" SE2? 3. Jois, Adv.)
IN mm HEGH comm' 0;? KARNATAKA, _
DATED THIS THE 3rd DAY OF APFEI4L:;..2£§1ij9.A 3 % "
8 E F 2 "I " '
THE E€iON'BLE MR. .JUs*:*:+:;;E BV§'8REEN;3fl!i$E,V: >
Wm; Petition N}%:;«? 4.5. of i2Ao:;:f7_{%s} E
Between: *
1. Sim. (3.8. Jayalaksiltni' __
D/(3 1atcC.S, Rag _ «V
Aga: 32"y<§ars;_}?[e--.NG;«58,I_y..
"S1j.rtiatI;i;é'§_ Stfitnajn :1' . V
Tm: B1c;ii}{:;"4*h .PI1£;$;<é;v--BSI{».:IfI Stage,
Bkar1ga10m%8%5.%%%
2. 32-; N.R."S2it§.:ané:1da
_ _ S/é'~VN;Raghav_eI':'dra Rae,
Age: abgut 54 years,
/Q 3?, 65*31"'s;'3?0ss, 3" main
Eadarixthi rsiagar
. vV"'B;a1iE;~31¢3."e 72.
'~ §'c:ti1:ioI1e:1*s
A n"d; 3-
= T113 {'.»<:3fi'ee Board,
Rep. By its Chairrnan
Vidhana Vecdhi, Bangalere.
:2 The Ijnien of Inéia,
Rep. 855 its Sacretary,
Ministry 0f Commerce,
New 13611;} I20 O01
TN}
3 The Secretary ,
Coffee Board,
Sr. BR Ambedkar Vcedhi,
Bangalore 1.
T
{B}? Sri 355.1%. C, Ravi, Adv- for E91 1;._R'3 _ 2 " "
Sri G. Shankar Gmldr, Adv. 1b: 2)
This writ Pefition f1}€ci*I_}r;e:i;er Armies 226 And :22?
Cif The Cflnsfitlifififi Of..~I:1d_1':3. §91f3«§'in5g"-to.v"diIect the
rtispendents to ext€2}€jA-- to .pé'tiii.9i1crs with 5111 benafits
of retrospczctive proniotjari to_ '-.thc'' -. cadre. of Asst.
Supeziiztenciezat (M}....aI1L§. t§fi1§5::eaLfi;s:r'the next higher
cadre {)f, « _A-::C£mt_,s Qffi§$§'/A$St.. Director 91'
}E'I'o;110tiQri;':e'_*:s§t.¥. V -- . 'V S~5:c;"eta1y / Asst. Cofiee Marketing
Officflr and c:i.:;rifi1;é'z::_ti:;_r6vise the date: of promotion of
the: jietiijonsrs 'Ute _ "i-:hé:;' of the date of which their
rasmctivt: 313.:1ir$'?g&?*f::3:f€3 pmmotfizd and extend ts mam all
th3C"n1oI1ctaI'y'benefits and arrears of salaxy, direct the
rfeéapgzjdgnts i:'u-:'r5:x.s':'se and rfifix tha perisienaxy benefits
" i:§:§: tfis: p€;tj_.t:lone:'s and 11smut::11t on revised data of
V pmAmQt'esr;$:aAVa10ng with irltersst on the beiated payment of
._ é_r3.'ea157s"?.A. from 81% date, the arrears fail (1116, till
Atfie dja.ieL~'IQf"pa3'mant 0f iritemst from the Eiate on which
their~.fju;::a"i<)r were paizi arrears {iii the date af actual
§3a§;"3I}fi.I"ii {:0 the petitioiaers.
This Writ Petition (taming am far Pvelixxxixzaxjv
héafing in B' Group, this day, the Cfc:-11:": made the
fofiowing:
/4 / _,
%,.f-3:'
ORDER
The petitioners in thiar writ. pefitisfl’
fer the foilmvmg reliefs:
iii)
issue a Writ in the I3at1.iI.’Ei ‘c;~fA’mand,afl1us ”
directing the nszst-;*c»ndez1tsV to ;-:’x’t’¢n4€Vi to iitgé.
petitioners with a}1_”._;bene’flts’ -,_9f’, fatffispectjve
promotion to the cadr%:.._of Asst.”S}.;p€I”ifite13dent(M)
and thereafter to fifixt I”1i§_g.11’1tiI’ cadre: cf
Accmmts Off’ic;er;’As’._st.:.Dimctpér cf Promotion /Asst.
