High Court Karnataka High Court

B Ramesh vs Mr Gladson on 15 January, 2009

Karnataka High Court
B Ramesh vs Mr Gladson on 15 January, 2009
Author: P.D.Dinakaran(Cj) & V.G.Sabhahit


EN THE HIQH scum’ 9? §{AR?§;¥TA}{A 2%’? £%a:§€:§.&zJ.;Q.}é:”‘% – H

BATES? ‘3″i~i£S THE ism my <::'§"JA:2=::»;A.;Ry.;<:§e9

?RESEN?» V»

THE: H{':v'%'~§'B.LE MR. E3, 3_§i5:{rz'}<£;¥é;gsa;fss-ELA.ac§«%§Eé§';;.':,§.§';':<":§;
THE §*{QN:'§§._:E;

:_. »:é§_v:§”*:9;’__;{‘:} ‘:=~:i. Ix: 9; 3}:-;_: gvéaag
8E’§°’wE–;fi.;N_;., ‘ »

1 B7.§~€;%_%’s.*iBS}~§’.”‘w-._’* _ ‘
Sfié R;%MAP??2%:_”~ _ __ _
A{frE§§Z’_A£il§ iii’? as *sE;»>:.Rs
‘R; A’? §s;~;xNm;§::AEA::;”

4;f£)’§2′:? BEREBAEL CHURCH,

QfKQ§¢aA3Y”~ 11111 ~

MAE§{‘:j§:;QRE 57%: 093 ?Ei’]£”§’§”E{3.?\¥E§2

A §~:’§§v:32§:x:A 3:; sanmami ASSGCEATES. ;

_ 53°33′:

ii T ma.-iG;,A.1DSab;

» V ‘ ‘mags agsaygaa

-. ..;m1z?:m A808? 39 YE:-&RS
amgr £’éE§§£?; SA§§Q;%E*é§§{§:?§’.%-£2X€\§,
Mgmgmazsamf
E’e4{Ar”~§Cn%%L€}E€E 37% 9:33. :%&:§;3>z%§}§5:?§’r

‘?HiS’» WP ES FELEEEE §’Rz§YE§’=§G ‘?{3 €§U;’%S%% & EET’? x%§*§§§f3£i
T.HE- GRDER E)’T,?£E.e1€}.08 ?;5’s§§SE.!_} E2? A??E§&é f’E{‘§.i;Z{}8€}i§”}§§?

2

BY THE .%:.?&R§§ATA§<;:%E<{§; gwxrg: €23-?~§S¥j:'v§ER8 §iZ}§.§P{}"'?E?.?vS§'g
REQRESSAL maum A'? B;~a:~s{;A;,@RE A§\_%_"£;.. {'}'§3f.'i_"}E;'r"'¢–.–_ ~–
:rm1.9.01 PASSEEE Eéé {3{}MPL?s£N'§' N@.};;?;S]§é'Z.3; By. 'E':?~{E;-.
9M{SHINA K.ANNA;::A CGNSUMERS :)§SpUr§;S":2-~:a::.%e§:wss$;;fi¢,.
§3@Ri.§M ms MANGALGRE1 EN A§\é€'é-:?A avg' 5:%E::3:2*;§:'<:%f:_*53:?§::Az
wags}: ACCQRSENG 30 THE P%?:':fi'£"§E'{'}.§'iE;E7€»._ :3" ¥§§e:§;:§z;::?_'

ELLE-GAL ANE WITHCRET .3'UR§§9::CT:@%,"';zs"wysifxggés 'EYE
LAW ANS VEOLA'FiVEZ__ 0:3 §?R:I_Z€.€j,':i'?;LES :§;a;:::§~2g:1
JUSTECEZ Am} EQUE"§'Y.U_ " ' "

This Writ 1 §}r&ii1:aina§:’§;

Healing 911 thisVda§?,v__ ;.§u.gd:.:: t~5;1€:’ foiimving,

% ..}.{§.2{}€’}8

:&7i;V$;*€i:1′:he.’?S:?,at$ ficmmissimz 3:133 dismiggaai aha aj{:;;>ea%

éiitéi fizé”.;3fi’5§%iofiar’E1er€iz: 9:; {Em gmmsxé 3%” {§6}fi}’.

