High Court Karnataka High Court

A Manjappa vs K N Chandrashekarappa on 18 October, 2010

Karnataka High Court
A Manjappa vs K N Chandrashekarappa on 18 October, 2010
Author: B.Sreenivase Gowda


$5 Efiifiié fifiifig? €33?’ E{§§§§§%?§§u% B§;§§i§é..Eg$RE;
§§7§’?f’§:*”3-S ‘E’E~§§ 33%;?’ Q?’ fififififififig

§;%-*?€§§”;

*§§%§w§@Eéfiagfigfifigggggaagfififigifi§§éf .

2% 2&2: §*§§¢§?§2;:2§€;%5: ;

fig §§,&§§1§§g§§§%

3; if} %§:.§§:z:’g«§?§g

éfififfi §:§{3′{Z§””f 5% ¥§_,:§k_:a*§:_$~~-._ . _ ” ,
QfiEE£$§§§E§E?&§§§£$?§E?f,”g
R;{::§%§;:;g§*§%§g;: ‘- _ i
§é%EéfiEEE_*_ “”~’

P %%%% -%’» Lv;. »k»% *~-%% Hgayygzgaw?

gay 335:: gaggagg zjgyixa, $§,%;:xza;:

égfifi: 2

3 V _ 3; E; a”§3’g%’;*%«g%:’;’.:f.%-..§%3?2§~:§’%.ze%;i§iEg?§.a.
” agfi §%’§:§::,;%%a§?& V
‘i. ‘ . . . . . ..’
V. _, §§:»ifv’»’~.,:§§;*~:’%:,§:=§’ §&RE..%”‘£”§-EE {gag §:m»§€
_ T. 3%} ;%i§;;«=§3%%§ fiééé, ESQ §%f,f’m¥§:,L2E E%7E§%%’ :.£;’@r:§T
._ , E.::£§;§;;?€&%;{§§:EE:

2 “E?E%§;;’§%%§%£§§’;R
~~%3’E%’iE”E:3 Eifiifi $63 §;.§.:§
A. EEK $5§%:..§*:%:§ Eli} gzgz?-§:§§g:a§%
fiafigfifagafigggt
‘ §§$?fiT§’€$E§*’§’S

:33? fiiféi; Ea» §:%QE§i§§£§§£”§°’fi mg zgapmasa azegg
:g§,:;.§$m§gm§;a§ am! 9:33 32;

Egifilég §”E§.E§§ 335$ §’§’Z.%§§.§ £33?’ %¥ §;{§’E} §a§£§$T ‘§.”E§E
s.§§’§§E%E’%”? fi£*§§ §a”§s5 §§§§§§ §E§.§§§§£{}?{}§ Eiéfifififi E5
Ekgfi E%%§.§.$§s§;§§§? 233% ‘E”H§ EEEJE Qé? E fis.§§E§?§$§’§%éE; i§E’*§E”L=
:§§.§§§:irE {§§§.§£§=%Z’§ afi 2’%§§§?§£:}§§§£.,y- %%”‘;iE’§§ §§5<§.§2§*¥%E?;§,

8'-r

:2

?§s§'§'E§"2:" §;.iE,»{}"§?E§€€§.§ $33: "§Zi§§§§§ §§";"*E°'§'ZT§§.3§*§ "*.._ §5§§
S-i§fi?§!E€§éf§§§E'*§ §;§*¥§ Eifé' '
€G§§E:§~§?&%"f£é}§§'.

-mzs fiF?EfiE,e Cififlifeféé Qfi’ mg: §<*:':«::;%§..

"EI"E£§S may; i%;'T.%§;E'; €_";{}§,_§g'%'T§ §§:§.,:2;'%.a:.*%§§§ mg: §?{:%§?§»'{§;;'§¥§?§%& V "

Téaig é§;§3§§&:< 233; "$3; .:;§§ifi:f:%_.:1é: féffi' ,:::'2§2;'§*?:é;_z":§:&§;";&:é%:z':~:£_''' .

