High Court Karnataka High Court

Basavaraj S/O Shivashankerrappa … vs The Director on 24 April, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Basavaraj S/O Shivashankerrappa … vs The Director on 24 April, 2009
Author: Ravi Malimath


EN *’n~:§+-3 m§é£;;:2Qe§ « T

§:%§iE~'{‘}’§€E*i
mg: 2;:\m:ge: §*v’£E€..§i!E§”i’f.€j.7§§;; Qavi’ §’§2g\i!%:i;i’j§V;l4i¥;Ak’ir¥i:>Vi
‘i3£§v2E’I’ @;Ta.’m’1v:%}%”2=–s.;<::a, 2é::'§,é<3 éjgsfzzyog gaéfiucé

EFZEZ $5":

2 . §3A§§av;a%2;aa’,’ ‘ _–

g G ::sH:’%.€:=¢:s.};;;xN1..?{V§§T§&}€E§;; ” ‘
<,_;<:::: }~31;§§5§w'_-yzgs-é;w,, 'V
'$2,! §3'i;i'f}'"1"" 2'a:::';..«%::~,.._ % _ " .

$:”§””:; ;<;'§é;::: A'E'._'xf2% ' "'-§2L:'k;E-;-_€§i%}Ei'§¥<Z:'%,

{E-'é§L£%A§§%.{§22. ' ._ "

, kg; Eifisifi-E-iE?§§A%,L§ 8:, 863%,
._”.:5′;*?’&§€f’E_fi*~:?”E=’§_§f€SHEVE4*’E%7_E.E>E§:§ ‘:’me*;;<3-E;

_ §'E"S""%»%A%§§i{}£?€{} E1'z%§€*'§"§*%E:EE€§
' "'£%§gS~:§5i'AE?.AJ.. 3; <1: Simi:'vASHAN:«:E:R:2APPA

.;-5'3:-Tam;:a;;;Lz;~5:35;: €25 YEARS?

‘- . €’}i’f:{3; ‘:£3i;–5s§s*~: £3.33,
‘-f§§f’€§}_.E~°’~§,_t:j§j’T;” §*«E{},4£3, ;s;m}A’:’§:::~ sari’-
%zA;£3’3’I’:’::~§E:§é$

£34»

€33-s’zé. ASHQK S KENAGL A:>v.;

” _ ‘ E32′

E}. “Fiiirl §_”}§§zZ§?,1C”i’ OR,
” .:=’&PP§«’E{i, RAJ If-3I+i:%Vf§N EEKEAI},
;§:.§’A2%N€;.’A1..f{E..1.: — 2.

ENJ

“.2. ‘§’§-{E2 Siiiifl E?L’§’2’3si%Z’2’,

gxpzxszcig {§{ELB:”aR{}A, ‘:é%§e;§s;;:?i:.:%:L’z3§e:’:»:<i**§3V'

{E-E}; Sz'1'.8.S.E{iEMi%siAEé, {Tm §:':e £2:-‘if ” «_
szem.::3__§e

“E’i%£$ K519, is ;?:L§;;i:: :;.:%§{:r§s:z2 z&§i<"§f:{?;L§:§:§ 53"~;é5:*§"';a:€:_{3 22'?

5;}? '§'E:%E3:Z :;:{_}:~ss'?:'I*i:1f:'N o;§f’_”‘;-:s§:A>:Vg» ?E§A'{§;bé§A{}VAf§'(j} (gmsgi
*2!’-‘W: ¥¥v§Pi_f{}?~§E:E) N::>'{:fj£%::£§::~§.’_’:3;§.’:fv§:;::} v;3;:«…3;.<.2
.1532′ ‘§’%£3E3 i23′”3 §:a§:sm;~;;3§«:§s*§’ ;é.1:§-x: M ;é..;5ziJ’:s3.§?5:»<_: 315? i:::.«{;.

-‘mgg :;:g’.’;::.J:M%::m;::r~;<.';; £2?' v?.:?2.:é;L2M:N;,RY HE}}A.¥€§§'%{L%
"$513 E)AY,'"'?%§.E::"££3~i';:§§R'£fE§_"E*'i§£:3,.:i%'OLL{j}WiM}; ~

§%.€" 2*-;._%:€: ,2'*<:9%:;;:::4:V=:s_1," ..%;!:E”z the {§{l?EEI§S€3§ fora” ‘éziizz 3::ar’i’,.§€:;$,

z_.§r;§.:;;. :”::a%.§.%::” is?’ “%fl::<3.E§;;§;:j';v 1.1;) €232" 13:32:} <_§.§$p<:sSa§_,

1 f;:s<:f£'.i_:,i<)1'1s;%§' E§'z:,=.£ was §:i;§{';t€;.%§g2f%;::§:’*E{‘<;%i: "3'z§:"<i, Efakiéaigéffi, <j}z_1§§.";arg::; zmzi

t:_E':a:*é::–:gf%:é%r, 2;. Saks fif'/izéé was f§§{€§€:'1.i?fZ{.3. {HZ 253.88, E<.§"?§_% vids:

A;j.2.§3;$§t_z§t:~1%, {E33 'EEK: z~3§§%:g{“% ‘€;i<3Ea%',.i<):: $3? %",E'2€; f.€iI"§E'ES am?

