High Court Karnataka High Court

M/S Shivashakthi Industry, vs Karnataka State Small Scale … on 23 November, 2010

Karnataka High Court
M/S Shivashakthi Industry, vs Karnataka State Small Scale … on 23 November, 2010
Author: Mohan Shantanagoudar


:3:

£5 §E §§§ €932? fig Xfi§%é?g§fi %? fiéfifiézflfifl

Sfiffifi Tfiffl ?fiE 23 §§§T§F §§$fi%$E§ §§3§

Efifiéfifi

ffifi §§fi’§§§MR,J§S?E$§.%§E§ s§A§?§§$§f§$$§” ”

fi;ELMGiE§§§ExEwi0 ;é§éK§§:§€§ ; ;7 n5

& . _~
§3$§.w,§§2$i2@§§

EE?§EE§

auuluniduunlauntinntflni

fiifi 5§:vAa§ax?§: :fi§§$$a%fj a
£333 §§.§?, § § $1§~ ; >,’»§_~
K§R§%TAK&’§?§?£ sggnzaggaza,»

2 fi$?§§E§f§%?ELfi§%E§? *”~m»

£@RE%E§?Ififi”&TE;;ifififizfifié
I§E§3TR1%L_E$T§TE;.§&L§R

xazgg E$§EEEC§,¥§?_I?§ ?%R?fiER
5R£,§}ERISHfl§»RE§§?

553 fiQ§QA§§§E_EE§E¥

;§m§§ 4¢«2§§g§’ … ?E?ET£$fiE2

“{$§ §§$_VEQHHESH%AR S Sfi£S?REg a§v.,:

2 K&R§§T&K% §?%EE §%§L% fifiéifi 1§B§3?RZE3

n;L §E¥EL$P%E§? CfiR?QRA?E§fi’£T§.,§K$§E3C}

V “*§§EIfiE$?R§?I?E QEEECE E¥£L§E§G

~E§E$$?RI%% E$?A?Eg R&$&JI§£§fiR
%%§Qfii$RE*§§§ fiéé
B? ETE ¥fi§§$E§§ §3E§$?$R

2 §E?¥TY CHEE? fififififigfi
Kfififififi, Z§§§§TE£AE EST§?E§EE$}
@3333

figtitionaz £33 ailattafi Indugtriai aaiyps

sheé hgaring §a.§? situatéé at En£ustria;M$St$£§,

Main: Taluk, Kalgr Qiatrist an ci§§§Q2§§é; *

Subagquantiyg i.e., ax 21,?.Efi$é it wag élléfiteé.

twc mare §~ty§e 333$: fie&%in§ “§¢§;§$ V§”mfii$

aituateé at znéufitriai Eéfiéta; fi£:u:_?aiu%; Kala: =L

Eiatriat. The gasitimgar §$§ t32é§.§&3$&£$i$fi af
thffié sfiada gafi sigéiad, figngfixafigrimg afiaraaai
yswfiér and aga§bathiw3$§ aateffialbgfih 1%.3.2@§6,

thé ggéiiiséét §§%3 :§§re3éétatiaa ts the aecfinfi
:e$§$n§%nt ta §éiS§_§§ét_S§i~2 whiah ia aéjatent
gigs :5 i:g”§3?&afi.i§ gs mach as aaafirfiifig ta Eha

§%ti§ié§$f, tag éaié site gauid he ugaful far it

.”f§§W3t$£i§§_th& E3? matsriai afifi far fienatrmttimfi

*g§f Trafiéfiafiriai qmartera far its wa§k%$$ etc,

§§9§:%:.–ti<é'§:é;tL–._égéasitasi a 31.223 €::§:" §'1?g§§€3f- tawearda

Ear§a3t§M%fi%ey E%§fiSit baing gait sf the iané

W¥§i§%'f én 21.éa2§§§. fiufigegugntéy $336 tha

'F§g:i€i§§sr ggva §é§E$3fifi§&§i§R. Sn 29.i2.2fl$§,

"'tfia 3i§§Eé ¥ifi£m§ Qemmiitée haadaé by rasgenéent

"pT§@.5 ia its yrafiaééiag fiaaiéad ta ails: tha gist

$3 ges §%l$3. fiaa3$§a&§tLyf :53 inéarviswa fififfi

V"

