High Court Karnataka High Court

Congergy Renewable Energy … vs Nil on 2 July, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Congergy Renewable Energy … vs Nil on 2 July, 2009
Author: B.V.Nagarathna
 

-1"

EN 'Ti-iiéi E-iiffifi <.::L;:%":* <32? ;<:Am«:A'1m«:A A'? Bfis3'~IGALORE1
DA'"i"E:I;E) "1"H1f5:~ "ma 2% DAY 0;? {;uL,¥, 2009 
:sI.::§2{)RE:

'THE; :--:Qrm:_.2;~=: MRS, ..}U8'E'iC:E B.v.NAGAR;éi§f:TiV;mj:fA'  ' 
90.11. No. 119i:26t)8~ '_  'A V
ma. :m.752g2<':o

titgxé

69.19.. 'No. ;.~1":j2*.-07¢:-3

C.A. 1*H2?; ':'5é*z'2o ;o;_,3f   .

-G

co.,?.1~zo.   

a§:+'i'\.s.v*1::::_jE:§~:;.{_A ' " 

<:Cm{§i:.i%{3:~z* ¥"€I:";i*~E E:w..£}aw:%£:::«_ §:3«?.~1*:%i§€€}'z"
yaivmg: :;:;%3§£':i':::§§,_ « 

A. ::0;M,mN¥ 'EE*4fCi£}?é?;*?CZéR§§'i'E3£"} :.:ér~:13§::fe
"'i"E~i get: .€Z30FaEE3;%f€EEE1'3..fi;€7E', , E956,

" '' '*.AE§i} §*i.c'%,\?§§'~é"{3} ms R'E§'<;;;}:», QFFEQEE:
.' ,g3;§. _¢3§;}_€;  
  ::.::5{i; FEE?' Ri§n§,;E5T:,..

' '  Mr. PE€.A§§5%SH Sfiatwy.

% 5f"{53;é?"$%~§'r. Rm: 8¥.§§'ii'§';«§, €3{}U?~éSE:L}

é?§i::«E.RA'N&.'§f§:&}§2 
B1%f_}FéAL{"}RE:§V. ~4 ?:36{}{}38§
REP; 81%' :':'E:'D:REc:'1'*aR,

E"E?Ti'"§'E {EN ER

REL
E%ESP{}N§3E§?"§'
{BY 3% §3EE;E3f§§*{, £X£}VGCATEZ}

'E7'§iE'S C0352 ES §*"§LE E_} LESQDEER S§E§{3'FE{}N .3'??? §i?'¥E} 3%"?
Q? '?'§%Ei {':{}?vi§¥%é§E3E§ AGF, E935, §'R§'§Y'EF'€{} *§'E*i;3;f§"' §3'{}R 'E"E~§§{i

REASCENS E§Tfi[E'E{} TE"§E~:-'§;§€Ei%'i TEMEES FEE)!'-3§E§LEf {3€C}E.}E«E'§' MAY"



 

