Ashok Narayana Rao Deshpande vs Sri. A.N.Patil on 11 December, 2009

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA CIRCUIT BENCH AT DHARWAD

Between:

DATED THIS THE 11"" DAY OF DECEMBER 2009 

BEFORE

THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE K. SREEDHAR...1§A.Q'   % B B

AND

THE HON'BLE MR. JusT1V(:EflRAV1*--MAL1M.A1Ef ''  

R.P. No. 1552/$69

BETWEEN

1.

 <1

Ashok Narayana Rao'Deshpa'fiiie',::V:: _  - 
Age:55 8/0. Narafiafiflao D'eshE1_£1iide,"' ,   
RJO Shani Sa(:1an,"!f1__ Néaiij,   V

Narayanapufa,--.1§P:aE\X}Ed:5 30008; ' 

ManojKLk_;1ar'MujuDdai1'E,.  3

Age:64 S/O Kumar §'\;'Iu_§"k:1B1'1d_2.11'*'--R/'C5. F1at'No.13,
Gavisiddeshwazta Colony, A{'gop~a'nakoppa,

V Last B';1s"Stop Keshwéipur, Iiubiui~»23

_   «Gudi,
' Age:6'O,_ SEQ ' Bhi11ia' Rao,

IU.O"E27,"P1ot.,E_\Jo;:'T39, Madhura Estate,
Keshyvapur. .I"'{i3};)1iV"23, Hub]i--23.

D' 'Francis George Gonsalves,

.  .Ag<=:.:5_S S/O George Gonsalves,

  N'._D. Chaiawadi Building,

 Ia: shim Nagar, Madar Maddi Road,
  V' Dhj£:u'wad--58000i

fig/.



10."

R.)

Shivappa Gurappa Akki

Age:62 S/O Gurappa Akki

R/O Kumareshwar Nagar
Belgaum Road, Dharwad-5 80008

Totappa Devendrappa Mummigatti,

S/o Devendrappa Murnmigatti,    _--
Aged about 63 years, r/o Basaveshar1ta{Nagar;' .. "
Yalakkishettara Colony, Near Shankarr:'1ath,1'_'° ~ 

Dharwad-580 003.  _

Basavanneppa Maiiappa Kumbar,  

S/o Mallappa Kumbar, Aged about_6.2_Aye_ar's,
R/o Kurnareshwar Nagare Neelakrimal,  ._ , 
Belgaum Road, Dharwad-583 G08--.__  A; " '

Smt. Girija w/0 C::anarashékha1§1:aegadaL  U"

Aged about 55 §)}eaf;;,.d-R/o Deviarigpeij, (_3uddad..€}ni,
Near Banasigahkapi'§e1j}p1c,:_Et:Ii:b1i.   '

GangadhafeBa$é;1inga;:pa K1n*'dikefi'," '  "V

S/o Basalingapparlzlyxdikerg  I

Aged aliouf 68 y eaVrs«,"1*/0"E1r_i"{31;i'.;. Basava'NiIaya,
Basava ShantaNagar, C-oiohy, Vidyagiri,
Dharwad-580,003,  ' " 

 _  s/0 NinAgxappa----Airani,

Aged abom 61v.years, r/o Bhusappa Chowk,

dd'  Iiomboafa  E_)harWad--580 003.

 Niaigafipa Humbi, S/o Nagappa Humbi,
Aged about'53 years, r/o House No. 28, -

 Mangalwazpet, Hub1i,Dharwad Dist.-580 003.

V' 'A:   Iu'fabhakaran s/o Krishnan,
"Aged about 59 years, r/o House No. 32,

Nagalinganapura, Old 1-fubli,

d   Dharwad District--5 so 003.

©%/



13.

14.

15.

16.

17.

18.

Subhas Tippareddy Gangal.

S/0 Tippareddy Gangai,

Aged about 61 years, r/0 Aravindnagar,
Hubli, Dharwad District-580 003.

