High Court Karnataka High Court

B M Puttappa vs Shekarappa on 5 March, 2010

Karnataka High Court
B M Puttappa vs Shekarappa on 5 March, 2010
Author: Aravind Kumar

:§~§m§-§ flmmm my

flfimm Tfiifi $3′? ‘FEW $55 BAY QF

mmm

fiifififiw 3% $Q§?{§$m A

Sfl§fi.M,E%}”‘E”m.P%%
am. mma
fifigfi

“F5;

RE ammw €1.15? ”

% H€I§iI:”§§.¢§§; §-i€3§$;§”~;£;}$i§}’i?fi?$s._f’1’L£%§EJE}K
fis&EIRQ*&§U”;7&E&’E*P;1£;’*§§ : ” ‘

?E”§”E’E’I$E§ER

igay. Sri :%{%ji;i$:¥:§mmsm§%.@g§v§}

. .. vv
_ £{;i:”;~¥$K§ 5:g’*\..’.i.’.”,-‘?«%m§”3’* “F3
*R§*’;.S2:”,§§§€iE’¥”§’A.QF Efifihfimfifi mmag,

‘~.’=.§;$’i;%.m..iE4.a;*s§.”Ir-§£§EL-E?
mzmgmmma mamx¢:*::

mymaa ‘mama

§RE$?€}I’¥13Ei’§T

:m,a:,&_rm~&.m»:m$»§% Mm}

mwamfi EmwAma.51~§E “‘%;«k:.%

;mH@@ b*7

Am, mmm

cw um am QB’ am, mAms*r%%k[%%?:~§’§

M’ mm §i”3ECR§£§E m*I’E£>: mama msaw ‘__}R;;A. ,”
zmw; fifi” mm W mm mm MUEE (sRg;:*m;¢;%T

Immmm ism #
Tm

fl?’5’35~; Wm

fii Q,3,N®.E*%}i
Jfifififi {7a.}’R«fiE€}

RE€$’%?E=fiY” my mimmt _

PET1′”rzo;\.t a
mag gay; ” ”

Jufige {$m.mx;%a: fiamgémé aaemg mmgwg m Isa sat
% 53:5: ‘7″

§a¥é’x5 §m§.gmmt wmd the dmw

by fim §*fix;ai§};¢.;:. {J1-fin}, §iaaa&ui’%: in

flj!3:$ ‘;§§Q§¢%;i’.~’:§:§ Q; flaw mimm rev:-Mam mfitinn.

‘lgfgm mfmmfi gm am par Elm ranlm in me

L

imfimem a mg: (LE3 E~Iu..241i2©G4~

far mmvery fif a 313m af Ra.};4,?5§j’~

V — at ?&m raw 2% gm? mnnth fiwm the ciatsa mi”

ms fiw flaw af fimram ma current ixxmrmt an tim

fmm fim fiam wf émrm ‘$3313 $4133 data Sf

$333 ..

fififi fifififififi EATEI3~1.’_§,Q&20{)§f?’fi.$SEE?_V
$3 ‘I”I”% j

-:- Rfim fiEi’I’;R£»jEEE’§€;l’:’ ‘§’H~£7:1 ~ .

§. fin amf mmtim aiafmfiamt mémretfl apymififim

ma am him mum mmmmim

giainttxifl” Emfi aim ffiw as amt. fix fifi I€m.§63i

:3? Rafii?$§€§$§m

amid mm?-t ‘im e’;a:;zeLz’*;;

mtwmtmm mf mm mains: fiaaumniza haifi ‘éyafiam _ ‘gggigi

guhawmflmg gm éfimw milifit 113$
imtimmd am pxfmfimé: %x1..3.T:?4′-s8’;’….:_._”‘j%«– Itf :4g}$i$«.%fmmnt§i:e§3.¢d that.

