Loading...

Bageeta W/O Late Dhondiba vs Mrs Siddamma on 3 March, 2010

Karnataka High Court
Bageeta W/O Late Dhondiba vs Mrs Siddamma on 3 March, 2010
Author: Huluvadi G.Ramesh
IN THE? I:*f.EC}l--i (I(Z)L'f\".I." OF KAI-{N1-'\'1}.'\.KA
CIRCUIT BENCH AT (}U'LBA.R(f}A

I)A"]'I1ZI__):'I.'HIS'i"H;{3 :31-<2 DAY or? MA1eci--:1.._2*<Jj1:§j;~ VA

BEFORE

THE HONBLE MR.JUS'I'ICE H1..,11,fuvA1_jI' A GLRISM 1§:sh=  " "
M.F.A. NO. 7462 OF 2()o7; (ivrxfi  

BE'I'V\/EDEN

1.

Ba1gect21.

W/o. Late Dh(.)l'”idib§1.

Aged 29 y<321rss. Ocgj1"H01.'£s<;j}}A('5id_,», "~–.

2. I.(‘)kcsi’1. V ‘
S/0. LEITIC.I:’h(3.I’)di}.?E1. V
Aged 12_Vj{pe1’1ji:;»V; _Nij1’2;)1*,_ V

3. M2ur1at21. ‘ .”

D/’o, Late 1)hoVr:¢11?1a;i;A..[M§” %
Aged ‘V10 yeaI’«S,”‘M£t1§)r.! ‘

4. _I_;31’1tr:1, V

– / Q-., Late Dh tjraflri b 21,

‘ n , Aget3v.8.years. Minor.

” .g7;g1;i:x:’13%¢;%%1a’;::'”

A / 0 ,. L2:1’1j,c: ‘ D h on di b 211.

Agc?’dA4’yrs

* Urider g,I{L1aI’d1′.21n ()f{.}1C1’1′ rnc)t1i’1c-;é1′

Smt. B£1gecét’,a1., appe}1az.1t No.1

6. Sh21ra11ar11ma,

‘E2:/’

VV / 0. f:’mcr:.1pp’.:.

Ag_§<==:d 63 yezixm. (T)ctc.*: I–i1’1(‘)1c:1

Bee.1’21ppa.1,

S/0. 12-L'(LlI11£;’:l’1. Agcrci 68 years.

OCC: Nil.

All are 1’/0. Ja11wv2.1cia1.

‘1’aI1.:I<. &. Dist 1'icrt_. Biciar.

(By Sri. Sa1’1t.os.1’1. I3i1’a1(:Ia1*. .’3;c1x_g’.L)(:2;11 c,)V_

AN D:

1.

-CI ,AI’M

‘ B21:»:.:¢1\;’eS11’\v.f;1i’VCh(‘:~wk, Bidar.

Mrs. Si(lci2-mnrraz-1, _ -_

‘N/0. L2-1t.ek Ad€Vetp}’)e-TLV V
Aged: 55 yealfs, Q<:'C':' a"

R/0. H._No; ‘:;;,;8#2:70.; Jyoti: Coi1*o.ny_,i

“E’1’i’e B17ar’1c_h ~NiAa.1§z;1gt::Ar… ” _
N21ti0~.1’1a1. IIISLI 1’}:1n(‘:€” Onlpany I,i’.(i . .
B1*a1’1c:1″1..Office, ‘ ‘

S1b*’i. R,V«…_ NaCiz1g0uC1a. Adx-‘()Ca1e for R2._
T_1’=J1r)t’i:;c £0 .,R> 1 clispcmsecl with]

1iH1ég:LMFA FILEI) U’/S 173(1)

FAS’I’
P F3’I’I”I.’IOJ\§

gV/

j A f} 5-/\j3.}j(:!1.:i.:”:’£i§; 5v ‘ .’

: R@sp()1T1dC1T114s

OF Mv ACT.

AGAINS’T”‘ ‘I’H}33 JUILDGEMENT ANI) AWARD 1)A”1″EI)
21.1_’1_.2iO06 PASSELD IN Mvc NO205/2004 ON THE:
% ‘FTILLE OF THE PRESIDING OFFICER.

:C_O”URT–II 31 MACT. BHJAR, PARTLY ALLOWING THE
V FOR COMPP3NSA’1″ION, AWAR]..)ING

AV _e::0MPENsA'”r1N OF RS.2,f_S().40()/~ Wl’i’I~I1N’I’1ERES”J”A’l’

TRACK

‘.».J

8% PER ANNUM FROM THE DATE OE'<" PEI'i'i'1'i()N TILL
"ITIEI DATE OI' REAE.,IZ.A'.l"IOE.\I AN F) SEEKING
EN HANCEMENI' OF COI\/IPENSATION.

