EN THE: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BMANGALGR-E5"T..'_
DATED "5313 THE 301% DAY QF ?v'}~'AY 2o:;"- « I T'
BEFQRE
THE HONBLE MRJUSTECEZ S'L';fBHASIf1 s.A:::% V'
MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL i5¥'O'.':87;4'5_)'2.{}
913;'? - ..
M.F.A.CROSS OBJEC1'I61'J,NO; 53'/20":;,;; N 'V
IN M.F'.A.N0.87'45/2010
BETVVEEN:
Bajaj Allainz C:€I1€I'EI}~h'1S£lf;'<1I'1"L'€
Company Lt<:i., I _-- Z.
No.363, Seetha 4'_\/'i.l_as§RVo_ad. 3
Mysore Repres?3nt€.:1.b}?"'--V._ b 4' _ V.
Bajaj Aflianz Gene:»?aE'V¢;Inscranée' ~ V
Company Lttilg - _ AV TL-V
N0.10'7, TivB.T0wer:5"V
Mission R0'ad§
Bangalore r€p_re:3Aen'te.C1V b V' "
Asst. Vice PresLi--:iVen.t, {C]_aiIr_1s}=.,
4_ _. { R; Ren1ii:'a.,. :Ad¥.'}
1";
" _ V/:1)" Ré;ma:3._aiah
' Agéd gbo£:._é=¥}~2 years
Ramanaiah
n 3/0 Mizsalaiah
* V Aged about 48 y6:ars
Bggih R/0 Munéagadere Viiiage
7 Arakere Bablig Srira::ga§a?;ria '§'aiuE~:
Marzdya Eisiréci.
(4: APPELLANT
Kumara
S/0 Masthaiah
Adult. R/0 Pamhaili Village
Beiagela Hobli
S1'irangapat:1a Taluk
Mandya Districi.
(By Sri.K.S.Narayana Swamy, Adv. for 5' AT
IN M.F.A¢CR.C)B.N0.58 2011
BETVVEZEIN:
1.
Subbamma
Age: 45 yaars
W/0 Ramanaiah
Rarnanaiah A _ H
Age: 50 yeaI_iS~,_
Both are V1’§:si:€iiq:j3fg af ‘ . VL
Mundagadgjijs: V V
Araliere Hotbhg $r1rangapatna_*Ta1uk
ManC§ya”I)isUfiCt;”~ .. CROSS OBJEICTORS
{By Sri.K.S.Né;i’2gyanfiVVSV§§:§jny,’iéféadv.)
_1}ND:
‘V ” _A”ge: Majo
as/0 r§2i5$:ha:ah
‘ Rio ?_ai~aha1ii.X?i}iage
vfirilagbéa ‘1rIc;}§3i;Z.; Srirangapaina Taluk
” ANi21’r1dya- Disfizrictg
The E\}ianager
Bajagfalainz Genérai Insurance
AA Cgmpany LUZL,
= _N(>];36:3% 8&3:/ha Xi’ E1215 Raaeti
A’ M32301?
.. RESPGN§);E1NTS
.. RES_P{)3§JDE§E»§;1″‘”:; *
50% deduction, i’: has awarded eempensaiien of Rs.9§91V,E3-.00/~
with interest.
3. Learned Ceumsei for the appellant W in_sML__1r_er_s’fi}§I:1_iiieCi<T b'
that {he licence was adniiiiediy in the :1a_fiie«.V’£;1S ;:1’so éebmitted
that, even after the death ‘ef:§1e licence was
renewed. At any ‘eouid not have
been ‘taken by 35 there is no
material to_p1_fQVe iiie f::.;:a:L_rV1V1_e _ .. V g
4. C11 thee’other ‘?1an._d;’..1earned Counsel for the claimants
submitted ‘t.1j22{‘L._ eiaeifI:«;éi13.t”V:€ather of the deceased is 80%
physically hafidieappe-:1A:2VriG.e.’~~he could not manage the stone
“erushi:1gi:.we1’E:Vvand fi2e..__deeeased was earning much mere than
F3.§.”;§;E}QO;’;”pe;: “‘:Qr1th. On account ef the uniinleiy death if
the éieeeased,’«–‘V.’i:hee:=eexrents have lost not eniy the son, but 3130
me in<:(:{::ze;'_ . '
per ELXPIB, the licence was renewed again on
The eerzientieiz ef the eiaimante :E:a?i;, en 3.eum of
fieaéh ef deezzaeedg éhey eiepgjeé e”{e:1e <::'uehei1:;:_§ xerefk
c
(J)
1
appears fa be incsrrect far the reasm’: ihai the licence has been
renswed even after 131% éeaéh of the cieceased. it gresuppeses
ihai, parerfgs ham ssntizzued ihe siege crushing werk. ‘§”£VG %’.»f€§E{§’:}’,
cantribufian of the cieceased in assisting the fatheii’?-‘ _
N32 in the sigma crushing vmrk cannot be :_?.is;:*1_1_i::’c:Ci;’–..:E3;1 -«.
éZ}§}§I1iOfi., caxziribuiian <3? the deceaséfi '<::f::11,1<§. ':36.' gsiixfzaisd aff
Rs.'?,E«{)0/~ per manth. I4: is mat' 1;: éiépxfte iha3i»v"'V£*3.::.*:=:V é:ec€ifa:t§éi:d *
was a bgcheior at the time of in cf the
same, {ha €i€C€2':'LSf';'d must his If 50%
is taken and if multiplier of Ais' ycaunger paretnt
is aged abcsut 3§§§*€$§:j$*at élaim petition, the
claimants are' *" (Rs.3,750/-X12X15}
tcwards If3'SS"<5f é¥,gé§i;'1s'i§Rs.9,{)O,O00/~. Yowards
medical entified fer Rs.81,00C%/– and
further on e:{1Vr3r1’ti’1’§?’::3l: _§i<3x:1pex'1?5at3Q::«.of R$§25,{}{)G/-. In all, Ciaimants are
"z:::::§:1's:1V fgra R§;?'_,_61,G00/'~ as againsi Rs.9;.91,80{}/~ with
interest.' V
Acéaféiingiyg ME?'.A.E*~3§.8?'45/ 2318 flied by fi'}€ insurer i8
" in. ?arv*¥§?": 3*"
§§§_§*a_ar¢é;’,¥ it: View Gf aiiewéng Qf apgeal cf the insurézx :*ed1;as::i:1g
C0i’§3§€Zf}:1-‘Siétiiéfé, C3935 Q§j€{3{iQ§”: ?$3.§8g’2$}3 stands
W”
fa:
M5-
dismissed. The arneunt in deposit be trzmsferred to the
Tribunal.
. , “””E~;§3¢ssr:zs»§ 5″” H
Cepy Di the cxrcier sheet cf the @931 may be S€.11t_7L0_ih€
Tribunal forthwith along with the copy of the judg;:::ee’r’if{ .
case. _
KNM/~