__€':§.*:§T:2:%§'f{.i<';::$, 3. :1_:{‘§; 0;”: $325: g_;%<=:%§€i€*::':£::r$ sizizd

§,§"":£e %.2"i3p§:g:3:*:{'% m*<'§{~=::"' 223%; §.3a_$§;é=:{§ {:;:§.:'*:z:i:i2§z':gj ififé &:%{.<:a {if

:3. §3f:E§.§E'§{}E'§€§§'fi"*§. §"T§s:*:2f;:"":e'-:3 the §}§'€iiS€*EE1§' §2<?:€:§.t.i0:j: 35: fiiétd.

afar

3. £é§:”E.;”::s%1c:§< fiéfiizaagifi Em: §é':i8'Fi'"i€t{'i {fi{}i.i}'2;;$i§'.E3.' –a;;g§;c§s::i';:g

fez" E316: §}€'f§1i.'§i€)1"}.€i'S s:,ib:3i1§§:$ 'iifaaf. this i::'3.§;s§:gI}'::{§" 2::§ §*<}::n_{§$ in §.1.1§;;}af::*%;.. cf §*:'i_s 7c.:.;3:$z:a ' .
<3», {Tm t,Ir1<»': €)':".}'T§€':I' .3%1é.g:3s}i::i 1'é3X'II2€'3V{7:§
<:<::z1a":::;€:1 E1§f3_§I)€8F§§1gf%C%}fj 'i'he» Vt*é:§.f;{{'.§f:r'1VVV<"i€:f_;'1': :"§':,§bi11§t.s; 333%:
if} an §(§€fE'§§i.{3'i3 :?(1z;1'i4§£mT:*:"*:f,'-i.2":<: r€}§=:r .:§,29 3-:;:»;:a;-;«;;;d% :,::”‘.”:2′:j<)g% (AP?v'_§{TZ§ am:

:i:é:rm:<z<:£;:”:$
:{e:~s:§,>§::zg,::: 5%}:-,3»a§:cx:.ét._;::e ;mp11§%:€?:<i aasdzséss ':h€::'::1::. H1:-2

€::%§Q§".<z:*L'~§i:.:"3i€T «:§§?.9 m:”:{i for §}i,E§l'{,§E'”i§§’ 2T1}:

» ‘«§s:*::2:§j:%.’s;_z:=:::3:§”ii: ac{:{}rci§a:1€:€ $211.2: igw,

‘- V{}€:’:’–.§%:{3:§:”‘.§:1g %2{}’:.T%{; €;%:<7: ::u::::§<»:3 fog" {E16 §::az*E:3;<:s:: a2"::<% in

%3§€';'i§:' "1'<};§' 'mg: :;%:i;:':'2§$si{;2: aifzaééz its}-I iihif {3G'%,E§iS€fL E gisiéiam E:

x }E§i:S;E. 32.2% §3::*{}§3£*:2* %;%":§:f; €316? {}E'i.§fi§" amii €§:§.E°ii'{f'f'€;§{}I"1 <,£:~:.i,§:€§

°,<:%s:;}{23,2<§<:z%; ::::a<2:: E33. '{.<~':~:f:'n$ {:5 '$3.§.5},E'*§{:,é§«{}4-%I32f2{}{T%8

{?a_E3?if%{.3} am}; ::<3z1::§::_:é:;é§’;. aim.

:2:€:«m 1

§{‘{::::”:£;: EEK? ;;}s:é:é3:%{::’*: is (fi&;§;>{3$€:(§ azaff’ .é :’% i:e%:;:[“§’1′:}§§”%:”:”§””–€.%f::”:

a,}51.:{‘i§§1:”:€»:2″:§ £ia?£é:.{}3’;’2–{}{3<} ';i;¢;;§:s%:<§_i'¢. ifzj

%L?£%14Q%$2/2668 igpxfi-a§§"¢a§n$mea'fix$§xg

€7§:'<'§€3§*€a::§ a.::(:{)_r<i§I1§;E};.

– — ._ »% 3&5
/4x\&/Rik} JUDGE

wa-