EN 'i'HI-C men comm' OE'~' KARNATAKA. BAN(j}AL()~-RE
m'r:«_::') THES mg: 19"" DAY OF JANUARYQOV1'0 f.:A.'
BEFORE
THEH0NBm£MR¢h$wcEHBfi@M%A_ 3F
3uscELLANEoLmsFn&n'APPEAL5K1iQ707§H>2006$@fl';
BETWEEN:
B5.'1'e'ég(.)\x='('ie:
S / (J . H 1.1 E. L' 1'1 t;?gu\.\fci 2.-1 ,
36 Yt'.2ll"S._ -- V V
Er12ployee as Lc_>acie1*=:7r1 Lc)1jr'y';'» -- .
R/11% K2-1E.)i3i11akm'e~;
K2'1.s21i:3e'i1H0l)i.i, _ 'V .
.Ne:ge-111'1e'ingalaT'£1iL.1_:}{;__ . » A' f;.APPELLAN'I'
Hg srawnanfifieshgs gpgnggn.Aav";
I I:;3e.1.~elu.rc:1'. ,' 'V " '
E5 / as K 1.1 11 11 ii'. I")'1'*'iv.r3_1_f_,« .
- \-"e:'if;;a} \}*'i}}e':.§:,c, P1n:Iz.1_1* 'E'e1iul<.
V if 11: 3.31:" 1 :--1_V1'1'g':{1 cii ' P<_)st,.
2 R:':1d'}ikriSii:}215'N21iI._ i\?ej;i'a:~s1«=1'in'1a Naik, Owner.
' , R/AI I")uga111a('rhariya Viilagc.
" -- --. V " I-3<.§Z}1 ]'1a1i"1ga1cli [Son 1' 11 Km 113 ad 21.} .
_ "!f}'1'c.- {f)ri(-*.nt:al }f11suram?e Co.I.»in1_ii.egi.
" {..'3V'!'2iI'1('I'}''1Puilul',
" '"{?5m.I €_}"1 Kz1m"1'c1<i2-1.]. ....RE1SPONf)ENTS
221w;1r(i1-1:1. I~£'9. i.1'1crcI'o1'c. $11b111i1'_1.c-rd t"hz:-11. 1110 i111;31,1g11(+d
_j1.11i;;11'1(=1'11 2-111d 211.11-'e1r£;I needs in be 111(')dific*d.
6. As. 2z1g____;'-121111151. 1.111s. the 1e21.1'11ed C()1.mse1.~~fTc:)1j.fi31E 3.Ij<i
1'1'.n~.e])11('ic-*1':1 s11bmi1:1ed H1211 the 'E'1'ib111'_1.fdl p1'r:'b>1')"e.1j
(rm:si(1emt.ic>1:"1 c.>1'1.hc* 111;-1t.c.1"ie.11 on 1'ec1'1a1bI€= c01npc11s211.1011 and,€.}1_c1*cf(:'i1'f:.'it' does 1 1101, ci;~11}"i'0_f*.
E1116-'1'l'C1'cn(:c.
7. 1 lmve Ca1'ef1.11Iy (',Q l"i~i~'»idt'fVA1'€',C1V Ef'i1gs 11.bn1issi1)r1s made by
1111» §c211'11cc:i C()1111se1Vi'(.)1' f.h(::fv'j'_) 'c.1:~"I.l'L?.v:$f. 1'
8. ']'1'17:.;_' p~r.}111r' i:E1'é1t.ALé'1:?is*e317:11' my (*.0.11side1"ation is, w}'1eth(:*,1'
11:11 'E"1'i}:.Ji1:1e1_l l'V'1'¢:.!4',<_7" 2'i.\~'k1'E'1iT'(\/itirjiL§1.§.E~§1 and r02;1:s01'11able c?on_1pc:1'1s2=1i.i0n'?