“I’}’11’s MFA c()111i1″}gg on for c_)1′(‘1trrs. 1}’1i{j3”:é1ii§;x.:’l’1’1t?
C()1.u’t: cl@li\«’C1’eci} the following: ‘ V’ ‘-
JUDGMEN:I’

Though the 11’1a11’c’-:1′ is }iS’iié’«_d 1111…’):-cfin=_x–s ‘t”‘c:(iVé-iy-.–..«\iI?iw§.’}”1

(?o:’1se11t of the }.(?2 11′}”1(;’.d <_r<)'L1_I'_i's:="} on"}3o1.31_S'£de$_.'"E:-.1'1i’ by”‘i:hi,s HJ31.:dg;n.c1’1t.
For the purpose of (:’o’1’1’ueizhiénce.0″the?’parties would be

r(~:fcrred to, a:¢:.:th.cy 33:40 :*e1′”er1je’c1’V0’i11 i:I1e..Ci’_l21i.111 pcimion.

_ . V’E’h;i.s.’~._ 21p1)’cé.¢T~.,1’ii€d by the (:12:.im2;1n1′.s who are
flu’: \Vif’c%.’* n1i1:1o1′._jj Vf:I*1-E1A_éirm”1 and {)2-1£”(“”I’11S of clmcaxscd
I*)hondibe01′;..s(:<z}<.i';1g,6nhéu1.1’1sat,Eo1’1. ‘1’he

(:13?-:11 0’1o<3tit:i()fi=.. .\:xfa1S«. filed by the <t}a1'rnam.s–appe!1e1m,s

A '11′ twh(3*-:ie’a0’é’.:1 Dhondiba who died in e11 motor accidem

“*.;11;~.~f i’i’c’1-if—(‘)f€{tV1.1r1’ed on 09.05.2004. ‘1’hc (éiaim was

(_%(:~1’__11we_<_;.*xcédfiay 1':ht1° }I1SL££"2.11"}('.L'. c:.rcJmpaI.'1y.

3. In s3u.ppd 11″1e1’1’1scI\-Fes 2′-1:3 PW 1 2 emd. 1)3’fQ(‘}1..1(‘(é(i

(‘1<)(tt11'11c11i.s wI"1i("h \v('1'c-: Illa"-l1"1i(i.'d. as Ii3x;;'i"'~';.1.'V'.i_§) 1T}?_.'£$..

O1') be1'1a1f()fi_1'1c 1"c'.=sp(')1'1(l('111'..:9, 1'10 c.'.\:'1'(.1L*:1c.?::.\-§"2:.§sV in.

4. On the ‘f)Ef1.’:’5i-S of the i1j”<==r.<s?_;_3c=:?<.jii\9'.c:L1*:;1c11t..eii*y _cvid}:m0c, and
takillg” age of the cié(3r5e1séc1 2’E3j ‘3{<3f2-e-1's and asscssiilg

the i11(:<)me <.)_f*1__hC cfi'(?%CiE.-:'1};€-r(i' RVs.1«V.8'()0/~ per mo1'1th

and a*1ft:'€r:a'–.dtjyd1.:1Vi§i;i':=1.g".1'/.3"!'""0{7'i't. tm-ve11*cis pc1's;()1'1a1 and
1_iVi1'1g;_§;.,' exp<31i;<i§:.–:s-.,"<:f "111"1'c.. 'c1c*t(%<-saseci amd app1y1'ng____{ thc

mu1t.ip'1i€r i1"; ';1:fiif'21.;;tiéCi 3: sum of R.<;.2.30,400/–

A : Mailti 01.1 V *

1'.()w'snfc.1s 'I<$s.<._; of.«:}tii…i’11.UH I110 (iau-* of1*c3z11im1′.i(“)r1. Cim’11’:e1″1(_1i11g’ um. ihif

(“(_)1:1})e1″1sa11.i(.m 2-1\.vz11′(:ic*c’i 1i)y the ‘1’1.’£b1,111e-11 is r101″. ‘j1.1sE. and
:.’e21s(_)11ai)lc. ihc (‘§a.i111e1m’.5 112-we 1_)1’0f(*:”:1==tc:1 1.1113; _;1T__pp<=*2':1l

:scei<i1'1;_§ en1'1a1T1(re111c1'11 of m111pc11.s*2-11ion.

