High Court Karnataka High Court

M/S Atria Brindavan Power Ltd vs The Oriental Insurance Co Ltd on 24 July, 2008

Karnataka High Court
M/S Atria Brindavan Power Ltd vs The Oriental Insurance Co Ltd on 24 July, 2008
Author: N.Kumar
a...

£3    ésggzxar or KARNATAKA AT Bgmfiéfiififl.-. _

Eiatfid this the: 24*" da}f'bf'J'L3J.§g',    V
3E:§%sr:gRE  
-mg 1-ION"BI...E MR. ;:"*:$f*i*z¢:.E it 
Writ TPet:it_ion, ._13£'5'"Z}m1'V_§fif'§;§:1§'F--«§GM«§ESj

BETWEEN;

faiij 3,  B:%:i;1:iE1'?jE3:1 §'tr:xn:*Lr..VLtd'.';'
E3 i"§i«:v:.:1pm:3?1:reg.§;stef&ti.11n.n;ie.:' '
Clumparjjitzs r"1r..:'i: §i_;.:.»1§fi1:g 1&3 
Regisififad £'"}f¥':¢:a '2';_"%'§ri.J  
Ba11ga3.0ra?'--E>6QGt'j1 I " ' .
R<':1:::T'«€e:9£:;:1t:::~j~i_it::s . .iZ3i:~e§-t:t{3r 

Firat Cmaei Gajldhiiisggar  " L. ' 
B'c'ii1g31iT5£'€: ~ 2360 {)6   _ I

The B1'.§;a;_1i<th"~iv2é:iz:;*:~?;g§i-«ff-._  _ ,  
O1:'i§-.:1'£a1 =¥.:1sI:;é7f»:;11<:'t: f3z)f}2§:31ij§' Ltgis ,
 "  
Nf§v:f§§¥3'ifSf'?}f}Qf"<,'   . _
E¥'i.:'*:4;i Cross, _  __
Bangagorg M 3:160--om"  "

Eviiz A K Gapta' 

_~ 5%, K Gaxpta 3% "2'£.a§§§;¢iates
A "R~1'4g'14'(;} New Raj Nagar
V' ~ v-_-- 2C}1 {F812

A . 'Mr, K --.BE3i:3han
.33 B fasscfezriates

Ciajlmsh Facififatgrs and
Re"::::::m%¢1'y Agents

 " +..T}_~3'c:»,f.s?%'=¥;~§ Ur:111aniLay::2:1i"
 2&1 Crmp£m3z in appc-iiating K N Ehilshafl Em:
Imspondetnié as 'L};T;€ i:uvt:si_igaiu1' as itxtigpaitzd 7§I;i"i£:~s.:i;:i.i:i:i' tfiaiagd "
1%-'--?--2GG?, A:11:«:=:xi.:1*e-G».   '   

T3113 Writ Peijtion s::c:111i11g 911 a 1EE:1"»1'{:»iii€1':§..'  £i£{3-*;"1:ije._V
C,'»<:r:11"°t maria the fflfléwiélgi ' 7 V'  1 M '

0 R 9 

That pf:.it:i.1:1'I*aI'j._ q1:as}1.i_H.g--V. 1%.I:g,u§3Xiir:::¥§'3: -- by which can:

I<:,:\L B1j;ii$é::1;-fighe " gggpgugzgfii'  ha;:i hem appaintcd by
1B3ponL1ei::i--§39'mpai1§}"~. VaL~;._.V'T'i31§é¢3figat0r anti fer a writ of

manéamufi §:ii:3tiC?1:it;1g'._1'és;;§cr§:ii€.I1ts-2 ix) 4 to Séffifi the ciailn of

" v the §;€i;ifip_;fi £31: and' ii;r:*..£?s.fht::' f:{}I}S€q1l£i',21{'.'iEii n.=,i1'€:fs.

