High Court Karnataka High Court

Narasimha Reddy vs The State Of Karnataka on 23 November, 2010

Karnataka High Court
Narasimha Reddy vs The State Of Karnataka on 23 November, 2010
Author: B.S.Patil

fig

BEFQEEI

3»: ‘TE-E Efifiéfi mare? i3§”K&§§§fi:?&K& §mGa;m§%3% f 1

mmm mg *:’m2 23% my my :;§as§.za€s;a*;%z«:LL:gz:1:;i _ [ %

13$ E-§fiI%**§LE ..31é%;s*z:s§%3ag$i9a1*3L

aw? P§’Z’ET§§2%” §a.:m9;%2§%:g2 §§_é;;1%-ER;

sswggxz ”

Srifimmmiza’ ,_Reé5.§+”‘ f’:

gmaaze

Agafl

miw, f ‘
355:?» Lfi?¢%k§2i%zrfi}*a??&:$
‘W3 $*~’5%°*~1’f«’5?'”‘»”‘f%kI:«*f&«*=!’:=*§«TkT%% & %

Bath sfiffi S ‘

;.;~ ‘ mm tfif

e§ Efismzuag,

‘?i’w Spwiai Ekayuégr Ciamméazsisrzm
Ewaizzru Srhmi §%£s%§

FE;’I’§’§?§§7ER

P§.§l~.Eaad,
Bmaluruw 5% am

3. fiw Ta}m§ aim’
s%gwka},$

Bxgaiizzii Urban mam’ , f;a1%ms? <3§%mE1é'§S

fl'? 3%' 'am ficnsfimiimngf Ezidia tfi' aim
imgugzcfi. arciar am §:aa$Ea*<§:§{ kg?' mg ~2.%_"=é yiwganémt fiat-mi
:2.m.2m9 £2: mm 2§a,§3:¥::2}%_¢:~;i:5§§¥*3e:«:£m {mum at

W the A

£3? " fiammisaémrzxarg
Bawlsérc an i2,i€}.?§§§ ?m

% fi'i$$V"%¥g*r?l¥;'!pa:§'£§.e:1. 33; the am aréar, rm

Qfifizfififiifinar wifie wmaiaéng gxmm *mw& in

1333; af tha Eiarnaialaez Lam

" §'9§@ Ems mt agide ik $§':EE'§e'" afimtfi in

' esffizs pefitéwnegs in rmpwz ca? Sy. HQ. 53 92'

"

‘zfilhgag yam mm ‘i’a§uk.

.2; im East; 2% Saputy Ssemwkgéanasr has

mmmn ardar in rmpw: af ” u

namw gawk; anmaa Emfi ham efi’$:;t&’_E”a$.§

aimfi grmzé in §%%%i asf ,5. . %

mmwma it; S-3}: Essa. 33% afegargagéiemé
in £1} ‘fix
fififiiiiff CQmm. :1$_$éif;§_£1$£’: W téw
“§’&§1sé}fi.w in me
mm sf fizma ma Lands
and m §aw in rim

Ram Em ffiéfifdfi; éjrézaéimfi £3 aim igsazaa “:5 axis:

thnaai *w*h!§’va:<a-rfiin umuiémziiaafi iswsanassion 9%'

£32.. *am?;£h m% aa aa ta safmuard {Em

V' _ ., §f'{;§fi §fli.

af 3% ma §£fi§§$E3.fi%3 mm are.

V. tfw mém 35 fig 3epz2ty

fismwasiazzaar, 7% ahai: as: wan: sf’ 8 saw af iaw

gzsasmgriawé 31$: fig. I€a.S3 wag grazimi in favmxr af %

W

Aig =;;z$u$*ta.i¥:%fi.’5fi§a§ ta: 255

fathsir an E%,1§,3%%–1. ‘E”r@ have: piamfi

Ccéurt aészgfi wfih the mi §’53aZa§§,g_xaer{:x– ‘4

gm: mrfigate at

% %zg§;m-m.

