High Court Karnataka High Court

C.C.Shivanna vs Channabasave Gowda And Ors. on 31 July, 2009

Karnataka High Court
C.C.Shivanna vs Channabasave Gowda And Ors. on 31 July, 2009
Author: V.Gopalagowda And Kumar


V ‘ :5}§,Ti§f’

£2; ‘§’E:%’%%: ;%vT_§%§_<:§*%% <"3:'fTsE;"%%'E;i' {:3}? §§;§_”€e::> %:3;*’§__:v;~g% :’:§.:%*3’u L~.’}l– ;

$39-if §?Z’:%§§%:.E’€’?’

‘§’§€§%3 .’§:—-%§a’f}*§’VE*’§§§…’.*:4%’2 g_.§%_.§§§’E’.E{.7§;’§%§ as::::;§i”;§f:f’%;2EAA-@::_::%é..a:A:i::;:,%T f

é%§’s§E’} _ , , % u
§¢§§%3., L.E§,§§’§’§’E’§{ifE%§i” ,5-2};::av::%:’?:i;:4 :”«a:T:T:§:s_:;2;:€ ‘
§E»G§§§;&R Ema? ;:$§£E.ég:e; :§§;2:*%s0i:s* 349$?
E”%%9f§”%?¥E%:§%:E\§ $ A Z

f1{T’3.$%’.:§¥a:1:qa5V .

Sfa <f§§:a:'z:'1abz:TS.a§'¥$ {;}0w<i;gg, . "

Pégaii abo1.:€;?_%€§§§&:>:3;flgg
Egg Séasgijiff
{7i%’:%§{:§.:2’§g&§.fi::5:_ ‘ ‘ «

§:’.é i:”:<:s§ iééééaéé 23:':fgnféegagjéyzfgiéii… $5}; __ 7:33" 3: §;.. E35;
E. {a} E§22'3E;§ 22%-:_Ej::.:2£5:i{:;2%':§'é_£:.;

iii?!' :j%§':§.va:::'-::";? " ' '

5%.?' '

3 {jg}: …..

.f1%€i»§:<3§€.§ 3

A ' .}§.%§{3 §?§v;.4{§;§:'€'£T!§§€§,
§%€::}':g.;2?.=:§;'3a;ja_%,.§':;3;;;3'€g:z2. {jf;i:*€.:'§<*:§

{"'§§:§§<.:§:;::g:,a7iI§}; <1

.3 {E5} E; T§T,Z?€:¥aE§§ fl

'i..§£,/{E ?2:'§'3:':§:,mza;?;;§'§ Eiéfiih
" «. '_ §%€£§j{::*,,
" jéajcli §€zzs€§”::;:E:’§ 3

Eff {.3 %€a£;§§g§{P} ,

u ‘§’§<3z§.§}a:? fig. ;§%a§{'2:E:t%;E":§;:,_;;;

§:}§.§fs?E’.§{ff’§; gags $231

“§§§:.:} §7s§2’2?i’.,§3m_§;:§§;2 <1§1"s.

$5; €13 ;’€§§’;s:u’:_§;§:;22 ii? §;..’§§j”€’.§,’§f; F

égaéz: ?:§23.§<:s;';

€Z§<:rs,:: _§{i€;z3;$@.?:§é:{%, *
§i5;:’zu::¢:.a1′:fi::.a,g:z§)a ifiimkg I
{TiE”;%i%<_;é3E91″€.

E. {:3} S323. PG€}i”‘E’i§.flEfi,

E3/{: S§}.i.’§?3I}§1§:1,

Age: §£2aj0z;

{§}<:<:: Eti<3u3aZ<::<::§2′:;3;:f;E§’:i;:?;;;az*,'”‘ ‘

$55; SE?1ii«’i%3;’E.i%_»§,

2*%g§:.:

$353 i?zé§,,{f§’;E€:;:%§;3§;,’ ‘* _
Tiéazé;”a:z;::;z:€’.%;ag;:§3:: V’ ‘ ‘ ”

