High Court Karnataka High Court

B N Padmanabhan S/O Late V S … vs The Chief Manager The Bangalore … on 19 December, 2008

Karnataka High Court
B N Padmanabhan S/O Late V S … vs The Chief Manager The Bangalore … on 19 December, 2008
Author: D.V.Shylendra Kumar
-ii-")NIMQ'1'1OE. am 133%: .1;-1r1:> am. 'AVG SIHJ. 'df"1OEiD.8, f 

QUNIEIVEH AHV!\EIWI'IEI&¥cf 80:1 NO DNIWQO NOI.LI..Li§c:I SIHJ.

"'3;-1.3 
aw zawvs am zamsv 'CDNLLLCEIS A8 8ooa'2:'6z';.I,_ _
am v~1\n~.Iv Hsvnb 01. 'C)NIAV&IcI 'vicml ¢IQT'agIo1_LrLL:1.sNo:>T3:nz:.v
30 2.3:: cmv 952: SE{'IDLL2:!V azaam GC>3'IE¢i $1 !§1C»I.LI3.3cI"SI}iJ._ '  

[za 10; vow '9'TU9€I1T1W_ !H!.f€*I3S._'n131S~w_v
f"{,\_1 .10} "apv '"093 mmqpnsnqpew V39 [1a.:eAa'g. 5 V
&LN3CiNOdSf:¥&£  910 .099 1--V aa<31.V::ir5zva' 
   _ '=..L::x.«12?vz~3vs~zvr1.:,w'
_ _ :Mo1s1ifxIa_3*z:I"or1v%3r.zv'8
}bS'S£l,Lf31S-OS' HALLV'd$icIQ~*OO
1 .-  ' d_Q_ava4;s1-93:: M10?

('1

V ....  " *=:;,_ 53m_o@§Nva
' .. ij ' *  J.'_E[cH'VHVP'\[VHC)
 ._ ' '7{I'a~'.£_T)i':.i IA%i}i"»Iia':m:vdwvd 'SUN
"(I'M mva. d%::%:§T'.&_Li':3, 4iii.\%I'1v1;);x1va am.
 % '  >_a*.a{_)vNvw grains ZEHJ. I
L '  '- F ="£1"§I"v
 [Maw 'nrBM~=c1___1;14)i 'us Na}

a3No't3,1.Ltaa«--. _     990 092:: - EHOTVDNVB
 ,.  J " J.  ' - " A.  Havawwvxzalwa

Cwoa }£HVd 'zz:'o:~1 LV/2:?

savm at: maav «:1-am!

avnvqnw wvavwn 9 A mvn O/S

NVH8VNVWC]'s2'd M 2::

iflflfilfilfifi

" * '. 1'.§3'Z:f':'S'.f)} 8003350 I 99$-'01:? '«'9.'.1.'13c{ 1?-'Ad

iwriuauaas 'A'q p1=.-'q ,s;;»2_:'>§1o;g; , 

'{I0'§'31_C19d :11.i;m  _ _   TA

'I 095 $0 17zz.'N {wide In la-amxeutrv zédoo} .80QE..f:?;"_:6u?T   

patmp .1sp.:0 .1901 Se {B9ddB 9111 3m§s{ms'§'g3 .i;§§;to_fl9133§f9&d*e;»' 

9141 EH8 Iv-amxsmxv zm Adool  'i§AA:'J?1§@:q.Iv
9111 Ala: passed pmmv 9q:1§..;<{   'Z'

N  'V .V A    *ss9:3:ms
zitm {mm 199111 1 C-_I'I " pgpv   11013399 .19p1;m
{ggfiqgi g1g[;gdgiy 9/Opq pasdde Qsoqm
DUB  My iaefmbiioq-«--Iunoum UBO'{ 9:111 Stxgziedsx
Audmmfi'   "§p.Iemo1 xueq 9111 .10 9:)m=;1su;
_/uggxs, :§fi}§jggoos 9A111a.I9do--o3 3E2}IE'1'€3'LL1"E'}}

91;,-4 . 3§,*.~.._ (}1~ I.I0[i1;}§S Japan ssnagoos 9A_m2.I9d0-0:) go

 1.