€333: E’€$§3{‘}§{iE’*3fi?. hfiffiiifz fiiaé zfiamgéaifié

u 9:: ‘she fiie af Eéaksizézsa Eiammaia §}§s;”‘::’§a’é

ikazésfimsr fiisgutes §3$E§I’€$$3,§ Es’g§”um, Mazzgaime {%:€rati::a

Cailézi “sh: Qisiréci Fcmm’) saeiéing far §§:j;m@§:*£ of R33;

U Eaiiéz {mm $26 respargdfim with igzisrasai ;”,-5?: 35% 33.3. from

V”

19§§~{§a%€ sf ésgai msiiisaii 311%} {£35 ztéaie <3§ §}aj§fi§€z:§«i§:':::f

a furéhm" aiirersiiatz Efi pay 'due <::;n3gl:s;i;1a:zi_. '§€s.§{;:;}%T}§,§j'iv1 ~

tirswaifig Crag? U3" 1aWye.r's noiice and ¥.%.::£’E:’:it{$ éfifipficafion aniegmai
321:9 an era} ag;;:>§me1jr€’ fez’ €336
consfzuctien. at mfiagarizzg 6138
fiqft. fm’ ag;’5e:z:’: zzgjmrg was
Rsqfifififgf pfi ‘f;:-éysfi agzziifiéfi; ‘axgafi Rs. .3;,«%G,€}{}{.’,:t,i ~
vshéitiz a<:AféQ:%i§::g' "25 é;m%§z'2{§e{i {r§:;f:~;*-i; <25

mai:::zf;a§;:-z,_ E": E3». ths" fufiizar =:-9.5% 95 {E533 €?{}i'£E§§i"&§3}£¥i§l"§ €323?

".:–"2r;2:zo7=£.;;:n': %§%f2sasVVI%&§:%ed ':9 E36 paifi if} Siagss 3115'; iii: <;'=:.sm;::§.aém<s1':t

"3:1fit;a31' effefig '2;::mf"§. flfliifi? 1:; cam ifiiixi 1:336 Qfififiiilifiiififi 23%'
g . , V _ ,

the »._§V;0u§:3..' {ha r<:s§sG3:&a:1E;.:«§ paéfi §§:§js;' §%ss,$Q,{}£}<},9'–

~v.__ %.s:e€ping ;a5__ 3%3a1a:a.ce sf R3} Eakh anfi éespiéfi mgéatéé :°€<;}:§$'§

amfiiifii §%?'EiS :10': ggaigi azid %,hs:'£f<.3;%:*€:, '£216 ztemgéaini

K %:«é:§"§:'s thfi Sigma? F'{;3.,'2.1m. 'E'hs §'}i$$.§°;?.a:§ E¥'<;:*um afisz' c:":a<;§u§z"§;

afloweé aha <3mi€m3 is 33:15;

Ra} 13%}: 'fieézag 'gigs Eaaézmce amaamt ém: is {'.0m§§:%3'.~::a§:%:

W

'es;'%'il*1 imsmsi fizeraem 3*: 35%: pg. fgfgkm. :_;f

ifitgai Bfiiififi iii} 31% éaie sf pa}fi::e1}iAT§is'iii2 1'iE:&'- és:3 3:_. -a5:=;,A

§~:s.1,§s3§;» by @135? flaziaé 11.%::¢2§m. ";:?.;;;*;:;g ag-g:£a;;eg§_§;{;:rg¢ .

S3326': érfier passed by $236 §is§V§£;';%i_V":":7'–::;;z;3i;s%;' }; §,§.28G§
pefitiazser harem fiieé a.:1€iv'AAséVA:vQ\;e.:*:5 izhére
was ziaiajjar sf 254$ {}s;§*$ E.3'f§}é%éA¢;';V:,§,L1.: ..%%p§§.';{?§;é"fi01"} 22:33
fikzé far ca§:€§ar;;i::ifg§:;:j.i{1':Ve sJ<;mm.i:;s§a:; E33'
mfifizs tiatxsd $5 254% €§a§,.~*$ hag';

Emit Eaeeifi’ $§@w§i;;2g 2:213; §’§.’£fiiC.§€§3’§I
cause ” :10′ mafia 32:: fax” cazzaierzixig 323%:

izxartiéfiate d éE.ay” 313$: aefrzifrfimgly, {§iSm§SS€€§ {he agpficraiifiié.

