High Court Karnataka High Court

Eranna vs Basamma on 4 December, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Eranna vs Basamma on 4 December, 2009
Author: Dr.K.Bhakthavatsala
IN '1'?-'IE H1C3§'l CC)UR'i" OF E'{.i7\R§\§A'I'A}{x'\ AT I"3ANGALORE

Ii>A*ri'«:D Tms ';'1--£3: 4?" DAY 01: 1>EC£::M13£:R 2009 

B E F0 R E-

THE HONBLE BR. .JUs*r1cE K. BHAKTHA\(.z_§.*:'SAi;g&. 

WRIT iPE'I'iTIOI\E Nc>s.3379o/2:335  (GE\./_1¥CPC}. ' 
BETWEEN 1 A' '

S1": Era.r1na.

S/0 Chanrzamallappa.

Age: 53     --  -- 

Residing aé: Ka1i'1n'121{.1'1 Max"ikL11}i&:_Vifiagrz,  V . " 

Challakfire "].'()\>v;},    . ~_  -.
Chit.:'a1d111"g&1 If)is1;1-icé. A.     " " P€{'.1ti()I'1€1"

(By Sri B M Siddalgjpaifl  f'Qf=13e€i:ii,iL>n'ér):V  " 

AND

I. Smt. BasaaI';_z1'11a._    
W/0 E2116 Kn"sh1*:z1§"im.1"i..?}y; '~  '
Age: 55 Y§fE11"S. ' ' V V --- "

2. S1"iRaja.  ..    -
S /  Efa1.us<:%.
. _» " Ragi \}1':1m.éi';_«
_*,_R-c11_}.e_bé:11*1u1* Taiuk.
Ha'vé'1"i I;éism.

5. Sri .»'»'~._}'j21ieial1.

S/0 lam? Héu'1u1'11.:e111I"l1ap1.)z-1.

Agcrz .30 }'C'cll'S.

Both are r/() Near Ci11c?In21 '!'21Ikjip_z.t,

Age: (:37 }'ea111s's.   _ 1  1

Residirig at Ka1'm'1121t11 M.:»,11'iku11[_c> \-'iI.I;«.1,L{r:d'd;'v"» 

Chailaken-e Telluig.    _  V - A  V 

Chiiradurga I.'.)is'11'ic::,. _    'V    '  Respondents

This W1'1'.t._ I%=.'1'.i_1.iAi_m'.. is; '1'Z'2',Ie*.d_{.uj1_cim*_'Arficées 226 81 227 Of" the
C01'1sILimi':i01"1 of I-I,'1di21. 1')1"ayi§'1g: 1"_qt;1__z-:$s.'_1 the order passed by the Civii
Judge (Jr. I')iv11.)'.u C11e1iIaE_<é.1=<;%;-- oi=:..__ §1f§.II filed in O S No.14?/2008
dated 31.1.2009 xf'::%_§? An1':(?xid:.1*éé~If.."'and the order passecl in M A
No.2/2009 cl_:::1..<':ci 2T.._]();2{}()9'- by-' l.I'l(':'. Civil Judge (Sr. Div'1'1.),
(Zh211'l_21kr21'e \»*.i:.3€c' AiiI"]{3X1.1I'€' '.

V'_I'}1.is' 'I%'.e1.1:i{)1';.ctr}1:I'1i1'1g on £01" 1'DI"t'fIiE1']i.I1.EJ.1"}--' I1e21;'1'1'1g this day. the

ORDER

— -. iv»-‘«.’_If}”;-»(:.’ pC1.1’1″iE;n_§-§’1″/ {)1a1i111.ifi’–a.ppeH21111 in M A No.2/2009 the fiie

V “-4_V”.{)§4’~(VIVfiv–iI”.»}i.1cigt’a{_S1′. E..)1’v1’1.). C?]’1a1121kc1’v. is }i)c’>i'()1″c? this C0u1″1. praying for

que11sI’1i11g the 01″dc=1′ c12.1I’.c*d I3l.1.2009 f.)’c-1.SS(.’d on I.A.Il flied in O S
N0.l=:I~7/2008 on the file 01′ Cix.-‘1′! JL:cige (Jr. Div11.). C11;-tllakere, at
AnncXu1’c*–F a1’1(§ 01′(;1c-*1’ <'1:'1u=d 27'. §.().200()O 1'J'<':1_SS('.'d in M A No.2)"-2009

on me filc of C1'\.:'iI J1..1(§g('t [S11 I._)1'vr1.). (T112-1I1z.1§<;£*1"<«3 at A1')I'1t?XEl1f§?';G:'

2. l.,c2a1’11<i=d Ci()1.11'1s5el for 1111c' pe!'i1.i01191" subr1'1i1s t':11;1'i.:—1.h(§'ti'g_§}1«fling: *

pe1':i!.1'0ner in }:)()ssessic)11 of Lhe suit s('I']€_r,i.1,1E_c })}'(_')'}.3vf;"I"1'.'y– U11.€iF§fxEhfi V

ag1'ee11'1<?m to SC". the 1:r'1'z;-11 Conn!' z"cfi}'c(.*!'c»:d_ I.A';'I1A."fi.Ié€i_ I*IE1"Ci*ETI:

XXXJX Rulers I and 2 of C P C. lie*t'i.1'r1._1'1cr the

Appellant? C01.:1'1 afso C0r1m11'1'!Ted 21.11 1’de1′ 01′ !.I1c.~1′.1″‘i:11.. CTt’)’;;tr€:_ by the i.1’11pug1’1ecl order
at Anr1c=~>:1.11’c–¥ “})”eIdv ho prima 1′;-mic case made (nut:

by the p!z:11′.11!if’f e1:’:(ui’@1111]1&6.Af’A’.§’i):’:’i§5(;%1’1imkm-> we-15.3 aiso in Iizwour of the

1)Iz1i1j)t.E§’§”. iI’1_j.LV1}:’;_{‘:1:i{)I’1 2,1ppIi(tai’i0n was 1’€jec1.ed. DL1ri11g

the (:t’;:_..11′:€:¢ ‘(E111’3a.SS§1j§§_T.}’1{:?_ i1’1.’1p:.:_g;§r1e<i o1'd<3r ai" Armexu1'e~F. in pa1'a– 13.

:§".":[1e I..1'iaI C;{')E.1'}.',T'11215:;'.{.)bE§CIV'V(%('} ms:-at the :*ec.i!.2.:l of the sectnlci agreanléélt.

dj:11.eci . ].3.'I§Q3 '£.hax1 the vendor/Kr1'shnan1u.1'1.hy and his

b1'(_)i3:s%i in };5()s9se5sSi01"1. 011'-:.'1.:iI p1'c)pe1'1..y .:;1nd the ssame is adm:'i,1.eCI

9

“E335’Vi.l”1Q*_1:31Zai1fi”t.1§’1 ‘§'”I’:e1″c:tI.’01’L:. i1l’1(~. a1’gL1::1″1(?1″1!. 01′ the’ pefi’%.i()1’1€r/pIaini.iJ’f

LT ” V . 1’F12it, syn” t.:It~1’é basis of t..I’1(-3 fi1’s1 a_a;’1’ee111enf’. the nemm of the plain.1iff<:ame

\

\W,'..