High Court Karnataka High Court

Almel Educational Association vs District Registrar And Deputy … on 23 February, 2010

Karnataka High Court
Almel Educational Association vs District Registrar And Deputy … on 23 February, 2010
Author: Manjula Chellur Gowda


:$’:’t:m”:i:N<}"%V ;_;–U:3-.:;_:\,§§s:§~I*:* "EH18 E"}A"€}
.¢:3§4{3LLr.r.m5_ J.j; 1'.fé'E§i,§;'%JE~:§%E?;§§ "rm: m:_§:.,<*}'*~g-*ixI'::*x.*sC::

.ASSOC1A'I'ION, ALM £31.,-, TAI,-UK SINDAGZ
[)ESTRIC"i": IEBEJAPUR

3, RAMANAGOUI).A

S/O RUDRAPPA MAPEAJAN
AG 1531) AIBOLET 53$ Y1e:Ar~2s _
occ: AGRICLELTUREZ AND ALSG V}iE:"ZM
G-OVERNENG COUNCIL 01? .AI;1\«'I'E£:I,. ( is
EDEECATIONAL Ass0<::AT10N'; . A1;.1vI1~:1,.

SINDAG1DIS’E’R.£C’I”: E31Jz?x£?_UiR ‘

ii. AP’f’ASAH 133

8/0 BABANM s~:;a,:,.LUR _ ”

A6131) AIBOUT 75 y:~:AR:s ._ ,
occ: SECRETARY’ ‘SF z\mf::«: E:’i)U.c;sa:T10NA1,

SOCIETY” R/O V’£«:1aRA£3:e1;’>;:)RE:::»1»:i\«s,:27§;.R..9;-iewza
.E1XLMELs’FAL{}_K: s£N’:w’;£ ‘

D1sTRI«::’r;’~;31JAri:3I2: V’ RESPONEBEENFS

(13? s.;€:1».§§is?’;– D::%:’$’:=:1’i%>g5>,:§a1>’E:; ECG? FGR R 2,
gig; _mg:’1«:’2::f__:§;UIsx;:gva:% ::::a_,s_ :–§:?;.§«»§Arx1:>1::q FOR R24)

ms w§§I”;%” ES FILED U/S 4 OF’ ‘i”‘E–IE
E:{ARI’«s'”A'”§’1i&KA~ HiC:.z»i” .CQij’R”1″‘ ACT’ 1″»w~.y’1rvG T0 33:’? ASIDE:
mg. _ORI)£§’§% §3ASf:§_E1.L’-._ 1rm’m~=: WRYI’ E3E’.i.’E’E.’§ON 8.3858/2099

1″3;§:1:_;fE:J:;«?.: 2 /’ :2;.2 Q’09

CQMXNC; ON FOR
MRS. MéNJiTL&

*2f’iv}::s§ “»_CRI?.\z’EENA£, 5-‘sPPE:”;;?’s.i,

J Di} M E N T

.£§

Heard ‘£”.h€ iearned ::rm.:r:s«s3£ 2’3.ppe3e::i.1j:;g _”;.r.>i’ i:E’:€-: ”

zippeils-fi3.i’, Si} also Azmieti E'{um2::::” {}<:%§I1de1it.
Bisiricti. Registrar €m’«_;1. ‘*~1.’)e}:iJ:}1;yV Réigifiéarzlr of Co-0p6:1’atiV€

Soe:i<~:t:i.=:«3;s;.

2. IVT}’11.é%”V;»pr€’§§CIfi T i:§p::§€é_E filed ithalieraging the

Qydeéri sf ifiéé’,–.$¢:.§1’fI1e::?.V:V”iiéiflgiég Jtxdge aimed 11.12.2989.
Thfi 1?V:=§f: §7″€f,i”€;.i.{V}}’;3 ‘ .t;0 bfi fileéi q’L1ning the

<»3t1»;};::ir32f :'etp»:"nft'Z'V which was <i§_z Meeéiing z»:fi;:»3r gggivizigg nzyéicazt

i:<:{"21Eé–..V1;:"iE~;%' ms;:’z*s in 2;.<:<:r°da1:’:c:s=> wim Ezzwx 5§.’h<3
.. . X:

