I
IN TI IE I~-I1('.'3i'TTI ('I(..".)R'E' OI' I(x'\RNz'\'E.'A.K.;'X.
CIRCUIT I23 ENCH A'? C} U LE--'3:'\I5{(T}A
I.)A"i"E}D 'l"HIS TH E ZEST" DAY OF FE?-'3RUARY 2010
BEF'()RE
THE HONBLE MR. JUS'1'1CE I'-IULUVADI C}. }{AME_S__H
M .F.A.NO. 30 1313/2008 [MV]
C/w
MFANC).14762/2007[M'V]
IN MFA NO.30133/2008(MV)
H ETVV EL EN :
1.
I:3ALAI’3I”‘£\ S / O. RAM/KN NA
AGE:-41 YICAIQS. . ”
OCC : COc>1′,I_I:_:.;’v_ ‘ ,
E-31–IIMAWWA’ W”/’ ;;:__BAE..{A.I—?PA” « ._ V
AGI<:::j.'5 Y1s:AR:~:, _ .
OCC ::g:0«1.1.E::’A:s;£:«)A 1%’IQLe$i’::.1 10-1.1″).
3. 1T1ANUMAVN**r1—–1A $1/O,;ViI’3A;.,_A”r?I:>A
AGE§:21 Y1′:’,.Af'{S._ A ”
occ sfru {)”i’i’3._[.\E”I”_~
A1.,1_;”1)
‘IQ ‘-. sI’:\JV1T):1m;\1LJ1a. NOW R1_~:s1m\1G AT 1.138 N/\(i}AR.
‘ ;2A1~<:_1 Eula. A *
gx)
… APPICI,I,AN'iS
(B'Y"SR1.'13}5;s£i\IAR;\J R MATITI. ADV'OCA'.1'I'£}
K3
T111'.
NO.1
TI II”;-I J…)I’v”IE5I(}1\}1\I. CO§\.l’I’I-{OI,I,I’iR,
N ICKRTC, RAICiI—–11.5 R I..)IV’E.SI.(‘)1\§ .
E\/I1′-XN’I’I–Q/\I,1\\”Al\/i ROAI ) , I {AI C E'””I’ L? R.
… RiéIS§’C)I\§_I__)I€E\?’I”S
(BY SR1. E–‘RIi§I£’I’1£! S f\/1ICI..I{U 1\1I)§ II. 1’\I)V(:)C1’-\TI’C]
M1-‘A 1111.191) U/8.173(1) 01* ]\/IV .A(f’1″‘1″=12AY11\1;€;. *rO_ :.V1*C3’11>111=y
J UDC3 EVIICNT E41 /\W[\RI'”) I”)A’IT*3I:) .1 7 /_’20£)7 ‘i.’.ASS’E.I)” I\7iV\_-»’C
O4/O6 ON ’11 11: 1:11.19 01-? “:1 11: MA(3’I’.’.ANEi§_) J.>”1′(:{;_-111A.” 1-.«1m(1:.–1’1’L5.11;
IN MFA.NO. 14762/2007
B ETVVEEN
AN D
‘1’1—-11-3: Ij)IVISIONAL C.ON’I’R
N.Ii3.I{.R.’1′.C.. ..
RA_1cHU121)1fv1S11C31\1. I
MANTRALAY.AM;5RQAD’,.
RAICHURX '_ V " _
1112111. BY 1.*,:fs1..C1;111<:1«*LAW; .,
Q1.1;1;:1§,:"
_ _ _~ ...APPI?3I.I,Al\%'I'
{BY S1211. ‘1->4111§,.11 1
£3A1»i;§3I’I-3231 5/ O.’1?;-°V.1\v/1__1g11_«\1:*\1/1
‘ – AG12 : YEARS.
» QCCV ; .c0o1;_11~:.__
‘ 1’1/(,).1′)1::’;-~:_1 CAM}-{%t
(1)1~3\/A1iAGI_J1’j1;1}’TQ. SINDIT1ANUR’I’AI.UK,
Now AT I,._§3,3.NAGA_f2. RAICI 11111.
_ 131 1111/12x\11AfI1.111/1 W /0 1:3A1.A1I>1->A
” AGEIIJ A”13OU’I’ 35 YEARS.
O.(_3C”:;CO(‘)I.II’-3 AND 11oL151..–;1101.1′).
‘:1/”u”.’1)1-«:v1 C’:AI\/II’
(1;)1£VAI’2AGU 1:31}. s1N1)1—1A1\11.;12’m1_,111<.
