IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BANGALGRE: '
DATED "mas THE 2"" DAY 01? MARCH M '. :1 T 5 A.
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR.JUSHC'E :L%%g .,. :'%
WRIr1>E27r1oNNo.5:9_gx2oos
BETWEEN: PM
Aflamw
Sfojierappa, V V _
Co-Operative 'Q ' ._ V
-- PETITIONER
flli,
Mysore I;)istIict. % V _
( By ws Advs.)
" » df--P.A.C.C. Banks in
Myséfi; .Cl1amarajanam' Dimict,
' A "Rep1Imet_§efl by Member Secretary,
"'««..Cz'o.__;M.l,3--;" D.C.C.Ba.nk Ltd, Nehru Circle,
Road, Mysore.
V ffimnoaa Ca&'e Committee for
Mung of P.A.C.C. Banks 2:1
Mysore and Chamarajanagar Distriats,
Cio.M.C. D.C.C.Bamc Ltd, Nehru Cficie,
Ashoka Road, Mysore.
3. The Prhnary Agiculmre Credit
S lL T' _
Rcprwemed by its Presidanl. A'
S E I-I1maa;ma.._
Mysore Diwicc. " " V
4. 'I'heStateofKamatak;L,
by fut
M.S.Building9 L ' i % %
Ba.I1galore----56000l._,_._
(By sri.G.B.Mamama.:;f' ' re: 'ii--1:tn:i{.73"
Sri Shash&<fi1aS'gf~.S§"' ~ H(_3GP=§xiR4)
ms Wrii' Articles 226 & 227 ofthe
Constittxtionof the letter (med 31.3.2008
imled by R1 3311:! R2,
on for Final Hearing this day, the
"VCieu;xfirma¢ie§'t¥t§'f{;Iiowi1:g:
was. workmg' as a Manager of the Pmmy'
% ' Credit Co-operative Bank Ltd, (for short, 'the Baum
Iimmun:_ ' Tahnk, Mymre mama' ' - The Bank is Wu unda the
VT of fine Kamamka Co-operative Societia Act, i959 (fur
% 'A shott'1heAcl'). nmhmmeofmepaiximamzmsdmofbirm
E 15.1.1953. A1 the time ofthejoiningtm Bank, he and finuim
3:
33%
-..
2. Respondent Noel and 2 have filed
objections. It is comnded that
ma filed writ petitions before %cougteg;geew.p.r§o.4.5?z9/2364
seekmg’ a direction” to respondent 2 f’é)i<Vthe1r'
salary. In the said writ an order on
28.6.2006 to pay
salary to the éageagm to the Registrar of
mat all the Societies
make 1 fimds created under the
Cmmnon mandatory on their part to make
oaf'"fl:e–.–.c0mxflmtion to the Cadre Fund of the
The petitioner has flied a contempt
Noe: And 2 in ccc No.23f2007
of the order in w.P.No.45719r2oo4 dated
' and that the said matter is peming before this Court
Neal and 2 have denied am pet1t!0ner' * has furn§hed'
original S.S.L.C marks cand, cmmuazive record and cilia'
cextifieatesaitbetirneofjoiningtheserviee. Itisfmthercomended
Q».
4. On the other hand, aoomoa Ativocate T
respomiem Nos.I and 2 submiw {mt
respondent Nos.I wt! 2 in
Registrar of Co-operative the
Bank has produced the The
petitioner being tho the said
documents the age
proof, College, Pmdavapura,
peat!’ finer is has pro¢1ced 3 copy ofthe S.S.L.C.
«sf binh of the petitioner is shown m
ko;3.1§s”0. It that in the writ petitinn flied by the
% M petiti6~n.¢i’in x%v.§;o;o;o45719r2o94, this Cotnt has clearly held tho: the
is by the Cotmmu Cadre Conmlittee Rcgzlatiom
‘ Registrar’ of Cooperative Societies. Tixis Court has
the Ccamn Cadre Cmaw e for paymm of saLan$’ due
the Therefore, the petitioner is not guocifioa in
K
con1endmg’ that time is no relatsfi ‘ of mwm’
between hitnselfandrewondet11Nos.1 andV2;”‘ A
5. I have canefinlly
teamed Coumel at the BarVa:§Vd on
5. m .< is am there is
no rexaamsiaip between himself and
salary by them. Unda
the % respondmt No.2 to the third
t-Q petitioner as its Secretary with effea
fi7zxt3.&<!'§.3;f2()08:_'is:ViL1A§'ga1 and unenfarceabie. There is no meat' in this
othershad
~..__ ti!egi 9. in W.P.No.45719/'Z064 for 3 direction to am
_ V tepaythea1thesa.lm'y.Infl1esaédme,
j has recorded a findingthat the thkd wndent Bank is
by the pmvisiom ofthe Common Caée Conrmitta
Regulations framed by the Regim ofCoopermve in
Ks.
X
30
appoixment ofthe pditienertothepoainquefiion.
has not produced any material to show mat the H
indicated in m said pmposal has been accepted.
his daze ofbirth ceztifiwse issued hy_the fem ~',:;.~,,-3;' akso not in dispute that the a V d1spute' as per third respondem amongstptmrs the age proof,
the qna]ificanon’ V % L orme Banks and
for a Service Regiaa’ of
prociwj his under his own sigmure with are
‘R1’and’R2′.Theagepmofissuedb°y
College, Pandavapura, Mandy: D1s£n’ ‘ct is at
These mm would clearly mdimte am the
ofulfi:-ԤVh ofthe pefifimaer is 6.3.1950. A1 thetime ofargusneats.
V A Coumel for rwpondm Neal and 2 has produced S.S.I…C.
V’ méxaswdofnxepetuima-ominedfiommexamaakaseomuary
K6-
Age} amended by Kamataka Agt No.22/1982 states ‘*
any mm equivalent theme, the date ofbirth and age
”
itlthepresmcasesirxeethecomaryisnot mmisnea A:
H
w@ ‘ Examination Board, which also indicates
birth 9f petmmes as 6.3.1950. Since & V’
petitioner nag. disputed the con-emy
cfitected the i:oaned HCGP to .-eievm; the
HCGP has produced _by the Board
pertammg’ ‘ to the Board
(Public 1968. Leamed
Coumel regfiexs nmI1E8tlwd’ ‘ by
the §aid towers at an undfi
point of_t’i1neu’1mk.e date ofbfiih ofthe petitioner is
M . V_ who has pwsed the SSLC emmmaI1’ ’01: or
thefageadofthesavice,ihepeti1imer!1asoomeforwardwifi1fl1e
5
Wk:
_,
I2
preseza writ petition for a declaration tha his xof
15.1.1953. The Hotfble Supneme Cour: V’
petition filed by the Government x Af%
service claunm’ ‘ g a younge: aw “ass: ‘efé?I&nd1ng__ ‘ V
services should he
STANDARB c0MP41W1;m, VS.
- AIR 1995 sc 1499) that petitioner was born second rmondent was infomimg
hirnthatthepetiticmeriiag ;ug5.32oe2 mdhse
cannot be id’ tooomfi séiz:
3. petitionand it isacconfngly
No m.
§E§§§