IN THE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BANGAL--OR"E.b
Dated this the 4"' day ofDecember. 2009 'V
Before: N
THE H()N'BLI:' MR JUSTICE HU-.2'U'VA ()1
Criminal Petitions 6209 c/w 6210, 5211, "'o.--,._&213,'};2'14,.
6217 '@2909
Between:
In Crl.P 6209/2009
1 Sri Chiltaranjara Shetty, 59 yfs
S/0 lute E3(3:11a11:.fLy'y'z1_ShettAy V' 1
RM # 605, B;'n:(;;<; B Wing ~
Skyline C5:-y "A4pzf{fVt V1_1'¢'e11Iv:.: _ .
C hzmdr-:1 La1y0§:"L_Baflg;-:.1o'£"c:?L3 " , V'
Sré }_,<.)E:':'ez1n.' Adv.) V
I ,_ '. I ' . . . . . .. '
V_l . ..S[a-ii; 0f.K;V;:":1;1la1ka1-- by
V T_SLabri1':11ai1iyi1pz1i*2; Police Station
2 ' _SVri Ra}1,gin"§;_1:'E:1a1 S/0 Hanumannal
29 yrs. Rfu" Rzmlziimshnanagara
Sar3§<k'i Gate. Bzmgakurc Respmldcnts
s;~i 'c3_.Bh;m-me Singh. SPP)
In Cr¥.P 6210/2009
E
to
Sri Sudhcea' S/0 Prubfzaiczara Naika
3! yrs
Sri Rujcndru S/0 M()ha1ndasa1cha:'i
49 yrs
Mela} Ckosurczs Pvt Ltd
Kanakapura Road.
D0dda.ka1Iasandru _
Bangalore 62
("By Sri Amar Correu Assts.. Adv.)
Ané:
I
State of Karnataka W by V , '
Subramanyapura Police st:-_i_Ei:('re --
(By Sri G BI1a'\m:)i4'SVt:1gh;._$VP§)'
_1n Cr¥.B (;iA2'EV1:'2{i09 "
A S/.0 Thimmayya
3 E' vy_r{s';--.B'ehVi'1~:rj Church
. 41;-:c"E:r§fi;thaIl.i,'Bangalore
Sr_i Mc)§ia1n.Vl'.i'u1na1', 4! yrs
S/0 Sicidaiah
AA 'Sri_L,0E{"esh S/0 M Chandrashekar
" 3_9_yrs
,_
Respondents
DJ
2 & 3 are 211 Meta] Ci()SL11'eS Pvt [Ad
Kan-ukapural Road, Doddatkallusamdm
Bung'.-1I0rc 62
(By Sri A1n;1rC0:'rea Assn, Adv.)
And:
State of Karnaiaka M by
Subxtlmunyapuras Police Slaiion V
Sml Sz1vi1.hr;1mma1 W/0 J zmappu
42 yrs. R/0 Sharacl;m21ga1:'a1
Konzmakunic Cross. B2111g;;IL):'c 6- R'espo"ndents
(By Sri G Bha1v21nESingh, SPF') VA
In Crl.P 6212/2009
Ix)
B~f'1_:1ga1l(n'c 63
Sri R'c'vE111a1:1yV .5;-5/0 \/'éf*-;"1i"<;11zi:"e11AV1'1a11z1
39 yys. R/0 'F'i'1--.:'1;1gE1éii£2npL:.;j21"2., --
Ba1:1g':1_E()r{: 62 '"
Sri S():'m1L'1--:n_;1 S/0 Va:11l{'.s_[a1ra.;fia1121
3*? yru. R/0 Thulaigh'é11.1.;1pua'z1
V " --S_ri K.vP«Si'1<:Mt{yS/0 S111-ccvarzna Sheity
'V _+:«'§4 y1j,_s';=M€!iti=.Ci§;su:"cs Pvt Ltd
'}(;1':1uk21;7{ur;1 fR;<'V)'21c§
A ._I_Dc)dda}:;;1liér-;;4i1c1re.:
B'zu:1ga}():'é' 62 Petitioners
q ('BySad?LAmau9'"C0r1'ca1 Asstx. Adv)
Pctitio -4 .