135
4. ‘i’I.’1C mat {er wzm (“O1 11 cs_;1..1.’..”.>.{1»11′ iégsiésgs
and z,1i’t'(‘1′ 1′.1’1c}u1’1″y hold 1.11211 i.I’1e z==1<?<":i(.1('111 was (.)(.%'c',r;'11'1'j<"-{.1 '”
t’:11<=3 1u:gIigg(:11(rc: on 1'he;' })z'u'1. of 1_1"1c ("l__'i.»'i"v'~{".*.Y_" (")E'.'II1L.;"i3~{,I'1% i'.I_;1c
(¥.c':('.(§21scrcl in the 1'e'1'{i0 of (5{'):-41') ;2'1.:'1é;1 4.1'.-V.2i'1"€>Vi1’11QLi.fest. from ‘me (kite
of pe’£iti01’1. till_.-cie1)(’31§i(=.’_ ‘V 1?3»pi1’1g g”tgg;’;’icé\-rL*(1 by the same the
(‘=.laima1’1ts are s_-;..s:_~,(:*.’:}.-_’.i;1gf E131′ «.c2 1 1*ijmjt”e111£:1T11 ()ft1’1c compens;–1i.io1’1
and 2.1Is0 1tth2111L>:’§_g;i1’1gfi4’1.11§:’a_€i’:’1’1é:,§;§1i’gf~E’3I1(‘TE? was solcfly on tho part. of
the driver 0f\”1l”h_ (“‘?’U1b'(i1″i:CSIli()I1. The NEKRTC fi1<=3(i Ihe
e.1.}')}3e2-11_{i1'i ;1:1'1e '"gA1iQi.£11c1' mat: the (1c(rc21s<3<i }1i111sc11" has
*Vr_§()1'it;1'ibi;1t.éd5"50% 11eg1i§§éI1<1c: 10 the 2'-1cci(k*111T to oc*c.:1.1r. Even
ihf?'Qt"!£%I"1T_l,iV1}'}..(1.f '(I§5I1'1p€1"]S&1ti(..)1"1 e1wz11'dc)c1 is on the I'}ig_{i1('i1' side.
vA('t(?()1*{1ii"1;g_A§Iy. «s'<.§f1:;g_{i'11 for modi.I'i1>i11g:{ 1″1(.)1.i(‘(>d is Eh:-11 11’] 2.111 z111c1.’1’11.:)1. 1.0 111-111” 1.211111.
1.§’11.* I’i(i§v1″ <3!'E%'1I'{.’}-‘<"T11' tin? ;.'1<'r<*1<'1c.'2'1%' :~;z.1;'<1 1.0 }":;'1w <.1<'.:<:-1.11'1"1*<%
e51.11C1 1111: Ic:f'1 1'1i11('1 \-'VIICCI of 1.119 13115 11111 111101' 1.111% d(.'(."t'*e;;151'-:.(i"'1.VI'1(-*11
I1 11:1} ('1 cm-111.
} “a f’\
7. ‘I’l’1c 2=11’g_§1.11’11c1’11 ()f1:I’1c l<:2.1.1'11(:(I <:(')1.111so} .I§'7€J£'_:"H;l1?'–.NEKR1m
ES 111211. 1.111–2 cleceasr;-'.d l'121s no valid cl1"i\.ri1'1g..11<':}3111{§t§' .2;1f=.1:1'11'<-* '-1.111113. of
1.116 e1(r(:idc1'11.
8. I1 p@1’1.i1’1e1’11 110 11010 1.he’:111′.~..i_1′ is 1’1()1.’-2.: «_(A’.Tg1.é;c;=;*. t1fI1(%21ci 011
(?(1)H1.1Si()1’1. and 1.111% .;1;i1j1\rcr’1″– 111 ‘1.’}§:ijc }.)’11.:.s 1’1″; £111 e11:’1’e1’11p1. 1.0 ova’ 121k:-2
sh(1w11 to .111-1vc.>. T(e£1;.:..1sc1§i¢ 1116?”~21<'*<..'i_c'i111′.. As s1.1c1″1 even} the bus
d’1’ivc1′ also ‘0?~.1§L:f1f1t: 12¢.)Vh.E*i’a’V€’f’–._1.é’1K1?1’1 s11ffi(.;?iL%1’11’ (72111: wI’1ilc over
1;ak1’11g 1,}.1;:–v 1f1de1.*,V-.\1r1″1’o1 was goi11g_{ :;11’1ead of the bus. EVGI]
:’€:_1″1e11’g.(: §’}’1cé%1L.:’.2-1.159filed by 1119 p(1Iir..>c exficr 1’1’1ves1.i§.;’211.io11 2’1ge1111s1′
t1’1L>”€i.1’1x.;fc1fTA cv1.1′:”i’.].1(.: in C111€’§=5Ti(‘)1’l. T110 2-1(t(tic:lc1’11. 2-flso 1101. (11:11
1Vc’1_1hc 1″11€:,(‘§:_’1’zi11.162.-1.1 (1l(:’Eb<'1. In 1111'': ('i1"('.LE11]S1é'1I'1(?L'S. w}'1L+11 1110
"{'l1'é\.{C1: 1'11 c" bus &:l1113I'}.1p1'.(–'(I 111 ('1\.='<-'*.1" 1e.1ke 1.111' 1'11(")[(")I'(.'}-'(.']1S1 P11:
<"€j11._1I(T I"1'e.-11%'. blctw 1111: }."101'11 01.' e.1\»'()1'dL'<1 1.111.' E'1e;1})}.)€:11i11;_{ of 1111.?
