Hemant Kumar Jha &Amp; Ors vs The State Of Bihar &Amp; Ors on 3 February, 2011

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
          CWJC No.8673 of 2010
1. HEMANT KUMAR JHA S/O LATE JAINA JHA R/O VILL.- LAGMA,
P.S.- SONBARSA RAJ, DISTT.- SAHARSA AT PRESENT POSTED AS
HEADMASTER MIDDLE SCHOOL SHAHPUR, P.S.- SONBARSA RAJ,
DISTT.- SAHARSA
2. BINOD KUMAR VERMA S/O LATE CHHEDI LAL DAS R/O VILL.-
KAYASTH TOLA, P.S. & DISTT.- SAHARSA, PRESENTLY HEAD
MASTER, MIDDLE SCHOOL, KHAJURI, ANCHAL- SOUR BAZAR, DISTT.-
SAHARSA
3. MD. SHAHANG SAH ALAM S/O LATE MD. IDRISH R/O VILL.-
NARIYAR, P.S.- SAHARSA, DISTT.- SAHARSA, PRESENTLY HEAD
MASTER, MIDDLE SCHOOL, SIHOUL, ANCHAL- SATTAR KATAIYA,
DISTT.- SAHARSA
4. HARINANDAN PRASAD YADAV S/O LATE GANGA PRASAD YADAV R/O
VILL.- PARMANPUR, P.O.- BHATRANDHA, P.S.- GHAILADH, DISTT.-
MADHEPURA, PRESENTLY HEAD MASTER, MIDDLE SCHOOL, KHONHA,
ANCHAL- SATTAR KATAIYA, DISTT.- SAHARSA
5. JAY PRAKASH SINGH S/O LATE SIYARAM SINGH R/O VILL.-
MAHADEV MATH, P.O. & P.S.- SALKHUWA, DISTT.- SAHARSA,
PRESENTLY HEAD MASTER, MIDDLE SCHOOL, KHARHAUTI, ANCHAL-
SIMRI BAKHTIYARPUR, DISTT.- SAHARSA
6. ABHAY KUMAR S/O SRI KAILASH PRASAD YADAV R/O VILL.-
PARASBANNI, P.O.- ZAMALNAGAR, P.S.- SALKHUWA, DISTT.-
SAHARSA, PRESENTLY HEAD MASTER, MIDDLE SCHOOL, LALPUR
PIRNAGRA, ANCHAL- BANMA ITAHRI, DISTT.- SAHARSA
7. AMAR KANT JHA S/O LATE PANDIT YASHODHAR JHA R/O
VILL.+P.O. & P.S.- BANGAON, DISTT.- SAHARSA, PRESENTLY HEAD
MASTER, UGRATARA MIDDLE SCHOOL, MAHISHI, ANCHAL- MAHISHI,
DISTT.- SAHARSA
8. VIDYA NAND PRASAD YADAV S/O LATE BHAGWAT PRASAD YADAV
R/O VILL.+POST- BAIRO, P.S. & DISTT.- SUPAUL, PRESENTLY
HEAD MASTER MIDDLE SCHOOL, BRAHKANTOLI, ANCHAL- NAUHATTA,
DISTT.- SAHARSA
9. NEHRU SAHU S/O SRI CHILMIL SAHU R/O VILL.- PAHLAM, P.O.-
PAHARPUR, P.S.- SALKHUA, DISTT.- SAHARSA, PRESENTLY HEAD
MASTER, URDU MIDDLE SCHOOL, BANMA ITAHRI, ANCHAL- ITAHARI,
DISTT.- SAHARSA
10. BHUP NARAYAN MEHTA S/O LATE SHANT LAL MAHTA R/O VILL.-
LAXMIPUR, P.O. & P.S.- BIHARIGANJ, DISTT.- MADHEPURA,
PRESENTLY HEAD MASTER, MIDDLE SCHOOL, SARDIHA, ANCHAL-
SIMRI BAKHTIYARPUR, DISTT.- SAHARSA
11. BINODANAND JHA S/O SRI HARI KISHORE JHA R/O
S.B.BUILDING, GAUTTAM NAGAR, GANGZALA, DISTT.- SAHARSA, AT
PRESENT HEAD MASTER, MIDDLE SCHOOL SULINDABAD, ANCHAL-
KAHRA, DISTT.- SAHARSA
12. SIYA RAM SINGH S/O LATE NATHUNI SINGH R/O VILL.-
BHAGWATPUR, P.O.- MAINA, P.S.- MAHISHI, DISTT.- SAHARSA,
PRESENTLY HEAD MASTER, MIDDLE SCHOOL, BHAROULI, ANCHAL-
KAHRA, DISTT.- SAHARSA
13. MD. KALIMUDDIN S/O MD. HANIF R/O MUSTAFA NAGAR, WARD
NO.- 6, P.S. & DISTT.- SAHARSA, PRESENTLY HEAD MASTER, URDU
MIDDLE SCHOOL, CHIKNI, ANCHAL- SOUR BAZAR, DISTT.- SAHARSA
14. SUSHILA MISHRA W/O SRI GANESH CHANDRA JHA R/O
CHANAKYAPURI GANGZALA, P.S. & DISTT.- SAHARSA, RETIRED HEAD
MASTER, MIDDLE SCHOOL, NAYA BAZAR, ANCHAL- SAHARSA, DISTT.-
SAHARSA
15. RAM BAHADUR SAH S/O LATE BHOL SAH R/O VILL.- RAMPUR,
P.O.- ITAHRA, P.S.- SOUR BAZAR, DISTT.- SAHARSA, RETIRED
HEAD MASTER, MIDDLE SCHOOL, GOBARGADHA, ANCHAL- SATTAR
KATAIYA, DISTT.- SAHARSA
                  -2-




