High Court Karnataka High Court

Sri..S.Ramadas Shenoy, S/O Late … vs Sri Prasanna Kumar Alias … on 11 August, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Sri..S.Ramadas Shenoy, S/O Late … vs Sri Prasanna Kumar Alias … on 11 August, 2009
Author: Ashok B.Hinchigeri


~ ~=-.~.«-~ v-.=-.v-« -.-. w.–VII-rv-w ‘-tutu’! ‘III–II-r1l\&’rIl3l”Il\l” 3′ N’?

1-gm

wt’

‘%s$.z::=d§ In supmrt. af Euia 3u§fi§;i$$L:i£§I”‘1E-3 fim

:3

11191313? {if {:13 reswndsmts ha asz:-zcutaé £2145 A’
iease daaé an 131.2333 53:’ a perfind 3%’ an V’
per 2125 aaid mm lease ag*aam3:::§V.;€£,;..§A

antitigé is be it: §t3$$<%&§.i3z1 sf fiw V :ix%,VVA'q:;a,gti§}';1 ».,%/..

tiii $313. '}'h:3 mama mz1x:$:e§1*V"azs,;f§*z3";ii:;§
aafi Sm'£:.Jam1v;:'Z ;–i§ Véiafi
arifi again: af aim fiuifififitfi
fiat ta fiviéence is
ghmmaarjs. I-2.16:} fi:3m3:.rnm'21:s are: it:
her c1.zs'§::b&§*; that :16 yrazjuciime
wauifi hfiliffiiléeé if sh-,3 £5 iaguefi am

wimwg . *§::~;v:3&*:f:m $333 izww ::19£§3;.ma§1m fifim

"bar He that $3: :3 akways gym: in: the

"£€§r.: ;€§}YQ$$"§;'fi'1fiiI1§g '€21: safié Smifiaxmizz'

— E3′ fiat ‘fiw gfitiéfimmgm haw afibggaya

éiljiggiézt; is: 21m .ma2:¥:m: Se Emzg $3 fizzera am :13

= zizaavmg the wimma

“if far pmézzcifxg am deaumgzzzs sag: aways fig

V. mumai hm mkiami an tlgw jufifizgi tzzf $32313 £3-msrt, fizz. 232::

mafia af SsM’TZ’§,&.$§

a5Wr«..u:w.w?m azmamm»

war-unas’ur*vnr’uI\rn amiwriw MWWWE ‘WE’ if”&.I”%MIV3*’\El'”k¥’%J”‘| i°”H\W§”FE ¥p§J’§JKi WI’? MAKNAEARA Hlflafl L:WUK¥ 5}?’

§

irmaacz-:Az=m vtmwx-{mg 55.1»: ms agmféiigg

mpnrteci i.z1A§R 19% KAR max The wzmga

cf me said guémmt is. cx¥x*a:7&§’f§@ ,%e.**eF}:aI%*§fi. fiag
[*s*%é:;{ae mgaxfifi mi:

hgazgggrzegrzg gm”; dag
I; game is §m*::%:§.§%;::s. w:£’§w.$.%&
fig,

mans: fie Féjézfiéfi

V bemsw iafwag £9 & iszie may
T. éfffkwe is gfiaé yggsasz far
A szgnmang fa Z£%ii’2§§-SEQS’ 3 ihs

. sham mt rwfism mmimfifi awn 3;?’ Efifi

. set afimzsrz 3%?’ wmmfisfzég, fifi
zziaw finm 5IZ$§$§’§” fivm flag §§{.fi:$§§?§ flf éfzfis

_.._w …..v–…- wwugmqma nap;

Cam’: in pa {:3

1 way; Mys 1…; 343.

ik fazdgnimt am?’ tm flaicéstm fig}: {hart 3:”: 33% 523% «Sf

38%.

Ehai Ema fagfisag’ mfigd $3′:

Wfifl fit

a
2
3
§
E:

9

in

3
:3
.;

x
Q
3
§
§
Q
3
§
§
is
3
E
:2
3
3
:

2

:

S
E
5
E
E

…. mwwvuu-was umwu”‘mrflt§ ‘mm:

vs.