:2: Wm gtmwwaixfi izmzmavable

pmperfim mfi t§m£%§sm?:§z..&’_V11&:’*m£$i mi? mfizmsity ta “mrmw kxan

finm fiw fire pmmiaamfy mam

m1*mifimf”a%n%;¢€::%g31zi3%% The: dcfmrzdant aim
fimmiafiw €}”m;vmm:§iw<..Vmfi' Tha ahara made in

Wang aim figmiafi. It wan apacifmafiy

wmiéfizfia-Er§_ 7.['j@s":'i°E"fi£m stammsm timtg ma zsigrmtxzrm

iii-~t§;m"m;:§§§m?.s§~@rm.timm mmigt mafia ymxmm are afi furgafi

; aamxmmmim mafia in tha piaimt. mm ta he:

{Em mm zsffirm MW fiw mum beimw framed thaw

V imxmfiww

Ema imrrmefi as. Emma af
sa ififiéflfif – an Q9» MI}. igfig mmfi
mmmmfi prmmmvim mxfi wnaidaratfimm

mmmépt magi agwwfi ta my iramraat; at ‘aha

ram af 1%.f2% my mama’; an tha amffi
aafimmmifi

3» tkw. pfiaintifi’ ‘
i:&m%. {Em ciafarzdmifc Ema
Ra,’?’flr3Z%,fw mwwfia iimzwrfiat am §;ifi’.’e;:<~.rc:;r:s.'t{j=, '
fifimfi am fiw mini mm:mu1:;t'maz.::§& V
mm mm 'V Z
§r1wm%mfth$piain'§-'E ' "

3″ Whmfiwr téw
Em Wm fimm mi” Raa3,4;?§Qj?~_ fi*€xm«.;t_h = 3
ziafamfimaf; M an mg d.a;%a§¥c:s’fL:5%;.%.it’%._

fin. wgmamx we %gan:gag¢
far fimxm M2 Wmymi. ‘§”§m’?”– 7 ”

é. Tnggzmm %m:m*ma as W»; and

9 – gm g§i:§§*?;«$:§mr§mfi; em mg am pm and
gm w;é<§::m ' fifi§31.3:Xa"i§'4i–£t#$ am Egmfii tn F32. T113
I as 3W1 and mmminmd am

fifiafimazit Dirwtmf at' Famnaie

fig.

é

mm EEWQ mmi gut mmiw tum
‘x’-ifimumxifijfi aaav.§§§z§s.;E§1 mm m. fin fim mafia csf {ha pleading

— ~ an cmmaéfiéémfixmm wi”

* ma mm’: miow

gum gfiamfi by the pimmfifi and

Elm amt agaimt the

a mam mf }”~7éu.k3%?’$%f-~ akmg with ammmt arxfi

afi “mg ram asf €$% pa, tiili its mafiaatfimn.

(R//M

“T32 Tim amid 3Em&gmmm; mld

aama ta he _

aim aammma. fix} §:m«9,rmm mmmgm aim %

ma mi: wnmiflgaarw aim W5d&rm:=..:4mf

mflwmw ‘Elm
xmpazmiwatg Fimfi figygafiiatfi “‘~%§,;3.1,1m’é–“.?,L _ ti-cw fcxlhwirg
:;’£:}’:m§w ‘ V , . . ,.

aw

3: ,~Ew_wm”—« ‘t$e1=%i: tifmdaffimdant

…. _ wgmmmci’ *-aha prmnmia fer’
_ “?’.7RE§;,§:%f3;§.’$$3’if»=– fawur af ‘Kim
‘ £59? vaimbk

_ é<:m"3;a41?}¢*;%_x'a:.£?1é;:*m hawawwafi by

_V mm in mlmy 'aha
inmwm: at the raw
mf yam': ia prayer ané
mmmfi?

