MFA 1536/2005 C/W
MFA 1538/QQO5 8;
MFA 153?/2005
cmzcurr BENCH AT GuLBAR£¥AMM'A%%«" %
aEmdRE_ V
THE HON'BLE_} MR.J{JHSi'vVI_'iv{.',EwV§3.S..!.5!i'§7I:LA
M.F.A.fia;};m5§§(30§56*--.g§j
gr .A.Hm~~.£§§8[3G£_)5 Egg.'
A O; % .4
m1wmsrg;-----. N
The Branch ManagcE*,:"~ % _ VV " _
United Indiau11'1su1'a:1_ce--.Co. L-t;!'.',«
Bijapur, mprésgntnd by its'
Deputy Managei, ' ~ '-
Unitcd, insuxancg Co. Ltd. ,
Regional. Oifioeh _____ _.
=.shan1:amna.va3a31:m_ Building,
Baflgzilgre ... APELLAHT
my art mxfaadagouda, Adv.)
5:59; 153612006
' _ *3_.Hémt. Neciamma,
" ' W/o Channabasappa bmyyapura,
Aged 47 years.
W -.~:« -=--«--»-~w»w« wwm W mmmnm mm wmm" W mmfiamm mm mam W' mwmmm mm mum
IN THE HIGH mum' on KARNATAK3 V
DATED THIS THE 4TH DAY 01'» é3EP?:?E:zs§BER;"::§o§§
mmw--- W-u\Jw!?€.¥ W mmmmm mm-a cmmt 0? KAWMAM Him-i cmm W mmsmmm émmw «mum
MFA 1536/2095 <3/w
MFA 15.38/V2005 85
MFA 1153?,420o5
2. Sri Shankam Gowda,
W/o Channahasappa Muyyapura, I
Aged 25 years. '
Sri Ravindra, V
S/0 Channahasappa Muyyapzjxafl
Aged 21 years.
D/o Channabasappa ¥9i11_y}*'aptu:a,w , " "
Aged 18 Years.
Anam r/at0ddeidagri. :' _ %
(By Sr! Asgmk
:1: MFA 15331 300.5% A
1.
w
sri Ma31aP13%=i;~w %
S] 0 V’ Ma}1a.devap’paV
‘. ….. ..
wax Gdéafasjagi,
Basava:t1:.«1_ Bafgagiwadi,
. Sfi Ma11appfi,:’~”A
7, SI 0 Sansappa Vali.
‘T “Major, Féjat Odavadagi,
..f’Basa1.(ana Bagewadi,
_ Bijaplir. Imspoxnmrrs
Ashok H.Patil, Adv: for 3.1)
umr1n\w’lr’*maI’\E\£'”I I’El’£s97¥’3’ fin-“o.J”‘JW.’ ‘J?
MFA 1536/2005 c/w
MFA 1538/2005 8;
MFA 15V.3’P°»,f_20{‘)5
12% p.a. fnozn 1.3.03 and directing the
deposit the same. 9
These appeals coming on tor hesfing,
made the following: V
01. These three appeals.’ are by} athe. ai)pe}1ant–
Insurance Company 29.1 L200-4
passed by the Cozomissioiier’ ‘:Compensation,
_ ‘
02. The ;t’i’ieVV’oom1non order challenged
in these Channabasappa and the
other two ~.-iiamely, Bheemaraya Hoogar and
as loaders in the tractor–trai}cr
and that in an accident which arose
one course of their employment under the 5&3
V’ 1cspon;:iex;t;v:&v.C§1;annabasappa and the other two sustained
Vvinjmics. The Commissioner has awarded
_ % in a sum of Rs.1,7-4,605/– to the widow and
VT of tieceased Chanuabasappa and Rs.62,394/– and
b”‘4Rs.33,O39/~ to the injured claimants Sri Bheemaraya and
Mallappa, respectively. The amount is ordered to be paid along
%/
waewmuiw
WWW”-w» ww”om»mw”mwwwm &”i!£Ja”‘w1’€€”%’ mwwme WW mmmmmwwtmm mww fiwfifififlfifi W?’ Wflflwflguflfifi WWW fiwwfi? KW
MFA 1536/2005 c/w
MFA 1533/2005 85
MFA 1532/2005
with interest at 12% with effect from 01.03.2003 met
deposit.
