High Court Karnataka High Court

Darshan S/O B Somashekar vs Siddarameshwar N S/O Late B L … on 27 June, 2008

Karnataka High Court
Darshan S/O B Somashekar vs Siddarameshwar N S/O Late B L … on 27 June, 2008
Author: K.Ramanna


,4.-.

EN TEE HESH CfifiRT fl? KRRfifiT&K% &T EAMQRLGRE
fl%TEE ?H1S THE §?%K 3%? Q? Jfififl fiflfifl
EEFORE

THE HfiN’ELE MR,JflSTECE K.fifiNw£~-E* “x

mR§M:NAL &%?E&& NQ.1§:2,£GQ?’ jf”
EE?WEEN: ‘ ”

QRRSERN

33$ B.$QMR$HEKRR

AaEa.AE0mT Ea vgaas . , .=

gjfl mm.3$3, RM? :1 3?RfiE.”_’

El fifififlfif II fififififi I. =’: _, rjp ;
anmaaaaam w Bfifi @%4 .w._} V u,. Vafiyanuamv

$5? an: a;$.cwm&mfi&m@a§:f€ghv§ a “””””
i , . __ _, .

Sxnfiafiamasfiwxa &, M u»-

336 &&TE*E.§,mAfi$&§?a%*,_v-

EEEE RESET §?_YfiER3″¢ u_’, _

Rffl Nfi~3£1,ufRmNfiPQQRM&;?_’

1?? CRQSS, I: $T£$E-_
Gflfiflhfi 5» » ‘”

,5agQA;m3§e§6Q $§4=.m ….. ,V – an RES?QfiBENT

{av 3&:Vm,m,w$gn§ a A$flQfllfi$E§, REV}

u.%31$°a%$M:§AL fiPPER& ma FELEQ umnaa $Efl?KQN

‘V vafivaté; CR.? 5; E? ?HE &BV§%flTE FQR wag RFFELEART

PEHYENQ Tfi%T”THES CG§R? EH §h$A5EE T3 3E? Agififi

. =_$mg auwmwaww awn ammaa my %£QUITTRb HATEE 23,§.$?
“Ffi$$EE B?” THE ‘KKK flfifiha C,Ma%$, EAEGALQRE IN
“«a;C;wm;E%5fl£flQfia A$QUITTZNQ ?HE

§ESBflfiEE§TfRfi€U3ED FQR THE @?FENfiE ?flfl1Sfi&BhE

M_BfiDE£ sgswxmm 13% Q3 w.z, Amw.

‘ ‘CRlMIH&b R?FEfiL fififiififi Qfl Fflfi BIfiTfiTZfiG

JQBEfiEfiT Tfififi §AY, ?HE QQQRT BEhEVEREfi THE

Ffl&LQWIM$:”

En?

‘g a 3 a M E N ?

Thfia aypaal ifl fil&& by aka appa;Lgnfi?,

agaimgt the fiudgmamfi and arfiar mi acguitt5E fi&§§fiI,

z3.5.m7 gagged by tha xx: Afi@l* C«M.Nm,»§a§gai$r¢

thaxgwy acquitting tag raagmndéatfafifiuégfi_¢£ %h&.,_

fiffemaa yumiahahla under %a$tian’138«mfTtha fi;I;

Inst.

3. fhe ra3gmaflamfi*fifirein;137a*§r§yriatmr mf

nwhwinfi Eatarpriaaa ‘h$wiflg f®g§§fi#ég 5@§§a$ita ta
tfia fimuaa mg’:E$%$c§mgiaifl&$t;’l $&:mEdimg ta th%
3§$%iiant §§fi§ 5r E&é§£fi$§m§ ‘§°§aa mmrrmwafl
@$$Q¢£flgQ@&Em %fi$Hfi%%3fifié%§’ gfiffififie as imam anfi
tha raapmfiéént h&§ §aéu§fi a smegma far ra§ayment

‘ W

mf t&% gaifi %m¢an@¢Afifix;§w1 13 tha ahague fiatafi

;§:£,%§[ <&xawm. afi'~w%armata&a fiank atfi.,$akula

$£a§c%;.j§éngaimra but tha aaifi cfiagua Wham

g Vgreaentafi fwEj®nca3hmant mama t$ fie fii3hwn¢ured.

: _ Theraf¢rg'Ka.%fter mmmglyimg the atatutcry

— §§mviai§nEN Qf thw fl.E. ‘Amt? fie .fi1ec% a grivata

“H agmgiéifit far 3% $fiffififl% mmfiér Séatimn 13$ N.I.