5::–2-:2 tiw Qf fkw
~. A .v.T”vE;$Ww mum that fiw dafmfsfisant
ma sixmda pa 1: oaf
R$m?fi3§;i- tsewarcia infwmat an
: .. fiataak ia pm§m* mad
3* Wlmmfimr téw mmrfzzrmma with
ma fiasmfwm mmar attack 3:’;


.9. M 5.. _

 

   

   
 
 

    

 firm m.3:§fa,    v



   kg;  

fmmfi; arm am pmmmw am; eztmmpared m fine. ..

aigxmmm $3? fiw aw difiwwgmt af:*+ci:

mm ta a. émmtctérsmiam that the aigmmm fer}: ‘e.:.;.t1& fin V’

ia mt that wf fiw xiafiwmdamt mxfi £*;;..v’:mV

lam, fight af by mm Trmi Smut”: x”«s&$sa.pj:;i:e:é’i§§éi£éd’V:by ‘V V

tfim Fimi fipgmfimim flatwt {hm

mmlzmims. that giafixxtifi haé exwutifixi af

fim pmmm ;&;.&.=’e§;e.; ‘scfihf unfier the
pmmm. fie; mg: mi’ Ehfi mum with

mm mfjairg iBg;K;$is:iflapm W-2 mum

mama am §3m§§:’.’3§ mg: ream upon tha
Wfimma zfgi’ t_§f11§m’ %;§i, .

m ahow timfi thna éiaputemi

A §$tET4:f§«f’§§”:$:’;§’3E”K:,?::f§v»”1″:§é3?$»i§$’§,?’ mm mgmat Em mrmpmd to haw

.. mt

:wau1d fixrzkmr aixbmit. mat burciazn cf the

‘?m;§’ him yxmmm eamdi fiw mmifiarafimm rfipt havxw”

cfiémhargwfi by am giaixyséifi, Kim quméiari at’ buxfifim

fimma» mm: wing wxd Wm

mflcmgwim by gatiixwg ‘aha: emf fim cifmpumci ctiamirmni

@/

W

Fmmmia $mim:zm haharatery dcf¢n&mt..VV_”-iiag

damfixxawflmfl mat fiw diiapmtwd fimfimmsenm hafi _ ::r<za5:_{"
mwmmfi by" tkm fiaafmfiaflt. wxfi them: faata atram jrigfzizy 'V

thmfig

wmmcsi far mam gmtitimmr .1f§i-§aVas§§;%2m::§1§fé1eLa;e}fz1:;,.Vt.2m foazcwm

a far my m7g,*;mifiaax"gs;*wZv;s:»2*3§:'~ V "

‘ ~, :

j:saMs$;~€§;~i;1?__®$”;?*¥Q.3%1{2QQ’$ flamd
“~–.°_§£§’fl§%;EG?4′.T¥}f3?’«§:§’ ta N auatainw?

ju geaaaw by
Fimt. &p§@i};at@ {hurt in R8.
_”~*%j§£Q@fi-6: aéatm G’?..fi§.2flfl%§ ia
mm flue mtidmm piamé by
Jj§E.::;1e$ Emymfivm gsartim anfl £3
ta hm uyhaldfi mvimci m’
mmfimfl?

, mflm’?

Em 3:; Tim WW mawufian mi” ‘tiw auit:

mad ap§rmimmd §.xy’ 2
fax mmmm :33? %%g»rmm:j%%r¢aaas;;i;Ti

» té’ mi’ ~

&,__,_,,..

H

;%m& §;:’::5;ak~tsa:~%¢ea*§<J:*:'%ia.2@a;;§-V%5P.*' é';:aa.§=:§::*:2;': R maxaezi fix-"2 Fatzaéafi '%'%!"??:;'":§L"§i?i.fiT£.".E. fimtfifiim-mt

mmrxmzaaiixig f:3zT.n§3E. {sf §::m”§ma=:§.m*£:’a.%:::7;:”:s:*§. flm:’:smm §$;%;”§1s;;??§

