High Court Karnataka High Court

Mallappa vs Parvathamma on 4 December, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Mallappa vs Parvathamma on 4 December, 2009
Author: A.N.Venugopala Gowda


:3: ‘Ti-%E azga waga? Q? K%%?=§%”§”&%€§’a M’ §s’$z§%é?§;€’:§,?g?€iR7’*s’£;:
$fi{‘§’E$ “mg “=5″;-gé éfi 3:29? 3? $§¢§?~eg§§., 2::;:§i;,-23 ‘
§§§§§§ ~~. ‘
mg %-§G?§’%%..E gvéz 3i%§”?’E€E was,2¢§§é:;s§%:§,é’:.§*::g§§~’%é;§;g”%L~M,éfl’I
REG{§L&§. samaqa §&??5:E;.5,'{3i;~V..f%’éf§,’§’§§.§,»%é’§,S

SE”?’%A£§E?§: % V’

Maéiagpa,

Sic. Late Cézaszyzabasaggafi V

Aged abeast 44 yea_:?s,.._ ‘

Rio, Béaxsaééz, = ‘ —

iwyeagéy s%%@%;.%”; gag S;.:as§;i–j?’:§§§.§j_’+a§%%§»K§§e},-.Vv »

§a:”:fi§uget ‘

Qézamaraj,%’*:a§.a:f”;}§$%%€E:§€._~»~ ‘ .3:

:,,a;¢:9§:..:§§a:”:

gay fir:.§*’§.§§2;:§@§§’&¢%$§i;é§é-%”é$;’. ,%£:;$,}

m=§g_: ”

§.«.,?§:2;§i§*::=a§é”&€3j*:a,

I K
. ;f%_§:ea?»a;%~;«°§§;%t.T’3.;é’ §<'§:;;3§'$.

_ 2" f§"2%.§§§%_'§&é";?%;*§?a;

§,f§.., ?’a§:”=s;a:;’2§r;”::”:’:a;

‘ .. ;3;s§§€¥=a§m.§% 35 #,»’&s§§,

V §;’e=.g3:’e$e:”zte§ Em: rsatasraé §L§$§”§§%§°§ maiifiafg

§?:*£%”§ am Rm Qeyamfiafié viiéaga
;§un§i:,:§§e§ Taiuéc,
fihamarafiafiaga? Sésiriaés – §’.?§. 3:3

3. Cfiiéékafianjamma,

ifiifea iate Ciéasznakasaggag
§§§$§ gmssft ?§ ‘géfiffig

93»;

£99. geéazsafii ‘¥§%%agei
fiunéigara fiogt, Qursfiiasgat ‘§”a§s;s§<;
fifiamarajaaagar Séstséié W 3?} 3:3.

fie, Shévamma, Wjé. Late %’v%a%§a§pa, <
Ageé 3591;: 4% yagrsf
REG. Eacfiaiié asééage am ms'; V
éwremgiy Shawn as Beéabafié -*s;%E§age?}_
ééanjangufi "%"aia:§<i, V.

Chamaraganagar Sisitrigi – §?1.::.._3:_3k

U”?

Smxabasagfia, . ._

35%, Late £ha:2nabasa§;3gp;a’,.

%§ed aéaaé %«2yaa§’3,__V__’ __ * V’
Rfsb Be§ax;a§§.%«!§Zv§_age;; §-%:;;?:’a;.§j:gswaf-§sg:§,:;. ”

?’%§:”§_§3§’%§é§fi . 4′
§?s3r::ara§§§éé,:.gi§:r- –§’.vi”_.§:”§§V§%’T”_3E_»z-“22?’ $23:-«3 :3;

6% ¥*&%a?%aéev%a§::*’e2a– % . 1
Sjé .5 §.a*:;’:§ €’§1a§;:§’a.;ba»:§1aA’;3’§fa; _ ‘
figgé ma: fi;:;.,_=;s*$a§’;*:§,,
R,/’a. E:e§&.x§a::.¥.§ V:/éiaggg %r§_2;m§§g:.s:’a ?m5i:,
?*~éa;:§a:2gas§5 ?;*7a2E”:,;:%%;;, ‘
§§*é§rrf:a;’a3fa;r:aIg§:s’f.._§§ff¥~Er§a: – Q: 313,.