{ESE§;:”::::, –

;’:§;2;:s§?:E:::z::’:é:T§€_ta§,%:}

m€§::’:

E–$ {T’fE75a;t:3_:3h3.sa¥€’ €}2x;z§a

was E4.:”m:€§ Taiggzmaéargfi
$f{§’~’E’§’:§°§3§;€ Gafivéag
‘_%§§::::<f% &§T:¥{}T£2€i 8%} :5?-f3§§§'E§s§

§%§,1"<; §';§'1a,:"*:';§? Ciaiiig

' " '-%;f§%i;§§§:§:aga§z,:§_:

;%%’;s_’%’;:{::€i c%;:-itazi wig}. E2}; _E”:_%ss;

{ E 5 {gig} E-“*:_::._§*v;€{:.. $33121. H1 fig

Eiffz} ‘§;,9;i;<': {i§'1ai'z§'T:a.%;asav:: {f%<32¥&;::s,
5'-Saga {if} years;

Ego -E§T§’1a.r§f§’ ifiraziii ::§:::*<%:+s:=:1:.,

iffhiéizzzagahgr; –

Eifé §_§{B§ Eésizizavatig ‘
133/ 0 £43,116 §%§enL:.kag3:’a$a<i,
figfii 4%} 3,.-'€a§'s§ –

0:33: fis;r1ga’:1a_va{£i ‘£”5a:::§”;€r,

R / :5; ‘~!2§:1€:E:»a_r2z«&ga:;

§}a’r.’:3.z1ag€::’:%.

_%?§§}{{1}§E%hara%i§ {

Viffz} §€§§;§as’?;”§”£'<_iX5r££§§",:-_ I

fagsi: 38 j;;'{:rg;?:fs, V .

§f{} _ _ V
E{{:a<§§é';§<:E.3 ;':?§.%':;3;2":}:z2:§" fI%_§::"2§:;:; ~
E§a§{;–i§§%iS§'Z§:-E 3:; 3E'*E;3;§;:is:»::é: V

2g §<"?:::.:":':2§<2:_%V V ._ ,
figsai §}<;2;?: <»'§~1é? V }?t3:;a§'$;

” r {Té<.C}T§?iiE.;':§i §§%§3!5;;;§s~a:' '{E::;2a«':§a,
A % ::fi:T,+:;;?;g'=:::<V;2~a'%k.

fi;’gf’_:_,-(‘E 2§;E::L:;.?:,,::: _é;$a.:’:~;9
2 $953 €:1.%:;;:f:;é.g%A Effiagava €T’§§2§:2′<i;;L

£9 {§;~{§~i§:i_§a$E:a:'2§{a§;

:’%,§,;§:<§ aéémzii 33 }!€8_£"S,

V' ' – 3 ;' z::~»7''ff..".1?;E":a::§z:2 Efiagazrsz Esgaigziaa

. {"1 "SE §;3a$.ha3;§3<::::r;

VV “‘?:g§:=:.§. :~i,=2?2m.§’§; LEE} j;=;::¢:»u’*;*=;,

;§:;’s:: {[f*’;’;>g:. Eftéasaizvsi £’Zf§{j::%{§z;a»

§3€fE%.§§’}€3I’};{§{“31T.1″{lS Ea} s’*:§3§(§é§”:gg aéi
§i{}i;=:’:E “§f’hi§:1;;:23i’3E.: %il%z,:£_§<i§:; 4 ,
S~£:::a:"é§'.f {TE-::§,§i_%.§

if E_§"':§.i%«::z1§1gaEm*5

: }§i?E5é§f}{.}.§'£€73:%Ey§'3§:5§%' .