*A:§:;,+:.,£éss’i.1?V:3r;’1 ‘::h2:t 21i’&}£% far fhs Eearzlézii J2.2£§g__:;£:%’s {:0:1:+;ide’:”:_–1ti§2
A’-wéag-3° wiézfg §;;>;21.rc§ ti”; Sr.-=:c:¥’;:i{m 25 {}f the Kar:321i,e?:§a:21 ;’5%0§”: Ask E §«3§€} ax:§1§{,*.Ez r:;?2?:{§s+s 21:3 é’iE’i{§€§°Z

,,_\\wfl

place at. t.h~:*. §:e22dqL;art.<:%:*s; of tihét s3.t.y ur
21:3}? bif.”E:’1I1¢:T’h t1h€:’m()f; V

{b} he may :–3ur::m1c’m any p€&1*s3<m _v;¢'h':;§; _
reas<:s11 {:0 b€:1_i<?\:c:, has i»<:z1<}f.§\;-'§¢:#ic:'=.§,_:;;§.,€*' $2.7 (;s:i"_'
'the? e1f'fé1ir$ 0f t';11e3:':'§iiC'ictV_ $1.9 2.;.;:;:tp§é.g:.z"fi i3–é.%i'::{h§:

him at any p}21ct-:5-fcit hee1dqi1:–1rt:§§r§ *€¥f

th-:3: scagit-':'t.y §"}-E"x:2§¥§;i1'€'-~fQI'E1i'¥CEiv..ih€;f€Of and

may €V}<Z'}:':=I':'{"1i_1A"££;:_ Lsz.:§:1hi on Qath;
{C} [1] he _V1":1V ayV, anyf.hi;I1g
'é:'tQi?s'iai;:1_edg in any rule or
the péézind of noticf:

…. _. fa .._jgs:fiAeiTa%l:;_:{I?§eef:iI1g 0f {the socieiy,
1 AV ‘TvL’..’v:f§:g1§i;i2f§r.,_i1::§:__ ;_;Q’ve§°r1i:1g bcaciy an’ E13163 :~§aC:i€:ty

‘tg>”(:f§?E._E ‘e:~..g,ij'<-:«:~;e.re1.£ me-3s€t:i.r3g at such i;imr:= and

' jgvlgi-:::é'*–§it"t.Eie h<5.z1dquart€:r:a 0f the society or

V "g'::3y__§:i.an<:§1 thtareof and £10 (iet,:–:z"§ni:":@ such

m21£,§'.e:"s as may be dir's:{:i:€d by him, If thé:

v”T’-_ ;:::§<}ve;':1ing brody Q37 tihozzz S{}Ci{3E.y F{3filS{fS GI"

{ems {<3 {:aE§. 2: meestinaf. ha shzfli have
p{:eWe':" {.9 C211} it himseifz

{ii} any ms:e%.f£:3;_; <?a}Ee{i EH"£€i€§." $ub-{:'iause {E}

;<;=;f:12:E': izezzrs aié °s::.E':€: gzsziwésrss sf a ggisxmraé

me:€sE;§::g; gtgflizigi m'1{i€::' *é:§*1e IE'1.§;§€E'.§ gr r{;":g1i%at§«:}:1$

28.€E_2GG9, It is 21153:} br(>’L.:ght E13 cm: n.t:ice: d11rj,.:1_;; the

cijzzrse cjf axguzneili. thai; t.has:é Ch21i:’mar:5 i’,fIj;1eé- _}i:’rfé:s;€3:<1'£;

appeliarzt. and the 3"? I"€?E§p()I1d€f?f}'{.' are?._ e'i.t€§(:i.逥 * V'

ggxrerraizgg COLE}f1S€31 mernbers.

4. The co:3ir0versiaEi?:e:s_’ue: if1._fi*1–:% pré§$*§i%::1i{‘zipp:i:3;1~i$*

“Wh€t’her the Reg;i:3i’:’a;:* C0u1€i”V3fVi{é:<.?:: ta}:er§ATa5e:ti<§;'3 €10 hoid

an enquiry or: the 2113p1?i;':z1t2:';:3'x1g;af onlyizhree members" ?.

