'7
av THE HIGH com? or mmaraggf
cmcurr BENCH AT nuaawmi ' ' 3
nxmn mm THE 713 ms? at-* V
321'-'oR"1"s:, ' '
THE HOWBLE MR.JUsTI¢E::A%re:9HAr€ V T'
_W_,__P.No.6'2-463 n§*V'f2ao9...LtGr§i4cg__Q1f
c:/w §fI;3.A 2m_.3::rg_ 93.2003
IN war. No.62463 oF?O0 9
BETWEEN: f.'--
DAKSHIN BH.-SEAT;¥AI'T{SA'BHE
SE~iREE__KS'Ei.ETf-EA C'C1MMIT"i'E_E '
ATIKSHMA, ,KSHET'RA'~.¢V"' M " '
STAVANDI, ';*'c;*;;: 'a_H1;;GDi,~----I>Is'r: BELGAUM
REPRE-'».SE.NTE--{) BY. 1'f"S_€EHA~£RMAN
SR1 RAMGONDA RAfE"AG{)UDA PATEL
S/Q RAYAGOUDA Pfi._'§'IL"
Aczggg' 4.5 YEARS '
ojcc: ;AGRICUL1'U§%E'
«R/G. P.Kf)i'.;_TQ: CHIKQDI
..a":5'r:v..gE;;@5i.--r_M PETITIQNER
" . ' ( B*{"Vi\jr;;; SV.V GQULAY ASSQCIATES, A{)'VS.,}
m.:~%
" V. 11- si}1R1 BRAHMDEV
SHRI AD.{NATHDEV
Sf'-IR'! PARSHWANATHDEV
SI-*IR¥ SHANTENATHDEV
SITUATED AT S'§'AVAN§DH§ &: GAVAN VILLAGE
TAL: CHIKQDE, DIST: BELGAUM
BY YFS TRUSTEES
IA
18
1C
19
1E
SHRiKAN'i' UPADHYE
S/O DHARANAPPA UPADHYE»~»V
AGE: '72 YEARS I '
000: PRIEST AND TRUSTEE7.' «
VARDHAMAN PARIS U':=?§'9..,HY1é V'
S] C) PARIS UPADHYE
AGE: 78 YEARS
00$: PRIEST AN"::..frRL:~s*rEi:' 1'
SHRIDHAR UPADQVE
S/O PARK?-.= UPAI:i)§ki'.'E:=
AGE: 7:2, VEARS 1
0cQ:4..1=%1§IE;3*rV_A.N'D ' "
RAJEN i'.§!'~'1*$'%k.A1V'§:Ei€l:'\~x?'I.:?9_'fla §1}PA1:>*_;Hi?E
;s;'o'A.z.u%ENA¥*;?A U95-DHYE~~--
IAc3_ps.=: 43fYlE;ARS*._ ~
"mac; ;>:21r;s;*;%,AN:)--.i;fR1:s*rE:%:
BAHsj BALi AN')iAP.f'A UPADHYE
' " O ANNAPPA UPADHYE
AGE: 43 YEARS
' "<§ct(:;pR1E<5r AND TRUSTEE
...iz;§sé;1szf;f'.1UPADHYE
s'1f{::--% Exams UPADHYE
AG_E"}.: 65 YEARS
a 'gas; PRIEST ANI) TRUSTEE
VP;/0: PATFANKUDI, TQ: cmxcm
DIST: BELGAUM
SURESH UPADHYE
S] O SI-IRIKANT UPADHYE
AGE; 43 YEARS
OCC: PRIEST AND TRUSTEE
RESPONDENT NO--1A TO 1G ARE
R/O STAVANIDHI AND GAVAN VILLAGE
TQ: CHIKODI, DIST: BELGAUIVI » _ V " 3
BELGAUM RES?O?§.DEN'?:_~3..A '
{BY SR1 B s KAMTE, A[)V., FOR cgzm A »c:.*&.' SQ-j'I.«::1:"ARI'I--QLE;:'s._:225"';sa I
227 012' CONSTITUTIGN OF INDIA=.PR;}§YIING'?0 .QIIAsI:.'1*}IE
ORDER DATED 13.3.2009 PZ%SSED'}3Y=THE 1LEx',~.RVN.ED:';CI'JILx.