A' . '1  _ _ V."E7ij§:%:~.pt'iiiio;1¢r--C;«:3m;}az1y'was inctgqmratgd wtiti;1 tilt:

€:§§:;'.r:c:*L€.i:i_VAc:2fV 9. Hydra EififI,'i3"i(f P:r0je(:L pmduce else-tric:ify

V _.:»::_:t1d  {be same to Kamataka Pawer T'ra31s;;1:issi<:az::

.  fiivxféfirafigéfa Ltd, The Government of Kaznataka by orcietr daicd

 ._€')'T§_v.Q'?3§9Q9 and £'}5:3,C72.2D€}1 E1{iI?£}I'd!_'3t_'} its sa31(:t,i<):n. if; the

  p1f:;Sp03ai Cxf tha p€:t.i1jt:nar--C01;1pa11y fer)? i1}S'f,8Hai"."§{'}]"§ Caf mini.

k/



hydm 6:-.1€(::'{3:jc: power ge3ne1'atiz1g statioii of 12 MW capafirifir at

the head works; 9:? Visveswaxaiah canal 01;: the 1:::f"E"  'hf

E{:'i5si111arajasa.ga1' dam near I{a11I:a111'm:.fi_..i'  V'
Szirangapatfla Taluk, Mazzdgrsa iZT3:ii;~t1*£n:--*;,  Thé "*§p§:1:Vii1't:§:;1t:i:

C£ompa13y Iriuiy inafalled the gait}   
{ZTj3i1'1II1EfI1{3€{3. in November   $6": V
cost of R3.6D36.52 Ialchs, 'The ;;§~j2.f§§iA'(3x:«*2§_t:§*  %T,i*:£-;éQfi;:£j.$V.v%"£:'£>I'i.£i§'Sui0B. Corgaoration

Lirgi,  _  '  '

  T56 f;2efi%i§;f§i1:§94'€f§§)1¥zpa_ifg}Vmszlmti the p{)w:=:1' hmum
buiidixrigs  c:s:a:m,=: Vayffigicé» hoists and gates, giant ami

machfiggyg §i1';{i  ~EiCCfiSv§;0'Z°i;?.'»S, sW2'tc:i1ge~ar e»q1:1'pmen't anéT

   swegc, gates, dxafi: zinibi irubti gaies

  afrangemants, intake. Weir] fazmbagf, bxidge up

sizéalji,  iicrwn stmam, It was insxmzsi fer a sum 0f

  The policy was in fame tiurilzg the peziod

% V.I2:é.iTé2;.2o05 to 2m:2,2e<;}c3, A sum g:-f R$,6,3¢3,4Q5S[~ mwards

 :£:1sura:1c::: premium: Unformnaigiy, dim to tmferessma.

"fi:%?¢ésc:I13, an i2:8,{)'?.20i}6 at abtrmt 11-4i) 3,33, $12 }'€'£3i;'JI1g wall

of the }3{LI'§&?'£§1' hams:-2 ccfiapsed resuifiing in large volume gf waist

\\/



gushing into 2114:: p<:2wr:=.r siafion and causiirxg 1033::-3 2.9
e:"::::':.2.n, 1335211: 2321:} ma-::i1;i12e:'§;, Immediatag'  
a<:.t::.id::1£, {ha pefifi0n€:2"--{T@mpany in  4-:;»Vtib_1f:'f<"' ~
agenciss i::;:r€::3q3c:¥:te:3 'ta s1jz'iii;;-ii:  Withzh Bf} days, because of

{ielajging 'L:-1t;'.V9i;'ia.'7_s:A ad§fapték5_ 1311:: first I'ES§}{3D!.'i€iI1t, he did not

. _31,1b§1.i1§:¢:h§s"mpor;fi  «-.39 iiayss, However? an 29,65,203? the

 ..r::s;,}:3:;3.€i't'ijr£i:.i;1'timai:ec1 fag pafiiiioner that the Suzvcyor has

siii:s§ii.t_r'.::2ci"  'i§::'ie:r*im repcrri: in"ter+ai:ia mcrommendixzg far

.pa}mént "(if 35,5 Cmres as an 8{f{}{JilI1t };}Ei_'§:"£fi€fI1f, a~u:1»:i after

.44"'a%§c:Aepti11gVV"ih€ Samm the repaggrii has }.'.3fliE'.1"; f€iI"W£7:!1'Clf3i3. in the

