High Court Karnataka High Court

Atul Shantilal Gala vs M/S Shah Murji Asoo And Co on 15 December, 2010

Karnataka High Court
Atul Shantilal Gala vs M/S Shah Murji Asoo And Co on 15 December, 2010
Author: Huluvadi G.Ramesh
E
E5 "iifi %§{2%E**§ §€?'é§§'? G? E{£RE'*¥fi'EE%}§§;.§ E}? Eéfifififlsfifig
§§?E>§ EEEIS "I"E-§ ES??? 3&3'? iii?' &§§§§;§§E§i' 233$

835-}F'§EfE

 E~§€$."§§'%'ELE 3&3 gzgsffigfi §.§§L'%i:%§E £3 §,%$:e::;§:§:4'

sgggwaz gwma §ag%¢»$;2§%s;§%%jLf%' ;f_  '

EEf'"§§EE>E§ :

35$ S§§2%.§T§.g% §AL.&

fififilfi Afififf 43 YE-£38  
§;§:m::3§»5@:§ Ramja. §a§§§%*-.A 
Esfififiéisfii kifigfi Réfifiafi,    "  '
Efifififiifififiwfiéfi Q?'§§;'=  _ 

 

 

gag: sag   § $3 §:.§:a§z  2;'-2;
agm  L % A A     

fififi

 »  .3   Tam; '§:s§{,E§=i€:,§£ &$€§§§ gggg £3;

  §$'1?§;3,§'%.%i=*L{f»§§ir§$:§§{;€'i'w§§
 A » .§§:§;%5§fé2:%»;g§% 2%§&§§i§;'E2
 %'s;$§+§§ ..E€g*a,i§£, bgfiéaszmiwéafi ?<:::3,
. 'REF; §;%:':g   
 3&5: ::;2~::;%g§$§: zaigmz saga.

   

    $§§és§~§&§$:v: W353 gmii

_ ' ~   gmég     Ea
= &%§§;$ gm:-§ §»§§§JE mm & :::€:.:rW
3; 2%;   wag, 2&2: mama
EEEEELY §'§$§§§S fififif?  §
gmg    gag,   gag §§::;,

   



2

3% 3%: Pififiiafiiiifi $5333: fiiéaéi

%  :33,

Egg $2 333% max gmés fig am

3; Egg %5e.§.%RF.§.?¥'; 2% Eé**L£%i:1"§§§
mgu ?am%§$ $©€§f:%* §:::vg%§§
gma ggmm {E}; Iaéifiefiéai-4%§§ {ms

 

Q. E§fi.s.§'£"'§'EiI€SR£ §%i§_¥EJE 3&3};

   Egg

3%; 3% $ §«§E}RJ£ asm &£':§a, T
E~E.§3 saw %.s;&aa:%*§:;, 1: §21{:a:;§5;'« 
§~«:§m:3 E'fi§.E§§$ ;'3££«E'2T":"' §s§$§*    ' 
¢,:€;".::<'%E S§~§%&RE :33; 2§§§%~g£fifiE-%-i:§£"§--€Z'«%}{},}»  . ' " '

'W-v-' -mm mm.»

mww ""W'

gfl

SETE §<:,fi,f¥€2I~+Ifii'*§'EETE§  S3§:§.§§;E»§.'.=
$3 8, S
§~§.?§§*E.§ §€"§'iEE§°fiS   

£=I$%€',EE 8§§@,.%'£E {E:§;"§¥§{§?§si§§;i»:--é{?{} 

J W V J:

   §¥}Vfi=::2=~, &

    
   

RE$§§§DEE*§'E'S

.  3;; SEE

 

{fig Sré KE{k¥$**z;§'*%§s:..,§§[ ts: Qasiaééfifig 33%:  
§§§§,$%::§§:g§;€;:~§:%§%:'; ;m%;?s,,;

  "€<:.§_R§s9E§§%;3;i AWAL :3 $3.23': a.:§§$i3€?$§»%»E
amfifl  "Ea: gm' ggafi  g§m§§§T §§§§
§}E:'3§iEEE§E~';'v..@fi§7 .%§£?;?§§;.E1°'i?&L Sfiiffifi §m;25§%;:2:§? :+%%.$s§§

3?. '?'f4IE  J{§B§§}¥ Sfifig? £3? S§.:§.LL §&USE$
& fiém ;fi;'§",§E:%,§ E"§.$-SEE» E5 SQ §£'%.28§§3§$-ér 3&3

 ' §§§§"'§£"££3'?.. fig RE$F§1*§§E§"f3; ,%§C?..§$E§ FSR T.%§«
 i:',3??:?-"F%';.%§€,*".f.§."%;: Plfifiifiififiafii EEEEEE 3E£"§m§ 13$, 2%:
,.j g;:§§';- 4.1%-2 {Z}? SE. 5%?'

  _ ' ~ .si:;:{y, filfi mm":

   

.

:’ -1 ‘: ,1, ,5;

-.,

émm

éiffifirfixiifi-§?

‘£”§*.£3 agyé %§’ iim mmpiaézaazai cizaiiég

arder :32″ amuzléiai yasaa-ii 11::

2m2;2m;: *3? the V Aaagzggxzaé;

aazgm 3% 2% gszsm,

Q2 fizzmréirlg a::*mzaaé. K9»?
beirzg aha :3f%¥$s§;.g barmwafi
a gum 3? is
pggay yam’ by axemutixg a
§§z;«mTm§::§r:; igsazafi as shagusz éaiaafi

3. 1 g 3. 2 3. «tswarfia rapa§*men: Q1′:

V. ‘_ prsfififiiiifiiififi, t}9:5§:« ..;t:h::a§13.$ was éifihfififiifirfié wig: at’:

“”-.§ng§.2.%c:§fim; fiznéggi }§»§3z1£§§ {Em

* & $$§fi§%&i§’:’§Z- “2:¢ifs:s:*e5 “::§1§ igizai figagrt

a§?.&?” Efiai zfifimx fig Bzfiéaé Clgmfifi afar

% %%jg§§;g$, fiifixmisgafi mg amgiagxsz. zasiaésg iémfi 232$

iéiéaé in gmw his saga wtzé a@m.i’;*€&§;

V u aacigsaé Efasnég 2? 3 M16. 2% Emmy 23$ -: ,

3, Eiaarfig

éu it appears 3%? tha ‘iziai Camri: V.

smmpéaizit an {Egg grsyunfi tmt 2i;’5§::<*; "

ymfium xiecwaaiy figmwnfi 3:'? §1'¥§é'e"3 §f§m~:'c:afsas_{ " '{'a

axmbéa thg mftsiag fig ymcium

wfam aim fig}; Smart; 'éém £3 gm
impzzgaafi; areisz' $3 3%: ;r§5m.z.::$}:* flaw
m istém itéai £-curt far maria;

5-, §;;§;:§;iza$:=g&z%g 'wafers {Ex
rm: ¥'\3;«:::;1:*t.,iii=f1*:$v f§i;E.§§3–3. §ép:1s%…z{r¢ 3:': zimvag 22$ seas;

:a.§fii%§méa§ " __ fiw amugaé am §8§'%§€§&§

is Qfifiififii 3:' may may 'fig

., 'ég bgeggzfifizmizg fif masfi mfimg} far tits éiisgaaai

§?;*T.z:E:a§ :.::~::$&. ma} Czmrt is

mr fiiggmsa $3' 'Em

wit}: kw? wéghézz fiwm mgmfiza

V V %anfi bask £233 ffwfiifiz

Sci/-3
JUDGE

.. fig?