IN THE HIGH covm' or KARNATAKA M' BANGA;,5"m;,M é DATED THIS THE 22% DAY or JULY. 20;é.._ *._V PRESENT THE HONBLE MR. JUSTICE 13 V :
THE HoN*BLx: MR. JUSTICE B; N
Miscellaneous Firsi Appeai :’§E'{>_, ”
BETWEEN: A ' }
B SURI~3N'DRA Si-4L'I'l"Y
S/O I.,zm:: I23 I-::RANN.»-fix V ..
AGED A1'~3('.)U"f' 62 Y'§5JAE-{E°'> _
RET1 RED J U2.\I.%.()R Ii3N(.}{.NEIvjR "
NEAR BI--fAI?'.A."'Ii'H 'I'AI.F{II*3S H '
MAINROAD.KAM1--f>L: Q - '
¥’3f3}1~LA1*W 173*$”¥’?€1″7″‘¥~1I.j’ 2: ;’\PI¥-‘Iii.,LA?£’J’
{By S1i”i R§v::ii=’e-;fi}’Ti.;*:..I’3é41’l:§1;-5}’);’2t.1£;51 *M;.m_j1.1Iz-1 N V. :”\d\-3:9.)
AND: —- . H A V’
E33/£’I’ s1,,?.;;IA’§>r-ms; S5’I3′}’.IfY ‘
‘
W/() B StJF1€i*;NDI%A ‘$3:-::’;~%1″:” ,
1)/0 M RAzv;~;\NA:.;x:::-:; Si+2’E”I”‘f’
AG1~;1:§ .!\;IE${)l§’%’551$-AYEAIQS V
” v 3/:’m1 ; ‘ ———- ~
‘R/, E3. ,.J ‘ . ._
~ :3Av.¢xr\$L:-.:>:I~z 13:’ — 00:2. . . . R.E§f%5P( rm: 1:) E$;’\£’i’
E
IVIV 4; ._
cit-7f”c’31’1dz.arafts 1 to £5 }1;n:’c 1′”: 01″ 1..)c-3011 :.11’1’a_w’:c.i as pa1’Eic.ez;1I .
The 1′(:{_L§ist1″y i’t’1″1.is <':ou2'E., on 11<'}E'i<"ri1'1;_.gj 1PIC§I'ILi'E'E5'{f1.S% i1:
{"129 pI"('.'-3011E'£:1.1'i0I1 ('sf1}'1(' 21;i)}.:w;»21._ maid 11<)E.ii"1't*(% 1.1171}?'11}:-:«–i_'§f1::f___fbg'
'- w I'; i ( ?'}"1.
1’eu’HI>’Vi-51b} .I(‘);’1§.ii-\’;’i.}.1.: i”j1 E«k’-
in tl’1<'-? appeal ':3ci.11§.: not in
in {he s..sui1', in l 1'I('.' Hc'I'1:f{". .r_s111V._c_-3:}V}’i» 1_iM3″ ;..)e;-‘1.f1’1t’>§: j;’1H1f?1c’ SL111 arc’
11’1is3si1’1g in the e1},>;:’)Ce–:§.””– ., ‘
E5. ‘<.'m1V3'<';AE1:itg_5:vgf }')I".s§1’\.’
that i;1’v1Et=. fin? a1pp.1’1E has 1:12-‘1c.ic;: thv
I’li)lI(.7’FV’i.1’L€$§ c?L1xi ti £,> 1’S;i’.1:1’*1c:é fit. E’-‘?l.€:;5.1’2,{)1(}.
‘ . a'<.§]{r.-":'2<.'i<z1'2i .4-"v'o.I Lo (5 is:
e:’l:§s:’::j1.is,§’c,r.:_g?_ c:nz.1._z,r (‘m”2Ic-?,’~::;Ii.1′:’1_:r; I’)cj/ie?:”zci<'z.r':I. NCL7".
_ Vf)§§f%:r'zcl.;zzVa» No.1 {'0 65 not 11c3c'r9sscL:"g f.i'1.is ap;.:J£~3(1I.