Ea flaring tha cmusaa mf argmmants, tha

learned Smunfiel far thfi agpfikifigt aummitted that

‘R~$§e ifflthe§* mf th@ aggeiiantw

‘”a_ $fi3igm%fi my Ema trial Smut: flflé

iwauamce sf thg ahaqua ham amt bflfifl diagmtad by
tha raspmmdant. 3% alas t%e aignatura an it. vha
mnly dafanfla takaa fly tha xaspmndant 13 that tha
cheqwa in qmestimn waa iaauad fig thw fathar cf
the apyellamt; aa ;3 aeflmrityw

that im apita mi aervima

raspasflaat margin. haw mat flan: any” xagiyg ‘ “If
xaaiiy the che§u@ Ex.E»i afifl mt$%Q”%i3fikvc§§qw§S5

ware issued by %im ta tha father Qfztha épgaliafifi”

ax semurity, ha wmuld havfi g%fi’i3$m%fi=a;$§tiE% t¢

the .fathe: mf aha mmm@1ainamt =£¢,.retQra.wfihmaa

ahaquas, bufi na ammh “att§m$fiv h$s_”&aan mgfigx

Tharafmrég ifi .i5fx§m&&i:tafi’ that tha Eimfiings
racarfiéfi &y*tha firiQ1=Q@uxt ifi tmtaily garwafifia,

inaamrefifi and ii;ég§iw’$imae thm apgallant £3 tna

Wfifin flf=ai£mrmar mihifitafi, at aha xaqmeat mf tha

ra.e.esgm;§’¢:seT:z*2:.,_”%tag.flWe:L:1.a.nt¢ ma-2 gm: Rsfia,2:;,m’m»*-»

am tfiérsaggfifidéhfi amd tha rafigmnfiant haw ifififiéfi 3
chaqu&”tm$ard@ gaymant af tka aaifi gum %ut th%
“xt3ia3; CmfiEt $eiiav3fi tha flefenwa taken hy the

kgspfinflfint that tfie chaqma Ex.§w1 is iaaued ta

?ha aaid reaaams
tatally

imcaxract. Tfiarafaza tba uxfiar mi acquéttal mf

/\’ix
‘3 .11’ N:;:-“”””
.–«~”‘”‘°” ‘

It is mQntanfi%§=_

mf nntimagw- t§%Ifl”

tha ufiwgmnfiant ifi tmt&ily’ inamxraat. If any

amgunt wafi invastad by Chg matmax sf thg ,

aggaliant in tha partmaramig firm rum fly t§é”wif%f%

mf aha raggmmfigntg th% flame is a ~fii§fer§nt

tran$aa?imn, amt E@lat%d 3% thé,m§aqq& +”ExQFal,u,

it 3% ammmitted that w§wm’tha r$$§wmdamt?a&mit%

aha iaauamaa mi ths chagmag* £t iaVfigha-?mmmnfian
duty ta fiificharga tfia’$§ma;N’3$m¢Q_it 15 fiat a

Qammgrcial tranaamtian afifi’*t%a ,3@fi¢il3flt heing

the awn mi a gmfliatefig ;$;a3 §aiter§a3$iml® ta

lfifid lean tn””th%~fgfi$gmfifiam%mHf?he£fifar& it in

$ubmifitafi,mthét ‘fifig, fiafiifigwmaracwyfiafi by tha
€murtwhalfiw:’i$V”§m$H%££§”~am& %anc@ praya for

aiiawing th% %@?fi$iw\A:

%;3;Qn.tha ¢iEm2 hamfiw tha laaxnad Cafiflfifii

fa: .t&ajtxé$p§&fia&t arguafi that thaxg ia ma

. ‘.V fimmmflgfifia$y*7g¢ifiam$e grgdum&fi’ by tfiw aggellantm

7, snmpiaifiafifi Vim gnaw that ha baa withdrawn

, fi3;E;&fi,Qfl@£m frwm hifi aaflmumt in Emmjah fiatimnai

a,m¢%,%%m 2:3 argmmfi thgui: mat: hag admdttecfi rm

sfilinq af .four rivafia mmmgiaimta my tha

3@p$iiam: as wail ea fiifi family mmmm@ra againat

tha r%apmmmemt anfi tha fiflid mthar threa mriminal

2″‘ _,@–«””””V

…;»….»«-

L29!

aaaafi are atill’ panfiing and’ eha cmmplaint dmea

mat di%clm3a in what amntaxt tha a%¢qu@ in

gwafitiam aama ta ha ififlu@d is him. Tha aggallamt

whm filafi a grivate ammyifixmt hag mat a§§:maCha§

tba flmmrt with miaan hand3¥ Exwflwi ;é1&arl$”

ififiiflfitfifi thag th& mmtfi&§ mi aha apgglEaét<&aingg

3 fiixfictmr mf 3 cwm§a&y' ta WfiiChi Qif§2 Cf.'tfi@ H '

raagmmfiant :5 fllfifl a fiiracfifi§,imw%wfifid_a$$fifit_t$
tfia Emma $5 Ra.ifi§Q%,fi$fifi~ a3§V§$.§acQ£ifi§} fiiank
@i§n&m shaqmwa warg tak%%_f§wm %hQ %§3§mnfiemt and
fmur fiwmgiainta Asamw §m fbéfiAfimfi" ffi£a& by the

fiathar af tfié pgpailafiE" fhzsmghv hifi famirg
mammars. X_ ?&a. é3lag@fi",;§am' tranaaatian cavaxafi

