IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA. CIRCUIT BENCH AT GULBARGA. DA'£'E3D 'rI~i1s 'l'HE 28": DAY 01? s1:«:1:r'rE::\x:<If31::,3;~\'~;----2Q.i_'Q°.:' " BEFORE '_I_'HE HON'BLE MR. JUS'i'I(3[i_ A,11f1f };Ji.:,ENa;.:i2\:1;V-._: X WRIT PETITION NO. 81383 oF._:z e 10 m.:I%c1sc; V BETWEEN: 1.
I3/\I;?>Y MONIKA v
D/O ume: I?3ASA\7;\.I§A..J’ NiII*JA._[AGIy 2
Age: MI’NOR,_’i?~J.. §II11:«:.i-2 AG 0.199»-y_I;ARs3 ”
U /G OF I–£.12I{‘«I;:\2-A’I’U1r2;\:, 1v1o’1’*1»~:112’R.= vi–N.E)UMA’i’I’II
w/0 I,Af}f’E4iv Bfigsavsxma .M1NA,JAGa.
AGE: 30 YIé1A_RS. “c>c4C–:..’j1~-1035EI>:o’1,1)
R/QI1_;;1v.NQ¢”1~a.;;_55 AN.I.__)’ ”
66 “A1wANg5z«:-s1Ii:§A: £1 RQAI) .
S’I’A’I’IOE’«I B2-i4..::A_R’= _ * –
GUI;E3Ali{GA–. ‘
.2. SM’E’. 1N’DU’M.AfIf1i1’~«,_
IV/Q.LA’1’1§-»:.3AsAvI:AJ E.\/1iN/\JA(L}I
1f”L:{.–‘JI:V-‘:<_:V 30 Y1:ARs–.–««9~c(:: 1-1()1,Js1
._ “L2/(:2 1-4»1.;\:*c)_;1-2. 155 AND
” eat’; ;’\4.I’VJAN}IE– .51 IA} £1 ROA
sf’1Af1f’i<)N BA-?iAi{
L;1,1_3;~;R_<:;;\.
…. . .P{‘E’I”l”I’ION EL’ RS
1′ ” * I¥3.v. JAI.1_:>I~:. A1:)v.. )
S?»/i’I’. I<As11=sm
R)
'3
W/() LATES i\/IALLISSI iAPPA EVIINAJAGI
AGED AIE3C)U'I' 75 'HEARS
OCCU: I**iOUSEi—IOIJD
12/ O Al\VANwIE'.»SI-"{A}—I'I ROAD
STATION IBAZAR
G U LBARGA.
A M ERS HA
S/O LATIE M.ALLI/x MIN;/yA:;;1.. 3
AGE: 35 YEARS V
OCCU: AGR1. AND M.)VOf;T.AT1″£%3
R/O i~£.NO.1wI 166 =
AIWAN– II:-S1-»-IA} 11 ROAD
S’I’A’1’ION BAZ.A.R
GULBARGA.
SANTHOSH
s/0 LATE y;A;_.(1¢1″;s;+i)-itérrfg.
AGE:30 * OCCU: 4.; " R/O 1A~1.:\io.;-1231 1663 » 4 " f
A1wA_N;£§-.3′}:-12>«;:;;i_I<::).kx:)" "
s'1'jAfr1oN ~E%}.AZA*é;{" _ " '
G 1;_1_.1I3AR<';A*.' . ._ '= '
SMT. :2/1Aw\I5':::vI, *1
W/O 1,A"'I~'E 's:.»-1A;NK:<:I-2~~'I?m0 GOTUR
g;G'1'.«:;. 45 Y1«:A_I2s
..'jWC:~<:(_:LL1: .1T1oUsI:i:~1-em.)
'R/O §i.N'0__.m 166 and 86
V' " ;\_1w;z-3N SHAI—–II ROAD
. -Ijsf1'm'iI'Q;_v 1«5';;A..;5:/xra
' . G1J1.I3A£<_<3A.
S1’».{I.’i’;”.A .1pAmvA’I*r~1 IBAI
w/0.. RAJANNA
n ‘ ‘AG1§ii) AIf3OU’I”‘ 40 YEARS
V ” ..O CCU: HOUSE-*II””lOI_.D
‘ (3.
R/ O :’\’I””I’AR C O M O U N D
(EAZEPU R
G U LI 3z’\RG/\.
f3s”vI”l’. INI)iRz’\
9.
.JJ
W’/O DR. LOI IIYA
AG ED 35 YEARS
OCCU: MEDICAL I3RACTI’I’I’I’ION ICR
R/O ASIF GUNJ
GULBARGA.
S3/I’I’. SI IAN’I’IIIAI%AI
W’/O BASAVRAJ PATIL
AGE: 30 YEARS ..