" .7Kir1L:{1§;: g2§{'(.'<.'}:)Z {he :s(.1mc. "
T I1′:…thi$ 1:):;1.<'I«;,j1’1T.11ac! z.’u’1d 512-110 of e»1ffz=1i1′>a._ IIM: ;-;1;;)].’)t-=a1
” _ ‘wVé.1’&..-: I.iSI.(“(l 1’)(.?1″(.)n-‘ 1’I”1t-‘* (_'<j.}L11'1 fol' &.(?(_.'.£'})f'.2:'11I('TC":' wt' Illt'
V
1'1EE}.C1 mod \='a1{a1.lz=-1§:'E'1 a11<E \x'l'1('1*vc.1’v m’211’1;=;’1%)1t’* in :.h<*
('oltrf 1)}; sc.*2"1cii.1";g' a :}l('H5t.'1"1g{("I' or if 1.12:'); 1121:} z-.2. f(.fI_e%p11o1':(_é
'1'11.£.1I1b('i'I' by 1'i1":gi11;;' 1.11.) and inf1.n'1ni1"1g___§ t'1'1c.:111.
10. \-N-‘c: a1′:=3′ no: 2m=’e:2′(.ii.:’1_}”{43
Rc*gis1:1*2;:1* in follmx–* lzhis 1′)1.*;’51u-?..1__§V¢-v V1′ zV;t’iL’cjf.}’>1.1″ VtH1’1Ti11″ £’
Eit.1’gaI;111t.s’ iI1t'(,’.1*t’..~5t’ £110′ not 0’1″ 1.1′}C’I’
1’1e;;l ig;f(::.1’1<*c;% or (%z;11'c1<r.ss.§; I1 A 1 1;;1 c;Li'.19' I_'S.
11. \?\»’b 211310″1_;(§£i<tc¥_ iigmi.' t"'E'.'1<«'5-'L' .j_:.1('l(.i1ff{,*&5S £131' sv1'\ric(? as
£1Idi(.:2.1.1,«:–*'(i""in ";:;):»11' 'r–:«1;5}'.1»–"1 <;1"'i'.1'1'c"m.0111c)1'e:111d:zm of z_11.)p:":~z=-:1
s1"t<.)\A:sa ffiti'._E1d(f1_I"€?1'.3i}-§".{fl .1)V:E~{'j'"{§,(_.1\'(}('£'1{('?H for t1"1(* 1'1D]I)€-'N2;-a:'1I for
*9
se1*\r'i(.'c'~ laeiizy' '2;: 3§}57/21?’. (‘}p;’)’;’:§ :’\1<1u'-11:1a.11a.('§('t\'i Roe-:Cl._ 1.);1ve11'15;3;<-~1'<*
_577?"€).(J2, '.7'J'u_do not 2f'i11<':1 a-my 1c2:l Acivm::.-‘1.i’. I)ci11__9_,’ {H1
1*(?(.;.«.__u_”(::} wEt.l_2″i§’1:_> 1:99;–21 :T1<I:_2:’;_)r’m’w
V’anotwif’i3§i~z;1.1’1ding mlv-~13 of (.}.’.1″1e1p1′.c–7.2′–\.~’} <1i'E'.é1c_" 1—ii;_'§h ('.To1.zr1 mi"
" KE:1-1"1'1Aé'1T.EI1}\'E't Ri]l(.'f'5., 19539. rm'-1(Ei1'z§.;' ass 1..z12c.1c1':
§/MM
I4' 'i"'1'a\’fci.i1′:§4; 2-1. l'<')ru21'1 wIai(*I'1 (_je"1"1":«{.'i'eé.\fa%\=’c?l_\.=’ to 1.1’1.<'=. ('I15-;~;_'–;1J1.i {?s 'i;1.j::.-sf ;11f'i'ss{.: 'V
wi{1'1i:'1 2-1 fnmilv. p;11'li(*:1l211'1\«-'. V=.A_1"@l;-;1..1Ti1'ivg ,1t':. '1"11z1:":'t"i}£_11Vif:v:14i_I’i{:u§:s;lV ;.’1.é%>
posxsiblv so %E’1z~1I: I::I”1c 1i’iig.j;’2m1. 11’ts:x1’V1!’V)m’:s t)i:?.1″1 1..’}%ub1i(‘: \4x-‘ma
approach ‘their (‘?<')u1'I. f ":1 fc:1£(.:_I' l§I}('3('(")'4I"{i5 '~?'h'(?._ J';-u'1'1i1y (.',()t%t.'ES ,<_{t;.=f.