Maw fiiam %§g3:*m%;m:’*aa~t7-2% fm-*:,xm:§ mm éiifm g:;’é;.§%§:%”§M;”§:»m:f§; };;m°-mmmm ~

fig mm L%”;,é2% $T§.§I}a€%f€.1é§”‘E§: ¢’a;.§:’;%-aii a:m:’::€.:»:’:%sx”a;%w:§fl:z-“:;gEf,,*” E”:x»;2.{§ z*mi:t’2f;:2%g;}”;.?z;%?.i.iV’.T’V”,:€”e:°%x’%T ‘

fiimemzwmmi M” fim wmifi,

3%. ‘§”7§”m E:2§.;m””a:’§;a*s;a§’s; mm ‘fizifi yiwimfifi m

£%§§€3m’€, flaw m:s:h::’a.3%,3Z§.’§:: $7? “§i»}£;’;%&’ff= g1»:””‘a:t:,*.-r§§’§::~:?%:.& §-ma;”%, “‘§x§4::m’;ftgifi: %::’;~=f
am-Kmifimwmfigwxia m”1::§§ mix: §§1.z.’§:m%:;ié,W§’€;?him*:&*p’«”I*;:3;%fi;r” aE§a;%f’§f£§.. §’:}”x;ix£ §”§%2fim2:”‘af§.$:
tfiw §:»%mx2§;:?.§.§” §}§”€’$%§’3i%},C%I€i€’§: “§;§;R.ffiE< _a::~::§; jg:3}r%*::s2cmm amci

€.'?fl}f*miQi&1."'éE%.'ET.§:éZfé;%"'3-. m»;":£:.e3§j;;'§"§ '¥:;%tI§§§;i::%'i3._ %:};:t:: =7:%:f;m*Em%:.mf§ ma Emfifi

hwmw %':.§:";w s:::sés'w""%:-. s;+sm: 'm"&£'T&:maa 'fififlfféfl Eigmg

m fim §=:xe"2i%;§:;&?*1£?aV2;«§ "%;:.r;s; firm; ¢;':x'zf:';"§$;é§:;%§fi}fls:ii;§ §;rw:*m:'m§m§m:g"jy mam ézamtfi ma
wafii mm Eim .;§f:;*=*:»:?»&:é,;g:;ia1':?: s:%§:~.;m?1%1v:.%§@:?gf'*§iI,@Vi;EVasr22;m '?,.%%m%: fiismixgi °v;ii:'m:2:ma
ixfifiszéfi Ema rig-gm;";3I§«%:a;:¢a; tam "aim §€%:s7é§§.?xm:*:Zx"@

mgmg W mg mg? m matw-awn

E?» "Zi"§'mmg:E'": mmi %A*<iE.r1§§:§g:%5 WW g:."}'g;fi§<'3.'fifiI%.'%'§§%Efi£€m?§§t"§. mas §m:rm:%,§w.
mmfi. Kww amw»~m:m::zfi2:ma:§ ifimfi §§§mr§:"££;fi

fimmhwikfifi ;%"::m~;= "%::asai~;;mt": ¢aiia:eim§:«;i f:$;'"€;m:1 §"1§,§,:3A £3": fim; w;"m$;%%~'»

wism§fi*:Ef1 §£%?"&%i a:".%am:3t":» em ?:h.s:r: Emizfi imm: iwaxa. ~€ii$§T5%§QE?%:@s¢%

§:3:'3°§xm&§.w:%§;a» Wfxim émwiia w.&2"m.mEd§ 'ifimx h'kEw?9«'"3»§~E3?£$£¢.§E._f§£f33'If.§w?;"fi{.:V§asé$$i;E':. ;_ '

%..1:?m§ a::.*:§mQ"::':a zxxawfizm in "ifim mmfit hgsm gm7%':r', m'~a";.«:%£.'?v::;i%.'aim…'-£:@:i*h2:~;§:'2T?«

%m'€.&m%:; ' . .