/iq passed p.Iem.V 119 119113 8z11_H_r3[d{I:Io:>

ofign. H§)f§.*%’1[{II[“[ xmag 3Af113.I9dO*O() A110 9.I0[‘E23IIB8

191:} 91.13 go Jsmonoq B Aiq u0§ZlI19Ci mm
H E! (I H O

80’! ggmm @-

.10 919.: :)IpO’_£.I9(i .10; pspmoxd 1u911Ia@.{§*e qfinoqa 19113

f:11:n331q.:0x:; SEEM xueq am Aq pafireqo 1s9.1a’1u1_7 go 919.: 9q_;_ .

19:11 tszxonusmoo {[3119 psugmexa JQAQU /i1I.I0{{“3,1’1’8 91e{19cidfe ‘ ‘A

9211 3911:; $3891 .10 syqeuom-39.1 1011 S; 1; 113111 E:1s- §V::.’i5:»1’I’.1_¢= gpmzmogg” 2

AT[I(} pQ1SI}_{‘pI3 IIQQQ SBT1 ‘.1[1″{’10′{IH-3 SUI}, }Q V’ ”

zrsg moqe _;o uomod {rams Jog 1dao:}-52:»

ms 9: xuvq am “/{)00′().L’6T’SL\¥

[B101 p”§’3d9.I pm; .29uo;111;§¢1 9I.{; _
Slmmotx mnouxe weds; We
Sugsaoom 1:1 9:.)r.1oB1d: ussq
pet; Hung 91:1 1811;: 91:1 ziq spam
sI;m91 91;”; J0 sfimefi .._9i4″.; pm; 1o1m1′;q.ra
sq: ZiBf.1[‘1’vvfIIII'<'}{CV}4€.I:§'c'}'5-{Z1 _;(u).V am /iq paonpmd
. 1011 pyp .1o1e.1:rgqm am
11313 Jsdoxd 011 3:91;) fpmme
3:I;${ba;;Eis_–{I0u é~ 91 .,Io1m11q.:e 91.9 Aq passed p.1eAm

91:1 Lzgpfiéimaqsn pmom 1:.:as:,m0::) paumay 'nwieq

" em 30 .1I9'190. 0:0 Smmaddv '17

V . ._j91'B:)dApv 1[I3[IIEI.I9A0{) peuomppv paumag 'muemnw
gtrgiariés '3I{IS At; p91u9s:.:u(:i9.): 91 991191303 9Ajm~3.:9do

80': grgvdm E?

,./9′

9113 191111. ‘.tI9}fI-3T1 sq UB3 nogdsoxa ou “1C)’8.I1IIOO sq} _;[o sLII.19:3,

ug; Alfuo 3111913; pmme 9111 mg; ‘::1s9.1:;11::; 50 am: ‘{BT”l1:’)B.I1[I(f):) °

3{I;m;2.=3[3 .10; auaurgpadzug 011 Sam 9.191;: 13:13 Epafimqo ‘ ~ »

seq 1q’31L1 on 11331.13 *;.I:;>mo.I.1oq 9111 91 pajétgfiif .

1011 SEM 1uaEI%z{13d9.: Jo ampanps 911:; _1[ 1s9j:«3;t11;’_”ya’t19éE._’ SI:-£,.I._1A9:;_ §

:1; aunotma am giedm 03 .;z9mo.I.1oq 36- ¥j;§)’»aJng113_;
3:13 93 amp Ame .;o113.111I(1~¥§3. .é§ q1_ 9J{§jé€j ‘ 9:1;
0:1 pet; xueq sq: :paq1 3113
.10; Iasunoo am mg) ‘9

VV : ‘V % ” . ‘.zauo;1119d
ttmm 911:1 go vI[eqa_>q_ no’ .S.i:am1o:> 911:1 AQ p9u.I:>2ao’23;2q_r¥31’1t1;;s’s3é” ”

SI 1II'(10{1ZI13 psmumoq 9113 go 1tI9ILI1{‘8Ci.gg’rS.V’;nLf.’1wE2tiJf.._”=,’=_>_tgj’_ ;§LIoj9J91;1
I){.It3′ pstrgtzrexa 9q 0:: _ *q§::§_1;:*.»;. 3.”-‘,_3’Li. 1%3IZ[I Ems; umop

11933; amrgq 99113.: “£19139 1393:9311″;
__1o 918.1 11811; fiugfigbo am fiumoydxa
mraq aguejadgffos §%mI~’i. .10 TBSSIIIISIP 10} Parifild 9JQI9~i91f1