5. ‘1’iT1c-: 1€ra11’11c(i (‘t01.111sci for N10 21})_pG11aAi’i’i.§ i*i–1″S’1–.Fy

c:c)’nf.e1’1deci that, the ciecezzsmi wasa4cé211i”i’1i1’§g~ .i;f:1c)i”:%’_’ ‘t.Vl’1-a_;’1 V’

Rs.4.000/~ by c1c)i1’1§é§ crollie w01″1{:._é’1’1f1(i1 1’flic%.1’¢f’C)1’11’1c–é of the (‘1e:<%_Q_IV’11.e1;{1éc1__ 14_1?1_nt:, t1’1011g}1 the: 1’1umbcI’ of
c1epe1’1de.1’1m SCVE?IT, 1}'”§.E?.T1″i131.1I1£1l orlght to have: c.1ed1.:(‘t.c=rci

1/5?”? i11stc2a11*..__df’ 1/3″‘ towards perso11al of the

‘cEc::(:cz1S€_d, “~..I,ast.1y he cromcnded ‘that. the c:01npe1’1sat;.i(>n

” ~.2-i’V:f%t1’d(‘:51.”»»..13Ei l.}”1e ‘I’1″‘ibun2.1l 1mdc1″ other (;tm’1vc1’ati0m1i

1’1éé1c1s’*– Ais}-i1s() on the lower .E5i(,’1C 2-ulci t’..hc.1″cI’1’c, he prays

A’ ;”(‘n:_e1’11V”1e.z1’T1 c.:e1’1’1c,>1″1l”. 0 f cornpc:11ssz1t.i011.

¢~’/V’
3?’?

(S
(:5. Per (*.011E1’2.1. Efiri. R.\»*”‘. N’a1(1ag__;'():.1(iz-1. t’.1’1(‘: lc:2:.1″11e(“1
(‘:1’1(ic:’1£. i11s;1.zm1’11’11pa1″1y

1’17_of {he-2

evlc.1c=é11(‘:c on rec.:01’cl in proper pcrsp(r(?11’ve _eji:;i5i%2’1′:5cf’;e.::1 5_j:}.1s«1

and rcasc)r1able (:.()mp<31[1etse11im1 it cicue-rs"~n':(f)~1':. "c_*.ai«Es __fb1~.

i :1 Kerr rfe re 11 cc .

7. It. is not in c1is’p:._1_E”j_(3}”-:’E_1a-LL. c.11.1.1″1’1’tg;;v1l’1gi?(:o111’se of

enquiry. the c:127:i111a11:1i’ts§’ 1’12§wc§ c?:,::s1é1–E§’li$1a–cd the 1’ac:1.urn of

aC(:idc1’1t.. i1’w_Ji’.(§%n1(%rit:”” of d.()Q 1′”~’ Vehicic bt3a1’i1’1g

N0.K’A–3_8./ V1E’}.:2.¥,.,_, “:;”e. iiht-in-c>.11__1_yAp(.)i1’11. that arise for my consid<31"a1.i<)r1

V ' .i¢;'1V"'i.1'1i§'s :'2;1p ;:s.'-?:jg1l 153:

= ~ 'V/?\_/'1jm.'1l'1(%1' £110 (.:lai111aI1ts–appcllz1mS 1T11a.de*. out
A f_ (',£,lS(? for @1111anc_:c111cn1. of compe1"1sz::t:io1"1?."

8. Re. Point No, (i): In so far as {.110

q1.1211’1E’11n1 ofc0111pe1’1sz:1.E:i(“m i$ (‘:()1’1(?(>1’11c(‘1. a-tdmiE'{.(rd1y. the

21c(:i(:Ie1’1t’. in (:[1:1es’:’1’01’1 had 0(*.(%1.1r1*o(‘I in t:l”1c..~«3*e’z«1:t_ _2C*§)4,

Merely bu;-mremse Eillcre was no (10011111:-i1.’1,L_§I*.2.’yV».1j’rQ(‘;{ ‘inu ‘

s1T:1pp(>1’1. of the i1:1c0mc of the :>{i(‘.(.’.Ci1_f§{.'(f1′,–_ i’I”1_ ” v’_i&}’w’~._(_)i’..J,h?::

001.1131′ CVid(‘.l’1(.’.(,’ of P\Vs.i=’& 2. 17t ‘V-vfx i’1’1»:C <.i .(*.(é;(1.SC (}1 R;s.3,()OO/~

per month {Rs.1OO/V~'–<.pV:(::1'_ ci:«_1y);;_.u F..1:1*s:E:"i'1«:r, as Eihe n1.nnb<-'21'
depe1'1.dc1'1.ts ofathe clr:rf’ ‘I /I311′ t,.o\,vards

pe’rsO.11a1l_ 21_n cIv.’v1i.x;_it’1g e.xp-c:_1[1ser.é4s of the decreasscd. As per
the Lrc:+p()1*i’:–. {hf 01′ tille (100021:-sc(‘i was 28 years.