{§_E§js;’ fesif E’-:€f§:’s%.«'”};’ 5% $;a.E §EE€:::f’i ,§mé:ié-5;’. §§E’.{ZfEi€%ET§’ ;§.:5§:?_ {.”5E’_{f5>

gagawigzsi; 32%;: J’::aigfe;m=:ni §%;§;i;§f{“~._{E€(f£’%:<i_ s;§:a1§,:':_:i ""ZV%€'}¥"E~§9'?§7,'
§3;::~:$§.=;4:§ ii: {}.S.b§,.1%:~%;’§*E, {}:*;:~«.{i’%:£:§’3E<: 7€;sf7_¥;,.%:€: ifiéivii Jmigzz,
{j3E':iE<I;:ag,aE"u::", {i§sm3Z:§$i:':g; ti-:?:: –:–€_§;1ii"-iiliéizi fé:er”§% hearé and :”<:::~;ézn2'e:£ for

'§L}.a'ig:::s:=.:i:€; V"s;':::}:1:'1.i§;;*.:=,g_ e:;»':'3.: 5:33' §}"§'{?ITfE;i§'tiréiiffiiilfifii; sf jixdgzgzeim
this If§a§f? J, :;"§€:Ei*;e2"'e<i {ha i?;;23;;Fi:1g:

g;;§n-érmm

5%’hi;=§”..§s’;3V _Vg’:j’£_ai’;*:_§:§Tf¥;’;’;”;%; ;,%§’3;;fia.E ‘£.E§”§{i€3F S€C’Ci{}EE 9% if “£;?”§i'”.ff

e::§:’:3;E§_§3:;gE”§ég:;v:Ef**«::’;§%:.3i:ig§:3;$:”::’§% zmeii siearms gjéaiz-;5»;<_:£ §';jg :§':::-:=:

' .V{7;§§¥:?§ 'ff-§*2i§{':*:2z§$g:a§':T2r 3:": £f'}.£%é.?§a;a j E.*§Z%<;%'i

.;3%f';%'é. «« 3 §<;%i%":,_

s;;»_S. '" ,, 5;' '.._\,.A:.( W …,/H}; 'S ., w..W.. .,§ _; ,1 ,., .3 :, ; …_,.,(; n_ g _ ' W:
:.;fi,: ;~”::;£§

/~

gzf, ‘§”§1’?;-‘:= Ea’:;::_<%%;2§.:§ 3%; £33.: §fE.§E§2g :3"? E'§'T§§Ei a':r<2g.s;,§
, . .. 3'.

2-ghj R _”§,.’j;(“f’ £1-

; .1′

._- mg . ,* ,. ,1, w ) :2 _ ,2 ,n
§:§%_jp%=i_:§§§§2’§i.~’ :f.§é”§E§:§.£§..s .?;a::._; j”*’a{£§§ 22;:
E E E

;a§§’j2€ ‘ja_::’_’:_%f§j§.-” ‘§’}IE'{‘§§}€§§’§§:*:f§:}$ §:§3;s: ‘§3§’SE =:’£<':.§"%:*'::"';{§V;é.i1%.3:'?',?'i. {.i7§{§ ":'"§<}*:

r 3

§;:§};I :%’%%$’g”;{::.:'”;:§ £9 $§1€%%”3 E’€:?€.§E§f’iE§§’§§ a§”:<'§"'-:{m"éies;~.

€15": §}fiéf;'f'§"'§. 2::0§:si:'a§::s?::'§" gT<~:§~i'§;:._E:};§;;s,§: '":5:<:s§,§':::éé '

§§§§%%E€;3{3 2-=3-*'i€,.E': 1'25; s*«;::a§§.gs_%':Z€f% giéapiy. g3§,:éi%,::+a_:.§'.:("'§

552%.? 563:' iihfi .§"'f?r§§j»s:1'_' $5' ;:::–:§'*§%f::§.<:%3«'::_;:i§:'?;.;2T:*z§_%:<;:-I §};§;§::§s;§.<'::': €fii§”§’§a:’:’3E–.§ ‘§£}E’

:22€:=:”::fm::%f.§: :_:§_:{“%f%:§’ {T%2*<'E€_:':§* 2%} -V'{f;'iF'C§ fz}? fl'§€iSI1{Z'

§j;2:°si:§§z':$; §:::9*’*” gizaii-. $.:~’..E=i2::,::’§j’f£ ::¥’if..i’:§2I’–E’é:2–i5:§”s,