16. BHIM NATH CHOUDHARY S/O LATE GANGADHAR CHOUDHARY R/O
VILL.+P.O. & P.S.- MAHISHI, DISTT.- SAHARSA, RETIRED HEAD
MASTER, GIRL'S MIDDLE SCHOOL, MAHISHI, ANCHAL- MAHISHI,
DISTT.- SAHARSA
17. CHANDRA PRAKASH DUTTA S/O LATE DUKH MOCHAN DUTTA R/O
KAYASTH TOLA, P.S. & DISTT.- SAHARSA, RETIRED HEAD MASTER,
MIDDLE SCHOOL, BELHA, ANCHAL- SOUR BAZAR, DISTT.- SAHARSA
18. ANIRUDH JHA S/O LATE PARMNAND JHA R/O KOSHI CHOWK, P.S.
& DISTT.- SAHARSA, PRESENTLY HEAD MASTER, MIDDLE SCHOOL,
BIHRA, ANCHAL- SATTAR KATAIYA, DISTT.- SAHARSA
19. SITARAM RAJAK S/O LATE BRAHMDEO RAJAK R/O VILL.+P.O.-
ZADUWA PATTI, P.S.- KUMAR KHAND, DISTT.- MADHEPURA,
PRESENTLY HEAD MASTER, MIDDLE SCHOOL, SABAILA, ANCHAL-
PATARGHAT, DISTT.- SAHARSA
20. ABADH KISHORE BAITHA S/O LATE BHOLA BAITHA R/O
VILL.+P.O.- TARIYAMA, P.S.- SIMRI BAKHTIYARPUR, DISTT.-
SAHARSA, PRESENTLY HEAD MASTER, MIDDLE SCHOOL, KHURESAN,
ANCHAL- BANMA ITAHRI, DISTT.- SAHARSA
21. NEELAM KALEB W/O SEMSAN TIRA R/O MISSON COMPOUND, WARD
NO. 29, P.S. & DISTT.- SAHARSA, PRESENTLY HEAD MASTER,
MIDDLE SCHOOL, HAKPARA, ANCHAL- SAHARSA, DISTT.- SAHARSA
22. MD. HABIBULAH S/O GULAM MUSTAFA R/O ALINAGAR, P.S. &
DISTT.- SAHARSA, PRESNELTY HEAD MASTER, MIDDLE SCHOOL, AARA
PATTI, ANCHAL- MAHISHI, DISTT.- SAHARSA
23. SURENDRA KUMAR S/O LATE BHUTKOUN JHA R/O REFUGEE
COLONY, LAXMINATH NAGAR, P.S. & DISTT.- SAHARSA, PRESENTLY
HEAD MIDDLE SCHOOL, RAHUWAMANI, ANCHAL- KAHRA, DISTT.-
SAHARSA
24. GAJENDRA MISHRA S/O LATE BEDANAND MISHRA R/O TIWARI
TOLA, P.S. & DISTT.- SAHARSA, PRESENTLY ASSTT. TEACHER,
MIDDLE SCHOOL, SULINDABAD, ANCHAL- KAHRA, DISTT.- SAHARSA
25. MURLIDHAR JHA S/O BIRENDRA JHA R/O VILL.- BHAGWANPUR,
P.O.- KHAJURI, P.S.- S.BAKHTIYARPUR, DISTT.- SAHARSA,
PRESENTLY ASSTT. TEACHER, MIDDLE SCHOOL, KHAJURI, ANCHAL-
SIMRI BAKHTIYARPUR, DISTT.- SAHARSA
26. SABITA KUMARI W/O SRI RAJANI KANT LAL DAS R/O KAYASTHA
TOLA, WARD NO. 29, P.S. & DISTT.- SAHARSA, PRESENTLY ASSTT.
TEACHER, MIDDLE SCHOOL, JHAPRA TOLA, ANCHAL- SAHARSA,
DISTT.- SAHARSA
27. INDRESHWAR JHA S/O LATE NARAYAN JHA R/O VILL.+P.O.-
LAGMA, ANCHAL- SONBARSA RAJ, DISTT.- SAHARSA, RETIRED