 Reggicfiilai Gffifse wiiiz their r¢:€:z3m::3e:::1§Eaf;i0:::s 3:16 the Regional

  in irftujrir fun; 11:33  fiat: Said report '£0 ihtzt haad office

" " "far ar:*.iIré§:a:1. T315 p::tii.i::>::.'m:'--C:cr111paaJ3y was Ilfjéi', ftzmisuhed with $113

x/%



 , is  

G»

f_¥3€'- 1"1:i*;oc:~:"t, Hgwevex', '£315: petitioner oht.aiz1cci the said
,f¢:;3:)fi by £1§}1JI"()§.»T£ChiI}.g tbs S1.1rvc::y01* dixectly. 
resgéerldent, ziiii not BVEI} pay f~2s..:'3 cmres 
S1§I"V!":jr'{}I' $99.11 after lapse cf .f::)11r momhs,   _¢  
C«:>mpa1:;y was constraizmd to iSS11¢31:.$>tAEAt;'V§f¢bT%:I:;'"cistL':v 
had 129 efi'e::.t. Instcacl of s.::-'d:3»iI1_g  of 
Czampany, the: 1't33ponfients i:1tit:3é"t.€d f};e"-- ' i£if.T!E3% 
dated 19§{'2}".2{)C»7 that: fhfgy   Vé\fh'";" Bh'£1S§13;l35

the 6&1 respondent harem  'i::ifie'r:v;;§friga:¥;:o';* 'éuvcsfigating tha

eiaim of tiié”;:z:’§iif§i0:iéi:7~–‘*{?2:§1:;§:2z311}T6′:i:ré”iiie points II1!i§I1ti{)I16{§ in the
said Eettfir csf ap’pQi1;i;:1§~::11i’ “}:’»::’ .An11r:.xur:-:–f3. Chaliatixging the

afaresaid ap§xfgii1h11f::§t €31” “i:;_§%iestigatc:1*, the: pxmsxsznt writ p€?:i’i:io:1

» . ‘«.§%a:§}:~Q31€i&n’:s are duty sawed. T11:-.y have fiiuad {I1-air

r:;r.s’_’:rf-.1:Vi’.’:eV..r $111: Cioclxmemis and have j1.1siifi$d i’}1c:. acticzn

. Qf iilvergiigaior.

AA ‘ H Sri, 8,K,\?1 Cliuaiapathy, iearfleci Senior Ciaunsal

‘–.T.’.*E:§§};é:a:!i11g fog’ fhr: p€:fiii0:1er~Compa1:;y relying 011 R::gI.11a’ii¢:}11 9

””The Insurance Regulatory anti fieygiopnmnt Authariiy

‘$1/..

(Proteciian offiaiicyhalders’ Interests) Reguzman ztaégfar
Short. herai”:122ft€r I€:fé:1°rt;t:’i 11:: as R€.g111ai:i(:az1s,
}}]S111’aI1(3f.°’. Company 6331 01113: agrpaiizt. .23; u
heurs fmm the rszcreipt cf intimation
i,§_§I;1Ivé:yc;r Eraas ‘E123 Cc::::.I1111I1ica::3 i1».i.s_ i:13§:§.ftta$’:1rt:r
38 days; crf his app0inimaE:::”:}: subnlittad by the

S-‘1iE’%iB’,?(}E’,vi$§i:!§’f}:l1pii3§*3′,. tin: ;E;1s121″*;::;::e:.cf compaxw can requast the