And:
%\)
State of K;11'11a1ta:ka -- by
Suhramallyapmzl Police Station
Sri R Ramakrishna S/0 Rmnegowdzx
27 yrs, R/:1 # 3E5. £0" Cross
Eflm Main Road. Kadircnahafli ._
Ballgulorc 6} '
(ByS1'iG Bhava:1iSingh.SPP}
In CrLP 6213/2009
IQ
Sri K. P Shelly
Sri Sumpath
Metal Cl()sL:7r"cS'F?yf Ltd _ A
Kaslakaiplma 'Rgaéj. v_{)()dd;rI<_al1E:;sz1 :1rJ*:'.1.;' .
Ba1:'g'é1A}b're T. Petitioners'
(By Sri Atlliuf C.{)'l"1'€V'a ASsE§.';,Ady.')'T'--." "
And:
ff.-11¢ git' iV<.:.irt];§1l'£.!V.é<E1.f:.'b'3:i'
"¥L1m*:11"tawiamy Lztyoul Police Slailion
2 V ._«Sri .\,/:6-}..1__«:|"i:'.11""c-'_g'¢_'.1.a1 S/0 AI-agancshun
3.? yrs; Rh: #345/A
._Ayyappa "I.',:ti'11pIc Road
T}1y;i'g:1ra1}L1 nz1ga1ra._ Chennammz1nkc1'<3
Ba1%;gz:E\)1'e Rcfiptmdcms;
{=33 s_r{C;_« Bhavzmi Singh, SPP)
E<1espg?)1';-d;;Vr}:§;"V
In CrLP 6214/2009
Sri Ratjemim S/0 MaI1z1de\~'a<:E1z:1'i
49 yrs. Mew! Ciosurcs Pvt Ltd
Kunaicupura R()dd. DodLia1i9' '
1 SriSz1da1V:Vian{iavv ' ~_ A
4. " 2 81?; V ijityatktl111:1?' « _____ H ;
' _ '=S_1fi i?;.c1iui<'c1;qf2:s;_1ci
4 r San: Ya;.:.g':a._od;;"
Ki] alffi at z'{/iVetaI C iosurcs Pvt Ltd
Ka1iakzipur21 Road, Doddakalfasandra
* .«B21ngzt'Iore 62
("~By" SVfi"A1:n;1r Corrczt AssIs., A(iv.)
5;/3&4.
Pf1'Li:Eionjc.r - " H
" Respondnets
P€i.i1i()l1€I'.'i
(3
And:
I State of" KLiI'l}Li[£tk'd ~ by
Subrumunyapuru Police Station
TU
Sri H S Pmhhu S/0 Mahudex-'21
24 yrs, Metal CIo.x'ures Factory
Bangalore
(By Sri G Bhmzmi Singh. SPP)
In Cri.P 62 E 6/2009
E Sr': RcnL1kaprasad
2 Sri Uitam
Metal Closures Pvt Ltd . _ _ 'V
Kunak.apu:'za Rom, Dtuddgtkzti]as;;mdr;1 V'
Bangaiore Petitioners
(By S:-i Amiir C()s':*c:xzV;B?'».':s:.5't'«s;.,"'Ac1V~'.«.)_'"' ~
And:
I S tjgdc of Ku:'11avt.:.1_kL1"--" by '
SLi'b£'&1IT1.&:1'1}/L1pl1£'21'P(1E.E,QQ .Sta1ti011
'2._V ' _"fE1:iV K-.VM'~Szt:.EV1}SvE1_S/0 Chowclappa
R/ti J;tkt=;1g:a~1:1a1I1a1!ii
'-- A I'{z1tnai<a1'p:t.I':1 Main Road
Bangaitttrc Rn"-sspondcms
.. a<_B';,z, Sri G B'2;.;;§':ani Singh. SPP)
'.'_It1_.CdV.f" 52:7/2009
" Sri Rz1_§en(l1'a S/0 M21h'udcvac}mt'é. 48 yrs
" '1"<'c:+.~:;:§'urb1dt-:V11t.<' _
Ix.)