Gururaj Shantrao Kulenur,
S/0 Shantrao Kulenur,
Aged about 61 years, C/0 G.M. Desai,   

Wa1vekarGa11i,I-lubli,DharwadDistrii:i--58:O,(1(}.3:1_g   " A  A

Ishwarappa s/0 Ka1yanappa Pujar; 

Aged about 63 years, r/0 P10tNo. 2.{);"~.
Veerabhadreshwaranagar, PB. Road; ' _
Dharwad District--580 003;   "

Ka11urappaN.Hireha1, H    _  -.
S/0 Nagappa Hireha1, Aged..abou.t63--.years},"*,  1, = 
NearKarnataka.,Cire1e_,EWS158;   _ ' 
Navanagar, Hubli, £)ha.1*wad I31.'istrict_-15080"GU35

A.B. Ye11ga1*-  "'{1a1iga11g1 1'  '  '
Aged about 65 ye"-use, 17%) Behind Vijaya Bank,

Kalaghatagdi Road, Sei1'a$W.a.thp1;urg,_.Dharwad -5 80 003.

1B. Thotager .31/0' Basavaaaepjaa Thotager,
Aged abeut 62 y'c.a_rsg r/0 At & Post Thadkod,

 *  _ Tam &;._1_)i:.;. Dharwad-.-580 003.

19.7:

 Jariv:e:1<af'1's;':()"1fa1<ir Ahmad Jam/ekar,
1' Aged«ab0.u'e».,64y;'ears, r/0 LEG N0. 261,

1 11?' 'Cross; 1N1a;.=anagar,
Hubli, Eihafsvad District-580 003.

   Pafilds/0 Dyamanagouda Patil,
 Aged; about 60 years, Salakinakoppa,

   ;fa'1u'l< & Dist ad -580 003.



21.

22.

23.

24.

(by Sri Rajashei{arg:S.~.Ara11i, 

anti

_Mukkeri Oni, Hu-bli, 'I311arwa'd...'[)i--strict-580 003.

NS. Ghatapanadi S/o Satiinagappa Ghatapanadi,
Aged about 61 years, r/o Patil Galli,

At & Post: Beliada Bagewadi,

Dist. Belgaurrr-580 009.

KB. Angadi S/O Shivappa Angadi,
Aged about 62 years, r/o Kurabagatti,   _ at
Taluk Dharwad, Dharwad District--580vGO3, A 

B.V. Doddamani s/o Veerappa Doddam°a,ni,7._ A'

Aged about 59 years, Near Old Head Post"0ffice_, , V _
K.C. Park, Behind Jayalakshmi hote1;~.Haliya1,.__ '   V' 
Dharwad District--5 80 003. 1" A  A A I

S.S. Shintri s/o Sangappa   . ,    _
Aged about 60 years, r/o c/o SAP. H11fi1e'd,    " .
7"' Cross, Tejaswini Nagar,..Dharwad-380' 003} ~ 

H.N. Benkai si/¢',_r~Iei'gaj«;pa     A
Aged about 62_ycair.;s, House  
Behind't'Kari3'aIi¥1,ma Iitevasthana,  A

«- Petitioners

  Pat.i1,'Managing Director,

 _  Central Office,

" Go3<_o«1Road.,._}io'b1i.

SriiiGoui=a\.x Giapta, Managing Director,

- i , ,  A  K.s.R;r.C. Central orace, Shantinagar,
A ' A   V' Bangalore-27.

-- Respondents

4

This RF. is filed u/S ll4 r/w Order 47 Rule 1 of CPC praying to
review the order dated 01.06.2009 passed by this Court in C.C,C__. No.
2009/2009 ‘

This R.P. coming on for orders on this day, Sri K. Sreetihiar p

deiivered the foilowing order.

Order

1. The petitioner pursuant to the observationiiof this Court given an x

individual representation for payment of gr’at_uity_.V Thereisino direction or
observation of this Court in the i.rri}*ugr~3ed §order__fi_>'<ing any time limit for
disposal of the representation. EV.€=n..otherwiAse iriiiieasev-.of'eontempt petition

review does not arise. iAcdiji'dir1gly pi'e_tition_is~.closed;"i

Sd/-4
IUDGE

ssssss 14 SW;

E3335