SL1('..h relief at E'E"1<;'. :'.;.'e'.;t'Ii§:?-;.s;i:;» .
15. ‘l’i’i€'”‘A.(j’l.:. \=v’i:t’?-‘:’:”* <:)i.)_jE'i~%'(.*'i' 1'1:T1s a.a1.<a0 I':;1}<.<~1'1 (IE?-LIT.' of
1~eg1.zlat i_ng' ._1l'1L-3.. ;1'p.}j;:<=';2é1=.;_1'i1~:;;¥V… of the-' t11(:?t1}§.')C',I'.fE?s_esi2’v_’;–.1 f’é.’:_11.’i’iTy c’01.n”1 in 1′(>rm.*;~3 of :«;c;*c*1′:1’01’1 13 of
‘ V’ .I:}’1c;:- ,}A:(>1i%,Teéaéiimil e”1S””médc1′:
to legal Representation M
_~–N(>;I,i’.i..>z’if1$£.cmc1.ing ar’2_1;!iu’r’1_(.y (‘:or’2I.’a.z’r’u;.>d. in
“c_:g.r’iy lm.1.’=. no _p(..U”{y In (.1 ;~”;u.z’I or pr”()r'<e (.1 Fam1'ly (hurt shall be cezLz,ii:'lc3¢i.
as Q,’ rz’_qi’1I.. to be r*c=.>pr’c2se.r2Iec1 Z0}! (.32 legal
prac.’ {[1 EUR’ l€}?I”.’
I {‘3 –»
Cxzrimr {.0 111:’ (‘m.1:’t’. If is ;)1″c:’s:.1z’1’1{T:(i or t’_;111″f’.’:’1(” I—3211′ hzwv aha”? }.1)(.>1’missi(‘)1’1 of i.1′{_(= :rm.m
{.0 appt-“2-:11’ and l’1()l’I’1″%ilU_\;-‘ e’-’15; ;-‘2 1’112=511.1()1′ of }’}%’21(,..’:fT§(,.f.§.’.: ‘Si;;%.(I”§1
t,2.11ci€rs’s’s:e’.mc”11 1.>c:1’1’1T1i[t.é11;;~_;’ 21;;”>p.:;+2»-1:>.:;11:1c*c:f”
as 21 1’11zi1i:_i’.e1′ of (*()u1’sv_
18. HOV-V€’.\-‘(?I”. the st_21§ge Ii’12’1S’~’:’v’i;€f:£i%(‘}’1’§”{‘§ <:oL.1rt: £1213
to inev1'1:ab}y t:.'X2:1I",EI]i1'1€' in £:§'1<?
baCIig1’c>1,2:1d of iljie z3.p<pa.':r1': c 1:'1(.136; ly(V$14111gt'r I}1ETI1]1,)€'?1"S
of I'.}'1C':' I-3213' aé 1.h('% 1'-ml' ;.11'1d
Wm.) Iiijgxy Fifi' 1101' hav<_* ge'1.i11c-r('I any-'
cxperie11f:'e#1 221E:~; ;1ppe==:a1ri1’1;3; for 1″1’1£–‘ pa.r1″ie=:s
1:0 231.£z11’11Li.Iy’ (ii-Sf_)”L.1.i”«<-.? 211'1V=;'E i"2!1'11g \.-':-a1s:sibItf <:'<m.11,.1t’ir’.)1’1 of tin?
p1″o’L3Ien1V ‘ bf ” ;=f}’1 1:)a§’t”ies. hm 1*2:.1t’._1-391′ t’z21ki11;;’ up 21
j (.’.(,)1′”iff(.\}’I f&’}.’£’,i()1IE11 5%.;-n’1(I and 1’11(:=rst.i:1gg fzmlilj,-‘ (“§is1,):.1i”ér<; I3};
. <Ihr;-'*Tp.;11'1,i(;'5 215.5 211"2y <)£I'1m' iiti_2j21I.i(m.