ASSTT. TEACHER, GIRL'S MIDDLE SCHOOL, ROUTA BANSHI, ANCHAL-
SOUR BAZAR, DISTT.- SAHARSA
28. MEHANDRA PASWAN S/O LATE FOUJDAR PASWAN R/O VILL.+P.O.-
AMAHI, P.S.- JALAI, DISTT.- SAHARSA, PRESENTLY ASSTT.
TEACHER, MOUJELAL SHARMA RAM MIDDLE SCHOOL, BANGAON,
ANCHAL- KAHRA, DISTT.- SAHARSA
29. GANGA PRASAD RAM S/O LATE SRI LAL RAM R/O VILL.-
GANGDOUL, P.O.- BAGHBA, P.S.- JALAI, DISTT.- SAHARSA,
PRESENTLY ASSTT. TEACHER, MIDDLE SCHOOL, GANGDOUL, ANCHAL-
MAHISHI, DISTT.- SAHARSA--------------PETITIONERS
              Versus
1. THE STATE OF BIHAR THROUGH THE CHIEF SECRETARY OLD
SECRETARIAT BIHAR PATNA
2. THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY, HUMAN RESOURCES DEVELOPMENT
DEPARTMENT BIKASH BHAWAN, PATNA
3. THE DIRECTOR, PRIMARY EDUCATION GOVT. OF BIHAR, PATNA
4. THE REGIONAL DEPUTY DIRECTOR KOSHI DIVISION, SAHARSA
5. THE DISTRICT MAGISTRATE, SAHARSA
6. THE DISTRICT EDUCATION ESTABLISHMENT COMMITTEE SAHARSA
THROUGH ITS SECRETARY-CUM-DISTRICT SUPERINTENDENT OF
EDUCATION, SAHARSA
                                          -3-




                  7. THE DEPUTY DEVELOPMENT COMMISSIONER, SAHARSA
                  8. THE DISTRICT EDUCATION OFFICER, SAHARSA--RESPONDENTS
                                -----------

2 3.2.2011 Heard learned counsel for the parties.

The claim or the relief which the petitioners are

looking for in the present writ application cannot be given in

isolation because the decision has to be taken by the State in the

light of the decision which has now been rendered by the Full

Bench of this Court with regard to creation of two separate

gradation lists for Science and Arts teachers and the subsequent

circular which has been issued by the department based on the

direction of the Court laying down the modality by which such

exercise will have to be completed. The case of the petitioners will

be guided on completion of such an exercise. No separate

consideration is required to be made at this stage.

This writ application is disposed of with the above

direction.

RPS                             (Ajay Kumar Tripathi,J.)