9~f:,,I'i~ i,;'f--71_Vl.'€?'1_C'V£1.i1f: T('}"'i"1'C)1.,C3. 1:116'1'rib1,11'1aI has awarded 21 sum
2T.5;€)UvQ / :4"1't;(_'5\1vi211'cis pain 2:1.1'1d s1.1f'!'e1'i1'1gs. "H16 appellant:
' v.1'11.-1.1% s51EEI'L5:'(éci_ t"(.jEi'-§.';Wi11;,g iI1h]'ll1'i€SI
2-1. (_:(}2'11_?mL:f:c;:d i"ra(:t1.11'e of pr01.1".;:111t.ic area of 1.:-=:f1'. femur
_ '!':_._ f1f'<)111p()1.11'1(_1 c'()n1n'1111cd fr21c:£111*e of both 1:110 bones of
tin-:.* 1'i§g1"11_ leg
'J|
ui(.icri'
(.1. §£i('L'"Fé"l1.(",C.'! wotmd (.)Vt?1" the smllp.
'I'i'ic* appcliaiii has [,'dl{€I'1 i'.i'c2'1.t:1'nem. as il"1pEH'i€I':1'iJ".fQI'___ £fi)_(5i;!.'L
1.
1m’*v 1’nc.)i’1t’l’1s. The ii’1jz.1rieS have }’@St.1i1″C?d~-~.i,Ij'”‘ pE’.l%1TEEiI}¢i1’¥..
(1is;.ibi!iE_\/ of 38% in I'(:’.SpC(“.1. of wholéi bQdy,} ‘i”11é ATI’ibt!V11§_11
2’1\m1′(ic(i 21. suni of Rs.25..OOO/.~’ i:__)vvardAs pairiT.ziiigiv_$uffq31*ir1gsuv
wi”ii(‘:1’i is inadeqL.iat.e. Having reg2ii9Ci._t,c;,tl’1e ii;1i._Lire 0}!’ injuries,
($1.11:–1i’.i<)ii and 1"ia£',1,i1*e of tiz'°«eé;t'_rA1'i'\:=_:r1is.j_,'vvii'é'=.ii_1y"Coi'1side2'cd View a
f:3E.II'1i oi" Rs.35.000/'~.€U_uE-Ci"-bier V21._if§:2ist;i'1éibie S'L.I.1"1'1 towards
§ L V V _ _
i1'i;1.n"ics. pziiri 2:1.i'.1ri..si.i'ffe.yix1g_{:a and a(:tj()rdi,i3gly it is awarded.
EC). 'i5!f1t?"T}'i!§i,i'1.i:€i.1'xiiiEiisiigiWilFd€2C.i a smn of Rs.i0,000/–
1.m-mi”d.=_s E11l(Y}”1′(.’E’&]_}”liv.(?11é1}”§;f3S”§:1i’1(f 1′}.£)1,J.FiS}’}i1’1g faoci arid iiothirlg
“&1\”\-‘k.1}”(‘fé’f.’C.l: __ ‘1o}.\-*a1i’ci§s*’ «vc:01.1veyemca-2. ‘I’i’ie appellant has taker}
11’V'(‘-if’i>IE1.1′(,”1’1.T721$”ii’i’}Z)&i!1;.§”ifI”l'[ for 2i1b(:)u1 E.1}}’€(;’. m()11i.hs aiid. t:hei’eaft,€11
.i'(>il<iw~:ipA I"1'€?£31i'f§§1.('?i:1i. for a ccmsiclerabie period. "i'hei'ef()re. ii: is
.41"".'])'1'i'}.§_:)C1' 10 ~ e;m;'a1'(i 21 Sum of Rs.15.000/– 1.owards eiiteridant
5__ '.E’i£i.z’g:;:s. ‘ (.}'(‘}1’1\»”‘(,’:v’2..1.I106;’ and }’1()Ll1’iS1’1il’}§__§ food etirici acctordingly ii: is
‘ £.:1.’x?x-;;11′(“!,§~:?(.§ .