@/
,;;';..
21.. ‘i’}.1. prc:s<:?£1l is: m"1{-' wi'1i(*E1 z11'i..’.+I’ s’;1…:1′ ;321.ss(-mi lT)_\T»* she f’2::,1niiy <"roL.:;'E_ (.§1':'c-'{.'ti1'1g_g' 1:116: 2-zp;.:)E.*ilz'11:1. to
p2::y R.<;.3.00()/~» p(:'s' m(J1}.I"I'1 1w2’11′(.i:e m.21£1’11’:(‘*z”1z§«n’.:<.'(=jVi}:'i }}-§\¢'()1::'
of 'the resp<m<'ie=:11i' wife wlm is 1i'\4-'iz'1g3; ..~ac-rpz.1:'21i'g:fE}¢*; A'
22. In m21t.t”.c3″s c’>f”Ehis :12-1i.1..11’c-*, .i:i.i1’1’\.a.-*£:.>.1″ (‘1 <1.) :1<:":.1 22t:§:');L\.:.:'22
can go for cief21L.z1t" zmd :i§:_§’.f.’»,”–;’.Qr: 0:11′ 1-16:”
sat4isfz1(.%t”.01’y 1fes1’1_oi’ the _£§i$§’;;)1.1i.;»s–:_ 1:Jei’,\§v”(::.>.,1j_1 £.i 1;5;r p;;.1’t’.1’ctss.
23. W0 an: (.;1.1iE’;.-;’_1*'<'-=..«. i7_1.i’1(;..I}’1c.\.g.’~.€j_§:1:;s.1.: ;==1 qH(‘S[%()H ml” iimz;
1’122.t’.z.1n=’; hz1_.LfI”<2.1._"<–t .E',.¥\':<'-:;' .<e:i:'1;._;'l<– §–3m:e<":'*2,_i\(..n"1sesic.ic:'c'c.:l by 1.1'1fs ::(.)m"t: in 2.1
1-eepg+;}tm, <:;.1V:~,;'¢:…V_'_V;si9 'MRS. KOMAL s PADUKONE us.
PR:ivcifiAIQ "'LIUBGE, FAMILY COURT AT BANGALORE
1"CITY«;4}Vf}v_v.Afii(}'THER' 11;' p<):'E,(==:(i :11 AIR 1999 KARNATAKA
425*'; .
9/
,. 15;
thfi’. Ad\:’0(‘.a.Ie;’ is v:*1′ E310 1v!vph:)1’1. z.1p1′>1’isc(‘i of
mesa ciev-‘(rl()p1’1″1e111.5 and 10 i:”1di(’21i.t.’ tihexi. 1″1′}E’ mz,1E:£”c1″ wmxld
be £:(>n.’1iI’1g up ;f(:’);.’ <:u"('le1".~:.~'. z.1§;;'2:1.i.1'1 on 26.7.20 EU é11f'1€'}'"é}_§.§'§31'iS€T
the 121x-x-'y<–?:' 1.1131 if t'I'1c_V E;£}'i' still i.1'1¥i<'I'<_*s'e1ec.'1 %:<)__–zi;.p}:)Aé'é:§f'*i.1'2.:'7ézE1:;
mzatmr on €:}'1e:1t. <:};=21y. ._
30. List 1.1″:i.S 1:”nai.1.{:1″ fin’ {‘)1″§i.3.rc?1f.s 1’1ViZ§;5’L’?.2() . .
31. Copy of t 11155 ()I'(.”1€I” :;1.1s ItC*.,V§”§’t’:’. ft.)}”Wé1.iTd'{If(‘§ :(1i1:tj(.Ti’]y ix.) tin-;.>
£}.pp€1}ei1.1″1!. Mr. B S¥\..I1″t’¥I”%::'(‘i.i”‘~2§E£ S’>t_:”.$1″i_\,j_ iii;fi’.1’§w’it.I’1.
w.
sd/~
JUDGE
,, ….. _ Sd/-
” HEDGE