” < ,.fr Cfiizdgfiafiszz @ f'{1::.§.;a.§,:’and canseipxexaéiy {he appeal is $130

{iiS@mi§$€ff1:#”‘:v}:¥aEiiiE}~§ aggriievvzid hy the said wafer ciaiegi

}.f:’>:_i petition is fiimi by {he agzeflargt §<=:§'9re

j the Siaf{é"£::8mV missikm,

H * W5 haw heargi €116 Esgzsaé mzmsfii agpaaiizzg fez"

pfitiiienm”.

mi”

E3, Learnaé csugasei apyearing far E:§1{:= x.’.§J€L§Zi%£§{}§’:&f:.€”‘ K

siihmiitafi tiiai {Jim ap§€:EEaa::.t was 33:}? S€f3;””%*’~*3(§ ‘Vu:i%3%1{‘Tv:}€;§33+<:z:.

beforfi the fiisézéci Ferum 331$ €316 <jE'l€§é:§':' ;'§1«_ ifiiizg

3985918 the Szaie Cammissian was 353$ 535.1% :0 .i}§§}€SS'~€3:f;§_§ZEf:V"

appeflazzt ané '§h0':.:gZ': §T}€fi}'1 mafia €313,
fiiifi' State Commfission Ijgggaé' VA r£;j§:3<:=.t%1:g me
apyiicatioza f(§If"3".v(.';*fi};_;':§i€-v.'3L"€'?33a;{3:fC}I§:€ 'a::s:§= c011s&qfiu€:;§}§; {he
afipeai ancii. by {Em Siaatfi

Commisgsion be 7°$é'z; 3§S§d5*

6. Wr; VE:a§%i:=_ “giv:.=.:;A”_; caraftfi causifiarafieza fto {E36

£a::’¥:¢1_§:1’£i’?:3-:33; of V”i;?:;é”1ea:’rz§e:i <3("}"11§}S€} agzpéarixzg £92" {aim

§r::'i.éi_3Z«::s;::e%° gcrufjggiseé the mafzariai 01": mcorfi.

0:1 zscerci wvzzaié show {fiat SE38 :1<3§:é{:€

fig the afigsllaxxé was issumi E33; E35 Qisirict §'a§':1m at {he

afiémss 'as: which iegai rmiice has ham: igsaeé.

Eéégvever, €336 Elfliicfi Was; ffiiiiffifid Wiifi €313 enécrgamfirsi 'fig

" §i;§%:h adfimssefi' aria the Eisiriazzt Fgmm Ezzeié $13: $16 neizice

ismifiri E0 ihe apgeiianf. 'WELS sufficiem: ané ihrsmaffer

W

pmcseded '£0 ziigposs 0%' fiififi mattfir an merits agigé is;

avexrad ihaét the agpaiémzi camfi :0 kv'1'1oxv'{)f.%.§:e a;w3._:j3a§':– _§:2;g s'3'€d

by the fiistzizrt Forum srsfiiy afifir ".;'ec&iv¢(?. ':1<3;§:i<§»s "of

executioxz, the date: an w11ich"*v%«§é;. rec;éiir':?*,-§f_1"Vfi:'£:3 in
€:XfiC"t1'Ei0fl has got baezi ~..$€n£i6fié£i':' –.t_}1e Légjpficefizion for
cemdsnation of delay that appellant
was aise suifgfisggj 'was advisesd 13;:

take bed :<t:s'1i,_3'.$ on that bshaif;

There is; which has no’: Ewen
satisfatgterfiy “;~:-=b.;»::’é¥:i::g my causa mucfi E383

sufiicglam cu:§»::.:_;z:s%c:_ agfmi vS£1’i?.i§§:E an the appeiiazsi is heié; in be

_. _ $:1ffi<:§?§<é$:{'}33z- D§§b@§i Fcséfum anai Siam .?omm has 3336 faund

tliai, t§:e :¢:fiz:1;%–:§s give}: was Sama its which Riga} notice has

gr'-r".f€V'3'7I.£..i§L§S%1é€}..,_S;fi};§;"V§f:i'$*€'{1 upon tha appeilaai and the data an

Whiéfa the mzfitice sf execution pfitition was received" by the

E133 not bear: $ta'£:e:<i in the applicaiiozz. Under {ha

" , 'uiiturastanceg, ifi the absence: sf any cause much Ems 3:513?'

u ..sa£fiicient caase shawfi in cendssming the inerdinaie {E3133} sf

VV 2548 days in {fling the appeal, the Stats {fbmmissien was

W

V " j:naex;._Ye§/ Na

jsmtifieéi in dismissing the appficatien for
dtitlay ané cansequentiy the appealfifié' 'avg: 'Ida
ground to difiiar with the View taken Stafij .,
as the impugned girder ;3asse(iV»i3i;a%L:'i31¢: $063 'V
not sufier {ram 3113*' @3531" a$'v–..§-9- §c3}§. far
interference in this writ ' V' A
Acco:ding13::,"t2;e

"Cjflge{ Eusfice

Sdl
Judge