§’?§i.11’V€y01′ “fQ “fi:1:)iSf;.V:E;:itiifi€i::;;§i Ifipert 0:1 Cefiam sgecific issues

as may bi: §i’&:§{i:i3x::Vi :f1§1lS1,1It’:I’= The said :n:3q1.1e:3tl is “((3 be

.v _ made: 3.33 the {iaie of the repuri and 2:311 re.ce.ipi

‘ <:sf §'sa'l."§11i;?:., sheuld E6: dacidtiii Within 30 days. In E1716

iIi::t:13)Tt' £§é;s§:';;._:h~§%"S11Ivcy9r was appo:int&.1;L H: has submiitcd

.his fiiierifii Insteafi sf wailing the claim, as per

.!?i'I11}f3§§:'I.lffi§¥'(:i', 0212: more Invzsfigamr is appoimttd. Thercforzi, he

that 'the: appoizltrnant 0f Invefifigater Itqujres to he

.. "cgu:«:sh::ti and a cI.i;r'e<::i:i011 is 'tr; be issued to €116 instzrance

\q/

Compalry to setfle thtsr. Claim wit.hi11 the Time sfip11lated"'u nde:r
Ciiause 9 which period has 21130 expin:-d, .

43, Pet: Catalina, the Icamed Cmm:3t:1
iuaumnca cgtemyany submits that {Si}:-iAi’;V1s é’9v
rjsniy speaks sf appoinfmgnt of $’uIve§?o;’
damage, it is true that 3. se{%cs3:§ci’v–Si’;$vey'{g;1*
under ‘iihéit said p§:3vi.si0I;,:–* .’xI”hx:-l i1ai}:5″:1Qi’,”%.ppoinieci

a second Su1v&3e*or, ‘ififhalfkijatygy ‘i3.$1zing An1:ui~t_x1_Im~

C} is it} appiézim’ V-ti«;gz;;=VV’%1:sp$C%i$ Wilzich 21113

§LI1{i7f1″§}:CI3’i»S§€§: in Af;EL:.t§ ;EiL€§T’g§f,;:i{Tip(Z»’iI1¥§1€1’lf, which was not fllfi
gubjact m’&:i;’né2L:’A csf r§:fi::it::r:€.é’6.___f:3 ‘Em: Sxzrvaycyr, If the iI}Sl,1I’3.B£.’i(3

cwmpzaztjg ..iénG§ré flia f:”£’:1tj; of the: izaciticzxat and to find out

‘£f~::11eii:s:éi’ ¥:heri:._is anffiiischief piayaci and wherz they have film

‘3:g3i3*;3z:.f ‘£13 A3_1i_:;:Z1 apggyointxnenia the pe”EiiiQ:1er~C{>mI2any has

:10 imgétls SfEifi’£.§,’iA’f,0 :i:.I’2.a}ieng€ $31.2: Said appeintxnentg In so :far as

‘£31: {é’Eai;;} i~.3f the pa:%%;i'(.i;z:>3::ae,r Wit}’.1i::1 T335 peiimi Stipulaied in

“§€t_:gt1i:si”_%i<:11 9 is <;x::11t:é:::fr:ut=:c:i, ii: is 3Z}K:Z'.Céi11S¢3 0f '§'iE'Ei;¥';1¥; of repert frog:

izwestigatcri rim": sama has btzzm with-held, Hcswetvargg staps

Em 'fflkfifi "Eat; saifltzt this ::*:iai111 at the: ea1'3it:*3't.

\~./

'2" Fmnm Eh: facts, it is: Clear 'i}:Zz1fi'i.{" i3f1!3»

1.}4:’§ifiz:>:.1a§:.r has i:t3,$ure.x:i its pitrjfici with the
far :21 :31..1:n1 {sf Rss,.33,’;2:3 cremts, Ht: has pE1i€i.v’.€;1″‘~§3I’E:§i}ii§_1’H1 [cf _

Rs,6,.’3€;fl»€}.3j—. The yeficy p€1’it:u:i
i2;6.i;?~2{k’36, Iii is ciurirzg flit? pagigrgl i”§iif.,
accident task place: 9:: ‘i;h’t:: VV.’Vi1.;_V:’;*ez”i12g’V
slzstaineczi Ifhfi 12333 haw’: Sift: ‘fi’1l3″V1;jI1§’:11Z’E!11C{?