  (3% :~":§:%:'--fx§,'%;:é'."%V§§§;ag--§s2~m§ {::<:; 
   ~~~~~ 
" §«EESP{}?~:fBEE~%"'E"

  "'7?H:S ?:;f§9;pk ES FZLEZE3 E.?N§ER SECTIOR 391 QXNI} 3%
®F"iF:~i§;"<;<s:v1PA%¢:Es Am', 1936, PRFNENG 'i'HA'i' FOR THE

 REAS£}i'%:':§'_-s STATED THEREIN TEES HQIWBLEE CQURT' MAY
  §3§?L §3i;5¥:';;5sS¥*3i} TO SANCTZQN THE SCHEME SF'
'*.:".%MPiLGAM§'1'i{)N TO BE BHNEQENG WW3 EF"§'ECT FRGM
. 'ATVHE-A"1S'1' BAY Q?' £PREL "2808 53 T8 BE BENEEEPEG GN ALL
  "§}§~§E1 SHAREHQLERRS .&?§E3 SREBETGRS G?' THE SAE}
' ....f;Ef}!%#'¥Pg%.E\§Y Ai'~§E;TI G1'? TEE SAEB {";{}M§3.&NY fiffl} ETC.

'Fhesa CLQR are ceming 9:} far Gztéers ihfis day} {E16
Ciflllft maarie the: faiicmfingz



 

GR§ER

These itwc ;3€:¥;?r{i<:;ns basic: bean fiietii bf; {ha '§':"an:§i}_:r0:°
.a/'4' I 7

{Zmpaz.':}=* anti "E"'r3;11si§%3r€€ Eiompzemjg respacfiivegbfg"--:;§€:%ifé_:i;4:flg§.

saziction {Elf ea prpss€:{§ Schmmz of ;§2n3iga1'r;'.é:€§0;1AT :i';;T%i$f* V'

¥€'§.}.i{'.'}1 fir: "f':"ansf€:I\~:';z: CG'fl}}3i;3_'I1j_$,? 2%.-*5:-aiiiE;*7£)§: figiergécii' -V V:iti1._:'7E,E"1é~..

"§'I'a1zs§€:'ti€ {:€}Il1§Z§£:1I1f{. §g::.:'3.ted an

2.2.206

? a3 3 Priarate hfiiiitéfi the pmvisians

{sf Campanies A{:i’},:avi1:§g”itsi at 660/1, 18%

ft. read G38.

*T?’§1e’aiif€;hg»iisg:=fi.»..4$i1are Capital 01′ the ‘E’1’ansfér€::r

{;:c;an1_;:a;1}:’ §’€sV.;Z;;E’,3{§;v§§{§;°ai§QQ/~ ciiezidéd ixzie 128,€3{),GG{}]-

§.i:2;a1~::$ 9? – aach. T116 issued, sabsefibeé paid

pip gfafpitai ef the ?“hi(“‘:§3_ aye {xiii}? paici zip

vi Tiifi mag: {3%::}&*:f of {E5 ‘”§’m::sa§Tcr(}2’ CG:i1pé%_I}.j€ E3 is

::a:’tr:’j: on ‘§31:$i:1€3$ as man.ufar:f:um3: and; t0 {£63} £3 ail kfildg 0:”

maaigiiiazéas maxi égquipmfint, a::§mp:m€:1’tS Eta, ugad far

variaus §)€Z)’Wf:;i” gexiaraténg aystsm has-35d an 3018.? €§1€§’g”:’§_.»’ amzié

::>i:.E:.m” a,§”£<::':22vsi7i%s:=: 5:§{}%1I'C{iS {ff 6'E1€fg*j;* ans? '£113 agiaciaiififi E}

L,

v i%3§lQ'~§§S:V

equigmerxt sixth a3 i3ht0v(:ltaic maduies, i11V€ft€:iE§’», cf

various kinds, mounting Sysmms, 3013;” charge ..

fiat pfiais cofiecters, pump assemblies, st01f§1_g€§’.§a1ikwsvL’arid:_ V’

Camplete S:§?’S’bE:3IIIS pertaigzing to Pbgbtoéélfaié,

pm.’ _

syst£:ms and othar afiiecl equipmefiéjfiand ‘£0 =

W.he}esa1£rs ta provkiing enginT€;::f’jng, fsE.1C1′}:Iii€.E3i,,_: :~V,{£:3§S;’ éfter V

SE:£1€S supgort and 22:33»-i_. 0’£:h.£:’I*” $fiéI”v’.icesV: aystam
integraters mciuding $013}? 0f the
Memorandum b zP}S:%”§§%>?(.§:E_.8f§;~£Q1§’V’ the Txazxsferor
Cbmpatzy is fii:.f§1;;:”1:3>§u%i’e:§?{:?;. »