55 if "F in number,
éefir:.it.r1 25 9f iihss Act is
{:QH::;}’ii?(it}i’ i: {he power af h€)}dimg
enq1~;,i%3z :’::-ggz Easy; his ow;/; g/;1{3§*,F:{“,*1~”;_g ::’:r’:i”i:”g:’:.;:;3F[~.

§§_ji”§_¢»€V:;u§’1iI}’§4″‘§E”1V.%’a:f3Tif§i§VE”ii.;;_i,Ef?ii§$§i{1’tii€)Ii E9 anquire mm a .rna%;*{.er

1§%§§{%I1€.i’x?{%’§”»~. f{,§’§€f%’°€’. i’E3′”‘éiv {‘I{3;E}’1pL’:’1iE3E. ‘§’§*2=3: 211:2iha§i’€y {£3 hoid

‘V{:;:i:€;§§;:§v:?§;–‘.V_Aza;ff’ ~i_%i_}c i::s¥:.2mc§: gf ihéi méjrzzbers-3 02″‘ g§{}vii’r:§_ii1g

{:e:j;:;’;.s:=;§. Qi {he S€3{Ti€f.}}’ is; 8. mandaiks. H€mrav€2*, there
» msfiafi v:T;;_:é§: be :=;=2.:;:{::E2 :”€q:;:§r:rm.§:1g,{

‘i:é>%,3A=§’:,€.;§§ 9:” ‘§Z.§’Tz€;’? .’1?fi_€’§T{‘i§}€f°7:’E%5 9? éézzé S{‘}{‘,§i§f.}’ iii’: hiséé 2:252;

,. — *:)””‘”””«~,

9

Ncma we Came in the mars:’1.’_c5r’u£::§§;§

c:or1tmversia.1 quesi:.icm_ xx-*ha,t,_”is Ifiiféliiif-1_gVV

and impcwt 0f the e:{pr<:35;.§{)r::_"*:s.;é hiss r.}$¥:1"'§*{3:f§f;§é«::I1'

and what is its i:1t'err4cIa1:.i{ti:; it) €119: –ém'med§.a%,V.~s3.é3cf;’i:>r1:V There V

cauié. bfig :10 d+::yuE:>t.,V.t:11::1ir€:f:s: expfevssiotl ‘or: his
own motion’ is”-Syntinyiixgoijéafté”suovmotu, which

acc0’rdir1§;§. 3:0 t.h;3-,..di(:i:i0na:;fy”iné3;f:s’;’ “or: 0363 own

inii.iat§i;€””?;~ ‘Owni ‘~”mt3i’i.C>:i’VV.._,,V€§bi2*ious1y impliaes

e1ppi1iC2;,?1’ioff1″ ;<2f b :":a::1€i"– .a;1:d'v.:»f0.1'mati0n of onefss own

,€;pin,i?é5r1§ .v;dOe.;~sV.__r§o't'~-maI:;i:er how and from what.

s0:_::"::*(;:VE7*;€:'=-giéts"i:::;%%%.r:f}:;i3§€.i03z3., But, it dees not mean

%; }12;t'[ f.h€:=._ ;;a»7;;;#,f1E:'@;9:ii::;'. conferred with such pejwer

$-h0z, :'iri§:_ z.?:s5{§.§qt7:'a;;,r fihm {iansideratian inforinatian or

3:f:e;c{;*3ria§ v'ftm::.isahed by axfigrnal SQUFCEES and sahauid

..vi0::I%«s;;,:ifi<;:s _§;ht'f infarmatien ::911e<:"{.€£i by his; own 361?»