»:::0131pa:.1y in iima, T316. i’1*;e_S1T::**a:}::i:%:%: gjzmjipaigy is under an

::»i::niig:~:§%:i01’1 it} _ Vi”i1€}: “:;~”:.:;§1Ei*.1s’:% tilts: Claim in

EiéfflfjrfdaI}€:€””i*?§_flf3- R£%?gf;:}.ai3’=9:’1–. 9, tsrii-bin the p€I’1i{){1 stiptliaiaeci
fiafirfiin.

8, fif_R3§§:11ati@11 9 skews that a ilzstireti :3:

. i’hEi ci.:2:i§;ai:? $haH”g§.§%;;__;1«:atic€: is the 511311131′ of :_=;u3r loss atisixlg

V_1.z:::.::f’:’er_V c;z:z1:i1i’:=1Cf. “–:>;_f E:1sura11:%e: .5-1’i:T the aarliegt er within such

¢:*;;cf£s3:1?iz:{§é»:”§2&::éV §1ay be ailowsd by {he iI1S1.£i’f;’fiI¥ Ca’I1{‘:£’3 suczh

.c::m:2:<'i:I1ie::V§1fit.ii is mceivetd the §I1S'{1IY3? shall mspond

'%"fi1;31r::j§:i;aii£5i3r anti give, 0.3%: irzdicaiign :9 the :ins1m::r'i on {he

_' v'Ai'§}I"i.T1;t:V,'/:l?,':;.i'it.§.I'i."'iS tiiai he 3h0u1r;i f:::ll<::w,. In case where a '511I"&T6jf{)3i"

in be ajppai:1te,::i for aazsgessilmg :3 }.(IzS:'Ei]€:13§1{1, iv: shaii ha :30

M/V.

Cifillfft :x2i”i}:;i1: “i’°3 h{:n.1rs 011 m<:'?.eti}:3t: cf the CGm.II1}.lf£1iC&I_i{3I]. fxfzfs-r«,_1_1 the

iI1S'i.1I"E1£i ,

9, In $311: i11s;ta11t ctascjt, the pfififiaxlar "

:::1aj111 giving notice to this. iznslmez’ ai3c.1’1t..th£: §0SSv§i1VS?E1i11E”:£i: by

him, figs fha i{1S1lI”aI1(3(i Crompany §§a:1:ié:i’T aéaessmcnlzvié.

S11:*v¢:%}’01”; ‘iiho1T1gh not wii§1:i11 72 ‘i1L}11I’S £1:-3 Ii:§111i§?’fi(i«:._’1:1<3@:I.::%':' {ha L

Ragzliatiuxzs, they have ap_poi:1ied1___:2§é"S_11;¢:v_eyQfi;'ings ti}: spot:
and assass tha damage§3;'<–_ tin' 1'r}:1e1§.5' of appr:;i1:1m1r:11t

whirsh. is proci.11c:::d at Azmm-:v1:r€'~R3 Asats ¥:'su¥;' Work e:1f:":.1st::~:£1

to 'this SI.1_13'i%r;i_'§-sf£:r:.f? 15t7:7a:.i.$ as 1::.1:;'n:a3':

'ff: Qrtfer 'Vii; i;1,i§y{2,ie the £035 mans: prompfiy,
; 'zgrere aci1%i.:g¢:éV'3;'o1;. in g,df2.ere 250 the foiicxwzhg cmiian.

. 'vffiiiiii Emci Zz'm.s:-Ti }§é§}zTe{2'z; I8:

VV ‘ 2{j§’;.V: .YO”£1 musi reczcrzh 15:92 Site of the 133.3
1:;i£.h.:’?§.’I__ hm_:,r:3 fmm recyeipi cf ih.e letter; i

‘ €:r:§:24::,ék:§ied by £1.23: 0!}z.enm’:3e zzzithin 48 Emma

:32. Yaw’ prefim.ina.r§; c2s3és3mer’:.£ report

(:3-n.:a.z’nin.g ihir: foI§<3'z.:;ir:g zmzsi remirfeg u;~:' ziriiizin 16

k/%

:1Ea3_E;s frzsm (fate {if your visit :0 {he sits.