$4 “”” t f.§1B~~~~T§£°’dIiSf€FGf Company has
been. a£:zj;_:*eg§ an 31,3§2{}{}8 am: as pm’ the

Eaaiagacte s§1 ::{»::f 1116: as$¢5i.§ aafiiii Eiabiiiiiea of {ha compaxzjg 3375 33

A Wwassfim

:%7210′:,z:’:€ Arrmfu ni-

-V Shzfit a3&2,81,{:@@ Fixeci Aasats £,64,2§39}3

u x V fie. Siiiphis Efieferreé ‘i”ax

Assstifietfi

M …_§..3;i}S€€E1I’€{i §.a:;%a:1s ¢h34,§1,Q§§ Nat. Carreni

Rsaetg 4,77 3325

Froiit & Less
ficcaum; 4,28,’?3,?5 E

‘}”ata£ $’;’§%,”?éé,”§é?é Tatal é;§?E§§,E§§

/4/’

6. The Board of Ejirectars of the Trmxgfemr

Company by rtrsoiutjon &ai;po:~;e:i s.ch€me of amalgamation. Thereafie_;%’_ .C{§£i:§;;i§:j¢%j_ _

Apphcatian Na,’?5:2f2€}€)8 was iiieg by _–Ci;e.:’::jTfé§j:sf¢ro;f4

C0mpa11y S€fiki1’lg p€I’i¥3.iSSi{)I1 1:0 coi1Vene.T$épazfE£E:i:’ meeting .’

H18 Sh£:’LI’Eh{)}(fi€I’S ané cxfidiiom f:_>r the.3gi:rpas:”‘§*TfAégp§)r<§;vi§:g

the prepesed scheme. 8}; ::;r::ie1*v'VL'£,';.$'£'e::r1_ 12:2i'¢..i}t."Z:v58, figis court
permitted convexzing of the zifiéxfibem 311:1
also the Creditors of held 011

I.?'.10,2G08, 2;1»;fi+ :(::';.".+*€:r1i1;;<31"*s;L to eppose the

pr<)p0sedA*"sv:ii€:;fi1é seated in favaur of the
SC1'16II1é'. fiakasn Shzstty , chairman 0f the

meetings flit-7:1}? E:1i$9':~e'E;3Tr§:*i,%i:: this court 312(3) aubsequemly the

«_ 16;' baen flied in which flO?LiC€ was

~€:i:'r3:f;:*t:i;v h}?*.t§3;i3__c9u11 to the Rsgienai DiI"€CEC)1' as well as {G

__Eisjiéiéai0r, in rsspztansa :3 which 'aim Regianal

Di:"é¥;'to:* E.1a:3*?.V' flied an aifiéavit to this Registrar af Compagxies

a:::3_t21é"'z§i:icia1 Liquiéatm' has 3133 filed his repefét.

"EC 'E'he Transfarta Qamgany $23.3 itxcarporatefi on

2fi,?12Q(}S:' as a ?rivai:e: aimiieé {Zem;:)an§; by sharm undaar

{he ?[_}£'I3Vi;SiO3Z1S of ms Cempames Act having its registareai
Gfiice at @538} 1., 163 ft Raad, Endifanagazg Bangalerfi –

$66338. That at3.th0ri$€:;§ sham capitai sf aha '?i'2:;z::$fez'*€€

./0

Company is R$.14,(}O_,G{3,{)00[–{Rupees Fotirtaezx éifirtrfzg

Q1113?) divided into 14€)(}€)08O equity Shams of

Tha issued, subscribed and paid up share" V'

Transferee Compggy is Rs.10,€.§5GM, 61','{:8G«j

Crates Ninety I_,akhs Sixty 011:: '£'ho{r;3;as:1:riA.Si:c.i%E_7x;i':’V—- $}:;a1″é8 f» ‘V

each which are. fuiiy pa3′.:f’;~.;;p.

8, efhe _;:;:13j1:: VA jfififimpany £3 to
marzufzicturfi Iiifeegfiiéh ” .::VS%;$i3;?—-«;z11ergky ge:1f:~:rat1ZI:.g
equipment x»=;%_Eé3;§& ;,sr.}’V”i1:x:${€;fif1a%ivc;”fa6§$rces emf iiflfirgy arzfi to
design for Infiia and the
.:1eigE1§}:§’i,i§j3}g:1gV m&Huf.21Ciu:”€ Solar Tharmai

