High Court Karnataka High Court

Akthar Ismail Mukthesha S/O … vs Manjunath N Naik S/O Nagappa Naik on 3 December, 2008

Karnataka High Court
Akthar Ismail Mukthesha S/O … vs Manjunath N Naik S/O Nagappa Naik on 3 December, 2008
Author: Huluvadi G.Ramesh


1?-E ‘rm: EHGH C()UR’1″ or 1s;zaL1{~w;£x’w;;<;¢§§;;»s;%:*
BAE"€GAL(}R§€ %

BATES THIS Tm: o3R'*nAY 012* DE'iif§ 3~;Im::§ mg

3,réf*'j<3%t1I«:A . %

THE I:i();\"BLIé1 MR, .§gs'1'1C§: %:~1.{;LL?mD%i.G.%£g\§§x%::11§s%H

msck: LL_A:"£ 2:0i;s§:{%Rs1" 39.7621; 01:'
,_:;_@ arm

Bi§'i'V§='§:ZEE\%:

Akthar I§::”:i’:~1i_} “E’1I:2§{:the;:E1.é=;; =
Sfe: Isgzzaifi M?ikthesha_, ._
Ageé *
Farm’ rgéagig Eié;mdap_u;’a¢
R:undapi1z?i%;Vy§7a3’uVk, ‘ « » . . _’

U;3;sp;_T2.:u1; mg £§;’v.§i§Ti”$1’§:i:._. …APPELLANT

{By $fi;.M’ahf:VSE1ki:f.%;1fi~~~éhc£t§;; Srifieoji Santhenshkumar Shetty

” and Sri,H.M.ANagaraj, Adm.)

E\;£vgg§fi§ifith.N.Naik.

V_ >3,-‘:3 Eviagappa Naik,
,. ” Major? Residiizg at Hirmm;

‘=—Meiimnannige Post,
Hesnfiavara.

2. The United indéa Insurance: Ca 13:6,,

Branch Ofiice N-0.6851 ,
Urbaiz Bank Btiflééng, Main Road,

Bhatkal
Rcprfizsanted by its Branch Manager” …RESP(}:’€DE:’€TS

Vijajgashree Hespitah Kundapur. Tha ciaim pciétion was flied
claiming compensation of Rs.3?5G,0(}{);’—_ The. Inguraace
€:0mpanj.r contested {ha matter as the anmez’ re;t3;a*éfi}3dT’:i}:;3arte.

Based cm the pmadizzgs f(>}.£§’ issues were ra.i::j€{i by T’£}: é”+”fr§1:3’i3r:aE

far consideration. Afier sraquérfg-*;”‘in:§.r.i%ngg th_.at’ih’e accidei:i was A’

due to the negiigence an tige “‘c§.z_£.: A

hearing N0.KA 3Q } 915i};/.:i.f:tq.”‘§1as ‘fa3t@_fi3d m;1 fi3e
Insurance campan};j”¥S? Rs.56,500x’~–.

Being 1ji(i{W $3;EiSi§¢d §}§ith_”th§’ sa12’1 €i”{‘z3a czfiaémant is beébre this

Cauxt

’53; the subxziissicm cf the ieamed Ccsun:2€§ {hr the

K ~.:appe§}a¥§Vi’ that the ciaimamz mat baen suitahh: awarded and

‘ Aéfl§;§3′{fiA.1gh there is a. disability it; the axizexri :21? If3% tea the iémb he

.4 has nut been awarded an}: amnnnt cm that head. A€C{}i'{fiI]g}j,v’,

sought tbr enhamtemcmz.

3%?’/’

cnnmensaticsn within thifie {}3t:; ii3.f;c. Q5 ICE:-€i]_’i (‘if

fine cap}; ofthis nrder.

8. Ac¢é:d§n§;E’j;*§ Vappéaé ‘ §s 3;§§{_3weci in part.

-.1,’
$3.

‘L: V

inmnzc. He is 3130 awarded a gum of anather-“*.Rs.5._€}@Qi’~

towards dict, conveyarme and attezndant chazrggs :~D’i1’3jr’ an

amount af R3.i3{}0f- and Rs’..2[}€}.f– is a\x!:grd%é’c§.L§:i_.:t§§§:$.a’

Or: the head of loss (1? az:i§n§tj.c?4siA j.hu€: bcgggg ‘é;:w’éi.rded_.

Rs.i2,008,«=”- and another Rs…_3:,O{}'{}}’¥:Biéscsgzié.méuiifihat
hsad. Thus, {he ciafimant f1)2f’a~.V;ic:f£:;&§ c€én2pe:1sat§(3z1 :31″
Rs.26,00Gz’~ (‘aver been awarded by
the “frfibzggwaéj ‘Nth egg, % date ef petitém’; an
dcpesigx the enhanced amnunt szzef

Sd/-E
Iudqé