£1215 mifipézzéagiizgzz awayfiafi E;}§"§;g::: f';E':*:Zb:;:r:%§§;§§
Es Eb: {Em afaiisiéi §f*'_::a§;:%é§'::.;é;:;%§;i::§:-§ fiiéfi §§E"?.§fi$ am

§'&§§f'E'{":;£§ is $3 {fig}? 3.36%: V~:%i;€:§'&§':;';%*g;:?;L':§é_§': *£.§*:§§ céaégtfi pfiiéiigm

Egsfays 2:315 5'F§?%fm'§g%:é§§.;v 1' __ l

= ' fiigvésrééf f a? 'fifi ffififififii

f3s::§.g§=§;%81.:~,?§{3s€s"3aéiizfizz zfafi :::E.§.im§.::;;i wag €23: 3:3

v ':'~i"§,§::";a:*;__ Q}: §§§g.–…m§ia§?$§$§fi %s$&%._::*§2'zg mgigzfiaéiagz gag

Er£i.é~4:?*?';5§§}~.§§%e§T[:V:3;&a:= 'xfagié ?:§s::;€: 5%}? 9:23. Eéaiiadé §~%f§&§§ 8.

:9§:§[;é=:;%:§:%A L §.;'}$&§*i§§§ gfigésérgiigiz gs % §':.§s.,°"§%'" :@.§«g~§§§

z::%;m§' fgiém §§;§§:§§€;e3 £§iE'§£?E§$3T§; 32,3; a ragfi &"'§§ gfigfigggai

A' -.Az:";a&zi.ié;:"_%.$:' 33$ Efifiéigzi sagaigigé. big fi"£{f?§{}E"§:§é"$§fi' $3 5.

..-:"%3§u§":3 E23 ffifi giazm: afié gzzgiegizzfiii §:1_§?é..1:*;fi;g5. E-ifiztzaag ha

fiifi-.:§¢ 3. itiagim §§ii'€3:.z;'§;',?, Efffiffiffi ihzz §%@$'E', Qavafzagfira
$5,.

fix?’

fifiéiiifig a’:’%§§Z§%fi;§1%.§§§:§{§§§ gf ?§9fi§§:§,:3§i§f«,”§j T225 ‘i”§*§§’3z2:’3.aE
awaféfifi Eiiifiiz 3; {:§.f:§T§ aim

fififiiififiiéiu Eitzafi gazgggézzfisfi %::§°:$ §£§E=m%*’i::.g 2i:;§u:éis;%§:«
95/

3} Egacazzfiififé ‘fismzzzrgé avg? maéiaé $1’ Eafi
fmi mfiaguréag 3&3 $122 531$ mafia:

Ezgiéaaifiazg Exififi Qmfi
?a;§m fififi ififéflfiffifififi gsérfiaem fii-»s”s’:.%.:s::”«..:;*3′.g§f1%:.
farfiarzzzg, Egafiay m*=:.=;§§.§g§ pffigfigrii V ”

.§}?_,”

«:3 iacemiaéfi fiifzzziii-gé §,”3§”fi$fi§’3§§; £§*;-‘:3z’ ‘ “§%f:}:”:fE;2::§5
mgims maagzzigg £5 am 3% Engiggfig… ‘ Q _ ._
5%: iagfifaisré Emmizfi §Es3g§se2.;§,:”§::ég v:s::z;;.§’;E*}?

ma avazkefi %$;§’§§;$é§:;_ _ .. ..

5:: fifgséséizg fmgfg Easih §’; égééimfifii hag staififii 222$: i:.%:e3zf§ §§ §§$&.§3§§§,%§§ 3:’ Si}% :3

‘§:?”§§ Eighfi. mpgay iéimérs.

3 fiafiaigifififzzg ‘$23 §.’E.%E’;”%.§§’§ Q? 12:*:_;?’e;.:r§a$§
§$;§.$;£}€}€}§~ §.”%-?:z’§.1€’§,fiéZ§i. bk? ihfi ‘§’:°§,%s:§:°:§i §m%’§;r§$ ‘$32312

fig.