{3{}§.§&g”:~f€,}I.”S5 §5I;t:§iQ§Id;§tai:.r E$¥};:s&’uies, Smaii Wmd turbines 331$

. “–.Bi0>–m1§aa;;2;. <3=F;11e:a'£cf'S"Q'&n{i Qther sguipmexztfl A copy :31' E116

firficias “a:3i11ess Sines \§’£3;}.}F 298$.

“”§7′;3;é :;-jcztouzzts ef the Trarzsferae €,fi$mpan§g have beam auéiteé.

sigaé fiat: au€iiE:€{i éaiazme shes’: as :31: 3132068 is greazizzcefi

as Am2exm:’€~EET; anti. (3 is the psiiiien,

9, “”§”‘h:~: Bears} cf ?[}ir*a:;:.t9m zraf {ha Transfems
€Li¢:m1§321z1}; €313 8=8;.;Zi}(}8 reSe:>iU€é to agprmze tbs pmpased

./2

Scéhsma ef Amalgam.ai:i0:z,. Thereaftsr the {3Q.¥’.N0.’?:’33f2()fl8
was flied beibre this <:::3u1~1; waekiizg i3(fI'£11iSSiO1'1 '£9 comzaxw

3e:parate maetirfgs 0f the mambers and €?§"€dif:QfS 83.T1.:('§~ by

ordar dateé 1';2a9.2E.}{}8 this €€3111"E gmsntszi V.

parmissicn, 'E,i1c:1'&af'{.v:-:1' the meetizfigs wart: s:i%:sj:'iV:::1$:i' {§z1 T V'

1?. i.i}.2{}{}8 and five: {:1'€€§i'{.{§}."8 azffingiéii 'fi13_$'3id.;

uz1aI.:..im<::s11s}y appI'v£:<i the pr9p€;:se{i :<;§:§.§:€_:1I1ee "I'.E;i5::"<:ai'%€i'–:_'Sri .*.

Prakash SE1e'Et.t§;', Chairman saidg .3:1L1$:::'t§;1§-;VV§3;i£Ed'V' his 'V

rcsport: to this ceurt. :3;1b$eq'1£€;}% §}* C€g?.f'§<:;;. ":'1.1§.§{)G3 was
fiiffdw This (tour: 011 fiotice tr} E118

Fiegiena}. §}iI'EC.i(3.t§ 0f_ :£I1'v:3'.%f'}S13v(3E1SE is which

an afiiéiavéi, ?i31"'~*E;hé*;' "s;:~.f {Ibmpanies has bfififl, fiked,

_3_{}E:i§::at;ic::1 nf their r€s§ec1::’;ve patificns £11 “”?’I3€

Hméiz” aIic}:’i_’j’fiia1mada F-‘*ra’sha” and the 883116 was darm on

1. 1.2€l0 9g_fi:§<mg the daté of hmring as 28. 1.2339. Th-are has

A '~11' " §ge€:?:iE1~« :10 abjectim: fmm any quarter ta bath éhesa ystiiions.

13.. 1 ham Emarfi $16: igaznad CQXEIESEE far the
p€t’:it:r;{3:1ers and; the ieamgii C§}1131Sfi§ for YE}. iéarsha and

firm 1€Ei1″‘§§.€3{§; cmxnsai. fer £216 fkfiiciai L–iq_ui{§ais;}r.

//=

1.12:. Courzsai. £131’ £1136: yetitiarxem submifieé t§t1ai. ‘§::«Qi§3

‘Q16 ‘i’m.nsfemr iiempany as Wail as the *’}”ra:1$fere§…{;§i3:i:;:2é;11f;” V

are in the gauge ficki af husizmgs anti €Z331 ‘-§1CC{3′”L1fi’i M of V’

admi:;istr–1£?:ve C{)I},’£?€1’l.’EEI1CEi and eC0:ii§:iinic.«Vi3,bi1%t}f’T c’>f_’:7t;::’–%:W”;

ifomgarsies, the gxroposed -“S<V:hemé'._0i'_ merger: has n

approved E13,; the Boarfl Di' '.,,¢W;£;f€C.tQ'£'g~_' the "

sharfihokiers and crm;i§;ig1's {f'.i:=1;1pariy.'v–ATh{;ugh, in
i'€SpC3flS€: to the notice: ' f§SV$}11er"i L_{; :£;.":irV'£, the R'€g£o113}
Bircsctor has the proposed
Scheme: but; fig 39% of the shajts