JUDGE (JR.§N) NIP'ANNI (}I<s--'.,__fL'A_. NOV;3__ATvVN'£P}§N'N'I"LIN O.S;'
N015/2007' AS PER ANNEXURE :3' AND ;::<)Ns::«;QUENTLY
TO DIRECI' THE LEAI?1.~IED'.I::m:;«Js;I1;)GII; "£"(}~AvCCEPI' THE
WRITTEN sTATEMEN'm%:)_ ESE I§"ILE:1I}».B'YITI~:E PETITIONER.
III MBA mxago or geeg j; 'V
{)AKSI~IlN BEIAR-XI" JAIN'--- SABHE
SHREE §{SHETRA--_ COMEJIITTEE ATIKSHAYA KSHETRA
mavamnl, 'I'Q:_ <::I~m<s:)m
I)fIs+r.; BEIIGAUM' -------- M =
'V " «I2EI='R}3SI3:r~I1igD BY ITS CHAIRMAN
' .-SR3 _§A RAYAGOUDA PATEL
. $10 RA"'{A(2~CiiI'DA PATEL
'AGE; 46"E'E_?A'RS, occ: AGRICULTURE
Rm A,KoL;'TQ: CHIKODI
DIST; BELGAUM APPELLANT
" i(f£3"'I'._S§I N.D.GUNDE FOR GOULAY ASSOCIATES, ADVSII)
IND
1. Sim! BRAHMSEV
SHRZ ADINATHDEEV
SHRE PAFESHWANATHDEV
1A
1B
1C
13:)
SHRI SHANTINATHDEV
SITUATEB AT SI'AVANI9H§ 3:. GAVAN VILLACEE:
TAL: C}~£fK(}i)¥, DIST: BELGAUM 4' . ' T. ~
BY ITS TRUSTEES
SHRIKANT UPADHYE
S/O DHARANAPPA {IPAEDHYE
AGE: 72 YEARS A
ace: PRIEST AND TRUSFEE
VARDHAMAN PARIS UPADHYE
S[0 PARIS UPADHYE ' '
AGE: :23 YEARS V. --.
occ; PRIEST AN:)"*;*Ru's*r;€.E"
SHRIDHAR UPAB;1yJEV_VV '
3/0 i9'ARIS'1.IPA[;T!}-IYE'~¢: " _ V_
AGE: 'V
;:;>"c"':::'A mu} fnzu
f?g%L§1"iNDRQ§';AB§}\i23§PA:";JPADHYE
s/<2: ANNAPPAUPAQHYE
AGE:"43"YEA_RS-. " ~'
' DQC: PRIEST AND TRUSTEE
. ri&;i$I~§iJa3AL1 A§3§§APPA UPABHYE
" ANEEAPPA UPADHYE
T' 43- YEARS
. " O{3C--?fPfE'IEST ADN TRU$'I'fiE
m
.VA.Séj~xT UPADHYE
Sgi) paws UPADHYE
AGE: 55 YEARS
om: PRIEST AND TRUSTEE
If}
R/O PA'§"¥'ANKUD¥, TQ: CHIKODI
DIST: BELGAUM
SURESH UPADHYE
S] C} SHRIKANT UPADHYE
AGE: 43 YEARS
QCC: PRIEST AND TRUSTEE
mé: RESPONDENT N{).1A GO 1G ARE
R/0 STAVANIDHI AND GAVAN VILLAGE
TQ: CHIKODI, DIST: BELGAUM
2. SHRIACHARYA DESHBHUSHAN"J§'DYAP§i'I:§H_
STAVANIDHE .