‘$4: –».{:§{;:§€:z;f£;2:3:iT*’§EE;€{E :2 {§€:3§’££t§§{“E{i ‘=E£i’fi”§”.€?E’3
?§§.§i§Z€’%?I§Ef?E7l§’ “§’:°’;_%i%?::’ {aka ;m<E ;i%{:'§2Z}§'%T'§.§EE§ {ha

§v:=:§:»2":*4'§s:'::zgééiiaé '§'§§f};<:.%A._§§§2*~;§*.»-':'Lf :"§:.-:€E::~2"":s:%.='«2:':"%: {ita:i<%g€3:*i::€s§E§%};' d£5:':§:»3{%.

‘ §_*:22:<'§ §<é'%'<é,§.'.3ii'.sA:::' §<;:i:':§:: §7a§2":é§fg_3€%:*%,}a E: *§.:’22$

a~:r:E§’f €l§zff§T3i§V€§{{§..’::§~}fg’ §;%:{:’: ::§::%f$:’:{§a§:%. %._'”sa§§: Ex’: 333$ §§_<:z,i§’%’: f:’z.§§’:s:=r”2s:% §.%”:<*: §{;)§§=:::.¥§:'1g §.s$§;§§?:$:

(Ft?

§;eE*;{»:§§:::zE;e> ;2:”{:§3@:*%,§.€:$ $011′: ezmfi. :}f%;:§’1§:j:§§m, faméig §:.§”:<i$.

€3.22 2%: fiaaég 9%' 3&6 £§}G¥{"Z* §§é:a{.i§:';g$ 53:6 irizré

f'""'%. .1
)f""'

Erfif

{E} 'a3¢'%":§:§E';{?::* Efhéf §;=§§.:{'§s.':?£:%..f§' gzzwy-*€:$ i'.§':~:~:.*:,':T f€§'3.€.'-:

§.}§§%2:'";.{i;»mt szzézé EZETEQ jam: famiijaz' '*V_§§é%:}§3-<:r§}*

$§§%,:aE;$s:§ 3%: fiifeééaiaée "a;§EEa;§_§;?é""A

;2:,:r<:§':a3$vj;§z;>;réijg;_}?’ §_§:=.:§ii%{ési9

{iii} ‘%s”§”::i:§’:€:;* ifffésa ?§;§2§3;;f§.£fi’ j”~ §3%e<_fs§{as 1&3: has :3
aagzwa %¥1§€3fi_§§§%'§§§$E§h€'%?§9 E?

253:? 3:233¥_p§’e::2g§¢:§:*?:,:i€t$ ‘ §§§”§;{%, ..;*=f:?:%’:’%?§.%;.E;2:;*§ :?E:s3’* §2a;”z,2′,’§i’§s>:”;

“”” – T. §:f~=;§E§§ffi3?§§§{?§’E <":fEé.%Z.$ E. jififli $:F:.%:"{:%'?

{E':r';:- L' V%%?§:{i'::§"{:::? = ;}§zs§,§:é.%:f%.§°§' §'}3"i',§'i?'{':f§ 3:33 31$: §%='=:
é::<*;§"§*€'§£{%:f% "€32" §f:{:'é$§:{% g3;::§"§%.§§ :_z.:T;z:"E&:€* {}2"€§{f§' 2513?

'g§§%§E§?C?

{£2} §i£i?é:=:§§15:§’ iha _’§f}e:%}i:§”;{§a;t”:E: §::%:”:§%:$ rm: ‘Q26: ié’
‘ ~. %’sm§::{:;»%;;{: §}E”€§}’3f3§”{L§-‘ is §2§;’cha${:{£ Gm: ef his

€f£i§*§E§E}§§§ 339:2 iéi is; a S€?3§§~8.$Q_’¥.1§1’i’f{§ §E’i}_”p€f£”§};;’?