Secretary /Asst, ‘ ‘ f’.3s:¥f1fi2§:: Markifiimg Ofiicer and
consaqucrxfly ifgyiscj :21: dégteiz-§f gitremotion of the
petifio11§3:’s tc-9′ ma: r;}f’~.fth_e ‘date of which their
respc€t:ti§§:j1;1iiQ1¥3″‘ivef(:_ prdmcted and sxtend to
tI1t;=;n’1″‘v-ti_:e’ mo1}«:t.*§ry&_’ bcnefits and a1’rear*s of
issue “furt11c:3f “véfit, Qrder or direction to the
zfe$po1”:ad<;fits to revise. and rcfix the pensienary
-1?;6I1efits’t0–*””che petiticaners and conscsqucnt on
Argaviéczd dates of promotien aieng wi9th intercsi: on
. “”:::-a:?i’2;?;ed pagsmant of arrearzs (fig 12% 9.51. finm
date, the arrmars fell dug, fill tha date: of
}1aji’I§if:¥1f. or i1′}t€I’SSt fmm the data 011 which their
juriibrs were paid arrears till the date of actual
” payment t9 the petitianers, in the intarcst af
jixstice and <-fiquity.
Pet:i’€.io:1ers beforr: prafexrmg this Writ if:_..:2_%:s.r_e
issued the ittgai notice Annexgrg G ‘datéd.
and renxinder Annextzre iqghe
respondents requesting ‘é-if
retrospective pro1;1__3oti0I3. __.1_L: 1.336 of Asst.
Supnetary benefits and
0fV’ p.;a}%_ “:<:11'd_ "p<:13sioI1. In rasponsa :0 the
rsmintisf,-An1i:je:§':§1je"i*~!. the respencientfioard by letter
fiyméxum J' 16.6.2006 infemmd the petitioners
–:;Eatt€:r is Ming p1″0C€S$f3d cxpeditiousiy.
iéghcn 1:126 matter was iisied far hearing the
iinunsei appearing far the petitieners submits
” that {he rrequc-:51; 0f the psiitianars for extending the
§b)éiA1fifi'{ Qf retmspectiva pmmation ti) the: satire sf Asst.
Superintendant and that of ACME) frtam the date 33″ their
juniors nazneiy KL. Satishkumar and 7 Gfiaers is
$4,
csnsitiered in the light of the judgment of thi_駔ii§>1§1*t in
W.P. Nos. 33105306] 199′? and other
in so far as this C1a3′;13″”0f« .t1i:s:: 3;3c%itif.’1::z11ei’s Lnfor’ j VL
payment of arrears cf’ pe13fs.i_0i:_V. is ‘§;_;1ncm:’Iie d’–~.%Vth¢
respondents have ckxallézxigfiii, thé sof tiié
mdfiz’ passed in tht=:’°wf1fit pt:’*£’:i’t,i-.V*::If41:=aVV–ViI2._ wntgppeal and the
matter is pending bcfe1~*-fi_niie’:’ Dix:-*駧irfih;;. Scnch.
At t1:is”‘«§:.xj11Ct’§,;:r€; -:fhe”«.{é飔‘I3.€;C1:’.f«Counsei appearing
for V ‘;3§%tifc.i{>.i4ig<4é:i'5V:":§ifi1bI:1i§§V'that the patitionars are
a:1t31'i1ed" _ for_ V' if1At.,6I'f2$t.. the belated payrxient of
pensiofiagjs they 1213}: be givan liberty €10
repgtésexifgfiiggns '%:.(;~ 1:116 :r€sp0ndent.s mquesting
" 'pay interest on the belated payment of
V'
V In View of '(hit mattm' the writ' patition is
ciifiyosgd' bf with ma folkéwing observations:
E} The iiabiiity 9f the respondents in pay
axreazs cf pensicn, if any, tn: the petitianerg
'xiii be subject #3:: the resui': cf the writ appaaji
penéing i)t:foI'c: the Division Bench.
Petitionefs are gven iibertif’ « 5§:?:3.é;E<e
I'€.pI't3$€I1t&ti0I1 to the 1'espond
of pensionary b€1f12?’fits« .wi:h§,_¥1 %xwo monéhs j
from the date of =fCCfii§2IfL (if ea.’ CQp§;’v..LLAof.:. £5115 ‘
camel”. If such 3. re;3rei;ac11ta1:io13 is :13;é–;:’i’:3,”th<3
rem:-andents dift:(;te:ri t-:)'"'¢<)t1_sid§§:r 3:16.
dispose of the'–s;i:::1& in at:C:.11't1_;aij;:é"ivit11 law
Withm twee n1<}:aths; fi'–C%II} the date éaf receipt {sf
such r€;p:i::sc11.tati0::.