Ii
11. ‘1’1ic=-.= ‘I’ribuiia1 1’ia.~s 21\.ve1:'(‘1t1 a sum of E-{.~;.43.2()O/~
imx-‘;i1″d.~s 1(‘>sss cit” fixture €¥E1.i’I’li.1″1§_§S, iakingg the iI’1(‘.(_)I1’1€’.T_(‘H’,.U16
é.i}.J})t.’11ill31 2511 R:.~’;.15()O/- per mont_.h. ‘i’hc 2-ippe.li.21i’1E__ii’:1*:§.f§ii_ffé>iTé(i
p(_::’1’1’12ii’1ci’i1 (}is2=ibi1i.ty of 30% in respect of ii.}i:-:~’}€:.i’1″.:’l.L)w£}1’«iinib; V.
LE2.’-ém iii i’c51.)c(rE of i’_.I’ie i’ig1’11 I(‘>wi’ limb a1i”1~:£:’3Ef§9/ti -iI’i* I”€’i::%%{3_CC’:{:jV~€)f
E.}”2c..” \-V1l()1C’ i)0c.iy. “l’i1c: E1p§)€li&1i1’CV\’N’.;;v1S ag'(:(}’ a_E3()i€.ii’128./_y§>zii’s ai.
the time of 21 cciciei1i_. The;__ai})peil;iii{,A’ tiiat he was
\-v<.')i'1<..in;§ as a lmider 21i'iclvCI'e3Ti:iiii'i'g.§_ moriiih. Buti.
i1}&'i'(' is no E'}.(f(.'L.'1)1.§1bit/T_ t.'\'1':d"C?Vi'"vl'('II:f.."V::. "'[i"1C' 'F1'ibL1.i'1.a1 has
1.2.lkt":'I1 t.1"1t;' ii1(.é(i:'iu;'..§ii5::.:i;:ij.ig Y per month.
\-\-'§1i(.'§1 is i:iie:i.i the appeliaiii
}'1;1i-.5 :sa.1i'i'Lti'E(E of 38% in I'('3S]')C'.(TL of the
\\.s£'m1t" 1')(:(1iy_ u""i..'_4k'iL:1fL-ri'V(')re:,7_i.{. ]3l'()pE;'.I' to take iihe clisability at
z"-,\.<_§'('.'(_)i=iiiiiig}y_..if 1d1{CI.'1. "'l'I'ie app:'0pi"i2:1i.e mLiii',ipi.ic1' is
."; U'1.('E"i.i:'i£'i5I'!}.€' of 'c1}')p€11£lI":T, is taksrii at RS. '1 .500/W per
I"i"1'('V'2H._.l§':§'i _2i-'EVI'1r,§1:"'§:V1'Ll(_"v'V'E.1iS§;1biiiI.y is iaken at' 38% and I}'1l,1}Up1i€i' of
_'i'?' 'c'.1"dL..)])1'i.?(I§;'j'{'i31(?11. the (.'.()iT1p€I'1SE1i.i()I1 132-lyelblt? tiowards loss
' K " 1% 's'i\'<u 12.1 I'_('.iC'.'( i ii
of i"i.i1.iii'{'j= c;-21-Zifiiiiifgs L'.(..)]T1(,'S to Rs.i,16,280/– and 21(?c:r{li1’1giy, it
at/»
12. ‘l’l’1c “l”‘1’ib111″1a;1l has awmdcd 2’1 31,1111 of Rs.5.000/~
{ic>vv;11′(“ls l(1:s9.s of i11c*<)11'1c ('i1.11*i1'1g_;{ L119 p&*1*iod of11'ez:1I'.111e11t.. The
e111].1<*]l;-11'1l'. has 12.1ke:1 11'oa.t.111e?1'11. as ii'1p21'E.i€?I1£ for 21 p'ct_19iQd of
I.l1:'w 1110111115 a11'1c.i '£.l'1crcaft:cI; f01i()w+1.:p the I1'ea_1gtiI11«5i1'11.__] 1'?-»__1* '~31.