§I

far} Gfype gind ffizizgre of f£}~’3»£’i2

{’59) Digiiai phaimgnzphzs and

fif3’n= or’: C1} cfepiciirzg the rig1.m(1ge3.- 3
pi:oic;grt3phs .3hm,zic§ e2.ssg2;gi;’a=iZ3; i;é”i£::i’ie3: i2»$ ” _
Ezzmg shais giving fXZ3’ipfQH1£C:,Zif£f§’i£3 Gf

10531

{:3} tflzzuse cffire. gxcz.c*,:’ «:_~a;.11\:–.a3~[ iiqiii’
£fe§er*I:F:i:zed, _ the ;rne:::_.s__t f}r9£}r;bIe Ct2:£,:3V-3(3),} In
fmzzi :2 ciz.roi’:.;3§i:g2’c.i;£ :.:z.e:scii3:m.:f_A £3}? the axgiizriiies

sfa.ouZ(;Z be givezre} 2;:}<:A:'f'r;:fé ti£jihe_’_.e::2en£;

_ V1*’z:}”§é};ti

:-

” ,:”‘0’:_§r ()3:1Ser:;:1iiQz’z3 crznd «::G3’y’irma.ti0II.

‘ fire? E933 Ccmimi me::z»3u:1’e a.t:ic:apie:c.f by

* fire Ciiéezrzt and azzheihegr 2552.23; (1136 adeqzxciie

fgj 3″‘a2,:.r érozrzfinnmfian tizzzi suitfabie
z?zeasur9:3 fsazze Eieetrz. 1’Iz2’iia.1’.€:cf far retriezzirzg

me d£2.:n.:<2geai3 pmgieriy nrtznci giispasal af

:s::z.iv§z.g€:

(ft) _’I’€;ur recx)mmendaTiion fm’ reieasirrg “‘(‘_):*’s.- V’

A] 47:’ pa.yn:.§,m=£ ill) the ciéezrzt

if} You shoufzi aéso ‘g;”i:é%M;:;£11z:vj Qi2.:~:.y:-27″:.: :.L:.iit;”– «’
an. “I£)}111I,i should Iu’.1I..n3 beer: zifigfléf (1éfn’.ri£:i7:e::i fer T A

er:.32.m’r;g that 2f}”2eré fin rezé-‘z7;cf2i::.4:j*;*:::;’.:f:_”§éV’Vff
1&3. This E§11I’Vf3y£3:{” aftfir if; the spot
331d firs: he s11’r_v::1_ifi::r_i for
pa;;m1E.:::.t. ergf Rafi V«:r¢:rres__ to ‘£113

};:::i:Zt:i:):1z.=.;”:*;’ fgfii. to E§é”si:bmitted by ihe:-3. S:1rve:3:::::*.
Rfigtliaiiflfl’ “II3V€§Z:i(f¥;1.V1a(fl1§§}§:’3E1f3;tgE_::[af.€S the pciiitiod W1’thi:u which

113516: S1.1rvey<:rr has ip f:1::::i$i?,~':i1is i'imii1'1g3 and how the ii1S¥_1I'€I'

– . :3h(>1:_i<;i{'«:.a§:_f:' 0:: 3112.52}: After Stfffijflg ::mi'.wi1':11:i:1 ?'2 h{)11I3

fh€'!7§i£?-Cfiifif, of the hxtimatitrn the: 531}I'%I€}'{)I' is £0 13::

Rt:1g11i3ii:,::r; £2) siattés that "the: S1z;I'v¢3ycsr 311311

'V{:()3'fi1nizI;i{%;:.'f.:€ his fi;31{ii:1g$ ta fhf: iI1S'{1I'€2:" Wifhin 38 {izzijg-'5; afttfil'

aygmiéfiment sviih 3;: 1;'-Citpj,-' Uf 336:. rfitpori: 1:0 the ':I1s111"€:¢:i, if he