OCCU: IIOUSEIIOI-I) I
R/O II.NO~3~973/I–3
[\’I’I”AR COM POE} N I)
GA.’/’I 13” U R
CEULISAI-{GA
SM’? NIRIVIALA
AGE: 28 YEARS
OCCU: I–IOU_S’Ii’.__II’IIOI:.f) _ _ –
R/02-1.NG’.3~f-9.?3,/C=._ 2:
A’!””I’AR_.C{}MI§Q_U.ND._’ 4′ .
GAZIPLEIQ .; ‘
Gt;£,L3VA1-“2QA’. ‘_I’>A1=2A ‘ ‘ ..
AGE: 25 v1~:ARS”x’ . ”
occu: I10-us1«:-:_ :C’:L1′:’)~
R/(1.1–1.N0′;» ~:3-‘s1J’7″:3 /1.)
If xi;.’r1jAR ,(:0M1>U:.\s.1::’.; ~
‘ . ” :f;JUI_,I3~I<\»I'~z_(3;=,._
. . ''zxvIN'A§;::–§-: I
=.S/ O, ~p_Mj.I:3R1sn MINAJAGI
!\(_}I*3:a M IN OR, OCC U: STU DIfC'N"i'
" = «.1:-3AS2\\.fAI2AL1
u S,/O AMBRISI: Ix/11NAJA<'31
X\('.}I.E: MINOR, OCCU: S'I"1..Ji_")IiIN'J"
{!.30'I'II ARIC I\/II§\I(f)R$. E..}§.\3I")I£I{ (§E.4§/\I{I..)iA§\ISI III'
("N7 'I"I'"'iI.C§I{ NA'I'I.§RAi. I~"z'\"'I'I-II-€-Ii}
AI\/II3I{ISI§ S/(Z) E.1\"I'IfC §'v'Iz\I,I,IiI.S§'Iz\.I-'I'£\ MIN./X.}:*\(3I
of t"}i1e' ,__'Co.d"c of Civii P1'(')<i?:.~(iurLn
AGE: MAJOR.
OCCU: AGRI. I..EG1\L PRACTI’f”IONI’2I5€
R/ O AI\VAN~PZ~SI”IA.ITII ROAD
S’I’A’I’ION ISAZAR
G U MBARGA.
.. . R1«:$.I;’§E;>’N~ii)_’ _
(BY SMT. E\z1AY_.=\ ‘1’. 12.. ADV FOR RI–R:'”5 1<:…..,.. fa V
VINAYAK AI–"'I'{:I-. A.i.)V.. 1?c')-:<"'I. 1 UN1)1aR*.;gR*1f1c1.1.é’226 AN!) 22′?
PRAYING TO 1} 1ssm~:g4_x Mali” *c:»:j~’ (‘:–:.~:_r2″1’1AssEI;T.;QN.’..I.A.No. 15 IN
O.S.NO. 68/2004 V PRoDUcI1§:D” .251″ _£-\i\JI\PI%3XUI{E3 :2.)
CONSEQUEN’ ;LY’;g.I_)”IRI£f_3’F ::”1’1v~i”La “1;I;jzx–Ij’:~:RM1’1′ “1”!–2:»?
PISTETION HRS To’;gxMi:N1.)”‘*m 1;a”‘;>i.AI*NI* AS SOUGI 1’1’ 1='<)R IN
i.A.NO. 1, 5,~~I,a\_1 ":'~1_£:«: '11:s;.*1'1a;r-«:_1%:sf:' OI¥'~d.i;IvS'I'I(?I'oL:.0w1N’c._: * ‘ 1
2 zORDER
~ ‘~3’Pet:it.i0r1cérS 1ai1’1ti£’fs. The * 2.1m aw’ f1’1′.evecl bx;
E bk. 4/
“g_£2116’»Q1″dQr«.pz:1$st3jd by the Eezlrilcd Triai J1.:cig,_{(: 1’ejL:(.:r1,i1’1g
i’£/:3\1’1’V..I.A.N(). I5 filtacl un(ie1′ O1′(;1<:1' V1 RL.:I.€* 17
1908, filed £01"
V;:=2.1n(‘>1″1(1i’;3c%11′ of the pit’;-1(.ii1″1g_–_>;=_5 ssu 311.3 10 i11(_fEu(‘}(-” ihv p1″z.=L}.«-‘c1′
A “x’?_;1′.$c*f:i11\,2_>,” at 11aL.1ghI tI’1{_I aznd SQ)?” up by the
_ cic’%f’5<'r11(iz1ms"s« The ()t£'3c*1' éw-"(J :5_lI'1iC'I'](1E'11(,.'1IfS 2'11"? in I"('".5[.)(:*{_".I uf'
/W3
/
/
wk
M.»-""'?'