Eéé, m’%;;%M::r* axwiiabim ‘v”é”;.2’1.%**::” W”&.:%§
m axw-2.:sa”:§:§.3s:m.s»;% ifim wwéfi:”gm@§ .«:?+3fi'”£”E>1é.m3§”§:=;§w§;3§:%.a
ivzm”-xd £§-wyivfim a:”:»:§”” mrzmé. fig
mmmlm Em “” §f;£3%’£37§asf~3
%’?£&%.”?’£smfi Eésikm. ;%..-m Ehffififimmfi, ?§°”1:’m?A
mm mmmmxm §;x§£m”m?f€§ Em Ema xtaeithm”

m §éz:§’3.mw:i f&§;”§;~ Ewiflgfiiémgfxgfigzafl “§”E”2.%;:1§m£~:mpaa my fim ssmffifm

%3%**§;.;Vi’fl.,%?¢§;§fm”$z$mx?£m§§’jg3»;2a__ a:2§.21:;a;,*§ ggm t§.”:;3l&~ §§E’°flEI3′;§’§fi gaimxs g:flm.z”z;$”.;if§ Eitmfi

_ %mw:%:£?§% a..2;*.m%3;§%; E:}:’:;é Em %;:’:.3?:ti:%:%.:sz§ ?;:;2m*r:$As:?;:m,

‘ _’.”%%”~l§$ “§”7″”..”..%%;t§%;’«;_ si::’:zmi*t?. jga3″s:3s:::a::&:§:%%:s:W:’§;§ “M; M.m:m°3té m Emxm apfiimm

‘ ~V§i’E?§iT’:x=i;§’E?i;§’fi;’EL §§%3{‘g3″‘§}§}£1~£”§%”§ 2::s~;%”” éx::I:@3:m::§$’§; H12 §¥m.”‘.K£.1. Em:~m”;:§m Eisiw t§§&€}§”@z?:t§.§1§g?; am

a

Efi: tém .w§’§:&”3;€;~’:”r @mV§jgm:;§&§»;%mg tats? mm W tfimfi w’i’mm ‘fiw

?;;Em”%
A V I» ‘ _
V’ Saimsim mmrammr mspwi
L? : ass Ezmfifii W

“fiw W3}. –

fmunflafiflvn

vi’ fiw ymxzmm mxd

igt af awmfiarafinn 32% mt 1 *

Wmraid mt manly ha a fmtiig mama m @§:%.’gr3:”;:at;if¢éi’f%’t§*3~e§ ‘£”15w’§_t,.VA.

r: ~ . mi” e:;x¥o§-1?;

flm mmmfimx wffim pxmmfimy

3%: En mi” mm? 1 V9.52? rim mum

hmmw Wag in mmmr Era fa a’..im’fiés£§;ajg:§§VjWith ragmfi tn

mmmfimm mi” ” A

Q}. mm mm. mm piainmifi’ ta
am pmmw am the
fififaxxfiwt haa gang a step

iiiagmufmi fiasmzxmemt mmaly Ex.P”1

. — Eaimsxm Lafwramry fax” am-ftyaérg tkm

is mt fitzat mi” firm aiafenflantn The

‘mm’: gaemdumfi anal

émmummt fa mmkw thmugh

awn « fiwié whm baa. mm
wwmimfi kg @518; eiafamfiant. Tiwugh 9; fmkia fitmmpt hm

emf irxteram.

22. This ovm-mefi evidence placed
: bemum aside I %

qcmim that Trial emrtermd ha

mum ha mmm on
comm In him mm mg. timed
hh’mm1m an _

23. The amlm is mum

an ths and. Trial mutt

E suit document is proved.

A is not mam. Witness ea
mm. W2 has my-mt lmutila
The othew wttmm to Ex.P-1 has

% ms in we cannot bu mpmd for
in rorgomg 1m-agmpha. Home. I am of
that mid finding of the Trial cm.u’t does not
the teat of law and aoooramgy me juamm: and
ammmuaawzhanmmmsumwsaumhgmaaarmny

as mind herwi above. In viaw of the above. formulatmi

E59. ‘magma asfixsqn 9| awaxzamuenumau 2 a.
S mfliitfiamaantnmms

‘E ifififiihé %§fiH§H&§%$fl$ 4% ¥’§Af§f’%”‘$ Lifizm mmzwsumaumu am iwmfihn gangs

Ex.P:1″‘ :