of that .}h€1d by Fgreign 30$};

{:{)I’§€31″:g3:~t€§ ‘– in .bt’v:fic*:j::£iis;*:2<§l*atia11 9f the saiti C€}m§3£i}-'
§3umuam.« "£.=::__ th :: Jfiamalgamation iaeing appmved

{ha .. ¥%"a.§:1$:§€i'€€ V €3.Q1:a.pa:1y has to Comply with the Siammrfi;

.r5c:;L1;irc;m§::1ts 'z:Vr1{i€r Fereigzx Ex{:113n.g€ Managsmfirm 3:2: and

"(}§iE3',wz.?fIv"'I'?ft:iZ§;'$'i_i*E?(§fI};?!5l€V'iéf;S in the: matter Qf aiiézziimfini af shareg 1:0

'if}:I.e §3'0zt:ifg:1f3'V 306137 fjerporate unéer {he Seheme. Umier mess

, L«§:f–::f§J;m§,s?i:3::1<:t:s he submits {hat ihfim is 35;: iegai imyedizaeni

"iii "';;;:i%i:a:;1':3; gaxzctieza £01' £316 gmpéasazi Sifhfimfi Sifliifi 1:315

" " ~~v-'i":'*a::$§%3r{%& Eismyaily is si'a'€}»" %.;:'3u:3{§ 1&3 foiiaw $1316: s':a€':fiG:*y*

rsqjziiremfizzis <3'? P's::»r@ig:': Exqfiiangfi M'3_11agE:m€mt {wt ami
§§1:':;*:=.i5%31'§:? in ar'i€e2-as {Ff fiififfi %;&i:1g no m'.1".:§:" 9'§3j€:<:E_£(3;':,, €115

§.}€"3"§i'§_'i€§I'.3 5: hi: aiiisxxgfegi, //1,

13. Ciemmazi fist {E16 Regienai {}’ireci.c3r ha$.~’–.,ais:3

submitted $1113: in View of the ‘I’ra_n$fe:mc Cempam;

with that requirztmezits u.nd€£ the P’erc:ig11″ 1 ”

Management. Act there can be new “e:;a?.3jcc:i§n

S311-éfion to the proposed scheme étad

Liquidator who has filed his afiéi the *

Cfihaltered accountant W119 ‘fi’3S_H§}.If)iI£”£,§t(i {<5 {€16 beaks
of accauzxts and papeffs tIr1c:f, Compaziy has
statttd that thfi iiiiaé' "iézave 1191: been

<:03:1du.(:ted 1;}reju.aii<::iz'§13VVt:5VVV'fThe interest of fiflfi

x:a€mbE:1'$ "éf33:–. gis-b§i£i5 ::i;i15£"f3f,'€!SE?. 3.115%" 'fi::r'1'éf0re, a§)§I'O}}i'§3§€ Grders

may 'belpas$é:d; 3:"; €235: n::.*a1'1":_;fi.tE~:3: "

E'-. '.

34. “f=§avi3:g’ _%1éz3_;rt§§}ne iraugzzgei en, ‘é:;o’:3:1 Siciag am}; 031

__§3€IT.?’;:’f§:{&’s?::?i,§E(_,?V.§ 331$ ;11z§f.fi:?1£s3.1’s:’; raccordfi it is to be ::{>%;e<§ ihai iiwih

'§§i?sfi ' "§'ra:1$f:3f::s::* ' f;é::zz11pan§: as "$332-"€§§ as the 'Z';:":%:g;;s.f€:'mé Cem:_ga:}.};

351% 71:1: th%:: -§<;§;m?:e fieizti cf b":1SiI1CSS ané ihé rai:§c:}:1a1€ far thf:

p:2:;§2%:":3€:'£i§ séiaafize sf marge; is is aithisva maximum

. _ a!i:%$}:3iaELgf5.5 333:; haariizg 3 Singia Managamfifii in {he matter Gf

1<:é:2";*i:sEé21,z:£:€: xxsiiig §§i'&?€}'S€'. {';v{3v:::°nm<:::)"§; autimrities xxfiiiciti am

M V. .._I.'{;ii§"iE'Li"€{Ii. ta 'be §;8_E§e:t2. am? aisa far sharizxg sf Q15 faciiitias ami

:'e€i':_1<::"i0z1 iza arimiizigtraiiva cirats anzi thsrfiékgz Ea a<::E::Emz€

sc{;:'3;.<;:::'1ér:: Vif–1§3i§i1:i_§ mi' both. 131:: axomgaanies. /$4 t