:?.. ‘§<aVs%:.§ya§;};§€';v __

.§;;'a*…E;a:_e'C?§~a:§..§:abasaggaf
'– gggeeé a%*:':s7I€;a:€:;'?:f,?'§ years,
£55. §:~a~£*;_%&4;2;$%s:§EE '=¢§§§age,

V §z;;r:§?'§;s§ée% "?a§u§:i§§;’2§§2; ma téza fiéa Q? £:;?*:a *”£§a.z§%

and €3§9§.; Chamaraganagar,

This awéaé ccmifig gr: fey a§i’3″‘%§S’§;s§«%:”i; Ezézég. ‘mars:

Cam”: éeéiveygd tag fe§%¢w§n§:- Z
ggggfiégg,

“fizés gamma a§§e’é§_ 3%&””Efi?’&f§§¥3§3§§%E
§.@:S§Q%’%5€§’E’i§ 1 fiféfi SE. §2e§i%%,. %2a§$%ar?2$= E: wag aiéegefi %:%§a:,, fiafiegfiaazéi ?’~é$.3 fsgaé ifi

maéatgéa géaéfitéfig 32$ aegiétteégkem, fiéé sag? my

maéagteaasfie iimaigéé $33 am §%§%{,j%a:%§:”§ is?

wax I
_, ggw
m ‘

maéséfieséarzae ii} éhé E9′ gafiaifiiéfifk Ranfieg iifiéy ”

iézeir aééaae is’: E??? suit saheézéie §§”9g$::*’i%’%§,_ H

2. “fig 323% wag €$§”§’§&$i?$§. 1;a”‘.V_§€feré_e%af’§:»i

wfiztefi s’ia%:@§:2e§’:% §%§”‘%’§f§¥”E§ me ‘锑§§7aEi§$§?§§E§-§{V’ ‘@;b{‘é_E§VVé§%é§’§é’:%’ 95¢
wsvéée maintenance is ;3§aE’:”§%i’%{‘;;:%%éL§_ a§s$&§’:.;aé%%5z=’:e§
right cf péamiiff §%§,2 as _;:a::.z:V§–%iAA_’f§.”;=:f3i”?’_’..3.3artitéan. E
was stafiefi €§”§at§.. éaiaééaiéffg ihéfe
was as r::sp%::§;’ am §%°se gs: ?ia§:°*st§’?§
vaésmiariiéiy Eééée mayréage wag §§§$G§%§§§

$32′ 3 €é§$§£$§”&’%.;§§”§;’_ §ia§§%’:;e_é{.?ie§ 2%:%*%§.:%e ‘£338 §%§§::%%%?§ am?

..V%:§msa%§§: 332;’; %§*¥§’§:”§..éVse§;:%”a%&§§ ma fiéééfif §§*”%%§”% fig 3:53

‘=_:”§%a§*{§:§g%°:$%*f;:§§.;., ~§:§’~-‘*:£§3§ 3%:-3% siaétaé 2, §§§§§*:’i§§’? ;?’=-éssz 33 m:

E

%2§:§~:£g~:;%§%é§é%’_;»».__§%;,%§§ §i£%””§”.?*2%§” fiifiéififi %:%:a’i:, Eiem ;?%%$.E 3? 33%:

V .§?§§é%’§:*§ %;as§§.”:§a.§§§%:§$§& 3:”; 3;£,£%%.:i§8§ E2′; §£?§?§§&:”2§$ 3 E2:

K “‘i’:§_E:A*: .i§_’_’%§ éiéffie af 2% 3” §é’§F§§”§§§F§’i am? hanzég ii: ég :35: 3

‘_’_«§__é§”§3V§”*§a§r’§2%Ey ig§s§pert*;z. S%::’2§§as”%§, Eiam §*é$§.3 am § wew

. ;:’::§”$§:a$a§ by §§’E$ 1?’ §$§$§’§fiaf”§i fifiéé?’ 3&3? fiéfififi éaieé

3 “§3.§:.:%s’ee3 3%’E§ 22..i§;:§?3. §”&§§$£€§¥%§”y’ am iésay are we

£2

5:

‘vviéather tfie 3″ éafarzfiaat Qffiiféfi %%%3:<.::';i…"f§g
giaémtéff is we diamrcéfi wife $5.§V_:%§"%E .V_';;:§:?%
fiefefifiant $5 amegééaé in mm %°§§.

written $%a€ces”2;”3er:t?