"L;3f'fa;:g1f1i. "7£'?1e exercise of gmxvers SU;(}~° mgtu GE' on

Azamvszm E£'1{}§li(Z:E"i, camlm: afid €}%,§§.'_?;h§. net. {Q be

" V:":A{:31s§€;:*ued in 21 ua:';'<::w s<:~::":§s<;% and in 22 8€RS€3 which

defeaiis {ha sezizzéiary purpsve= Of {E126 p§”c3v:i:~::i_0E:k N0

E%.=:f,§’,§3rs; can Ext piaced an the 3p<:*.{:£15%€3{E 3.'z:%E4§":{}§'ii:y

' §"},E31'Y1T'i(T}iI1ii)i1Sl\,f zalci ta ef1'"<:cma?;9 ~::h-.6 obj@<:{.iw: if we

RAMAcfiANDRA;§fi§fiufAnKEaagmxfififikgfifi

CHAVARE. "

14. Thc3.r(:* is 21 faiiaciy ::m3::::y%::1g:;he ,;1§g”u:fr2_.é:;1:_

advz111{:e3ci by the’ 1e–f«}I”11ed’v. C<}Lu'isew%:,,v*~fner. Neiéherr (If.-“ii: T iiit€ Ip1*ete1ti0n
mar any (f:a;1:’:.{m. “é%f’Oi11(iVV{f{)iV§I1i1€X1aY.IC€
the argume:r1t. £3;f_ ‘i.?{“Tl\’.-3 q011nse1. The
a1’g11n1&:~.n_E4′ Qf’ :.i”1é” igneres {he

(§FL1{Ti$Vtf_Vf&1(§i” %

‘ §_’i’13{.’ .s{1.c§;n}(§?,:;x §§£3§#§€§r conferrc-rci by the
.firssiT {tan r;:9m(:: £11110 play
‘of pofi?_é’r”:§bnfided 1:0 ihe Registrar
in *f.’§?’i!i)V vss§§§’s:>.§:Vi:’7i;4j”=.ss%it;a§afi0n:s;. The éiifmze reievant,

c1.21:.:Ls3-s:~s ijxf Secffispiz 25(1) have to be read

pt}-“–‘€}\’§~.S,iOi1¢ “§”E’i”<521n1bit, and p1e'm7i:ud<3 of the pewer

v.e:S1:<3'd §1'3' the Regisirar to act 01:: .his3 cm-*1:1 maéien

é'2,*m'Ij:Q£iIg§5'é <:urt.2:i§<::d and itrippietgi by 22.32}; 'a ap2"ie:}ri'

n,.;}iZ:io:«–':5' ihai: ii' ss/é.2m:§$ esxatizzzierci whéstre {he mi%n1%}ars

'éZ:3$.}:–s them iiheié :"~:3e%.r<tm'1!i:21g;e b€'(3{§}f1'i€'

V.<:mp§21.i:’:a11t5s. “fh<~§:re% is; 213.0 f.z1b<:}<§ aggfzzizlaii a

gncnabezr er r;*;@:i.2b&?:*'s_"~;~ Ea-';=;s$ i:h.:;s_:': E ;';i*§"-§ 22.pp§'a<éE1ing§;

§:§.'::'-% E%<=.;;,3;§£~sf:::'z2:" a%:§"zh 2: p€i:.§§é<;::';; 22:31:? §:§.':s:: §§<:g£:%'{::';§.1"

Re;1cii.n_g 0f é3.bt'3V€ paras wcmid r1:1a.}:~:.e it £3163; :,;;_1':£iV;<?é':*%:i¥I*;-21$

all cin:?um$t:an<:£2s; }1?.egis5tii:'ar (12113 Eiéti. .i'i'l£_?1Y;"3_-€i:iIZh§§"w.€)5'Ii°i' the

appiication Gf iegs {harm E ,1' Bifiiof "fi:*.':: the

society. In the presczm. case, (:12?-Eh.€ r€:}".;0:fE', '0f';thre}:-.

members if the .R€gist:rar "by£ Vapp1ic%ai.i6n-7n€€)i1sfi

6. We find no gcoci gi*{§u.:n*C1, .i;0.I1_’it3fEerf€:”:: with the

ordarg cf

AV1%..:”:€0;{‘C€i:1g;;if;i.;.V _’z§A:*:-3: 2i.pp*fElf:§..§ “§§Si’}ffi:S8€§.,