3

afié; §’:,’z§T’§7’m~;§:g? fag $2: f:.§:& §L@%%§’fi:” §§§£Z§€: ami ii :13 iififififefffifig 3%

$2 §§:§;’:§.m::-£3: %}j;’ &f:§i§”;%:’:*:” ;’*§$?:§-fififiiéfl

uzgfifir mils; Egaafia

é’

§02%$’§,:’§§i?$’:;§..%s§g* =:;”‘:=::_”

§$’§5§*’%.§’:i3£ *§::£:§:1e3§E aggrsgzégasf K’

‘%s§f:.E@ §:f%;s::i%3a:;$:?2 :2}: §3;§¥,..E§i%;;,5%’ fig éhfi was
fizafaé 22$ fiasfigzza {$5«.§§§;%m;%;€:§:2é§:;§.j§::;”§§:* $32329 Eagafi,
513$ “§’§:$AV§,°§&_§m §.:1€§_E£a?$.:§ %i:.f’$:%é;’%:a&£.*;’:%;”$:;%;”‘i2%:§§.*%:i$:::*§. fcsz’ £9;

“§§fiE”i{3§;’§ :13?” §’§é*:§a§~.4 ‘%.::_ E-Eiaéggéiajé, §§;%’&.Zf1E;g§§’#3§
Qxangéfifiziiézg V :;”;%’é;.:::.;%:%$;’§;%z:;’2§:*;;”§f’ §:&a§;§::2§::’g§ ii fig jug: 331$

-E §Q%¥§3″§§

§:*&;;;g}75;’;;:* as :3z¢*%»§$;’s*%;§ ég gégm if §.§g§§

,’ *§::£::§j$;§:é?;;§ A’ ‘ ~ fixgzazzfiaal’ $2.:i€:3r: 3% saggwymige,

z§§s3:%;::’§.s’;%2§:?:j§;2?:,::%;”‘V$::§e aiiaszfiazzé §%1&3§e’:$ 333% ii fig

awégéégéz ” 4′

“‘§.’E:& iééaéggfiaizi Eff; $sa:;§§::a.:::*: af hiég fifiiiififiiififié

” ” -»-*:;;’;¥:$§. 23.: wag féiiiiéifig 3. ‘?§};@ E’as:’;%:m”§’ azéfi $ g 3.

33:1: $35 §$,5§§§§%§§m gfifiéi’ ‘aw; §§.f§::’§};§$$€§

iiifififiifl 3&3: Efigéiffifig 3:22: ‘§.Z§T”isE: %?2.§Z€”:§ 3% 239:, fifiifiifiifiiifié

3’-s

fig; grséagigg azzgz afigazr zigcazizzsézzig, E32 ‘EEESE afigaiéafi sf

gfiérifisatsfgéf §:”:§;:r.,:§m§:T§ it fig gfzgfié. anfi ;m*@§.;%:* 3% &¥$:*a.:*z§ ‘5ae;,§s1§m

pfiriaargé’ ggzé 3?’: $5 §;:w§§%i;£§a”§,

w :::«2s£§:*::§;g ‘Eéryafi Q? émagma §::;:i%Z:?s§;i_» :i;g::

3 EM, ;$”*%§§’1§_§ :E::;$ ::§§::::’:§? ‘:2-*§%;€: é:§_%1a:géZ?’§§’:£.,

mg aafizafi iizafii zézma 31$ §::$$:%§t:§ %»-éia gigm sag”

§;i§;”%§fi’E’f 332$. %&§§’:i§a:’:§2 g{::”::’&i$%.I’j:f;:§””i§§§?;s§ fit? flifi whgéa
hmiggz “i%.”§25 siisahiiéig £$j.:§;:%s;€:§’ _ §:.:;,Qz ham 3:}?
§:::§§::<:*§ €32: $§::?;";:%:'7;g; "1§?.'E"2m"f<:::§':+:::*a-ag %§Ti.E.fiE%§Q§§ af

a2¥§§fi§:é.:::ag §:a3:::gf":§:9é'::;,%§,;&%§¢%;§T:T;::"é;:,?;§£ ?;$:* zha Esaaé 'E5333 af fazmrg

ifim:.:::'£~"5- :§:w:=a:vv§;§$%:._ §"§$'§§!§?§§TE{E:fi%$f ficezzgiségrixag €21:

a%i;¥~'%%;Z$§g§.:%3;;§i V._$'£§::é§;"*~~':.:;%§ tie étiasiw §;§E§ sag: aififififii Qé'

:.2§":§f§§;§2§§§;e§§; me aréaéifiant has ta

§:a:;+"§:§ _. Ia fiifzfffi as?"

