IN 'I'I'"II£ I'iIG§'"'i COURT OF KJXI-{NATAKA AT I3ANC}Al,ORF,___
{').21t':.e(ii: 'I"'his the? 26" day fFel31*1,12_11'y V '
BEFORE
M.F.A.No.14505/2;cQ75f§/QV % _
M.F.A.N0s.14506. 1450'?'.,..145'O8'.
145\10g200'f7'VVr,\ 5;g:; "
B ETVV E EN 2
N EW :NDIA_ ASSUARAN are ' C I;9i'::>; .' ~
J.L.B.Rom).-mmmgmggsaP;ER;sé,M.'
MYSORZZ. _ _
:aE(3iOr~J;A.1, O'.sii~'1::£'9;;._ .
U.i\JI'E'Y' 1.:3Un'.jI->_:i\'w§\z----i~:><i';.
P. E<AI;.1NCi'A mo I€€)Ai£"):"
r-3AN'«QA1..oI2::«:g55o- 01;;-7.
I;3Y :':'"s MANA(3ii-;.1-'2.
V LA :1i2y s;~: _':(}: £'v'{1:3{i =1:1f«:s1---:, AI)\/.}
IN I\/:1".I-'..1}i\A.¢I\.i:.:V).4'14505/2007 :
SIMNKAR.
S/O Ki"-{ISI~iNAP13A.
AGE-SI) 31 YEARS.
R/O KOLLEGAI. TOVVN.
CE*'IAI\a'1i'&I"{z'\Ji\§\ff\C}/\I'{A I..)1S'I'RIC'§'.
KRISI IANARAJ ICNI) RA U RS.
MA} 0 R. S / O CEAN {T}/\_I-{AJ [E R8.
Mawz' 1M:é_ g:_AsSU 1%: vcofg 1391). .
... AI~'PI.*ZLLAN'I'
COMMON
'l"HE HON'I~3LE MRJ us'1'1c:[«: ¥f».uIAC}AFqNA-(i%:;FiJ£iNV
R/O 3"" CROSS, 1'"{C)SALLI.
MANIDYA.
IN M.F.A.N0. E4506/2007:
1
IN M.F.A.N0. ;4::%Q;71-,z20;j7;;
I
' '- _ I'ValA§'~l.,I")'YA';--.
RA'M'i«:si~i.
$/0 RAMALENGA,!\ENA. -
AGE!) 3: YEARS.
R/O B.G.DOD{')I G1-LAMA.
KOLLEGA.L-'I''ALUK. » _
CHAMARAJANAGAR 1);s'1'g1c'1'.
KRIS}-iANARAJEi\_IDRA URS.' *
MAJOR. S/O GAN'€.:ARAJ UR-S'.
R/O SR9CROSS."HOSAL1,I{,'3 ' % A
MANDYA. ,.,.,T;-R325}-JVQN1)14:N'1's
1Jo1<::e:''sé'1_;<--., '- ' _
s/0 Sl_E){).~:"%._IA}--I ' 4. '
A'G'I'£E)_ 3,1 \zr;;u.zs'-...»
113/ C: 1~:_.:«.E:GAL' ':';éx:,[J . ,
c1T*12xMARAJANA@AE:A DIS'E'R1C'l'.
' 'h.Iz1s§~1AIvA.x§RAJEivDRA mas.
MAJOR. S/OE-ANGARAJ URS.
1»T{,r'0.3H.*._J CROSS. H0sA1,1.,_1.
. . . . RISSPON 1:')£9N'1s
.I'iV~.1 i\/'iA_i*".A I\V'.V' 1£v.
mag) :31 YEARS,
S /0 I')f3E3HAI\EN,/~\.
R/O KO1,LEGAL"I'O'v\!N.
CHAMARAJANAGARA DISTRICT.
K RES HANARAJ 1%) N D RA U RS.
MAJOR. S/O GA.NGARAJ URS
R/O 3"" CROSS. HOSALL1.
M;'-'$5 IJYA. . . . . R}¥ZS§3'5'ON 1') £()N:>§:N'1'f$7 . *._
IN ;\/I.F'.A.Nc).14509/2007:
1 £«:£:RA.
AGED 32 YEARSE.
S/O MuD1.)As1::'1*I'Y.
R/O I--i.A%\IOOR GRAMA.
1/{OLLBGAI1 TALUK.
CHAMARAJANAGARA !')Is'1'R1q1'.