mf

In azzgpart cf

5

EIARESH gamma BQSE ii gram Q’f’v–.:i??E$’f

Bamm, ARE QTHERS, repariafi %F%1«*§5%$

CALCEITTA 3% Ha I’m reii«.§:.*§fir:;. gm éa: %

whim fig mnmzea %

“fag! §2s€d£z2sa__..=§{ra’* ;2aj£?;;7§$_ ;.%i_VEE:”5.§-4 :;%r.a>iai:;;;;:§m Qf
regisiets éf G3§’§fi’fe%~g§i€?ifi§f miling
fin’ arfgffwri
?€e?*;Eg§f_’ w;;;g.g §Q;%&ag gwvaa; fig a
ywiy zzy ¢;fr?2as> mm-sm amiss sub-
‘; {.*s9ng’:12za§ why 6?’ mg
m;m%g%%% ::?ms~e§_;:: mg
r;.,’=¢§;’€=$ egjf £3915 arzgizmg 5:? wfiifi: we 3}:
_ 513°} x£s§m£a_g%aas:;3m* xfiae-1;; aw
_ $£’$;?§§%£§§’ E3 aéimfiwfi in:
A % «.a»s:s:pa_; grszézzmg we ragiszm afthg
z§;§£§:m:£ maézm jay arm asifimsfi
%’ 1 93$ fig $5§,*

” the Eagflmg $3′ the fifizxgflsatiakzz far

fivfifirszm améyfi aha same mg kg

s;.§§§zma£a@::3 $37′; 3133?,
in my mtim $3 juégmerzt af §}:m Hnmgbia
$.33.

–4.’ -u-um xwvuliu \lI l\.r”\l\l’II1II’\l\l’| rH\”I”‘I UKJEJKI C

‘E’

Stigma Caurt in Elw mafia 23f SITAL 3&3 an 3&3?

RAMAED QTHERS repcsréeé irzéifi 19§é SC éfiég

‘2’. Pa mafia; Sri €3,S}1£sra.rairn 锑B§}2;§;t
mm gamma} agpearizg fer the r;;ep@zi:§..¢::13€:§ $”£1§i£_.% ii$v = n
that the pefitinnem hafi aaught mm’. S

writmn atammcnt its sum agzd Ea

smaanasa Kantian is tim a:::a~aW’I’fie:§”V_c;’*fV”t’:§.z:é $«3j_;§i%iA. g§~;-;}*1,e:i1z}:a
grofmty; tlw Ewan §}ii’5;=fii1’%

tzpan the , “‘ ém€fl§

‘z’rim; Saar”: by im
orfi-E-‘#1’; } mmmeé – 3*

aufimta mat finaiity, as me writ gaatiéisfi

‘mafia’ _1gf’ d’;ia4’fm«i8s:fii’§f ‘$132 3.9». far amgnfimaiit wag

afizaé 5:£§fizié%}a:;a§ % V V

1 3, ” Sri szzimgm gm: ‘hrfzzgg :3 my

pmviaierm anmiaimfi in &§er ES fink 3%} sf

VT _ i;%m–~§§FC Ea mntmci aim {Em pe3:i€§m’:$r$” éviciérzm mzmai

Tim fiaifi. §I”‘Q”§.?§3i@fi3 we Tm*r@i,z1″%::z:-:’%§~€§*:

FISH.

‘\l’\I\l’l’Ill’1l\l”‘ I3I\7I”” \.\lIJl\’ \Jl’ l\P|fll’l’\IP\I\I” “‘I\J!”” LKIUK3 Ur KAKNAIAKA C

8

$35.. Party to «wear _-

xefiuxsauaw iwzere a gwéag }f:.:Tm.9e£f
appear’ as at, mifirzess, he sfzfii 33 §§}’§:§’F’:3¥::£%é””‘
wag ether witness at: his behfif _ H
amsxzined, unless the Cflf£i2″s:~–f£}?’
remrfled; germim him:

méfi-3%wa§:m£f¢’fi’fi9′:§”is\« ” ” ” ‘

9. Sri :.i}zi::ff1;;’-13¢: sfifimits that trim
” ax’ fim& V_ ‘ £33″ 111123

§$s:§s.:1% ::_a”:{” ;e§:’1é…..§ra:iz§::%§.fifi $1″

&mmgm.g;§ § t}1a ‘”§”?:’*:&i {1$mr*t. ”
Egg Vé3;..%.::§ fiffififfi zizvg asxarma af

yewwar ‘”..§;i2:?”:–L:.:tsf§; C-€3i§1%&’%’£i’t12’fii;3i’E fif Enfiia;

V’ Km’ ? iihe Emrmfi Efiifiilfififi

far’ I in titw mums Q? Ezéa mgfceiziégy

‘.V:a’:V.;¢.”;_r:rwk3::’;e:.z:”zs..-?.?_”‘ zvééateg t§mt ‘£323 éigmfigai fig? tim

VI’

‘ Vfigbgfiaafiafi 1;? $$ %§ by 231% fig}: Céurig

$ §sfi fiat %.§’1& wtitiazégra mm aiways

. -v qgwunjnauv

what thqy” haw fiiaifiii 21:: Eésfiix Wfifiéfi

He was brig ha my mficfi fiat fiw Ema” i

fififi.