zfiz
tamfiuctefi aaa E§§$Et was gragargfi. ?h% asmmiitse

hagfiéfi §y rasgsfifiegt §a.5 £5 3 aiagia wiaéaw

gganay farmafi fax Eéiéfiiififi Q5 22% egigifiig

agglicants. it recmmmended :55 _”nam§Cf»$fgA~

f%3§Gfi§&§t §¢.6 .55: ali$tmafi$mH§§ 3iEé” §a Xfi§§tVu’

re3§efi§%ntwCsr§$zatia§. &$c¢:fiimg;§g1.tbé “fi:%$

ze5§sndQ§t~C$£§$r&ti$n has giiééfiéfi gigtjfiglvéfifi
favagr af raagafidasi §e.§”a$£_ §ék*.$fi§axg:e W3
mam §§;’2§..§.E’Q1fi.v§+:~%,;g:*§:”‘Aa};3..;::?¥;m§3’2-2 is cgliaa in

guestisfi in §hi3 writ §§§iég§§.Tg ‘

Eg “”” ‘”$ri; ‘$i§§$$§§w3£”””§.shgstxi, Eaaraéé

fifivécafia :§ar_ 5§a *§%titisaar aufimits tégt the

Eggammenfiétics $ad§s$§’tfie aiagia @i§§¢w agensy

., is $3; ap§raVe§ §§ aha §a§uty Qammiggiwnar, Kalar

‘=_s$$»gitkést $akin§ gggravsi mf tfié jurisfiistieaai

fia§£:g””§§mmi$§ia2e§; thé first f$§§$fi£&§E hag

§:$é€%§3§.=”i@ fiélfli the site in favsur ef

“V %a3§$nfi$§t ¥g.§$ which :3 iilggai,

.3, §:it §§§itiGfi is wggcaefi by the Saunsei

“w_$r£, ?at:i§% R.&ama5§ afar §a3p3n§s&t $93,} :9 3

33$ 3:: ,%.S.?ara§arajaa, £¢u§§%E. far regganéent
$3.5. They £§%i%fifi§§ that :ha gingle wifiéaw

agaa fifit aniy intgrviéwa éfia gelectg tha

; 5 2
e:i§i§§§ apglicaatfi, km: alga virtuaiiy

zacsmmefiés €§% firgt ragpfixéeafi Ear gilfitmami ef

313% aa t§% geléztafi canfiifiaté 32$ cgasgqfiéatiy

the first reapandefit has as sgtian but té éi§d§ ~

éa tée §€f8$E§ wfia :3 aeiefiiefi by “i§éq §i§glev°

wififiaw aggnfly.

#2 E: :3 fifit ia aiggate the 3in§2g”¥i§§m§’

agen$y’ is hsaéad by the _E§§g%y: fiswmigsiéner af
tha fiiatrifit. He i5*a Sigagifiég ii the galactiam

list 35% r%camman§a:icnAg &fv’*éfi§ saiacted

aggiicgfifig-_§fiar§Ear§;”=it “is””t3taiiy” unnecasaary
far tag Eépafiyffifiwmifiéiaaer ta agaia apgrmve the
vary salficfiisfig “fiigéaé thfi fieguty Qeamiasianaf

himself haéds *:he’*$i§§ie wi§fisw’ agency, farmed

“«3fi@wéraata§ fer tfié gusgagg af seiectiag eiigi&ia

7,g§§£iQ3atgf fi@_ aafinmt ha agkaé fififié again to

§@¢mmme§fiQx Ef’ thg argamanz f $3: $ig§ne5h%a:§

§x3§a3tEi»§’is am:e§:a§, iheng ihe §e§uty

V”€9mmi%g§éaar wiii fie fieing tfie fiams wark figty

” €giée, ?%a gacané racammanfiatififi fig” the fiagmty

‘f=CQmmi$5ianar wgaifi be 3 Katiia gxarcisa.

W