E1(.'('.i(.!(E"i'l't a.1.1'1(1 to ::.a(.)11}(..' cxtzc-::.'1t the (!(r(rL1as<;t(::! alien cr0u1.1'1'}';)l1tc('!
m-32;}jg;–*11<"'(_r H) the 2-a<'<'i<.'i<:'r<"'m'. in %.I'1<*s:;<:~ {'§E'i'§..31f§E.'*5'i'é'ii'%iT("'f%.
it \V01.1ld be lmld 1.112.111 the at-(.'i(.Ic11i. 01’1.L*.@ on t:i’1t-2 part. of the (:i1’1’v(*1* of the _!.=:«:1.1.s “e’ii i~<1
'U1 V
' . ._
clccrcrzmccl 1'11 the 1'z,1t:io ()1 80 ,1»(_)_85%' d1'1"C;§. 3()"1.().13%: »
1'espe2<i:1"iveiy.
9. S0 1111′ as the 21\>v23.1’ti…_()f (‘r<')Vi7'1p'e.-ti}ssgiiion ("(A)1'1"c'.c1'1T1c=-rd the
(1ecc'-r;.:.seci said to be agcrd 16 y(;a1't;c.V.V iI1I'wI'h'Ci"('ii5(.I1.11T1S1.&1l'1(f€'. the
VfE'E)12f1:;'1Iia{*':Rés';2..O(}O_/.5 13.11'). c:2:;11moI' be on
incom C tgakon by t_i1'é-5
Elm 11ig1'1e1" sidC,._ ',{:'i"1_£% péi1a* {lén-‘t’> 1 ¢;v3s’i, Eihcir yc)111’1g son. En
the decisicfi ()f’AE’,hC.,A}jnffX CU.:_11″‘: in the case of Mcugju Devi &
Another ~03? u1’\/I1.:scy”zirf_ PCi:5i.i.’I-a_fi*& CU’1OU’1(3I’ rcp(.)1*tc’-rcl in 2005
AGJ~199,whe1*cifi v-,ifi’S1 ma that 21\va11*cli11g comper1.se1t,ion of
‘V ‘. VI «:. E ‘ ….. .. ‘V ‘ ‘E5′
“R_s.2′;25.’UOO’,/}~ 1″(>~~1_..}1c boy of IQ yc2.11’€~.3 no! on the 1’1igl’1c1′ side.
}~Ierc*-._ iiitEAic:~.ij”;«$€.a.fi’1wixase. t’.h<:1'c is :+!m\v11 110 be ('rm1i[1'i.b1.11'i01'1 of
'V1'V1e_g1izc__§c'.11"'c:*..(': 1_3_\}~fl1c? ('lc:(*.ea.=s by {he
(.iL_’*_,g=_L=¢e3i:+;V(i(.i;’: c:0n1pe1’1Sz:1tic.n1 of Rss.2.()().()O()/– wit.i’1 (.3″%:} j1’1t.m’cs1
g_ X
‘W
wtmid be 2wm1″(‘.1c:’c’l to {he c1z1i1[112’211’1¥;s. ‘l’h1.z.=;._ 1.110 a:’.ia-,1.im2111E_
wL2E{jE hr 2–?:r’1i’;E’.Er:< i:’1E.(?1’t..’s1 i’mz’n 1’I”i(:.*
date of pe’::i1io1’1 ‘I111 (1e=:})()si1’.
‘E”}1o appeal filed by the: (~.1e=1imz’1.1’)1 is a111\-vex} in peuft-;«
The a});:)e2t1 filcrd by {.110 NI3£§I’§’i”{§ is (.Ti’i.<:+;11'1§..'42'$"(_?r.'iV«.V*–..vW" S
The amo1.111t_ in (i{§}1)()Si'(': bA£'"I'-E.1'E1s,:11SfC?§TVI"»f'%€1'I0 the-r t:rib'L1naI fc')r
clis':3m'sc1ner1t..
W
MM
2?:
E23
2 3
$5353
INV