1:? éiem 3:3,: $3 é-sew $33 tééliea§§§:*€=z’%a%%%.:§”:~%.%é:fiAéiééfi

{T

¥-3e.2 in me fiega.i%¥e w%’:3at,_h5er %%:.§”§;§.%_§_a§éf_fi§ VA

gmssas that ma 35$”ééfisndani~.§%:é’$ -ééégiéeciaé
a§E§ §%se2’€e§;r’%.:§j:% §§éa’%’:é:-§%”§’ §:a5′::°,._jc§§*s%é§:’»:;’.§a:%:?;§”‘4§:r”: iéaet
giamé? ” A’ ‘ ” ‘ «’

‘%?#i'”:€t§f%_e7’r,__ fiwa'”§ia§§jz%§§%?s:*.._§z’}i%.’:ié£;7%§’3a’i %:;%~=;e 2%
§¥§é£::

§f$f5>;’Vs’. §.§’E ‘€_§§§§.1§§:J’?fi4_4v§V=f2’§i$Sw:”‘5:’&?§E€”€ in we suit

firaass %§%§’i’ may 3%

&:éti:€%eé». far _?%’:–a:_%§’:%eaa::c§ at}? §$,i,§%§;”»~§r:*:,

. _, fr4§é’s”n._ ti°*:e’.’3*”§”éé%é:ééa:§t as srayaé is: tééa giaéai?

v_.4 ‘§fi€.svz'{§’§%:é& §§..%§’£§’?&S:E§’ sf §£§

V. ‘»i€%:;e§?s;é§§*’iI?%’é §§’ fiefenfiafii wave ma: 3% §$ tfie

E? item f’é§.2 am $3:

«V’T:c’_v§2&:i~’T§é gammi ?§e afeaiefi we? iéée aama §§

V’ ‘::;§.é:i:é§:§eé ii”? i/fig %%”§’§’3£?Z€§”: §%aia§’2*:e§”::?

‘ .. :’%%.f%’:a£%é&:’ c?’:§:’§e £352 fig fiffifiiéfié avg? ‘Em agéi:

§§’§§€€’i§§$ ag §’}§”‘§’f%§ fig §-iaégfi?

‘2éé%2§%%;&s* iééé 2-*5 géaégaiiégf E3 eiéiéfiieé fa? §§§’i%’3€§$f’E
arzé gaparate §$SS&$$§$?§ Q? fie/’2$?** gifiaéé is: 5%

\:,»

gig: grgaayiéaa?

my 33% §’§”‘%%§’?E§§?’§§§’§é:& amcgai 3%; fie 532% :3? §£.§§§2’~

§”‘$”E$5″‘.%’L’§'”‘§ ta fifié :3?’ §§SE§’3iE’§§ frsm ifié fifiié 3%: éészraé.

4. Aggrievéfig we 3″ éefeafiafii 336339; _ ::’§a%&:§./.::’*é§;2a3

§$§%&§ éfé tfie fist 3fi$€§%&§€ £a:§;s’t,;:é’e§$:ééf?a%;f%%’§§ *%i %*:e.:

“J’i§”°:§C§’: fie Md gut ffirétéé in iége vgrétftegé $%§.%éme:%iV.’§§§§;§’?é %:?gé ‘= V

“§’§’§a§ Qausé am aésa $¢:2Ea:§§i;’2g”V’t?%é:3%*£; t%3e”‘a.;_a§%§*£h.%5c§§’%§:a;§§VV 3%

e%.:*§d&fic& as; we éeaméfi ‘f”锑~;f§_a% _§%.s é}_§é-‘j4;S:V¢:%a%§y’VéA§*s’%:’za§zss
352$ ma fifiééfigfi aysé €S¥””:€§5..§$§$:;§’:§$’ §”é’?I.”§?§$§’.?§vn§’§f§ :?’$$ §?”?§§?..§§§”?§§

fiaségmarai am §§§v&§§§f,’– “‘%T’_%;&; %.éa;*:%éé.j_’~}i.a;_é§é éf §:%”:a E”-*”§:*”§i

;%§§e§éa:e’.._£§:;az?V §*2§is§%%%§»°*%’3é22.:**§ ‘ 32$ ‘%@a:*:’:-gaé §§z:::2§ éag

a§§§a:’%%’:§ §’a?’:é:§§= §’§_;:§ §§%:””i§§%§ %§*:§ :”a;=:e::<:§§

4_..V§'a£e%2:a§9§ ffwé :%:é'§i"§§a§ §i'f.§;:?%'%:, raigafi 533% i5%?§G%%f%%'E§ §i§§§%§$