Sri RC!1tlkaipI'£1S£ld. Malnugcr
Sri Srizlivals, Manager
Metal Closures Pvt Ltd
Kanaekapura Road
D(TlddL1§('dI1iiSzlildfi-I
Banga1i0I'e 62
(By Sri Amen' Cnmta Ass:s.._ Adv.)
And:
1
l'\.J
State of KLii'i1E1IL1ka1 -- by
Sub1'2a1mmyz1pLar21 Police Station
Sri Lalkkaamal S/0 ViE1a11;i"'H.¢'gdc
33 yrs, R/21 Lil"1gil(f{:1\»'Lii'LihIi]E3: _
Tha1a1ghaa£1:1pura. Balngaicaae
("By S1'iG Bhzavuni S"1,3'.§i]':._ SPP)
P€.?.:[if'i()lV1€_IfS " = '
" = . V n ' Re spo ndcnts
Th*3V-Yfji C'-."5I'"I1511ViiV}V'PG-'..ii4ii'i1§filer}-'uzider S5483 of the C:'.PC praying to
quash the cta;:1~ge"a1;eet v;1_fid- ti:e.";}:t§éee'dings in CC 6c)38/2005; CC 6944/2005:
CC (1946/_2()()5; 'v(:V94V'zJ2()_5;"C . 1819/2005 (before the v Add1.CMM..
me" ~fTdl'1o_\2.rifig:~ fa
...V.Ba11gzaEc.:r§3.); CC E'f--',.»:3,'3V/_2._{_)A(').*_'): CC'. 1332/2()()6: CC E339/2006 and CC
" '._:3214.r:2.(§O6 5:}-L;a-5 me 11 Add}. CMM. Bangaiorc
r "i°hg3sC_C':'imiajzil---_Petitions coming on for O1'd€:r>.: this day, {he Court made
ORDER
ln til} these petitions, cases have been registered tiguingt t’lie_’petitE¢’>_iie:_s
for various offences.
According to the petitioners’ cotin-:»’__e1. theée.petitic)nr:r:§”;t:=s:Vworkignen urlio,
did not go on strike. sti}}. cases have beeii4i’i*e_;gist.eVred tigainsit’ However, in
respect of some of the wt)rkiiten”:avhtifivere viit’i4\_{_t’;v1.iyiA’e’d,.iii and against
whom cases have beenAVregistere.ti_,V_the Vi’>’.~;j’.’3~:; ..\tt”iEhCI1’£1W’11 the cases on
such representation ttie”;ct1ée .fiC.T::~i[iOl1€YS have been isolated.
According to the petéitio_ners.’the1’e=i$x .l1(:)”pIT¥IT}li”.:E’21C ie ctise tigainst them and only a
faisge case has been i’e;§§~;.%.ere:_¥. ”
Certain zmnexuresjirotiueeti.by the petitioners; depict the fact that
g()V€1’I’£l’J]”.:’!}t having exe’:’ei.§;ed”po\»7er, has withdrawn the cases registered against
‘some V’€}{“‘a{:11C’5,.”‘i.\/OY’i’.l;’t3i211 in omer’ to promote smooth running of the il}CELlSE1’y and to
‘inai’nta_i.’n’ §itii*2nt3ny” betrgeezi the imiiage:’1ieiit and the wo1’§<men.
" . When' th"e—per-itioiiers are similatriy placed and according to them, they are
'no: iI1\='(}i\.'C:C1t.'ViI"lv£§1'1JV' illegaiity activity or pnrticipztted in the strike, necessarily.
I I"
s
9
proceedings initiated aguinsl them and me charge xhccl filed in these cases is
nmhing but abuse of p:’occs.s’.
in the Ci:-cu:n~;ta2nccs. petitions are allowed. Pzhcccclings pe:1cITi’:1g;;1gai:1st
the peiitioncrs in the respective cases are quashed.