% § ' 9 3 a~.9.w§3ALoaE
IN THE HIGH com? or KARNATAKA AT k
warren THIS 'me 23"' DAY OF MAY2:GO$9:V.: ' A'
3EFOR£*"'
THE HOWBLE MR. JUS1"I;€:E3i¥§:V\i\?AD"f«f@~!'}'b€ "
. CRL. A. %f¢9%.=993.%%995,9996,
993, 999, 99;7_%cu=x2oc<:;9 L 2
BETWEEN:
BASANTH i<UMARHP_ATIVLv._ . %
s;*c.T.K.P9:cr;L _
AGE9 A8'Q§«,.£T"S7:3YEARS *
occ._a:.Is9;m:s's; s§,<m*.._# 599, H 9
I'A'MAIfJ';_,.HSR :.mV., ma M/S H.R.
Afi§ANTHAKRISHN;AV_mJR'fi{Y 9 ASSQCIATES, ADV-S).
'AGE,:'.3 Aa::9w;9s5 YEARS
PRQPRIETO§i,' M;s.MAHALAs<sz-M
. PIC'TUR;--ES,' yew 99:. RDAD
WMAHAL VILAS EXTENSIGN
MRESPGNDENT
COMMON IN ALL. CASES
kT l_ ""':f'$y sax .K.R. LANKESH, Am/., F-'GR W3 59:
4 "9€:.}{'.'£\5AGESH Assocmves, ADV$.,)
*#*
5/
V' héaf'_r'i :*:.a";--v. _
"§
in
THESE APPEALS ARE FILED UIS 386(c)(iii)OF C.R.TP.C.
B-Y THE Am/C3CATE FOR THE APPELLANT ?RAYI_.N~G"-..THAT
THIS ¥-i0N'BLE CGURT MAY BE PLEASE!) T0 ENk!A'§éCE"THE
seweuce or FINE AMOUNT TO THE%:%%Tuz~:§%A'<::s%%
RS.10,G0,0GG/- DGUBLE THE CHEQUE AMOUNT OF
rz.s.s,oo,ooo,r- AGAINST THE RESPQNDEfi"T"A!;\iD 'AWAi?.D"r
SUITABLE ENHANCED COMPENSATION ' T§DV.THE- APPELLANT
IN C.C.NO.293.86I'9§, C.C.NO.291€-4?/99,A."C.C.,NO§29'15S/'£§§,
C.C.NO.29192/99, C.C.NO.2.9190/'9_9',L_ C.C,.i_5!C};v291E'%1f99'--..
AND c.c.:~:o.291e9;99 €3F*i_"««.'§'HE '=FILE_
AooL.c.:~m., BANGALGRE, _
THESE APPEALS'%A%k_ARE~%'§ct:rs%:k§i<?a« oN"Fo'R FINAL
HEARING THIS DAY; JTHE Lkjcoumh 'DELIVERED THE
FGLi_{)WING:~
Tffzes_e.AT*A'a'v?.:~*:;ge;a_éVAi2» mtfé- ,._fé5.es3 under the provisions of
Section "3.? }'. Carnpiainant against the
§ent§g2'1r:a.en 45;h'e.A_d:*fiiura ¢:5 tfiat it is inadequate.
_ ffhe a'bp~aa~£s are admitted and are iisted for finai
3'; stage the amaeiiarst has flied awiicatians
in %¥s§isa;:'€:r3.A No. 201532009, 2015/2099, 2018/2909,
kk%%%k2a;z2/2039, 2020/2909, 292112909 and 291932009 In an
afipeais, rapectiveiy under the previsions of Section
/
é
394 Cr.P.C. to eermit the aepeiiant te substitute one Smt.
Hemaiatha Rameeh, as the resparzdent in the epeeei in
piece of Ramesh since deceeseé and to per{z3.iif
proceed with the anneal.
4. In suapart of the a9i3i:i¢at§§:_:i1..:'It"is axéerrefi.e.:ha:A
Sfiamesh, the respondent ie'ti*:.i§ afiap-eei wae'v:'éejrf.#iV:ted
the teamed triai judge ufiée jud_§_ei:je:’-evdated:3e-U3-2604 in
c.c. No. 29186;’1994, c;é;N0*e.2eei87xea;’ec.;2e19«%a;§e, gf<:.c.rs:o.29191/99
Am te.e'"b§'fence punishabie under
Section 61' and was sentenced to pay
Rs.7,_25_,fifiG'/- e'w-Sift. sentence cf four mersths. The
""~..5;g;}.j"":se;e§:ee¢e i:§eir:':§"Vi:':ede::uate appeiiant had seuaht
";'1urinq penéency cf this aepeat the said
S.§Re:%nesh.e§–e:§ and is not aiive. Neticirn; the fact ef his
"~.~. __'=.death " new seeks te bring his wife Smtfiemaietiwa
4 his ieeal heir, as respenderzt. Eectier: 394 Cr.P.C.
' is? imrekee. The eipeiicatiens are eppesed by the ieamed
ceunsei wine ie repreiersting ariaginai respcmdefit —
Sjiamesh.
5. Tim fact of death of Sflamesém, is 21¢?i§.’3\’i5xV £3.i–;%:;3::iii’..en.
The auestién is whaher the aprelications
sasbstitute tfie deceased cmwicted:-aécused”..by_;v§:§§:v @3331-1hé}a’s V ‘ j
is fiermissibie. V __ _ A
5. sectmrs 394 <::=.s=V.cJ.,j%,j*raads;*::m;s:k_L
"Abatement of avrmeais 1.. A'
(31) Ever?' az3i9ea£ u:13_;§er"' 9.? section
3?8 shat! na!iyA'.,_aLb;ate'oAn. t§1ev &a:ast'h of the
BCCUSEC57 .