{vi} ifi§’§sé;.%: {§§.§’E§§§'”:€3{§ as .§7i’%égiE zagifl §i’_>:.§3.. E. 2:52 33%} 3923?: gggsir

_§3fi§$’,2 tgasggg €:x;%§’§:3Z.:’:5:€E {EB §’.}€;”.§’E:”:%E§ sf f};j:€*:-

§i}”§{§ ‘b:}§:§’2 §i%2:%;~3w: ‘§s2’§E}.”if3S§*§§?$ v;s::’€: e:::'<3s:$ €~:§«;"235;::;_2f%r::s?:sC§.[' "3§'§'3;%:

{§€;_%§E%::"2:i2mi$ die'? .E'i{T3§. €':Z",§§'%f§" éhe: '%i-'§'t.zé%:§§:'2A %_;:)–e;»=: z:<}:f"_g:3g'§;C2f§i{ie{E

53:'":§_: <§{§{.E§};E':':E':f'§".'£§'.z':'LE'j§" §22::7.(§.>2§C§’-..

€:2i§<§€e§":«::331 anié €’§.€>€f’§~1;;E:.;£%3’i?Z§i’i’i’§=” .€’E1::%.’.{TE<:27';ar'%*.= £3:-:E::;:z;

-1

a__:’:s§2x:€::'<:d Er': :2ega:':§i;§:"' :S§:::<:*:'§§ ;'3'{_1=:%V":2:..&z~22f:a5£ {'§§§Sf3{§§,E€E}€§§
ETi.€?§{f§ €}3:a%".. §3§§§'§..§€:'t 2"%{:e.3 {_i§_:%3 .:f_:<;%f:_é:é2:§$233.;§%:§;:./,§:.<:s:fés§{§£:é:*:+3.?§§Ta:=:: 3.::.{E
iiiéfiifééifififféé 'a;.i€%"A«j:§'§'.';§.%: ';§–%*:€E§';';%3§".':"§; ./;€E..§§i€::§ ;f3{f%~ Ee Eéfiéé?'

;§gg§€s:=:%;:~::% 3%}: ?%5.{*:'<_:t% .53ééj'::";%':;"'%';.§v::%§§.%:3§§é;§§f' figs f§€:*{§ §:§':£:% §}E'%.':§=.§f:',§"3'?.

§:'§}§,:éi:as,.§ a:':'";<j§%;%§'5'é%§{:§::£s:t}:':«§€1._;f::§."£§':<3: {3§3'{"Z' {T(_}'§'§i'.€?:E'E{.§§.§'I:5g §7E'"§§'§§

"£3 {f§'E?§.§§fifii§ §%'.§:.E"' E';,§fj3;&*fi'–::;§f:;¢:,§i9é' in "ihzi-?: %_~:::.s.§.*é.;, :%§t§:'§§>z’:§”€§’
5:33;? ;&i.i’s::; s€é<§Z%<;r§:j':g§f'g'§:';:s.3;;iz.¥;: §”:”é:€::’;széesgé Eéjgz E226 a§§3é&E§a:’;’i $333: mil: {Zi£::.%::”E,

‘%’}§€€;%,% €;A%;§é’a§§€ 3:325: 53%’ {ha €363, {hat the fatigcf :25′ {ha

é3§§§:é%:;%§Ea;::E. ‘§”§é.s:§ §§{}§€j§ %E*::*: a:1::$s§;:’-3} §.}§'{}§T3€E’i§€’if§ £6»; §€€}:’§’§

331:? 2 <3? §?;s:§*':§:::§:.:.§€ 'B' 31% z~:vfl:'§_:~:s agmi <:%..z"¥; :23" EEK: gaia
., 5: $3

_ '§:v»§":'2«¥:*-::::'<~.*-:{t§$ :"i:{:<%§_%:<:é ? §"ifi§'i3iE.1T§'Zi{T§€§'g §5:§':€t§2,f:§€: ~15; §.;§"'<:};g:::::%§'§§;a;*::§

" = .5.-,a:'%:*,:*s'~': ;::':_,:;§*:::'rf2;:§s;a=:<_§. 2:: 5:%z_.§§;;3e:'s%*%. :f:§' ééaézi <':§a§:'f:2 ihi':