('?£f)IiSi(flCl'&1b]€ })€¥1"i0d. '1'l'1t'(‘)1’c. ii’ is })1′(i)p€1′ to .~:e.u1:1 b~f.. ”
I-‘<s1E}(1)()()/– 1mva1'ds 1085 of i1'1c0n1L; (11.11jifr1g–11»fE.1€%'–. per'-i1A()d.,Q.f'
1'_1'va–111110111 2-md 21(:c.:()1"di1'1gly. it is.»e1'»\;fj¢11'c1e"c}..V_
"£135. The 'frib1,a1'121l 11215 1'1<3r1s21ti01'1
1ow21rds loss of e1n'1e11it,ies"0Ft1.ift§. to be awarded.
‘l’i’u:.’ 2′.1ppc11211’1I has :sL:vf”l”€1’L:1ii” “c1’c>1:1i1r.11’1:;1ff’c§_<1 i'1'21.gf1'L~:,11'(% of left. fe1'11L11*
and –._’I’l:1c i_11u_§*111:’i’:t.S” i’1ave 1′(:s1.1i.t:ed in pe1’r1″aa1’1€111′:
c;}viVs;;_1i3iiiviyi.<1)i'__ C3Q% iA11"«1i<:%s.pc:('éi. <11i'i:l1£-.1. left lowm' iimii). 32% 1'11
:'vI~';.;)'1?r;:€"of '1i.,1'I'("*: 1"'~..igi'1-i'. lower limb and 38% in 1'espec:t' of the
' '1.___ wl1<)!c§' }11c'_.$(M.E§,,r_ 1'1c)Ci1)r l':a:1,s deposed £11211. t,i'1<'-3 21ppeIiamt. finds
_ c§.i.Vf'i"ic"11lt1~~1'<)";ci() {he r11em1.1a} work. {*0 mm a_11cE to ('limb steps
"..'_ 'z1:_1(}."1!:1e1'L'{«is 1't-r5£41'iCti()1"1 .r1’1e11i’. of left and rig}’1t k1’1ees.
21§.1pL_*I.}211’11 11213 to .<;:1i"fc*1' <:i;'s<'é<')n'1f()1'1_ t.1'11'01ag!'1m.11 his life.
1
Q1.»/”V/N
Thy ‘l”rii’)11n;_».1E E1218 not”. ;:-1.w2=11′(.ic'(i any (.'(.)111pe1’1Saiion A Ioss of
Q» .
az11c:1jI_ics:. of iife which needs to be awzxrdcd. Pizzivilxgg.ji’=Qgze119d to
Ilu.-= 112111.211? of (‘1is(r0mi'(:)1*I” Kim 2-xppellelm. has to.–$%:.1f’I'”c:2;};fin ;fi1yA’v.
(‘:(nx>_;ic1c1’c~(.i view. a sum of Rs.30.0()();’ >~w.<,)1.11c1 be é1–:';321Vs<)'13.21I*;]e '
s:.m1 I()W'(.k1'(1S loss oJ"am(=mi1.ies3 of Eif€. a'nci" a1c?c_E0lTf.i–i1:1§1Y.. \"iii"'if?
a11wa.:.r(:1c.-Li .
M». The I”)()m’:z.’)1* has gig:p()sQcE-~–fI’i’e3.t”$119 a;51′)*ev1£;mi. 1’ec1uires_
futunr <..2pc1'e1t:i()11s and for '{:h'_a't }T1c:i*1§;ec%Ci?:é_ *2'gb"o1,1{. Rs.16.000/–.