(i€=,SiI'£s? Gilly in Speciai C.,i:t:u1n$i a11<:es§ Eifiifii" :i'L:€:. is iifis

~ u$};3£?:n:%iai ami :::€;:11p¥jc::ai::d ;1at1::r53 $316. S"E11'V{ii}'QI" shall 1.1ndr::*

' i::nf3I:11aE.ia:::1 {.13 {ha izmured saek extsnsien fmm the: instzrfir fer

\/

szzbznission 0:? his 3"ep0r'£;§ I12 11:3 ('.836 shall the. S1::i:vey«::r:* La}-:::
m::s:"t:2 iizbail Si); Inaiathfi fmm the dais, 01" his a'ppc.2iI1f13:1E.11t to

fzmzish thc I\Ef;{,}(}1"'i. If an iI1f:31lI{*.}' cm receipt .fti1e s1:1vgyVT»:fé’;;»g:>rt.

flnsiis that it is: i:1-V.0mpi::-the in any msp€:::t, hr: ;”:%::;€:t:-Si.

$11}YfiytI)I’ 11:1d5=;f* .i:1£:imaf.i<::I1 is: t3::t:'. iI}$11I'Efl £0 uai:3.1::lit_io:xézi '

repe:::ri_ 011 e:€:ri:ai:1 sp:=:.z::ifi::é iSS1IfiS xmay 'hf-7?: 1j¥:dffl"£iiI'.§3I';'i'..

ifiS1i1"€.I'. Sash a mq::t:$§T may b€ 'Il.'_1$E_ldB '{5}; the ius1n::+r:rV'ix:£"£I1i':: '.15 "

cié13:'s 0? the rtzccipt 9:" me oIigi1'fi';3w1V:.V'$1.':rveyV" fiftar $110}:

request, the S11:ve3*z:}r SEF'EL3}" f:1t_::":ii$'i1 '}as:i:§iii011a1 Wif;i1Li31

threze; w:3:£:3»{§i=f;:51:1 tfiést, =€;:1":z:= Csf I7E:':€?1s'3'5Z':.}3'i':: of n::r:;mn1L1:1ir:aticsI;, 0:21
2:-ziazsaiyt £1")§_7f."1,':§r3'3'il.Ii';€C;j§01;'f1*f31§t2:};'{"£i!;I' "a::1r.iit:i::)m:1} stlrvey regmrt the

iiflfiilffil" Shaii" zszifi-3 ma 14:11-4'::}:_*i"{,vr.'i:_'3:}f 313 iiayas Qfim" ea settiemsnt of the

1311:: rlrxsfirs-gi, If flit": inssurtzr far any magans to be

' I23€fG§?..i£3£1_i11..wIjii31g and Cgmmtxnicatfid to the .'i11S1lI'€'.Ci5, decities

id :?é§z:.-“_:?i. ‘I:€it€

which is 29/5 above tht: bzank 12%.: _'{31″€VEl1€=I1{ at _

the financial }”€§€i.{‘. _ __ _ _ _

11. {§1;f0ri:u:1at.:_=:iy, in rim: 3’§:1é;ia::1i&c;;as¢:, _i1va11y have .fC3flGX§Ti’§£’1§ théag-t:_ }§rQV¥iS§c_§fiS;” S The ”

ilifliiifiifit E093: place on, On fiG’iv,.08;2Q06 the:
pefi’£:i03.1E:1″ bdgetl the T ‘ ai§1′:31;ra;I1{:€ Compalzy

W35 €X”§3€C’i”.i3x’i, “;””;i’£I’+’:’f3«’GI’ Within “F2 Ilmlrs 031
mtrrzsipt thxfi ap’§Cri;1}ff:d fhe Stznzeyor only on
1€§.f}8K200§3 *i’h¢ 3:13 part shouid have: Sllbmiiffid
the reaper: ‘ 1.3., on 01* befam 16,D9,200€3,