:/

if

§

;:{::.33:5s€~:1 §<3:" E226: 23;;:§.3<:3Ea:':§'. i7:€}§"}§,'E':§"i{i$ E}.'3;§_2 §:a§a.iE1%.§;f."§ §iE£3;<I§

g;§_':;<§:.:::ed §'x.P. 3 {:2 E38 §T:z~::*%:§<:zT:}..3:*iji,%= §%7:x,§-',.§..__ ;~;z:'§<j§- ";."9';';E.,

:x;'hi_<:%*:: €.§{i'1¥.?E£§§"Ef%?§"é§'€,f§$ ihé: '§a::§: {Eat §_T_%':%:., §:fi§:*€'}§§;€frf"L;.§\€"§1'%§' 9'

16*

g%éi$§;:"§.%";s:<% in S{:Ea§2:'§:}ii-: 'E75? s;::*:gma;2:; 1§;L?%~:'i}§{"i§"':g¢.:i?€;'3: '§§§ u§§A};fi

Law

é;§_§§§::%ig2:':i'$ '§.%§€E':i:t:" §..f§.,, iE1{~:_ 7:::'$§' '–:;'§é:;f%zi::,{i§é§Js;é';.,.A V' 3%' ES;

:13 = *

i:s:"2z";Z§::;"::".%{')§2 0:5' é:§;::::;e::1§2::'§1% 7i:b§T;v.Ei:'€,' 'sfhsm-":"' §'::':': €§%$%§}§§%€i %_;§"2a§ '

?:':<% 3%; 33:6: f.~}{.§%.E3 s::~§ 33:57:' :'§€-':%';f":¢:::':{< £2::j:%:_%;<.:::'i§;:: {am :3? aa:€':<'§E{:{:§{

%;x:%,2%:§:<::': '§.%'sé=:~ _§;{<fi§€'{::::_:f?ia.:,%,f: "'"';3;':{i.' 2&3 2s;§i%: .i,af:{~:

S.'EE.'},%.'»a2%E'.'§}.L€E'-§.%3.é§%T'.§,§-"E §ae;::» §%"é;2:?%2a*§’2.é[*:1″=*€’»éI} f«,=’i’ié§.§’E§ {sac}: {§;},=:’§<::* I

is; :§;z_;~: §i.§_.':%::.%$%::.§§f:§~.g=:::{§' as $:a,:<:E11 Ex: Wag €:%:'2:',%'i.E<:z.i its
%;:.%:a;: <:'§.:;§::':' % E. ,%':§%°?"i ",%:';a{Es: in $335}: zamééz s~;s::§::s:<:%:T2§.:3

;}§':;;§2<::*%::§. L "

1%: §:€?§~§:.::*–:–‘T:—-~ E:::::<a:'<'§ %3a:{:: :§"';?',:<; ;~2{§1r:§:::::taf:':<'§

» §'3ra':%§:;z,§§ __22§;2§;3€5:§."é:2.§':%:: z'3,§'3<:§ '§E"£;€:': ?<'€:s%§} ;§:£§;::'::'3?$' <:.?{::':§.:':;'=sa?:§,

' 3%':

‘ :*’9:’i§:’:{3::*{§$ §:§*:::<.%:.:{*:s%<§. §;';%.-'::§€}?:*f: %fi}::2§_.§:"%T. ?:€%E22~g

:1?-sfiégi’ ?.?:.:’% 5-:§»;j§::§.€%:”:sifr:: ‘§§’f§’1{§§i’f3§”{:’f{§n ‘§73z;:€;;’§”; §:§”‘:<2 §§f;=§,%.E"§L§i'°;$

1 {3 §§:§%"€?IE §s:._:a;" :5; 's:.,§";:": s=§:i§;s2<':.

.7/N':

xv
E

aréiéa :3 ‘§£.2§$:aE;3a ‘§§<;':_;=§§, {i'iE"2é::E<§::::a a§2..1r' ".f'%"::aE2:E§§
3 « , ._ V.