v:1?°’:*§.:.3 $5 xauéaiiazz
§-§a.3.’?g §a;-% witfia. axfi «mm
mnfirzuad as azggégi’ fififiififléfiti
by them swim-3 ix;

aetuai is thcfg” fatmar anfi
the fiammfaaiamr

iimi aha – “2:”e%;§ar& sfi’ rights wera flwlly

wmmfiaé that

fimn efimtfi in $23 year 1§%§

by {ha aapuzy Cammw’ aiafief

$23 Efi mam w}-yazxfl ilzez zwaanaézle tzlzm

312$}:

)1″

 er'1"a'3m in tin     VA



 

ég 32%. E'.  Eggs, 

 wuméi  1-.   _

fax: the suhmitg fim’: ‘4

{Sm E3$;§::t§; flamxngsmum ta afifgzt ijéwi’ if

i1@a§ mfi mwmamm” bk as ‘ %

aésictfi fififi {ha 33235.3 q12$at£§:£§s..§é’i:,%2:31i€”fil:.;¢ pénsmas

af Iafiz.

E; Ea thg. ” mafia by Efm
§s&fi¥3?@z:azt$– §«.mm in feavcasur sf’ mm;-*
fatém é:¥.z&m& :2-m mm

§ss£ri7g;i§mf§ :9 swam the m*ig1’na1

fja t

“1a§.§§'<. r;€;§a:.§§ amzfiafila 'zém

mi' am aaifi. 2 rm', is is am that

. ifi £15 ém tifw zfiaer $3 ahme' the grant sf £213'

' tém Eafké

Sy, §§$.§3 in fafifilif of the:

h sf the Late Es§:3r@' gym. it 2%

ska: mm Eh: gsafiaimtz.

tsflmimatxghtha
§afigrafit%as5’£ata§§9}2a%M”%swr2maé;aifitZtmyaar

A”

3%}, 3:33} @215 year lfififiufifig as mfififi gram

mm ‘£5 Egg, E’: :3 mfiy in gm §*sa&f§§§5~§5′”i:3y’¢: J

2§%L§.B¥a.§*E€1?’;’95»~i% mmw’ gm §?;;’2J

the mfitianem ix: {Em rain:-‘$3.

mutsxmim enfry aim 6am 11$: gmn; cmky

‘ rfiem ‘£3 muiafisn may :32: rim daath

sf am fafitmr af t’§’;st3 __;wt:§.§i§§:1t:§§:f$ petimnm
as a2. ez:_~_a-~ thiza pzramrtyg

fexrm. af grant

.a%;é–._m** nmifiemimg $132 grant in

fawur af gmtifismra, qumficn af

‘gffizile mfifigaers agar: the éaatiz mi”

cf tgfima Eanfis ‘gmuifi ma’: arias, Yhe

Eegfitg’Ca:.;aE_§£mnw ugm: agzqaznfy’ hm famzzi tltmt the

mafia £21 fix zwmue rvwmfia wem armnafi aw

The -:;;%;.*~§gim% gm:/:1: §f’&§’§.§%§ mfcre

H tblm mrmizmésm reafimé. fig’ fix

V’ A ” Ci}

fiifififfi’ 33 §’2§§’£ £3 m gfitzy fmmgi in

33:2 §€$&§3

rwmgi fif BEE? wrfisn af $33165. {‘

if

V’ Ek writ gfififiififi i3

M3

3 fix ififfifik’

may axé rmré 2&2 af

game: ta iamgz ‘€sz§’£h¥ * A 1 %

§’§f$3:3.__e:iir§£%ti§::’$§V::i3;$f:z§¢.*iV_ m 55.2 Tamaxaaz is

eviai the V $:!?gé§_2 __t§m’£ tim Qeguiy
“*”£”s;§f§$ikia§ ta taka acfion
in azm _ ” ” .’§’a}25il&.ar wiil have ta

fiiflfiffiffi __ in $.€%fi3§&§}:$$ with law’

” by fafifiwixg $13.23 gzmaaas. The
af {Em fiaputy €$amm§s5§m1er Em fix
mm.’ iifi mt fimi any iilgaiééy in ths srflmr

_ ‘§’§;{“‘i_t;E1e fiaguty’ C§mm$&§m1m*.

* ‘:5-3 gmmi §§E fawziz’ ef Ekw fafhar as?’ tém

by aizmgag mg 3’a:m:5.as