High Court Karnataka High Court

A Mallikarjunappa Ex Director vs Standard Industrial Engineering … on 9 July, 2009

Karnataka High Court
A Mallikarjunappa Ex Director vs Standard Industrial Engineering … on 9 July, 2009
Author: D.V.Shylendra Kumar Kumar
1
wall:

2:»: THE HI{f§H aomr 01? I{AR1'€ATAKA XI' 13.s;_:v{;;g'i,::},gE
}§)ATEfi THIS THE 9" E3335 0? .n":m/-* 2&3'      _
PRESE?€?'E' M    n T
THE 11<::§z*3L.:«: ?xfR.,.;m':';{*:a mfg a§;'é3:T;rfi:+ei3§R.;§
fig; , %   1   .
my: g§<3z~:*'g:_;§;: Egg,  §<":i\;=1AR
     %  

A. :%Q?{1£:§gi§S-':,£.:z.-%'§V.;£§%.¥}é:%fl.',.':V- " '
 {};?.:~<:c,m:*._ ' V'

31.59. 2.3159 £2» CiE3E1df&pf§é2;;   ' "
RSO. 228;-"EB. S§s:3<::;'ti1é_ I C-Vi';(.)<f§S',: 

S§'§'}viai13... $11 Pai}.1*:~;, ::,,v, Ram:   %
Bzmgaiere M 560 t'}93.a  . ' '

{By Ssfii E%¢1ada;:_§§viG£3an,  Stié Miiimi G. Ggichala, Adv}
AND: = M %

 ._Sij:a.11$iar::i7 E2161;s1:r£a£V."f;§:iAgifieeri11g C0:I1;9:m}=",

V669  63% Mgsciitu. §{}arde:1s,_

_ éaiggga i§a§ag11I'a:1i;:_

Véjagfiaixada, Represezfied by its
'§"§é:'§&j:_":;ag;,-Et__';i:2.Vg :}§37'€Q§i';%f. '
' '-.§5s§§af§='''';?'9£ve§ { I} Ltfiww
iii -Eéqaidaéiiegl Rep. by QL R-2

 }3<3'a:a*ef {I} Lié
 Iii iégaidatienw rapid by
$16 Qffisiai L£qt:£d3.i:3:".
4 $2 :3. 3&7: F Vfing.
E<:e:1drijs_;;2 Saéan,

 ,  ' ...App«2:iia11t.

 



,3,

of the Qfdfirfi saugifi to 'at: reeaiied filed under  of
the {:£3iT(1;:}ai1i€3 Ad. ' '

2. The appczzai £3. substzmce is $g; g¥.§1"£S"{    =
the Eearfied Ccsmpany' Judge: 0f
Cm3'1¥*a11}* Patitima I\§c}.I8O;'2€;3y{q?%vA'\\.,¥:1.f1 fiv.=";fi:"?%   
21.11.2065

and orderizagfhe ‘izp. (3%’t§§€:2fid’,.vi:2iSpGfl€}6i1t

Csmpan}-‘ «~ Beiiary 4Pi0_:_a€’ef’ réprasexated by the

Gfficiai 1_ie:gu£zfi2:«.fz:;y_r.*~ _

3. ??.’~Aa1tef”Eié_ifi:;g9′ fog’ admisgion, we have Eiearé Sri.
fviaéati ‘§\é{;3f.*;..:<1n, "Ee3"z°€1'ad'."e;;:'u:1§:3i E02" 'the appeiiant and Sri.

§e§§{3;.'a£;?A. the Siaaadixzgz Csmzzsei far {he Qfficiai

.Liq1_,::daie:,–,VS';"i._ Rarrianna, the iearned sauxzsezi ffar '(fie

':'::;;p{:éade:'§§.'}j';—fifiiswpeiiiiiézzsr £5: Eiae originai é3€3ET£}§:§&i'"i}" petiiiazafi

..'§%§§;iEé we 59$, aim $53 caE%€:<:.¥ agagiiaaéigzsn fa: reszaiiirxg the

§§_:'::§?€':. égieé 2§.§':.2G§f§ csf 'the iearzieé Sizagla Eudga, gagged

zééadsg" Saiééazz #33 {5} and {5} G5 the Cazizgmzziag Act, 191%, is

:29': an apipiicatimx praasicieé fer in iau; as siiich an garder maid

Emzfé E3<::e::n zapgjeai zagéiészgt, we ilzriher Eiejfififi thézi 31$ Qfdfif

"s.£f.'°é;*§_':ixs::zi11:'§:ié:';..__ iigéif wag héiiaized and wiiiie: disniissed Eha

» ii*:é"a:;fi1er ?_§a::3 appziicatéarzg.