-fa: §;’::3§3_$é :.,’§i;é§’V.:%’:;§~{‘:§fi~:.**

“*s:;§’§’§§’%*9§¥ei:%”;%%:” %:%”;§: §%%%”§’%§§ ijizéii Eiééfié mg @:”*’§’&§
§ §°’% %*:a%£§’:%§ $23? §;§’2§§-‘Q wafi 3:6 aéaééé §%*:;&§=£%
§§’3E’*.é’9fEE?% the fiaénéfif 53% ifia 3″‘
fieferéfiarzi?

ii} fifiézatfia? iééa Eaameé €§%z§§ Eaége éfféé
iwaséfiirzg that 32$ 3% éeferfiafii is ihe
éaasgfiier sf 2% 3″‘; iaifziiff?

/1′

ES:

ifiaz sasééc sf gaggmnéeats 1 am 2;, war: %§”‘;Gi.%§§’% M

faééeé ta egtabiigh thaéf reiaiéarighig 5g’£§’é1g’€e*d; §j:2;’.,sas.;§§

33$ tfieir ergiitiamgnt $9? a gizarfe. :t aé§:é’s;V_Al:a:2′:’év;f’;%:d:1e:*§

the finémgs aszé €G§’%C§é§S§@¥%S 59?:-%4$§”:%;ed 3% %§§:%é’j%;,i{‘§_%§?§’?V”i:éV?%€ is?

the Cazirts §E§éW we £e3s%:§fa§”*;a.€:;:;>3″ §§é;f3§§§’%:§§;*$%i§:§é§’§C@

ms recsré am fiéfiiéf aaié’ fags’ § s2i:%§:j§’e§fe?:%cr2.%;V.L fiztamfiégag is

$29 §§3z”‘§%&d Sen_%c:2f széungfééég’téée. §%;é[§:–$f&a~sV%:%;%=avV§ Qéfiéfifiéfifi :3?

Essa: §£”$§%§€<.'§ "E5?~._§§'§$ 1 v§$§§.§§*-.§'*f{'%é"§§*"§"§?if:%§"§§"'i'§%'i?'?% fifi wéaa fw

£$fis%§e:'ai%t%§;!a §%féf:§ %"37§§%'sa;':e§;'«.."_'&%2e géiagzé aggéaé may %%
a§m§ttaé." *

5, .§~=%a2s%%é§ ._%}:e:a:%:§ ééaéfiéé $é?"?§§%' fifivficéifi 333$ ?§8'¥§§"é§

?–f:':§:'§%"'§¥'¥%§E;§V§'?'é'é§ §i£§§§T3€fi'€§, fiée gain: 5%:

Qé%§.§§:$§#'d¥:av§%3:%§:§V§{';§' §V§}. §%§§f§}$:%§E§R {fie §:*"£'%§E£§€§€§ juégmefiéa §%§%§%

' g§=$é?§.__%§%§sE ';':%:s'¥a§f§'§§%§tar§€£%a§ Qségiéfiéé: Q? éaw is éfiiéftaifi %:§*z§§

, asp;§&a§ fa: fégfifia? £$E"'§$%fi%F§'i§%§"';?

Via §§§a§%ar:§ ééé aémét ifiai fifi :'?"'§§§'§'§$§ im 3"

_ §}§*§§'¥}'§§§f'f, ,§<€£$?"§§?'§§ is him, ézfie :::§§téa§ aefémafiy ééé €33?

'fiaiée giaca arzé that $319 2% ffiflfififiifififii ,2' 2" giaéfiiéfi 53 age?

