiependants, ms inmnm
at 1′ 4,33! ~ 33$. the persomal

sx§:eI:;$§fi€df “he was 8. bachelar. The
age (fans of the accident was

45 gas éfthe law iaici dawn by the Apex

case, the proper mulfipliar

‘ Thmwsfaré, the: ccvmgxzsmafien

af dewnflzmy eumam but Q 3,i2,0GO[– Q?

33.2 msntlm x 13 muliiplierj and aoeoraimgly’ we

‘ éiwaré the saw.

fig Furtimg the’£’r%L1rm1Imerre’dir1awax’diI1.g

cnly Q’ 5,00Gf- tcwarda aansparmfistz azxfi funmal

(/ wwwflwflkfl

5
ezxfiw afi mt awarded any amunt mwarda ihss af

wtaiue era less at’ love ané afieczicn.

dmm it fit to award 2 mom;-» tmaararda

3 10,000+ E? 5,om;« each} meg;-gs ”

aw,-m’ :1 and 2 m,so0j- 3 ;gae§*

3″-‘ an-a ‘tr: ./Ea total
mmpensamm sf % 3.4g,cm:.[% 2,21,m<:,I- .

5% time apwl 'w

ccmmn judgment am
award in Mm N¢.4972;@4 an

& th_e*efx t1§g:r:a:idi:iam1 Judge & Mmnber, MAST,

% 3a;g af§:m:v'«vA.VA::"{S$CH M63 is hecreltry masiifiafi. Tha

'V 3351 rampcxzdmxt are anti} 11% fat 3 install

mgpsmafinn af Ra.3,+2,wa;- as wins: 2* 2.21.0033!-

~ by me *:a.~:mm1, The erzltmwwé aompensatisn

ta i' 3..21,Q09!- with inteamt at 6% p.a.

'fremfirwdam cfpaeti*5mn till the dam affilmfitanixl

afiditiarz B: the wmpemafifin awfirad by the Tribunal.

'ml

'fim 1* Impancient-Ir1a1.11'er is

the ¢ m t?mfl a .

wmh fium the debs (if gf

judit and award. _ _ _ .

cm of the 2 3o,cm;~
each with _ %i3’é:tez<'j_'£f§;t dcpaaitcd in
the name (sf appl V' lax} in any

Hatwna' far a p¢rmd' 91'

ye1°m;V' sim'1 "aw thsir respective" ixztermt
pea-:adic.a13y;% "

with pmyortianate isrzfiazmt

éhaiij. equafly, in fawmr of the appeliant am

immediately an depusiting by; the

‘ Imu.t¢:::*;:.

ts draw th-<2 , stemming' 13;.

5//WWW