.4.

mafia: Ex.F~£_ £3 V£a§VAtawa£fifl Legaliv” raamwaxabla

gammy _$fi%r%fmr%~ §h@. trial Cmurt baa rightzy

X§CflKfi§fi £fix f¢m&ing$ that th% aggaliant haw mat

e3tam3i3hafiw Vtfla%. tha £a$pmm$$nt~aC$mae$ has

‘ :wmmittgd_>thé? mfifanca §unifih3bia unfiar Sactiwn

*«ff?3$ af w§Efi hat. Tharafmxa ha prays far

fiiEm3$3%l Qf tha aggeaik Em fimgyert mf hie

“*mant&mti0n, tha £%arn@fi fimumaai for tha

V”«_r§$§wnfiant has relied an the fallawing

fiéCi§ififi§§~

{Fe

a§ Tha damiaimn ffififlfiffifl my the &§ex fiauxt

yr;

f%@flft%fi in Eflufl £E&

U}

am’ $38 §KR:$§ma7.

EENAREQEN gnaw .w; mamvmwaama Q. fiE@fiE§f»

whereim Head Hfitfi “E” refifia a$ §fiiiflW3§~

“fliafimmmux af chequ&5§@$m&¢$ * ‘
mat raquixafl ta sfiap iu€mb$i&m&§$ ‘
nwx, he may @immh&fi§a.hi§~mmr@fifiA
an hasia mi matazi3§a_Vai§a§§$5
hzmmght am “.xamm$£;{ §maati@fi”
Whfithfif 3%a%mfim;?_f §r§fiQm$t$$n
rabuttad_ mr,m nmtgA ®fiafi5g”Ee

“<¢£_ father

§3:e£mifi$§* in

aviaafica*$m £a$*

mfi : aEb$fi§ , §f §§§gafié W fi@uRT aagaa 3%
vEE;3nflAfiE%§%R*%§%§R ELEKB MAN: ,u; fi?ATE
.,%F' §fi3&3fi# fig? §N$THER§ wh&rein it hag
i§§%ax h$£fi~~&%§t the surdan liaa an tha
.M, »5§mgl§i§ant ta yrmv& that the fihaqma in
§fi§%§§#$ game am ka ifimued far iagakly

. Enffirceamifi fight $3 flfifififwififl.

'¢§e$wfim§@ it ix 3Uhm§Et&fi that tha ayyeal he

"=$iami33afi.

3. Having maarfl tha axgmmantg “f lgarnad

flmmmaei fax bath Qflfitifififl nmm I $xmc%efi ta aae,

§~’

imfiicateg that ha hag amt f:l%fi any cemglaint

M’;

making aiiagatiam thgt tha gammy mf the

agpaliant max méwmaad tfimaa fiiaak ahaguafi amd#g¢t =

fiiafi wmmufiainta thrmuvh mia family m%mm%§£n'”fifi.°
1 _A _ L.

has aiafl mat gm? iaauafi Vgmy §$tifi&.’Ft%_

%z.$$ma$hakar§ flfifi father mf, tfia? a§geiEah§,’%~

r

Aaamrfiimg ta fiimg in 31;” six hl$nk”chagaé§,yar@

takanu Tha fmrthar admifimganfi m3fia by7§tma

xa£gmmfi@mt aiaaxly inéfifiataé tfi3t2;ha.mati¢a want
my tug aggeliamt afigfin kavg fiéafi fiabaivefi wy him&

fi% fmrtmgr statgg. tam; 5&% v$m__fiha date mf
aflvamaimg af Raga &f,R£3fig§fi{g§$;~; tha agpailamt
wag ea m$jm£’3fifl’ that #%€~wa$ studying ix: a.3c.
afid ma might havé’3¢ammfi$afi&£ gmakat manay, Thé

mather suf the .5″ al$amt anfi aha wife Qf tag
1 _x§9

ffiaflpwmflémga a3artedC”§3rt%wx$nip muagmfima im the

flqm£ “w§ v3tyiw =mf ‘flica Ema Sxaam ?vt. &tm.*

Stafitimg “mf§,ag &u£inaa3 fig the mwtfiar mi the

‘a§@ailgm§{@ifih Ema w”fe af tha xa3pa&&%nt ia a

‘* Quitfi;%dif£é$en$» tfififlfififlfliflfiw ?h® Memuramfimm sf

%3$gsig§iwm Ex.§~2 fimfiimataa that tha mwthar mi

V”-t§% fiyyailant 13 mag mf the fiiractmfls wf Sica fine
‘flrésm ?vtaL2fl. afifi gaga mmgfl af Ex,BwZ diaclasas

Eh&t .3mt.Jaya hag taken J%§fi$ %guity* sharas ma

Q.

53″‘

– .. ‘».’____.,,..«
.-«”””

M.