High Court Karnataka High Court

Channabasappa S/O Krishna … vs Manikrao S/O Channamallappa … on 27 July, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Channabasappa S/O Krishna … vs Manikrao S/O Channamallappa … on 27 July, 2009
Author: V Jagannathan


sm%;A;

EN my E-KGB $0239? 0? KARNA’Ef;§;§%f§§”A,

CERCUE’? BEPECH, GULBARGEX V ‘

§A'”£”ED THIS THE 27% Dzc£”0F«mL¥

BEFg0FIEa ‘»__
THE 2:~1«::»N BLE ;%«’iR.J{}S’Ei’i~§f}§2. V. J,§g1£};a;1\~3:%e.&:’*:§i}é;i~:V
M.E3′.A.§'{}.6C?’?§*5[‘;§:{%§§Si§JiV}

BEFWEEN :

{3j§:3.:{mabaSappa é 0 Bhairiankar,

figfi 43 :sf¢aI’S: Bafbéis ”

R10 H;:~%oT; 1»..1{:359f§V1’B, ‘mnkateéh Nagar,

£§1.11b8ifg& ~ ” ~ % …AP?ELLAN’F

{B}; Sri.$Z’:§ra§:aba§éip*§¥é”.»E{.Babshetty, Adv)

‘ -.?3:ié:I;i}:;’:a;<3"~<$/ G Chaimanzafiappa Devani,

" _ Age, :3:1,;aj <§z*",_ QCCZ Busizasss,

R/363-:~§;:::di3::.i Raga}: Eiumnabaé road,

.. gs

-{fr:11§}:>3A”_g§~;

‘E’}ri€:=.V{}§*ie:1ta1 ins’1;ra:1<:e C., Ltzi,
‘T ‘£.’.’h.r0ugh its Divisional Mariager,
” -fiivisiczn Oifice, Siation mam road,

Gulbarga. .’.’RESPGNDENTS

53;; smmzseeza S.Me}km::éi, Adv for R2)

Pm}

This M.1?.A, is mad u/S.173{1) 0?

Ea modify the juégneni and award d;}1__t;¢%?(i::.

paSs€d in Mvc Na.i233/06 pasV§§éWé fhy«Tnh_e+:’:1.;%xa;2::.'<5gy:i«

Jufige {S1{'.DI1} at Guiharga. _

Thfaa M.F.A. coining V<;1f; *f;)i' é,’a:’;;’«:;’:’;:?,’% izé’ ‘fiéiflfifi in questien on the gvund that the

ii1Ac§fV13e.Gif appéziiazii was taken at R3.2,G{}{}/– per

‘V-..m0ntE’;§__%§ut Ezavizag regard ‘£0 tbs o<:cu_pa'i:ion as a barber

amaunt cauid have fieen 'taken. Secendiy, the

airmurat is on figs: iawer siéa lifififii' the head 'iess sf

M9'/$5

€;1fli€i'1i€i€S {if fife' oz: a£:::::}u;a"1%; of there beimg s_if.a'i:i:'e*t\-<i%.:_1V–».ii1_;':;';:_:{:_z_i'« _

right leg by 3.5 arms am? <:irc:1:11fs:1*en<:€ of »b§,»{ 3 {:33}:

3. Saving thus heard {he

()5: p<'::'uSai of {ha awarai of H13 "triibm1a""–?., Eaiift £:5"i' t3ié View

that the cafixperisaiigéii.__;'eq§.3§;:*{:s;3 .: Income
czméd haw been takaag month as a
barber arid c§3::é§;§g«u€i:i ;§i3{ ,'ii;':<iéi': t:§*1¢ 'bass of future
<2arz";éz1g for the wheie

boéy 39;'; -:as::%:":;s:$€i:.1"':";_V'V:';~?f_ §iEé’;dj.,§ and the Qacupaéiiaiz. Gf izhe appefiami which rézquires

” :9 $%;a:r1d far :21 iésrgg mime, I 3113 ed’ 7336 View that the

Said a::1{>u;’1%i {:31} ‘£36 izicrfiasrzxi by awardifig a furtiler

‘L/:5.»

sum :31’ Rs. 153.89%}!/–. Thus, the co:npen_:;é;E.i§S:_;-. _

€::1ha5:1{:ed Rs.5i,GQ§/«~ and the SQEC3.” ‘w

ca:’:”3: i31i€:}’€:sf. 21*: {$259 13.3.

4-. fimsard :~;£:ar1di§ ;11GdLi£’i:<§i:iv–ac<:£§rdi;'1giy'_:

ms appeai in pay: {him