‘ifi

mm above im in he awasaad in xxmatiwe and it ia
that juamuc and; amm paasad in as Na.2f4i}’§fi¢?}’i §~..V”. :
dame! 14.0mm oaznwt be 7m_11is;bj}§§:’jfi§’:::b§:.
aiamaami and mummy the mm as

hssfi tube armnmtm,

24. R4: 1-am m..a:- c§.§urt%whi1e
prwumfi by firm swim in ‘cm
csmtmluaion um man 9:’ 1=-$1.3 no
Ima, hm pxamm ma mt

‘ £3. P2 i.e.# Sri Eahwarappa

.

393:; at 3:11; ; fmmd that max mm ma

namely tlw afimr wztxm’ 3 to

flippa. hm mt ham

that initial mm amt an the

. hem flhemxgw and has mam ta $4.
‘Any mm mm mmiammmm a1} the available
fimcugtary avflmcm and cliaxxxiaaw the suit af

fi£”‘§’% agmzu %m:w§w§.33aw%% 3:3 éfifififl umaag wwwawmmam mam gamma mama; wszwaaaaaagweeg gm znnnw :..am:s.a waawmramama gm fiéflfifi mmzaa ws,2.w;wm.s’;,-;-W gm gamma 2.;

25′ It is mmefi mm gsaragraph 13 af the
air’ thm First Apmliata Cami that it has ‘A
widmwe at’ 9% ms, 5 ma. 5 e13: k

wimansm ‘tn tiw shama at Exa.P Nza.-$3
and the P7′ ahma was wtrrftztm by

ma 3.x.w.cmgw mmea
hmfikn and daniaad mt, aariba
Eshwarapw fiat In ihct,
it has mama fin mt signed
on tkm date PWFS has stated
tlmt. M was ban smut}: isrxterast af
Rs.3_,mKJ{- was ahara. ma hm utarbed

5;’.

giapoaed ayimt the defendant aa

and thug the €Védfl173X uf’ PW5
_ ha
avww nmmrw.’ 1 eviclem has ham:

_ t,a. Em’. .t”‘i”1’§’£:tfl mmifiaarawon by that: Firm; Appnflate Qourt; and it
he a mnciuafizm. that plaifl has man unable ‘tn

pfvava this emamutim: $1′ pmmta and the: mmidwatmlon

«er”’

a zamm sxau Jam ztzaw

E
§
x
E
5
§
3
Q
E
3
5
E
&
m
a”


m
§

“”15
i
E
$
§
E
€45
m
r:


as
33

§§§}§% %§’§.§;.’§”?é’:::5′:s.f”

aiwmtum; piacterfial rswecczublamac. 9%” firm

Qumficamd fiifimuxrm may be dtm tn

imgmgm gamma wfinpted in me§;~%i%%%

‘rm &ifi’:’:rmcw erbaeznz-‘M idetwmra’
the qszxmtimwd and A ~
aigmmm am ” ‘
and sufimimt ta ax§:x1*g;wa
opmkfi rmarding thc authgtdrslzip 6%’
qumtziuxmd aignaaum mgr§;aaci”–m P}.'(a§._
mww %

2?» In Vim uni” if 9f the
wxmiciezcrecl ayinizgn i paaaed
by the an prr~opw’
a1spa’vac+uTafi.m3:1:vicr.i;f mm and am mt
:s1,1fi’m* fiom any an fazcm anfi mm is In
guamm: anti éawm mm
in Ra ammeoa 7m aumgma. In men

aim abw mafia’ iu wsaad’

~. yatsitimzi in dfimfiaad as. dewridg nf mrmrita

_§:3rde:* aw: tn mam Sd/_

FUDGE

Nvjifiz

awmmm azzwxsaa

igfififi §=§§3§§~§ ¥%W§%?%§§”%% éfi iflfififi main wwwgwmzmams am