&§.€:iz’ef’. 3;i:::éai”~~aivr§dez’ this Chapter
{except”ae:1..__a;.:Apv2=;i””»f:’ert*§ a sentence cf fine}
shaii _fmai’iy}..ab.aE1’fin the death of the
app.e iia,nt: ” ” ‘
;’Previded-. mat where the appeai is against a
._”””«:.c;3_fwi5:tion a…r.t..c.:!«’ santence of death or of
_ ” ifiagbfiseizment, and the appeilant die’; during
V. “-V.Tth.g”%;;e.n1dancy of the appeai, any of his ma-sat’
freiatévesf-.mav, “withir: thirty days ef the death
. sf f:f%.’-¢-i.-‘;_ appeiiant, apply tn: tha Appaflate Ceurt
far ieave tea continue the appeal; and if ieave is
grsguted, the appaai shai! not abate.
‘ “~.,Exn-iaraaticsrz –~ In this sectian, “near relative”
” ..*means a parerfig, spouse, iineaf descendant,
brather fl?’ sister.”
;’»m/
5/
‘uh
?. The nrcvisicfis of Seatiors 394 Cr.P.C_..V’駧a_r§v
érrvifiaaas tfiat ‘every appeai under Sectier:
Cr’.?.C. Sinai! fiaaiiy abate on the deaf!) ef w
Sectior: (2) aravides that ‘every 79therT .é5fi’b«e§!..’ uh’d’ar_____Vf%§§Vs’
Chapter (except an appeai f?’finj a V$egi£ence.’v:§f*V_:f5:z}§) ‘;ish.éi§
finaihr’ abate an the death of tvfTi*xe a2::V1:ae§E”a’§’1*:tVV.:’_ iiiravise to
Secticr: 394, ‘provicia ‘=.:a’=fs_e. ‘a1s$§eai is against a
camiictian ané serztez1ce;A..::f’_:fie2itVij:pr”bf”i%?s%g;3’%isonmet:t, and
the a;2;;fe.*i’iéir;t.xfi}:e_s é€i’é’;f’§n§* ;3é.?§ici’éi§cy cf the appeal, any cf
hi3 neafV’re!’é:£iveas fi?§é§;’,_’w.§fii*z.§i..tfiifiy days cf the death cf the
apzaeiiafit, ébpiyv t§Vthé~-.ékb:i’éi£ate Ccurt for ieave ta cerxtimze
-‘”~..;:_he..’§i:;g-éi;.._and ‘if’-éeave is granted, the aweai shaii nut
it, it is clean’ that by oiaeraticsn af sub-
‘fiectiéén. $i1.) %ii agzmaais tmder settler: 377 and 378 shaii
“v.ffab:afe–..A:;:°3H’the éeath of accusefi. In the instant case, the
a®éa i is undifiputably under Section 3?’? Cm’-°.C. and upar:
. V hidéath of the resporndent it shai! abate. Sub-Secticm (2) aisa
adumbrates that in every appeai, except an appeai from a
sentence cf fine, shali aisa abates an the deat_i2..VV_¢f_:’the
armeléant. The pmvisa makes it very clear that_.3é’§*i’é’¢4£é-_;2′:i:f§*.:’
atzpeiiarzt (convicted accuseé) refe:f2f§:i»_t«a’ ir§*”5uvt$§éE”2:eét£ia’nV (2 )’~
wiii net abate if the ievfii repraafitatirm.
appeiiarzt apzaiy to the ¢.’:¢f1’Li2″iiV_f€:__.t’.E’.¥iV’;’f.i!’I’tV;1e’:Vt?ié’fi:p:pg§I.i’§ vv:;Eti1 ,
ieavé ef the cnurt. Tifi-5 is aV;*1: 1L:”e’._*-.»a*§a%~:z,i_»i_»z*1a’ .’;:ar<:§§f\a:vVi'j'.=.ic::§?fn ta legai
reiareseratatives cf cen§ic {ed_ .t;L§'A:'§:a:;1tin:ze 'the appeai
against the conx§.:'ct_jen sa%é.i,\§'v'w§tI3 :.L§ remove stigma
on the That errabiina
provisi§;;:1__Vi§ tiéffipiainafit /' prosecuticn
ta cafi:inu&AAVVé'¢9-feééi' –when the appéai abate-5 as
manfiatefi cf Section 394 C'r.P.C.
«.13: t§’§’é’t:i’:*z:umsta:1t$, the reciuest made by the
sfiaficcnceived as the appeal is under Sectirm
amen death cf resaondent — S.Ramesh, it
shaft ‘afiéste and accordinuiy, it abates. Thus, questian ef
ieave to substitute Smt. Hernaiatha Rammh, wfie
‘ deceased Rarrsesh — ariamal resrsonderat, aisa dues net
arise. Canseauently, the amsiicatians. ie., r«¥isc:.. Cri. No.
2315/2669, 2016;’20G9, 2018/2039, 202252009,
J
2028:2009, 2621/2939 and 2£}19i2009, are aisa dismisse_fi~ _ ‘-<._ _=._
as aim the appeais shaii abate.