7
who sets up a will as cicftrtlce Etc) pr<)vc the s'~;z11'11e. II'1dC('("}.
in the case on hand. €..ho burden is on {he dc.-fc1'1(.iz;-11::ss to
})I'()V('.* the wi}!. N(.'\-'('I't§'I(:'.}(.'SS, if thv emit' for 1');'11'I.it'i_m1 'é-:5.[1-.0
be doomed, the c1efcncc.- set 1113 193-' £110 dc'.ib1'_1-:i;111'E'us5«.[f}'1é1:t'v ~
they are under the will, {ivi!1"«céri21ii'11y"be:ci£ i'*;.c,) '
consequence. He-rnce, 1 am oI'–v.tLh"e_viewn.t;haI:.T :i_:I1é":V}é'2ii'I1c:<:1
'I'rial Judge was c~1(-mgzjly iAz'1"" e:f'mr"<._i11 1'c3j'ce'(.:i:i1'T1g the
application for an1e11di11g.T o1"*t.}=iC'p1¢21fiii1fig54 If c)fu*11
said f;h21t. the ame;1'c1111c§;111,s, zj:1'"C. '1TVG C}V1'.f:'~i.IfL'.('IafI.() be 21l!()\\'('?(I, .50
as to 21v()icii'" I 1_f1"ui{'i;)i.i<§ii'3é':'.–3.51' ._j:§:*(:iw;'f¢:c2x:iings. i1'1c'!téc(!. om'
could Ifrgéféf Court. in the 11t’ does not
the 2.1(:!ciit:io11 of a new tfzmse of
z–£C::.f1__A(A51’1 or misc’ 2:1 c’1il’forc:1t case. but z1n.1(:)m”1Es
” ~. }511e1’cir1y 1.0 :1 (hi’fL’.I'(.*.I’7l'[. or z22u’1diE.i()1’12-11 2..1I)}’)I'()E1(“?}1 to
the same f2;1ci’s the-: 2;-1m_e1’1.c!.1119nf. is to be
211′} 1?} 1{I’I}}’1(.’.I}1 .
8
allowed cvcn z.1i’E’e1′ (‘><pir_\;' of the s1.z;mz1or_v
period of lir1'"1i1211i<.)11."
4. inched. as ()bser\/ed, in the case.011:”}’1;,ir’=:.{i._thc”
suit is one for parl.ii.i0n, defmlce iii-9: r.)m:? <)j§" é1–_v§-*i.ll;—.Pi<:I1.g:e…,lT f
am of t.}1e View that if i'.ht:-' .fa1(:is '.:11*'o vie,-ma' frcmj :1
different; 211'1gle and if a diff€1't?i 1'%._Vé1i)_pl'()élC'i'1_:55.11:-11§("'l1. Ihc
21_r11enc1r11e11t sought. (Ii)-flsfj-1'1()'A_i (.*.§_l":'r,4;.1;';~g__—{_Lr.v% irirac nz1turc oi' tin'
suit. at all. Hzaviug saiAci..s<_J;V. 1Y;111f1 iii'. t}":–L?.f}izic~\x.-r 1'1'1at: flu-'?
in1pL1g1'1Cd {)1'_(i§f.jl' 1i.z1b1'c _i,1V"Itr.§1'*f:'}i'éid.
5. HenC(i’;*’£§3e I’cI10w.i_’i1g.QA19def is rnade:~
Petition isVail1:(3\«fifc:<c71:[A"Empxlgnecl order set:–aside.
App1ic_a_ti0n * i"jVlc=.d ;. by "'I…}10 p1aint.ifi' pe1iiti{:me1's for
"=2¢1n1evnEin1-e1':i– A. '_.c_grV:'1'1'itAc:(1. Sllch 21.n1e.n<i111c:n1: s3he.1.iI be
i.:afz'V:?.iéici _" \.l'\»"~i.t;,}§.i}1 21 pc~:.'i0d of «gm w<:c-:?k:'~; fman mciuy.
TI'1Ae»._ Jzarticsn 3312111 1101'. vv2.1:'i'. 1'01' i'.i'1c;*. (..1@r1'iI"i<':~(.i .)v of this
” “~._ m’de~,1* E:L(‘)€:1 $11311 amt on the djreciions iss1.1cci. “E”11(-2
_ ‘t;i._::1’1c>I1I’: withirr 1′.\-‘.–“(‘} wc.=(r1«;s fronl the (12,111: of
9
11′ is 211:;-;<) t)1"(')11gl"1E to 111}? z1<}Ei(*cecdiaT1gs \vit11’j1T1 j)€5Ifi(3(i”–__(ji7 .;1’ii’1V§§
months from the ciate of i’€’.(‘.(f:*.ipi’ of this’c>1″c}<=:j; 5 A . VV '
Rule is iSSLEf3{'l a.~nd n'1e.;('i'c –. :;1'h&,:;i;?.1_Li'{(? f()"–.£1T1§ cxtvm
indicated above.