03. The main grievance of the»evappeH’an.t¥’E–usumfiCe 0
in all these appeals is that tIie::fintiing” ms
Commissioner for Worlmaenfs the
deceased and the two the tractor-
trailer as leaders} free: the
evidence on the said persons were
grat’uitou§3′ risk was not covered
under the “te1i:e_s 0-f’the insurance policy.
04. for the appellant in support of
the “eententtiflefie submits that the complaint lodged
2 shows that the deceased and the
‘ Vt as gratuitous passengers in the tractor
that”tjtey Wete not engaged as coolies. In the light of the
éttieeeiteiabmissbn, I have perused the complaint lodged by one
Wadavadag. He has not stated in the complaint
V the deceased and the injured were haveiling as gratuitous
passengers. Therefore there is no substance in this contention.
1%
MFA 1535/2095 c/W
MFA 153332995 85
MFA 153?-[2305
6 ,
The Commissioner on his part has examined K
by the insurance company with to7._the
neeord both oral and documentary. “the
who is the empioyer of the the not’
chosen to examine tiieir; evidence
have stated that the were working
as eoolies in the uiznetor on the evidence
on record, a finding that the
tractor to bring fertilizer and
the two injured elite. were
txaveifing teas coolies. This finding being
V based. é ;_on the Vemefice on record cannot be upset by re»
same in exercise of powers under Section 30 of
the Act. At any rate, I do not find
any Apeztversity in the said finding recorded by the
mwmmwmmwewllwfl IIflI’%o?H”3 ‘énuflnifl-ifil WWW’ 9\:P¥.KE’W.9’\§.5’\W\fl
. . , Q ‘ ” — Qemmissiofier.
‘However, it is to be noticed here that the Commissioner
mw-«am-mu: «wvwwwnmn wave
0 ‘e .. {awarded interest on the amount of compensation with effect
he “from 01.03.2003. The accident has taken place on 19.07.2002.
In so flat as the claim made by the legal representatives of
J2»
MFA 1536/2005 c/W
MFA 1538/2005 85
MFA 153?/2905
deceased Channabasappa, who are the claimants
Compensation Case No.26] 2003 E’3f}I,’I’lC’fiI’1:)_1gxd:A”‘V:.
entitled for interest at 12% with ct1″e’&g tflé’
month fmm the date of accidcn£»i;.§i§’;~.fioni.’in far” V
as the other two injured ciajmants–i£i”L’W6r1gmeji1’s*Comiiensafion
Case No.27/2003 Br. Bhecmaraya and
Mallappa are congtjtngd, interest on the
amount of cflbct from the
date of v’:fCoVn1missioncr i.e., from
29.1 1.2094 as non-schedule injuries.
06. With .,%lb’0V(:i’vInACafiij..i:f’!.i%1tiOfl, all the appeals are disposed
he; ____ deposit shall be transferred to the
‘-$o:$;ifi;issi91ie:tj’ f6r_ Woackmcnfs Compensation, fiijapur, for
di}-{bu .:3a” 7 with iaw. Excess amount if any, shall
be appcflant-Insurance Company.
.5 wwrwmw w.mv’ mmmnwamwmmm mmrn mwwwu wa” mammflamfifi fllzwfl flmwuxi mi” %mEKNfl3.’Kfil.¥(A Mfiéfifi Cfikififi? W? §€1%RNfia”E%K& HEQH fiflflflf
wo–esvwnmw wow-as mum-1-numuum-gar-us-u”1 vcsmwmwe
Sd/-.
Iudge