{T§’:ick::T;z§g§za§:.3:° §§i€§%3″E'<%E. i§:::p§K~§/:% :’.~§’§”,£%?éfT:’€§§ ‘~:§:: {f;:22%: “~izzazifz-«$%’ 353.? ‘ AV

$3′?{:}’i{3EiZ’E.é};3i§§§&§2§’e’€f+ €:§::22s;{%a :5;’?:a’7,i.8:’~.’£»%3é* fig’-.s+:z?..* »s:_i»s;:?€*::.1:.3:é?f:z{,:§”:%:VV
h_<:r§;:E.§': z§r'§«:§ '%.E';.<':% &;a_E€E §:;:*z:';§§Aé?::'*'é.V§"';é$ <3;fisaz:-%'f:%}:?%:;§ _:aS*.§.:{:4§n Nat?'

2:}? E.<"§<:E:2<.:::i':'§E§::t 'E?' 8: .;;§é§;': .,; -.§,§§<éi*%5:iSé:' "é.f'§'::3: i;'}§;'.§"T:{i1'

'z=g:{%§$;;s:.ziT.:::{_% ékzzzi, 3:»; '%:'£"';3.€_. -151:3 géaf=%Z;:./E3;;. jEi§:_;.'?.~ E8 mgr} El 3%}

S};.?=E":1é?§2§;';33.§:§~:.sz_:_§?§.§:§g i35;.~':a::%4z*€:-1':~:»-i_3ir""§__gg;'fé::':§ia$ is aisza E1": iihsz:

o*s5s:'3€:'$§:§'§3 _:-'£9. H32%..{§Ef;%g;:1f;a.%saS;?z§€ fiawgiza, the: §§:*:s€i.

{is.*:f€§::d§i::ij.[E; is; Ehs Ezaiiex Q1.' Eami §.s~;$u:::%£§ 'iéjg

mg: '§':;§';S§E:§:3,r»;_ A' %ifi}:i:§'ti};<:§;31'::1:'fga}:2:* 'f§'a§3;2k E3': :*€:se§;_3:~:£t%t. =35
$}f,?§{}$.%T:;E%;" £f}'§';'.'i2'– a:-_:{i"*"%ea?/2&3 %:x§%2::2 §¥?i:§{'i§'1 23$

:*s:j{i€}::" §’::2″‘%:E3&:§* :§%::*€=::’:<!£:.E':c:'1s €E"1€*. saga: as" E'E':£?:

V :§i'§??§}§§i§§€i§3.§I;5f§T',?I§-:31;§E§.§§§ tiéaé. Eszfiii E3: 3jgahk:,§F;?; 2;': szaizd in

.<_3£'~ §.?§': <=: firs? :*1@1?*<%::":{"i:~1:':%:4

" ;<3__§3- '§."'%1;5: :*:§sgéT::*: 9%' ¥;§":€: §;§&%:";f§§'f in Si} far 3.3

" §§{:§§::%é::§:~2 §}g"€}§}{"Ei"E,§.€f;"§ 32% s%%:::':<:e:é3'§T2${i is Wig; fc:i<}§*§T;?<'3:":. 52,?' {E26}: §?;§.':{E§3$'§;§':I§E

§f}i'€')§}{°,E"3§f'é-2 %;%€%:a{Eé 3.? §"'§§§'{i":k{}.}§i§{"i yiiiéigéé érmzé

&;f;?':;§;*s7-é E31 f=§{','§}€'."i{§%_.E;1é"'. is? §}§'{}§l}§ff"Eif§?, .GE§":a;t{: Ea'; "

{E§»:{::€:"~:€: as:::{::'v:§§:1g§§;' a:z":{% §*€:fz?::"3{i "%;{i:';<*: €.TE<}:::*°i:~«f%i%€f:

§:_:§§:2'";:'2%%§i:=+§.i;2§€: :;§2§§=:"::' ?%"ifi':f §:=§*«:§vi.:«;:'<}{3;s :33' ¥{z;;1'ma§;1kg:»z'.{3€:é;:§*E. 4'

§?i€iE§ 333% §¥.1§?Zi°?: Efezizéaiiam 532%., E€%?é§,; _