\/

E2

mm is %%i:'*:'':'. '¥"%§e exsideréfie fircéaceé mi $28 ée§e::éessiVss-.:a

éeufi the cc-§+:3%§tatEn 93′ the 1%: piaératiff with

fiefendant arzé fine 2″” péairgtiff being 2&3 fi3:s§%*-.–§ér ”

3″ éefandant itseié’ is §ncm$isier:% avndm€–3.r;ir$£é’§§é§4g’,

aaéai fast has war: neiéceé égz éataéi b:%f.¥_A§iT?i’TV'{%%:al~.1f%;x3.,§V

am we sggeéiate Qamét. E’£V>%$:_ ‘~3_§% 8:§§$j$§§’T’£j’:Eé§”f§§”:.__:§§,’}:5′;*”i””i§§
essidergca af 9%: ans $323 2 §§..#:,”v%t””h.as §e?e.a;__%%a?5 Em
we 3.” piairstiff is fine ¥~;E§fi.=:’ cf “3f5ff-.V;i*éféV:#:é.%%%’%*_Vanti tfié 2″”

piamtifi’ ES me c?2§§§~.;3’fGg;§ 3 fi?%é§f3§ 2?

fast fig? -*§;}s~§’§:_§: _éf;?é*f: afiar z’&~a;3$:’eC%a%§$:”s
maid mat A?§e_ fe%;sn*&.,_1f?ahé.§A%é};a%;%.i§?2’«i§3s the first apgeéi-ate Cami;

whim if} tfie f§:€a§. Ci§:;’rt £3-:3 facts, Siam iisera Es €$?’*:€iE§”§””§=e”%?

:’ f’%w;§éVr’é’grs? b?*;;;>*t?§’e«’_C$§%§é’Eé§ow; that ice; wiié: %”%?€i”E?”§C& 2%

$2-agixfé-éigg2f§}a~§. §a?V§;.%éégfia 3:’: §’ecs§’fi§ éfiére is éaaréév my mega

fér §?2’Efi§§”fé_§’a:%%:€%§: AELEE $%::s:%§ amaaé $3: ma Cam’: if: axgriéaa

{Ewe _§a§’s%%$§9.§%€i§£}:a mafia? SQSS £?£, it 2% EEG’? tézg £333 éf

‘3:§{§f;:§%%ar:% fiat am: mazafiaé easiégréag %:§$ wag améiiad

—-. f§’£:§’:”?: £§?’§§§§§§°”3€§%?”% as’ fiza éiéféfifi $1? wag? iéééfi %?:§%'”€}%”é§§3f gas:

».__; %,§§$%’2 him 5? éfizeré is §’r%§$-§e3éE§’z§ af am; éigéfiéféfié 3%” méam

£§:*:s%::’%;a:i%§:: Q’? am’ §§€a§;’?*§%;?2%: Ea éiwe éfifiafifié $5 335?:

L

$§é3§ and gr; {ma face a? téze mgéaurrefit ?§§”%§%%”§§§ :”e£_Ve’:v:’–é_’§,é:”*,%’
by the fiezsfig heécsw, géfice ‘there is ma
iiéagafity in the matéar 9? m:*:$§§erva:»%s:f:_§f
a$§rec§at%a§% sf ewfiegéce by’ i§’%é”-

gabstaatéaé §§.;%é$€§$§’% 9? éaafis 3§*%$:¢;%$ ‘-fie? %.’§’?’¥.;é’§§i’;§V€§f$>i’§:’$A’§’§_g'”‘~§»%?.-ii”;

we C§iE%””{§ beiew fiaxse £0:;_s*f§s§§ez’V;eVas:}; §’%3:e; §*:”;:att%.=;é*”i’;%. §&§.;3i§% aszfi
have ;:*’e:o:’§e$ iéée ?E§2€d%’§’;.§’s..:%.é§:§Vi;E:..§§f§.: %3;§<aé fig iiéa
evéfiefiaa am ?&C@Ef'§§; E': mattgs", age

§E'?'E$%.%§fi%§ }?zg£»;%§33$5if§%;$_ 'v%%:w%;.£::_V.. §?.;;§'{'.§§'*,rf§é'¥V"V'i §"§$€ ta arr;

szshgiafitgéé quié?~.t~si'§;3i'%; iéf :a;%€"~§;%%' _€$*§"§$§§€§'3?§§?§ W t§'%§$ C{;!zs?€
if? gecanfi 3a§s3'e§§.' .f%'?2é'~3a15€;-€.;%%':§""a§paa§ éang éewéfi' $5 any

s:.;§$':a:73:%.a§ qaz'§ést,§0r~7e? éavaf is %a% :"s":a§2';%a%€':a§%&. §'%@?§"E£&, E

éa-as ét§'~;é 'f7:'3'5§§§%;.é:2§: """

$3353

‘§’§§é~.5$%é€$:’§;§§ appaaé giargdg ?’&§€€§Z%§.,

sa/–

JUDGE

$a£*