2 KRISE~IANARAJ[£N['.)RA HRS. _
MAJOR, s/0 GANGARAJ URS ..__ "
R/O 3*?" CROSS. i»»10s/xu-,.I_. ..
MANDY/-\. » > . . _ . R11: 5'rQN_;) IE':-,N'1"S
IN M.F.A.Nc>.145iO/2067;'
1 KRISHNA. .
S/O KRISHNAPPA... '
AG£:D3V1'y1§A.res;=_' ' , _ -
R/O Kc:1,LQ:GA:T.."?QVm'. "
CHAM;r~.RAJ~AN_AGA;;A~-Dismi(::f1'2
2 }~;msi 'ms.
MAJCJR. 3/0 j:;A':=e.(;2':.Rm mas.
1'2/c>%3m CROSS. .11~;QsAL1,1.
V _ MA:\51';~vA. . _ ' ....R€SPON1j)fSN"i'S
* _ (I3y'[_é.~;-1 ;_S{R:I,)HAIi"c ADV. m R C / 1-2 E .
SR} Ft EViAI,LI'KARJL}NA. ADV. AEWEARS FOR DR ABDUL
I RAv'LQov£c:r3M:r;N'1* i;)A'r1i»:1); 26.9.2007 mss£<:;.)
1.
N.T%_.w«1jVj’i1(i ¥ge1Ve-feiiiyAeviileifiee. but on the
()1″,hE3i’v7hE1[“i€i.Vi.i’if3′”d’O’-1T1′,i)’i7_{IV-$5155 busy on 18.7.2007 in the
lmspitai’*a’s*eigVl’it ‘ie;pe1f9a’;.i():1s were iisted on the said
{j;£’1′>f-7″t.;%’ anal tI”1e.__dc)(‘1or eoi1c,iuCt.e(:i three operatioiis
» WI-1ieh,v\;ue–::;f-pp to 3.00 19.111. A.par1__ Train the said
si.&é1–!:enie1ji1’.;.. the c1<)et()r has further staleci 'that. the
sigIie1.t.£;:.1Te found in the evidence said 1.0 have been put"
"him. was not'. his .sig§11:1I'.L:1*e.
3. In View of the af02’es2.1id s1.a1″eme11i: on
21.f’i’ic1:avit’ given by the cioeior. this court aiso ciire(:t.e(i
the d()(‘m1′ 10 appeai’ bef()re {his couri Emd file an
fir’
v
{u
affidavit and on g()i11g I.1’11′<)1,1g_1'1 the 221ffiy’~V._’1″*1<1V.[Vb’éé11’1. V’
takerl ;’)12–1ce befc)1*e 1..he WC CoIn1fiiss;io1′”1*’::r iI1fézv1bi_ t,heé;e L’
cases and Dr.Abdu1 Rav0oi’wl”1(5;1’1evé1* geivsa ‘c=%\,ric1’Jr1._(:c? bé:’1′<)'1*e the
COEI1fE1iSSi0l'1&'.l' in resp-TeC£:L' v($i'7'V 1j.hé~. jasscssrr1e1"1t of
ciisabiiity.
4_. ‘ !()§; the opinio11 t_h.21t:. in all
t”I’1es(~> c.21.us’€:-sax11v1: (;y14Vl§;_ 1?i’}§7(:()111111c)11 (‘)1’de.r passsed by {he
§;_?(:>111v_13’1i;§é}.’i'(melfv has to bc? set aside, but at the
‘ ..§E1’1I1.tf ‘v.f::f:1’é–=..Commissi<)11(:t::l§et'(“‘)1′<* ft:;._?":.é.' Commissiorler that {§)1'.Abdu1 Ravoof did
<:viden(:e be.f0rnm1issi<m(‘rat’,e wh(‘) 2-1ppc=:a1’e(1 for the 0I.a.in1ar1i.s and who
1135 sI”a1:e(:1 on 0a.t’h bei'<)r€ "
an VQV.E«5\.$2i§£»a&—‘N”‘:-$533» €.s:vs\5£»3 I
t that Elm
é\§..as\'”‘3~”‘°’
/’
,§,S,&;~J§S»
8
Commissioner in all these (‘.’c.1S€S. ilwse .2-1.p1;)eals are
alkowed by setting aside the i1np141g’11cé(1 u1’dcr as fmucl
will vit:iau~. the entire prmreedirlgs. ‘£’h.e amoum in
deposit. be re2i’1,1ncied to the appellant I1’1sxT1′:7gi’1ag§e.V
C’,0n1pa11_v. . _
Dvr: