IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BANGALORE
DATED THIS THE 27′”! DAY OF N0VEMBEF.,,V’2.(§G_9
PRESENT
THE HON’BLE MR.JUST_I§3E m~::,TT E TV
AND
THE HON’BLE MR.JUSTIC_E B;sH’EENNA.sE Go§:\fDA’*~w _
M.F.A.No. 627%:-f 2006 T
BETWEEN: ‘T T ‘A T I»
Basha Khan, ‘
W/0. Wahab K§Ea;1n_, V
Aged about V
R/0. 10211 Cross.
Kocli CvHampA,’:v.’T}irikr:’x:e 15′;11u[Lk,’
Chickxnagalbm.1)istrir;t.:~.___ _ —
… Appeiiant.
[By Sri.
L’
._ V. S,’ d”.~.,,Pap€”‘Gourd21.
‘ _ V Age:dH-i7sbbut4 39 years.
D’riV€:f of the Bus bearing
NVEJALKAM16/1349,
‘ R/T0. Uppaiii,
r _ Hirekolale Road.
‘A Chickmaga101*e.
st1sta.i11ed in the acciderit, he filed a claim pCf.i{i()l’1
eiaimir_1g c:orr1per1satio11 of Rs.8,00,000/– the
1’espor1dents. The said claim petition had come
t_he Tribunal on 18.02.2005. The~»T_1jibu.ria1.”0′
the learned Counsel on both sides
the oral and documentary e_\_f1’d_ence’ a__vaiu1ab1e.=jo1’rrecord;
has allowed the claim pe’tit.ior1__:oifthe iri part and
awarded eompensatiorr-of M withJintei~est at
8% per anrium on Rs. ii date of petition
till the date of_r~eva1isat.io’1i..:”: has presented
this appea10AA’o0i._ir g.rotu_r1d that the said compensation
awarded’ the. ;l’ribari.a.1″‘is inaciequate and it requires
eriha§nC:eri1eiit”byVrfiodifying the jtidgment and award of the
V p 0’ =
heard the learned Counsel appearing on
“-.both
— it ‘A After careful perusal of the judgment”, and award of
Tribtirial what emerges is that. the Tribunal after
evaltiation of the oral and docunientary evidence a_Vai1ab1e
on record, awarded a sum of Rs.2E3.000/~ towa1rd”s:.Vj”paiI1
and stifferings. Rs.87.593/~ towards
Rs.”/’,500/– towards travel experises;iRs_’.3,_:’§’Otdf_~xVt’owaVi”ds9
attendant charges, food and
towards medical expensos’–.__a”:1d towards
disability.
6. Havirig regard t:(),.th’e,1n3.u1:ies’sL1’st,air1ed. duration of
treatment ta1i;en,5″R.s..2’5,C90/-i.Vawarded towards pain and
sut¥eri1:gise»ap})ears:r3 t.o*be’—-.on t’he»–i’o\ver side and it requires
e11ha1r1e’erne1’1t.. Rs.-40,000/– towards pain
and sufferi1’1gs’;
V-i._”‘:’I’h.e c0m13en”at:i’O1″: awarded by the Tribunal towards
_rr’rediea1’~.exfierjses is based on the medical biils produced
ar1d__ it cioesriot. call for enhancement.
Rvs”;3,50O/W awarded towards att,er1r1ar1t. charges,
. rroijrishing food et.(:.. is on the lower side and it requires
#3
; *,.Nm.m
.5
i
;.._a
. Towards pain and sz.1ffei*i11g__;s 4O,OOO__/5
2. Towards Medical BXIBCHSGS g
3. Towards Traveliirig expenses Rs. 1″
4. Nourishing food And I «. A _ _ -.
Attendant charges A. V A..5′;OOL}-[7 ;_
5. Towards loss of income dui’ir1g
Laid up period. ”
6. Towards loss of a1ne1iit’ies’zir’1dVe–./:4 ‘A ‘A
future unhappiness”= ~ 2 ” _’I?’,s. 20,000/~
7. T0wa1″<:}.s i'uti.i1*ev_medi'eé1'1*e§:}:ien}§:e.é }0,000/-
8. rFO\VaI’d:_S’}%}S .SE:6f.fl,1tL¥..i”§::ifl.C0méV” Rs, 84240/_
The appieilaéini total compensation of
Rs.2.13,33§3/’—._ as.’ ‘VRs.1,22,743/- awarded by the
liiiitieiirgsi. at 6% p.a. from the date of petition
til} the déit:;.iio’r feeaiiiéfiioxi.
4}
Ilistireince Company is directed to deposit the
iieiiheiiieedi'”_Comper1sat,i011 of Rs.90,590/v togetlier with
.«-*
._f_”_……….._…._……..
1/