Eviewévéir, 16: ::~;;1bmiti4éfr_*i'”fh& ifitfiiilll 1″€t}”J¢3I”§L 01133’ (:21: 31.G3,2CIO?2

‘i1f’i”.”5_f1ii~’£:§’§1€f:T;(if” AV:1:Z5(,.’–?i’._’t1§)£’11’.1}?’ has 1101: mimxght. for any aafiditicznal

:’epc:}r£;,=7 ‘.E’i’1t=: –.S:1ii5-figor, even €110 this Eiéiiifif, has not stzbmiitetd hi3

V VV _ final ‘at, £5; is clear from. the af0:r£::§;aid Regtliafign, {ha

A. ‘ St::1{g3*ef’%T:iall Stlbitlflif, a repczrt within six mgnths .Ercsm the: {$3123

Aigisf .§:;3p0i11’i:1n;e311iT, which ¢::x:§23′;rt:c1 2:21: i6.G2.,2OD”/’, Thertzfortg it

x czébviczils 15.11.2115 ihe i:1su;ra:1ce comgsany has acrtea’ central}: to

1’5

tht: afomsaifi; Regtziaiinns, T116 ;;eti£7£::::nar~C«:3:npany 1’3. V§t:§;{fii_ie{i
in a;3p.1″*s:»ac:i3:i_1:1g this C¢:wur1′:. for 3 €ii.rer::ti(::n to fi;%f:¥ i12v§;:::1i?>f1:;%:sV{:§i€ _

::.::a:n13a31}’ is sei’fi¢:’: his C3:»1i1n withizl tilfigtigstziafgsgi» ‘ V

12. S12′, C}1a;ia;3aLh}«;

aggpczaiing for ihfi ptfififieszmr §’;!:…1.3.C.lTI11iT4′;:”i:”.t”-5,A:’Y:;~§)”A.¢’Efl’.
issueoti to irhts: iIl$l11″a13£?f_’. c:3mApa11 §?’L«L:.1;:i’s~3eti}v.c:é fhr:°tV
3t.ip11T§a’éc3{i tifizeg far 1116 fiiiifg’ bei1:’g”hc’f{ the. relifif

srmgh’: ibr 2:;1:ashiI:n.g iin_iie.$:mxé–.’G ‘:5.;p}_3r;[‘ .§”§§§%jsa&vz§i1; “Eii:$é::7f}’ 1na’3%”‘m::” msawezi its chaii:::1.ge flxe

sgaiti ap;3€;i11i:Q€¥.;t_ii’ X32123}; ‘iii becomés Iastzessary,
135 211:; }_1’g§1″: “]*the afciresaid facts, there is 114:1

j11stif§v::§:g;if;is:i:9 €133′ i315;r;rance company’ in not setfiing the

::?}::»’:ifQ w§:é1te»*§{r’*~. may ha this p:*€I’.é:Xt, Hence, fhct p:::iiticxne:r~

ti) that reriiéf 3n:n.1gh.t far, h7€;:n-25:, I $35133 E313

V _ f:3.1i¢3’aé:i3’1g ::ii”iii :21′:

apprapiiate eréers an than fiadm made by the

k/

A. , W’ri£ ftetifian is aiiaweé in mrt.

A’ -riirecfismt is ismecl to respargdants-1, 2 mad 3 to

sa/–

petiizigner within 90 days from today. tis

reset-sad ta the petitianer to chailgnge Vn3r§:?£’..

report subymtted by the mid

chooses in an». fill Imés flied in mi

filgd. _ % ”

By an interim gsgrtzgr Court
had extended the till
dispasagi of figs-Lcgzrse. .j}iVri*s;:§v:;£:_VVifIai;rAV’VV’Vz’0:’it pefition is
disposed to disposg af
the ¢£aim…Qf’A”i;f£¢ so aways, gm vaiidity

shalt gxztended by 90 «tags,

Judge