3. THE STATE 01:' KARNA1'A§<A '
(Rasponmm NOS. 2 AND :3. A.R E DELEYED' Vujgb,
coum ORDER 131*. 25.3.2099} . %
V , 5 " -«._v_;,,"i*?E)SPON§ENTS
{BY SR1 B.s.KAMA3*E,'VA_1j'.I,, .1ifb:=f%x C;.§é1}x5.-_:--G)
:sz1_sA"v.1S---I4?§_;£,E:: _'{;!_I (;")' 43_ :R¥J_%:.,E 1(u) OF CFC AGAINST
THE :JU{§GMfi?:_NT";-flux}'£;E<:Ie§:1=:'"1)ATE9; 4/9/08 PASSED IN
RA 216./07'0N'}%H-E'P1LE_<:3--§ CWIL JUDGE (SRDN) CHIKODI,
ALLOWING THE'A§5PEA;_;"FILED AGAINST THE ORDER AND
DEGREE DA5¥'Eif}.:4f4'i.2i.?(}7 IN OS.15]20€}7 on THE FiLE
GB', (1.1%, J'UI){.%E7(JR-.[)N) NIPANI.
3-.'I'»HESE= PE'I'¥'I'ION ANfi MISCELLANEOUS
» j3.¥~:,c<),N'£)--..egPPEAL COMING ON FOR ORDERS mxs DAY,
A "1jH;::-- <:'3::.»,1_3:2v'1§. M3313 ma FOLLOWENG;
ORDER
VVMSA 3243/08 is fileti by me defendant Fig.1 in 0.3.
‘ “‘V. i\i’-::;:1:’3/2907 chafienging the ordttr emf mmand pafiseé by the
‘ first appellate Court in RA, No.26/U7.
, ya
/V ,2
6
2. wnp. NO62463/{)9 is filed by the mg} de_fs_ndant
challenging the order passed by the ma} Court afifsi’
permitting the piajntifis to amend the prayer..jt:o11;J’1{.§:§i:Eo:’o;!’
plaint. 1 H
3. The records reveal tliat this ?mspo1idefi’ts:’V-1__1e§:§ii1
filed suit for declaration that ‘Nos. Esofistgg Vt3:2t_.: ‘ L.
trustees of plaintiff No.1 havo’ lawfully
administer the trust’ oft1q1′:Av”co;1sét’;11cn1ia’i ‘oencfits are
also sought for, Defen§§afit_VNoV,_3 suit is the State
of of notice on dcfenant No.1, he
filed Section 21 of CPC praying for
of nthszfisuitéion the ground of want of jurisdiction.
.’ “I’11:ot1gi1i,. vérious contentions were raised before the trial
._ of hearing the appfication under Section 21
of ttial Court mtgativod such contentions, except
V. (roe i.’e.; the Triai Court has pracfically held that the suit is
A’ Vnyoomaintainable on the ground that the plaizatifis have not
.–[taken requisite permission fiom the authorities conccmod
under Section Si) and 51 of Bombay Public Trust Act. The
fl./3»
that the ::>rder of remand passed by the appc1}ats ‘_’is
not improper, this court refuses to interfsit V
impugned order. As the matter is u ‘
will have one. more chance to T 611 ithé’
maintainability also. Aocozfiisglg, {gm-.ng _oi%iéi<:._isv ma-51¢:
MSA 910.320 of Q
Since thesuit is..at:’t§§3.e’s.ta.ge, issues are
not yet that interest of
justice of the plaintiffs for
amcn¢§sss1V:1 t;A “V This course avoids
sf Themfots, the trial Court has
r.Lg’ htky tbs’ afipfissfion for amendment. Hence, the
‘- _ 3¢’3i’1’%1.kC3IE¥Ci~5°-I’ ‘@150 ca” 11’ “3:1″o”1«:V be intezfered with. Acconiingly, Writ
of 2999 stands dismissed.
Sd/-
JUDGE
% ..s.::;ss