'E'11c.1'cforc. it. is p1*Qp.é3 1*v.1:_c) 2.1§_wa1fd' 21 $'{l'IT£'..()f"R.S.16,000/~ towards
ha: 2.211' 111(-.(1E(:2-:11;L*§pcrr and 11′}.e1’et'<')r'e". it does not
,»'<~"a'E1. 151' c';'.*.'fm't'-::11<t:-_~_ ~ ….. .. v
"T I"1'fi." <.Aiotell ('Umpcnsatjorrl payable L'::<:)mes to
t:I'1e break up as follows:
9
1. T()\-‘V2-lI”(1.’-5 i1[_j1.11″i(:.*–;. p211′}”1 e’11’1d $1.1ff(?1’i11gH R.<;.35,000/f,
2. “I’c.)\\’2i1′(“ls M.c3di(t21I exp(i:1″1s(i:s
15. ‘I’c)w:11’ds 1’1’1L’id(;’m’ai
vx.§:)c1″}.~’a(:*.s like (‘t()1″1vey2u1(?(:*, 1T:(T)u1*i5I1i:”1g .¢ L-
1′<md 211'1(;I a1£ic11ciezm1 (?i'1&'5l1'gt?S .
4. ‘I'(‘>=\.vz1.1′(.1s loss (}fiI1(.’.O}11C? c1L1ri11§,§1.he;”:. ‘ ~ ~. _ A ~
pc1’i(.>d ofi.1*ee.11’:n1c2ni
5. ‘I’mv2i11′(1s Eoss ()§’fL1t’L11’e ez-1r1T1i1’1g_;’s Rs..i’.«-16,000/A
(*5. ‘I’o\4=ve-u’c1.s; t’m’.m’e £T1C:’Cii(‘TEIE._C);.})(¥1’.’iS(?:E~SV ~ 16,000/A
7. ‘i'(}\-ve11’cis E()s:.a’ of a1ne1″:i1,ies <53'f;VEi"f%€ vAA.'_IE§§;3O,OOOg–
Te§a1_ . =f}~ ,Vurg§;.«2%%,26,00og*
17. !\(§(%'(>1fi;£..iV1′:i’;’__~3;. V 1,133 “*~.a;1*)}3€*:=.i} is aliowed and the
i1:’;]..):..1;_e,’1″1(T*(‘i jz1(1g.r’n&.*:<%1j–~;1hc1 ";:a,x3{r:1.1fd. .passec1 by U16 'I'1'ibL111a1, in
§\/I\=-"'(.f.T.N0. £75/21998. VViZ$I'E.i'}.i1 ('_iSv '}11()(1ifiE?(1, g}'e'1}1I':i1"1g{ ('.0mpensatE01'1
oi' }-{s.i1l,».'.4f§j'E3;V(){.)()/- V];'I'a.'.'j:sv;E:('V"cl('E :01" Rs.88,20O/A with imcrest at 6%
1')~..g:..1'm.11'1 I._I"1c_<.(i.2ji1"ei of pc3t'i1'i(m till me date of :1"-:.a1iisat.i()r1. "file
tI':m'.i~r{%sp(.)1"i(£3;-11'*;;l'iaIl dc3posit'. the amount. vm'_.l1i11 flight weeks
V.'
f1"–)m E"<)ci}.:\; "c;<(.1'£i1c1i1[1g.g' the ammulut already depos.it'ed. Out of
all '1If..ii"Ai'lh'::iu11(?C(i n*{}.§V§t in ,a:1″1y’ 1’12–1i’icn’121}i2:(:c1 be-mk for a. perioci of 1i”11’e@ yea1’s.
‘c.:};);.’)(‘:’Ha11I. :s§.”zaH be cm:i{.le.ci to m’.i:_}1.ci1’a1\»x= t’.I”1(> i11teres1′.
2
H)
eu*v1’z1c(‘1 on it. The baE2,11’1.:.1:”1t” shali be ;’el(:2-_1_se£i in
f}1\*<)m" oi' the zappeilzmt.
I)1’z.1w up H10 aw.213″(‘i._ E1(.’.(‘,()I'{‘1i!1§-ii}/’.
GH/VP/JS