—‘H -V–H VI -v’-\-‘Minna naun uuulu Ur IEAKNATAKA HIGH CC

9

Qatari whila dismmizg Kim 2: ay§;:1icaq:_ic=zz ea

6.-5.2%: Ems this in abaemne:

gs» mm 3.: hwe * fife-‘%s3é§». { T
hrmgamtthémmfimgz §¥2é’;%2ja$:’£:” ‘ ‘ ” ‘

mm pr9v?$§:::z%s§; ‘jgé mtg :13: 32am

that if 8. far ‘Liififi Qméagimz ‘$5
maniiééi s:a§”i’~s§ wim§@$ :E£§ mg gag: him: i.&., in ma
Est a£.u+;mesg;aa;.géhj¢T3;%:§;as fiiefi as gay am §r&vE&iQ:r3;,&s

sf 81.213 31 finder 1%? {Em flour:

m mi}. a pamaa ti’? % ‘figs Wiinfififi

éacmwnt.

a in the izzstaxxi cam? my Eméim 5? {ha

–. ‘a.2?’$§a1z§.t rgmaés that szzflséfizt muss £3 3f}.$’£ saimwn fer

emisaifizzzg $5 a mama’ sf fact? {Em E23? Qf wimmaaa £5

mt filed by the; pa§ti0:1aam& ‘fimi: $315 Wiizéfifi $3 was

mi am by avamfight émw mg amzfiffixzm & wiié.

£33.

$’££?3’1!3’ifi?’i the Smt.Jana§fi

—tr-Hr’ v-v- -3.-as’.-vn* v- -v-Ina1rur-IIv- v’II\JI” Luuni IJI’ Bl-|!\I’¢.i*\lI-\l’\.H I1″)?! \..\,)\.,ll(l ur AAKNAEAKR Hit)?! LIJUKI (JP KARNATAKQ [I-[K33-I CI

” . é tha

EQ

mafia? figtfia ffasstg am aimxmfizsgaswg af Exam:

§’ur’i:hm3 the Vit dam mt mrztain t}:e’;§

fiiicuiars. It flaw rm: agate that far *ee?E?,§§: 4_
rmaczn tifxsa éncummeztg $3 ” b j
Fzgrtharmam, as per 3% pm’sris§’é:;1i;-§é_T Afififiiafiiéfi

13 me am: gf cm? fig my :3

mréfimas $3′ sstilfifi Wfia 5% mad

withszrut aeefim 3% ‘iffiwmrt kg appaw

sea. hiss acaszm $=§t::fz::;~m £5: a; V

:?f_ whfla si7ma}Ez§¥?i:}g ‘€336
an mfiarmfingz that fimraa
Ex _ fly mfiiémgwm ‘H3 $§E §§

. :-. ; ti

amfisient is ham Efsw §.&; fig’: qmmfimn
aiigmeigég $$ whm: 33$ Km: :3?’ wimegaw as 33%;’ fizihw

x§RuiéE[_. :1c:fEu1e 2 affirder 16: amas. £5 fgxxégheé.

3% Tint amr*:3 summrfig iiw witnws $3″
fizrscfimczzt is aniy ax: amhfizg gmariaima fie mfiff cm}.

aifim it as a matter sf right 33*’ mafia? mi” mama; ‘ii i5

333.

. “an r Vn\I\JI\l \Jl l\l”‘ll\l’l’1ll”|I\P\ i’If\.7I”3 QQUKI C’

31

the <1im1*eti:;:m2:¢' mafia" :32" :11: fizjufi; Thgrafmsgfeg thég
€m.;2°t's fwm ix 31% , Whfifi
,§z;:*iséi-ac€"I:z¥aml wmrfi 53 mi wafiéantafi.

15, 1i1.t}'1¢ rwult, this

nrder as as wsm;

§efitimfia’s”a :;$e~*¥§§5k;?,awi:iL_ 1}1;1;§;é am’? 331% lmw fiwéé,
fiamfi 1:3. maze *mfam ma Tm:

§$¥.12″:;’i::~a{:§;3$r€:’i§:£::ca5$~!§;?ith 1gw;%

Sd/-L
JUDGE

n H