. ._;Idf1n1;1su0Q 913:1 J0 gag QIOQJV Japtm
/} . 10:1 ssop 19119111 am 9.IO_I9.IQ£]”1 pm?
9’ 9.1q119:1u1 01 putncufi on puno; mq ‘fgmsp

{II $3:.$;;(:is1r3 3391;: me psuimtexa peq A’:1§.Iomn’e amnsdchs:

90′: s:.291:»aM .x
130 mu s.I9p.1o 3.1″:-3 .IQpJO pm Jo__ :;Lfi”~.,19′{§1§:}” ruaqz

“pz>z*_a.1z>:;:)13.mq0 aq afiqm

osfe D139 pmmv uagq smaq
S1C)9£iS33 :1ueA919.I ‘zfiqi 93B[{9dd1a am
go .I9p.IO am pfilju’ V ‘.19do.1d 1011 am
S1[I:4)’£TII1:”V§:.Y.-“;.’:£”..i “V.;¥:;I am 30 uo’_ma1ndu1oo

1;e:13v,;:>e 3I.{ii”j1EY;f} S’§ :’t:§§1-.§%.§:ti£qns ‘ptllatif 191.310 am 110 *9

‘@3123 11;19s9.Id sq”; 1:; mo penrgod 9.1%:

L qons 011 ‘IIOIIUJIJSII1 Btlpfiraq geyaueug
0:1 $193 — 1u9pLI0ds9.I 9111 .10; Alpomne
sq; «– B;p3:11 _;o 311193 amasag 91;: Aiq pangs;

.10 SUOQEOIJQOU QUE SHOEJBIIIBQJ {DUE SQIYLI

8{)’I ’39’I”?dAA 9

{Jmme 9:11 “.I9A3m0I-.1 ‘uo;1;19d 11.15». Sm’: 1:1 {JQEEHIBXQ sq

1393:) qzagqm 110.11-ssanb B 1911 S; .IO’.lB.I1Iq.i”l’-3 gm 0) 313103 .191113.1:§i” D

9111 03 .Iog.:d ucmza ltmome 9111 DQJOAOOQJ ggaq ‘

xueq @111 :1s9.x91u;[ go 9191 11211;» 113 03 SB z}1nCiS§§:§”a;I:{;{1’

” A-._ ‘ ‘:;s:;.;:viiL%:i; V . _

reuoulpm 1″8I19d .10 %z Istnnll B 91*3ff1§ht1é 01 oéie 1

pmme 9113 go asgmamo .10 3I.I”gA}S;i”ia*:§ T.zo.;qQp:,1uIié;tI(1ffi§3nf~ am
IEO fiugpuadzzp pamone Bugeq’-3.s9.I9i:1′:1_’:’ ‘E§!:,:1:”t.»\1V.I’B.¢.\’-.__1_c) i1.o§_{s.éh’b 011
81 22.1911′; ’91’E.’.I p9mm.__m-$13 sré’.o5{fj1a ;1{I1″IO'{I1″{:?

p3’_1B{I1€i11S B JQI p;; 8mt§ ‘.«f.,.cV’)1*§:.=;,”ug(‘,;_.’,.=.rf:V.’VV’:)I;§»’ ‘pug [IE 0:;

911103 sanmd 91.11 9111 pmme am

_10 ‘3Iz;ss*§3d am fonu S; 9[np:;’q:)s 1Iz9m1{Bd9.I
Qua J1 B’ %§I1;.I9Ao39.I xtmq
amigo; Jsmumoq – .I9Ii0[“}{1Q(i 91.31 pus
mapuddssgti Auaameq 101311300 am smgm ’01

” H . é . .. ‘s:;p.I19d am usgzmaq

L’ ” pzaseq pamofge 03113 S; 0,355 _1o 1se>.I9-1111
13 ‘mnouxe fB(iIOII[.Id am no psmofie 31 9/031

119 1’sé.I91u; anqm 1unot1:m pmmv sun go I.Io11o”e;s;:11=3s—-uou

8011 99mm 1.-

~ {W

pasodsyp uongad 1§.IA& GILL ’31

— -. ~.’_5¥i3i1’B3s pxekwe am, *s13ads9.I .IE){[30 He II] ‘rq1II.IQ;mn

.. AV ” pmme 9113 no :1s9.1;):11:rg 9131 3L¥I_II’_EB’19.E

0’; paggpotn spams 3o:11a.n1q.1B 9111 Aq passed

é”(;fI ’99 £»;1’m Er