…-3-

sxziaereitx the Company’ 2.3532: éérecied ‘tar be wezmqzizd in
hem appealed against bf,-‘ the afar}? 0i3£l1pa£1§f _a§i:i’
has been dismissed in QSA.N:3_94.g’O<;"~:mi:; tazms =
produced at A.:1n€:xure-C to the presézggi V

5. The appaai came 19:3 3% efiszniss-ed 3.i’£it*§;1ii:£_g;v…i:i1:¢.3arder_’

pagsed hy the: 1£.”1′-£i£’fl€’»{i Sigxgie

6. It is imich Eaier the ~T-p:re§v:e’r:fi: ap;§#éi{1f;i*:_’_’ci:1imi;1g tea be 3.
famiex’ G}:I’€3C§Gi”‘ ‘§}fThé.’C;31I¥;%33f£}f: §};£d._..§fi6d Ehe appliczafions
referred is; a§«:;{*-;?.a:% i;: ‘éhct'{:é’2;;p;111}* Pefiiian Na. 3 88.526301 seeking
13:’ 1°ac;=é{i£1:5g r.3f’i:heV i:§figiiiaiV”?;5%der far sarixidizzg up the c:Q;I1pan§%’
d1:;$_§?;€3″ iéfi it:21b£’i£~3f§;-€12: :*ef;a§.: {ha éebi.

T315: iearfied Siéégia Eudge z:£:>’€i£:eci {fiat 313

a;.3pv’ii::fa’;:%.:a’31i f:3:* cendorxaiéém af &&i2§:, consequfizitiy dégziiissaé

S. Subiiiififiififl $5 33%. Mada: Mgizazz, ihe beamed

asmiizsei far {E162 8§}§}€§£.£i’£?L is; ‘tE”2a’£’ eariiar appeai fiad baa; fiiezi by

$23 <:::=:12;;:::.*a:*':}-' arzzi iéie pregazxi éigfifififiiiafiii $535; an E:x:«Si:'&c"£u:;;: 935'

M

€<3;:::.%';3:2ig':L:.«* Jggafga 'i-'%;'5:Ii€Li§.1i{g-i!§ iiaé c§:::':::p:2:1§;r had Efiéffiii

1 :§,§3;fg3éa?.i:?.£i'~A._ag3;':':if§:}~ »:»1i'i§ £22 {£29 agrsspaai it {sag been affémizeci and
4' ' = $K%;_mi:ia–§§s3:z.

apsiésgiiasa, ii; is £16? »;:&:1& pikgvédfifi £92″ £1″: E223-” Tiiaze is EEG E7%.='”&”if=;

the Ceznpagrgy prim’ :9 the c:<3rz1;3gm:§,-* being wszrund ::§:wvver;};Tf.i'»?§s:i3<3
wag»; moi: awars «:35 me pre:3<:eed£:1gs zmd %:E§.ai' he M
difgazéaargéz the iiabiliifg cf the <:e3:"r2p22:":jg'f2f:i*:é§ ceiiiaxagié ..
Cii'Ci}i11Sié1{1C€:S fthézre swag ms :3<:.::asi. s;.j:1
weasziai up arid 13.215, E§i§i"€fC3§'€, '§{§i:–.5_z;}1t igfififv.

he get aside.

9. ‘Ne Exam’: e};&:j§:£z1iad._t:i:e”§t:?_i%t:ii;:–§im1 zxiaée at ihe

B32: The iegfggzerdf’ tgigiiéei iigf ihé r£:§pé’::;i’é§?z1t and the cmazpany

1191:? re;:r*e3e§i&~:é €316..Q1f:c:i9;%=Lieifimiéatar, 113156 painted out
iizai :Ir1eTr_e i3_né;s qiaelfiiéufz.:§:’.i;3fi<;_. present appeal being eiatefiained

fer the :;i:n_;E:'ie :*i:;.:3;$;:':;–n ¥E§:3§;"~'E}:e main zxdaz' passed by '£325 ieamed

§§1€'?§%5C:1j£§' isééé: flfdéf dcneg me? §1::'2?é§*a ézxéegaeiadeniiy" iE:2:'

£8. Ekfizeiizer tigers :15; zzéeiagz" 9:" 2:143: £21 fiiia Siiiféi as:
. 3»

azwia ?€i"S§§Zs. siaizizizzg iii} ffifiééfif §%r&cf£s:.2:° in {E16 z::=::::2§§3;2;:;:';,, EE=Z'_'r"s&='

a:§:;a:£:2':i:}g é:1§':.=:§"@ss;'§ £2"; iéis €2€3é§2'§¥;3£,%.:E§°, giriiézzg :;:2%;::';":i' iéic Qyéer passazszd

®/%

#53"

by iizaaz §s:;,’::’::.:;:::E S§:1gie Eudge wiziciz has g0′: merged ii: §§:é_2i’ppe2:i

by the camgaazry and ihf3E”é3 $332110: be 3:23,: reimcirzg ‘(if ‘st:¢h..§sté;2s:« %

3.1. Tirsre ifs no qi_i€:3iis311 <?if'3ih'1§' i7",_~:3a;rt.;a:1:é:ft;:%V1ii11'g aitt.
appeaé a::ft;'i1is nature and 2ppIicaii0:2s:f1iéd for :3:Lt<'",=Efs:;i:'a::";3o*é:.;c"~: 'a22*é=.L

not" tmabie.

12. The appeai.,.”a;1& fog” ‘étafsvv bath are