:;:§_._ 5 Ezig fiztmrfi $3? 2?: fig §’::$’:: agzéi; §ffi§€f ta

iarasiaycifi firms fif

‘ –§:€’:%%i:’.§§ éfiiééi $3 $3 a”%s*§:*::i§:”§,

32$ ‘§”§m;g§ *::%:s fiifiifiifiiii is fizizizéfzifiifi; ff}? E3523

fm§maré.,§:.g é::::3§:§.*&af:§§».;%,’§@§::&

‘V ‘ _’§”:?;é%Ef:.§.}fi;E7§f$=&§i:$§’}§:}§§. $5

$1: Faéfi 332$ gigfiaziflgg ~» Raaififiéfi
33} Eefiaéicaé $X§§§Z§$’$ ~ figgéfigéjéfiié
$2 §§3::u:~§§s§;§:f::§a§ fixggmag ~ ;}Q%;i§¢;}£3a’Z1Té'”*,
rzifg 33$ ifiaama ::§:;:§’i§”:g

éaizé. azg gfirigé » E§$3%~«§%f;%:5.§
g} Lmg 3? fiflifiizéiififi –» S

E32 §&*;’i?Q§’§§.§§§.g§.f§§ §E§2’Z’é”r.%_§;*;1§§5.,§ i::.5a.-§V3a::;%;§é€;?1.» if: gafi, ‘V

‘§’E*:& jiiiigififizéi mzfi §_§é%§§.§’€§;*§”%§’ %:fl:?:é?V””§’:*£h:.:::&.£ 33.3
Efiififiififié is 232% =1E:.1’€§&:’IiE”.: $§f”£;§’:E%i£§_-*«._EE;;”i§;3i’£§;£5.?; gbaw, €22:

-:;’.:=§m5:z”§a.:-‘:?’7£». ffiy ‘:&;~w?:s;fi%;§£ §$?:}%§%3€1$$.§$§E 3%”

gh » a%£%2’%f{§fi€§ T5}: ififi

“”;§’ri%::§:”:a§ %:z;<.§£%: V§V.:§%2$:*}f:§_:1%:~~"V"=%:; §z%% §:%.§,. $3: 2?}: fizééaanafifi

§~ fiméa %:%;.., dais: fif szigém

a

._§Lé'+:€;§§i§::2:%; ».:':§é'14V"%;4;v;.,"2__§;j..:.*,E§.§§: $5 E'é:'$§§§:«%§.%,§§$?i"§5

35%., "';i"'E";§ §:':$;:..z:*&':::5; fiazézgsazzgr fig €§§.i%"fi§€J$fi ii:

» *%:f§§§::*%.;$§'?.'%?;: E315 $E§§§«§,§"E%f~fi$§., C%E§3;§¥§E"§7&%f£L§:%§'é a;::::.':a:.:§?.§. iagfiéfisr

"':€'€T§%§} Eziziarfisi; *§§'§%;E:§;:2 iaxgss §:@§2?;i"2$ 532323 ma égfitg gf

ffififiigfii <3? Q -»r..:::%§:§f iéf iééig éliégifififii.

$5

§

£331? 2::,z§" ifg, iE':E"§.§":§§'izfifi{§ a:a::2m§5z':§e§i:%.{§::.; $i§__% af

321$ afizsségzaz wéiéz §3:*<:a§::@:'%:§&::g:"_e& §§'§.'i§§%2'§ is g::¥;.§:j:=e}fé 2:':

3,33 éiivggtafi 3:: fixfifi iiégmfiéi 252: fizfi :§§;:§:;.$ :.*:§;&:§izi:§§,i§;%i V'

fififgi' iéfiwiififlfiiéfififi gamg Scfzfiafiéééaéé'

fm' 3. §fiE'§Q={§ zfxf afi 3%a;f§,: _ §&:§:§:;§%.*:%.3'3§ gQ:.;';:%.';f;:::: "';;§%§%:"=

§3§€}§¥Z*E»-Eiéfigifi §,z3I.$:*%€ 33 §:*£§§§'.;%;§ 'é*$§.%:;&3fifi £2:
faavmzg' 2:}? '£23; sigma}: "'j:§'%,z*z,v§§aa+e:;3;:?<,;1a;"§t,z:'3Z¥:§'g..%§.;;'!i;:$:* zlézfi ziggagiig

Fifi; 3% ififgitfié' V%€2j*é:::*.:%§.*%°:§, "

Self-

Edge