{h§3§ “ap1:)1*()p’1″iézfiév nh1.It.ipiic1* that w01.1]d. be 1ne1c’ic

. a}’)pEi(jé1l’/).ie’ z{.::1 the 1)l’€’.S(31″1f” (.’..’:1SE’ as per Eihe (‘,li(“i1,lH1 (_)ftl1&-r

‘ J-\’p–<:;v; Cmi_§_u'__t Samia V'crm.2_1's Case 17. '1'hc1'cI'()1*e,

tide" ('%!.aii1*12111ts are c::1'1t"i€"led to (tompc':r1sa1.i0n of

A1?{S*;{L8v§,6O0/– t:()wa1*ds 'loss of (.1c=::pc1"1dency" (Rs/3000 W

/'5th =2400 x 12 x 17 {1'm,1]t'ip1ier) 2 Rss.4,8E»).EiOO/~)_

in zmddilioxl. the (:i to a11(‘)1’.1’1(~1′

XX

51.1111 of Rs.:’30.0()()/- 1’11’1(ier other (tonvc-:1’11:10112.11 1:1(:2u.1s

viz… ‘loss of }_0\=-‘0 a-u'”1(i 251ffc.(:ti011’. ‘loss of (r01″1s(5:jt’.’i’:gm’.

“1’1T11’1c1’a1 L%x13L>11s@s’ and ‘loss of (f.<;f.211'c-2". T11113"'1'1«;. 'a…!._{.5igfm;

('7i2.1i1T12':11'1ts would 13¢ c1}1'.it"}.eci 1'0 R5.5.I3E3,£5GO..['»~».. ";~'.(:)1:.1'1.L'1§5ci'«..

of to Rs.5,4(}.OOO/~, 221.5 :;;_gm:n:5;i1V 'LTT1§s.'2–.;:3L3';2_g)(wa;.T.

Ac(:0s'di1'1gly, 1 e"11"1s\ve;' p0i1"';t_ f-0.1' (icr-;-*1'1'u11'12.{{:i(':A:;:1'V.i.;V1W'fax-*(;)11;i »

of 1.110 a.ppel121z'1ts a1"1d__1.)ass t11¢;i1:.11i(awi1'1g':

i] TvE","15t'?'..V£V1'_'[3[J63:7:A'-11 i'ik§.{i '(%I;;i1:n1z11'11'.s allowed

——– _ : ;~J;; ‘p§;ia:;t«_.

” Of the J1.1<:1g1'ncr11'{ and award
passed by the P1"esic1i1'1g
A. Oi;i3't:'(:'i*–;–Felst. ']"1'2-Lck C',m11't~Ii 2m(1 MA TI', Bidar
1VIVC.N0.2O5/2004, the ct0mpc11sat.io1'1
igayz-11310 to the claim2.111i':s~21ppc1h111t'.s
c:1'1ha;1.11(:eci from Rs. 2 . BO . 400 / ~ to
Rs.5._4().()0()/+ [Rupcc.s Iivc 12:11/ms; ikwty

U']()L.1Sé:iI"l(.1 o1'11y') w1"th i11iL.%1'cs1' at 141%'? rat'_.e of

b"?/o ;.)c1" zm1m1'11 :1'1'<m'1 {he ('.iz:1E:c of §)('1iEi()I'1 till

1 he 1:12:11' 0 1' 1'c-%et'1 1 i 921 E i0 1'1 ,

In View <_.)fE.}1e c1T11122n1(r0rm-:1"11 of c*_r;i»:'.1'1p'(-33'.

pE1yE'1b1L' to U19 (t1a.iI112u.1_ts. _'E'":1'V1"C""'!.5j'ii:)i'.:1i;11 "
CU1'(3(',TC3C1 1'c=%–c'ii_s3t1*iE;)1i"€«c 7_A_At*E'1:(*, 1'*E'i{.5i"T§1.}'j-E2'l'L;3"' 1uié:1f1

p1"0p()1*ii()na1,ely E1_lj'id" (j)l'(I1.é:f1".__ fcaif Vc1.c.p'r,§Si'{.~V:51" i'hC- V

a.m0L1111; in the-3*"";1ém1éé"~_of t1"1e.. p;Li1'101's in

acCorc1anc.c \-'Ji't'1'1' L-1::;u-'»'.

Sri. R.V._'”_i\I21c121g(3i.ic1é’i:. Acj1’»*_(‘é2’i’i’e ‘i;€é’ C1il’€§C.’i”{.'(‘1 1:0 {EEC

his n?)c11m_ b’15”._-;»1.pljeelrzmcfi for tho 2″” 1*csp(.>1’1(1€:1’11: within

four \,v(éc:k$.,

VR

$£.é;’j”

§§§@E

Sfifw
§§§$E

i”(‘T;._I”§i’ .

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

* Copy This Password *

* Type Or Paste Password Here *

Cookies help us deliver our services. By using our services, you agree to our use of cookies. More Information